2006-833-Minutes for Meeting July 17,2006 Recorded 8/22/2006COUNTY
NANCYUBLANKENSHIP,FCOUNTY CLERKDS yd iQ~6'8~Y
COMMISSIONERS' JOURNAL
IIIIIIIIIII III III 48122/2406 01;27;49 PM
2006-833
Do not remove this page from original document.
Deschutes County Clerk
Certificate Page
If this instrument is being re-recorded, please complete the following
statement, in accordance with ORS 205.244:
Re-recorded to correct [give reason]
previously recorded in Book
or as Fee Number
and Page ,
!l1~~ ~'h
-"0 Deschutes County Board of Commissioners
1300 NW Wall St., Bend, OR 97701-1960
(541) 388-6570 - Fax (541) 385-3202 - www.deschutes.org
MINUTES OF ADMINISTRATIVE LIAISON
DESCHUTES COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
MONDAY, JULY 179 2006
Commissioners' Conference Room - Administration Building - 1300 NW Wall St., Bend
Present were Commissioners Dennis R. Luke, Bev Clarno and Michael M. Daly.
Also present were County Administrator Dave Kanner; Susan Ross,
Commissioners' Office; Chris Bell, Legal Counsel; Mike Viegas, Risk
Management; and media representative Chris Stollar of The Bulletin. No other
citizens were present.
The meeting began at 1: 30 p. m.
1. Communications Update.
None was offered.
2. Project & Property Update.
No discussion took place.
3. Discussion of Lottery Grant Requests.
Redmond Economic Development, Inc. (previously REDAP) has requested
funding for leadership training. The Board asked that they come to a meeting to
make a presentation.
Each Commissioner granted $1,000 towards Central Oregon Visitors'
Association - Governor's Conference on Tourism.
Minutes of Administrative Liaison Monday, July 17, 2006
Page 1 of 3 Pages
DAFC Spirit Girls' Soccer Team has requested grant funding so they can attend
the national tournament. Commissioner Luke granted $1,000, Commissioner
Clarno granted $500 and Commissioner Daly granted $600.
Regarding a request for grants funds for the La Pine incorporation process,
Dave Kanner stated that he understands the Board is concerned about funding
being used as intended, but he feels it is the County's responsibility to help get
this issue on the ballot.
A lengthy discussion followed. Commissioner Luke stated that he feels the
funds should go directly to the attorney handling the legal work. Commissioner
Clarno said that this should be their final request.
LUKE: Move that a maximum of $40,000 total be granted for legal
services only, subject to review by the Board.
CLARNO: Second.
VOTE: DALY: Yes.
CLARNO: Aye.
LUKE: Chair votes yes.
4. Acceptance of a Certificate of Trustee's Deed.
Chris Bell gave an overview of the issue, which involves a property foreclosed
upon by the County. The property will be vacant by the weekend.
Commissioner Luke said he wants to be sure the contractors who worked on the
roof and the HVAC system are paid, and that the previous owner receive the
$30,000 homestead exemption. Chris Bell said that it is likely the County is not
liable for these costs.
CLARNO: Move acceptance of the trustee's deed.
DALY: Second.
VOTE: DALY: Yes.
CLARNO: Aye.
LUKE: Chair votes yes.
Minutes of Administrative Liaison Monday, July 17, 2006
Page 2 of 3 Pages
5. Discussion of Tort Liability Limits.
Mike Viegas gave an overview of concerns regarding tort liability limits. Per a
ruling on Clark v. OHSU, tort liability limits do not apply to an individual
employee, which means the County would have to indemnify the employee and
take on the liability.
Chris Bell observed that this does not apply to decisions made by the Board, nor
to employment cases or worker's compensation cases.
6. Discussion of Affordable Housing.
Dave Kanner indicated that Andy Anderson of the City of Bend would like to
schedule a joint meeting of the Board and the City Council to address this issue.
Commissioner Clarno stated that it would be good to know which entity owns
what land, and who would manage the project.
This item will be discussed further next week.
7. Other Items.
None were discussed.
Being no further items brought before the group, the meeting adjourned at 3:35
p.m.
DATED this 17th Day of July 2006 for the Desc tes County Board of
Commissioners.
Luke, Chair
Bev Clarno, Vice Chair
ATTEST: Michael M. Daly, Co missioner
Recording Secretary
Minutes of Administrative Liaison Monday, July 17, 2006
Page 3 of 3 Pages
G
too
c { Deschutes County Board of Commissioners
1300 NW Wall St., Suite 200, Bend, OR 97701-1960
(541) 388-6570 - Fax (541) 385-3202 - www.deschutes.org
ADMINISTRATIVE LIAISON AGENDA
DESCHUTES COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
1:30 P.M., MONDAY, JULY 17, 2006
1:30- 1:45
1. Communications Update - Anna Johnson
1:45- 2:00
2. Project & Property Update - Susan Ross
3. Lottery Grant Requests:
■ Redmond Economic Development, Inc. - Leadership Training
■ Central Oregon Visitors' Association - Governor's Conference on Tourism
■ DAFC Spirit Girls Soccer Team - National Tournament Attendance
2:00-2:30
4. Acceptance of a Certificate of a Trustee's Deed on Foreclosed Property - Chris
Bell
5. Discussion of Tort Liability Limits
6. Discussion of Affordable Housing - Tax Exemption
7. Other Items
2-30-3-00
Executive Session, called under ORS 192.660(1)(h), pending or threatened
litigation, and ORS 192.660(1)(d), labor negotiations - Mark Amberg
District considers
tax exemption
Affordable housing developer asks
Bend schools for 20-year waiver
By Monique Balas
The Bulletin
Representatives of a local af-
fordable housing project ap-
pealed to a skeptical Bend-La
Pine School Board to exempt it
from paying its share of property
taxes for a proposed senior hous-
ing project.
John Gilbert, a partner at Pa-
cific Crest Affordable Housing,
District
Continued from C1
If the district agrees to the ex-
emption, it would help Pacific
Crest's prospects for getting fed-
eral low-income housing tax
credits, upon which they say their
project is dependent. Their tax
credit application is due Aug. 4.
Oregon law allows local tax-
ing authorities to exempt proper-
ty taxes for qualifying affordable
housing projects for a period of
two decades.
Qualifying projects can be en-
tirely exempt from praying prop-
erty taxes if more than 50 percent
of the local taxing districts - in
this case, the city of Bend and the
Bend-La Pine School District -
agree to exempt them from pay-
ing property taxes.
If the city and the school dis-
trict exempt Pacific Crest from
paying property taxes, the de-
veloper would be free from pay-
ing any property taxes for 20
years. The city of Bend has not
yet decided whether it will ex-
empt Pacific Crest from paying
its share of property taxes to the
city.
bout 31 percent of each De-
schutes County tax dollar goes to
the school district. If the pro-
posed project was not exempted
and project manager Rima Wil-
son want to build a second af-
fordable housing complex for se-
niors, which would be located in
NorthWest Crossing. They told
the board at its Tuesday meeting
the school district tax abatement
would significantly improve their
chances for completing the pro-
ject.
See District /C7
from paying property taxes, the
district would likely get about
$400 a year in taxes after the
state reallocates money.
The abatement "lowers operat-
ing expenses, which means we
can lower rent," Gilbert said.
He said the abatement would
allow Pacific Crest to offer
monthly rents of $382 to $492 for
a one-bedroom apartment and
about $456 to $588 for a two-bed-
room apartment. He said those
rates are about 30 to 35 percent
below market price. If they pro-
ceed with the project as planned,
Gilbert said they hope to break
ground in May 2007 and open
doors in summer 2008 for the 53-
unit apartment complex.
In 2004, the district passed a
similar resolution to abate taxes
for Mountain Laurel Lodge,
scheduled to open this year. .
But this time, the school board
posed questions and discussed
how an abatement could benefit
Bend-La Pine students. Because
they would be losing about
$8,000 for the total 20-year
abatement period, some board
members questioned whether it
would be a wise use of district
money.
"The last thing the school dis-
trict wants to do is subsidize a de-
veloper, no matter how good the
intentions," said Nori Juba, a
board member at large. "I don't
see anything that says this is go-
ing to help our kids."
Gilbert fielded board questions
by discussing the project's values
to the community.
Board member Scott Reynolds
asked how many such projects
exist within the state. Cumula-
tively, that could mean a lot of
dollars taken away from school
districts throughout the state of
Oregon.
The board asked Gilbert to an-
swer its questions and come back
to them to discuss the matter fur-
ther.
In other business, the board
saw an informational video re-
garding the district's $119 million
bond measure that will be shown
on COTV and KFXO. The board
will vote to put the bond on the
Nov. 8 ballot at its Aug. 8 meet-
ing.
The board is still seeking appli-
cations for its Zone 2 vacancy,
which serves Bend's east side.
The vacancy opened when board
member Brian Gatley resigned
June 14. No one has yet applied
for the spot. The appointed can-
didate would serve through May
2007.
Monique Balas can be
reached at 617-7831 or at
mbalas@bendbulle tire. com.
Wednesday, July 12, 2006 • THE BULLETIN
Page 1 of 1
Connie Thomas
From: Rima Wilson [rimawilson@bendbroadband.com]
Sent: Wednesday, July 12, 2006 12:46 PM
To: Connie Thomas
Subject: request for letter of support
Attachments: NWX project summary.doc
Hello Connie,
As I explained on the phone, Pacific Crest Affordable Housing is applying for funding through Oregon Housing
and Community Services for the development of an affordable housing project for low income seniors. We are
requesting a letter of support for the project from one of the County Commissioners, or from the entire Board, to
include in our funding application.
I'm attaching a project summary that provides more information on the project. If the Board (or one of the
Commissioners) is willing to write a letter, I will also send you a memo that details to whom the letter should be
addressed, where it should be sent, key points to address, etc.
Thanks very much for your consideration.
Best regards,
Rima Wilson
Project Manager
Pacific Crest Affordable Housing / Mountain Laurel Lodge
541-390-4037
www.mountainiourellodge.com
7/12/2006
DISCOVERY PARK LODGE
Senior Affordable Housing in Northwest Crossing
Proposed by Pacific Crest Affordable Housing
Project Summary
Discovery Park Lodge, Pacific Crest Affordable Housing's proposed senior affordable housing
project in Northwest Crossing, will play a significant role in addressing Bend's critical need for more
affordable housing, and will serve one of the community's most vulnerable populations, lower
income seniors.
Funding for the project is being sought through Oregon Housing and Community Services'
Consolidated Funding Cycle, and will likely include Low Income Housing Tax Credits, HOME
funds, Housing Trust Fund dollars, Weatherization funds, and other funds.
The project will contain 53 one- and two-bedroom rental apartment units and will be restricted to
residents who are 55 years old or older.
To qualify to live in the building, residents will be required to have a household income equal to or
below 60% of the Median Family Income.
Two rent levels will be established based on two income levels - one rent level for households at or
below 60% of the Median Family Income and another rent level for households at or below 50% of
the Median Family Income. Monthly rents will be calculated to be affordable to households in these
income brackets (in fact, our rents will be affordable to households with incomes at or below 49%
and 39% of Median Family Income), and in order to comply with the funding requirements, will not
be allowed to exceed the maximum rents published each year by the Oregon Department of Housing
and Community Services.
One-hundred percent of the project will remain affordable, as described above, for a period of 60
years. During this period, the income restrictions will remain in place and rents will remain
significantly below market rents.
Like Mountain Laurel Lodge, Pacific Crest Affordable Housing's other senior affordable project,
Discovery Park Lodge will include several attractive and inviting common areas, including a
community room, a fitness room and computer areas with free internet access. We will establish
partnerships with local providers of senior services to ensure that our residents have access to a
variety of services, from meal service and case management to light housekeeping and transportation
assistance. We will also endeavor to arrange for additional benefits to our residents in partnership
with local businesses, agencies and educational institutions.
With spectacular views, recreational opportunities, and access to a variety of businesses and services,
the project's location is ideal for a senior residential development. In addition, locating the project
in Northwest Crossing, one of the Bend's higher end areas, will serve to foster the community's
acceptance of publicly funded residential projects and to enhance the residents' sense of dignity and
pride in their home environment.