Loading...
1992-11-03 - Voters Pamphlet - State 1 r-s pam i� � �. r. ,a•,' �.i 1 d z'�� � ��� €s�"� P ,,d S T tee �y ' i y J h M ► �br u I �":, •i;l II, � �• _.� ��«� y'e �.,ysr�¢ vM'�C`�y t,,,•!�,�,'S , phlet VS Pro . .. � . STATE OF OREGON GENE Compiled and Distributed by RAL ELECTION NOVEMBER 3 '1992 Secretary of State ' This Voters' Pamphlet is th4ersonal property of the recipient elector for assistance at the Polls. . i i . •. •. •' ^: 1n,('{!1MnQ 71 Ind!d1 !t`.C li4 ' T y T7tX,3 4ag4 STATE OF OREGON SECRRARY,OF ViTE ' •x{ : SECRETARY,QF , s MICHAEL"GREENFIEL �lr "" ' + 136 STATE CAPITOL DEPUTYSECR ST TEg ; SALEM,OREGON 97310-0722' (503).378-4139 ty°"�•`" ? 5 �' .. regon�Vpoter• 4 ote Pamphlet is one of the state's strongest.and most"visible symbols of, ° mnunent.to the:democratic..voting procesS. "Since.1903,;the Voters'Pamphlet has' a �heled�Oregonians make informed choices for their future. . "M'I � wTh>ls pamphlet provides you with information on candidates.and the nine'measures that } will appear on the ballot. Some arguments for and aiainst,ballot'measures that have`been W xs`submitted for inclusion in the pamphlet contain language;that citizens and parents may '. =find'objectionable. ,,However; Oregon.law generally requires that arguments;,inust be x `:printed as submitted. Thepamphlet'also contains information about absentee .ballots,;',! x 4accessibility,of polling places for elderly.and'physically disabled voters, and voter registration. -You•must be registered by...October.l3 to vote mi ,the,General.Election.'Please read the Voters' Pamphlet carefully and cast your,vote on Tuesday, November 3 Best, 'Phil Keisling': Secretary of State r x 1 k On the Cover: Tommy Thompson,,one pf Oregon's most respected and revered tribal chiefs,stands,on a b luff at Celilo wcth'his wcfe, y Flora,and her-granddaughter'Linda Mane George.:Thompson is dressed:n beaded leather and wears a Ceremonial warrbonnet Phgtogrnph courtesy of Oregon Historical Society,#OrHi 68314 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet INFORMATION GENERAL VOTER REGISTRATION ` ! C. Your official 1992 general election Voters Pamphlet is divid You may register to vote by mail or in person if ed into.separate sections for measures and candidates.Page numbers for these sections,as well as for the alphabetical index (1)You are a citizen of the United States;` of.candidates,,are listed under the table of contents on this (2)You will be'1 8 years of age or older on election day;and page' (3)You are a resident of Oregon. Material in the measures section includes each state ballot title,the complete text of the proposed measure, an impartial 1HPORTANT:You may register to vote if you meet the' statement explaining the measure and its major effect,estimate above.quahf iications,but you must be registered by 5:00 t of financial impact and any arguments filed by proponents and to p.m.on October 13,1992. Opponents.Where applicable, the ballot titles and complete texts of certain county and district measures also appear in this You must reregister if. section. Oregon law, requires the Legislature to submit one (1)Your registration has been canceled; argument in favor of each measure it 'refers to the people. ;(2)Your name has been ch Citizens or organizations may also file ange'd by marriage or,court order arguments on measures by purchasing space for$300 or by submitting a petition signed (3)Your residence" mailing'address has changed'for any rea- by 1,000 voters. The Secretary State may not accept any son;or argument which is not accompanied by the speed fee or,the (4)You desire to change your political party affiliation. requisite number of signatures. You may vote One time in the precinct of registration; In the candidate section,partisan candidates appear before without reregistering if: I IT nonpartisan candidates.All space is purchased;statements and (1)Your name has been changed b Photographs are submitted by the candidates or their designat- ge Y marriage or court order; ed agents.The information required by law—pertaining to coca- (2)Your residence or mailing address has.been;chaaged by the pation,occupational background, educational background and . United States Postal Service,or city or county,but the loca-. prior governmental experience=has been certified by each tion of the residence has not changed and you qualify for and candidate:Some columns are blank because Oregon law does obtain a certificate of registration from the county election not allow the placement-of material relating to candidates for office;or JAI, different offices on the same page of the Voters'Pamphlet. (3)Your mailing address has changed'but the location"of your residence has not changed. Miscellaneous voting aids,including district maps,precinct and polling place lists,voting,instructions, a complete list of You may cast a ballot even though there may be a question validity of state-certified candidates, and absentee ballot application about the your registration. ,.. forms, follow the candidates section.Another page, "Voting I If such a question exists,the election official may,'require Accessibility for Elderly and Individuals with Physical. You to vote a"challenged"ballot.You will be,regaired to sign a Disabilities,"contains information about provisions made.for statement indicating you believe you are eligible to vote the bal- r elderly or physically disabled voters.The Voters'Pamphlet has lot being issued. been compiled by-the Secretary of State since 1903, when The"challen " 4 Oregon became one of the first states to provide for the printing e process is Provided by Oregon law and sim- ply ply means your ballot will not be counted until th and distribution of such a publication.In 1909,'the Legislature e election offs- cial can determine you were entitled to vote.The election official passed a law requiring pamphlets to include information on has until the 19th day after the election to determine the validi- candidates. ty of your registration.This process is used to assure no voter is One copy of the Voters'Pamphlet is mailed to every house- denied the constitutional right to vote because of an administra hold in the state.Additional copies are available at the State tive error and to assure that votes which may be fraudulent are Capitol,local post offices, courthouses and all county election not counted. departments. YOU MUST BE REGISTERED TO VOTE BY 5:00 P.M.ON OCTOBER 13,1992. BE'A WELL-INFORMED VOTER. STUDY THE ISSUES. VOTE TUESDAY,NOVEMBER 3, 1992 . Polls are open from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Page Absent Voter................................. ......... ......: ......... 165 Political Party Statements ..............:.... 130 Congressional Map .................:.... ........:... 139 Precincts,and Polling Places ....... 161 Candidates for Nonpartisan Offices......................... ........ 159 State Ballot Candidates for Partisan Offices....:.................................... 129 Voting Accessibility for Elderly and District Map ....::.................................................................... 158 Individuals with Physical Disabilities ........ . .:.....:.....:: 128 Index of Candidates .............................::...............I............... 167 Voting Instructions .......::. .....1........... Measures................................................................................ 5 3 6iic l`1992`General V0. oters'Pamphlet , S TATE BALLOT - -- � STATE�M .'S REDS , , PARTISAN CANDIDATES No:l AMENDS OREGON CONSTITUTION BONDS (D)Democrat;(I)Independent;(L)Libertarian;(R)Repubhcatl �s A, ` '; MAY.BE'ISSUED FOR STATE PARRS;QUES- *# �T]ON 'hallOregon'�Constitution'allow state to issue PRESIDENT AND VICE PRESIDENT,AND ELECTORS^ .s u 250: amillw facilities?([rote Yes or Nods for state, OF PRESIDENT AND VICE PRESIDENT—{Vote for` ''N a ...r. ,g 8 P• , One Group) No: 2—. i3+'OREGONmCONSTITUTION•FUTURE UNITED STATES PRESIDENT—George Bush(R),VICE, ++ S 1VYAYtGO'.TO PARKS;QUESTION:,' PRESIDENT—Dan Quayle(R);ELECTORS-Craig L. regoit's:Constitution be amended to allow legis Berkman,Anita Conn,Larry Farris;June'Hartley,'Cathy, to dedicate future motor vehicle fuel tax increas- Leonard,Candence Mumm,Bill Stallings` ql�state park"purposes?([rote Yes or No)° '.1111 UNITED STATES PRESIDENT=Bill Clinton(D);'VICE ' S'CON31ZTL1TION:LIMITS TERMS FOR PRESIDENT—Al Gore(D);`ELECTORS LDonald'Allen," ISLATUR I STATEWIDE OFFICES,CON Wayne Anderson;Scott Bartlett,Eleanor Edmondson, S34IONAL'OFFICES;,QVESTI,0N: Shall Moshe Lenske,Judy Tuttle,'Al Young ' Oregon's Constitution be amended to limit terms for UNITED STATES PRESIDENT-Lenora B:Fulani(New , Oregon legislators,statewide elected officers,and Alliance Party);VICE PRESIDENT—Maria Elizabeth' Oregon's U.S.'Congress members?(Vote Yes or No) Munoz(New Alliance Party);ELECTORS-,Rose Marie , 4 'BANS:;OPERATION OF TRIPLE TRUCK-TRAIL Borchers,Melissa Fisher,Sarah D.Lyons,Raymond Gerald 4 4i# ER'COMBINATIONS ON OREGON HIGHWAYS;`; Monroe,Barbara Soriano,Lilly Statzer;Pat G.Wagner ' "f yQUESTION: 'S 4,Oregon law be amended to ban the UNITED STATES PRESIDENT—Andre Marrou(L);VICE ' ' granting of permits for triple truck-trailer combina• PRESIDENT—Nancy Lord(L);ELECTORS—Kristdpher ' bons on Oregon highways?(Vote:Yes orNo) K.Barrett'Blair Bobier,Spencer Hicks Edward Marihart ' p ; o,S-CLOSES TROJAN UNTIL NUCLEAR WASTE, Tonie Nathan,Fred Oerther,Jon E.Zimmer ar x COST,EARTHQUAKE,HEALTH CONDITIONS UNITED STATES PRESIDENT-Ross Perot(Independent MET;QUESTION: Shall Trojan nuclear power plant Initiative Party of Oregon);VICE PRESIDENT- Tames operation be barred until permanent federal waste site Stockdale'(Independent Initiative Party of Oregon); is licensed,other conditions met?(Vote-Yes or No) ELECTORS—Sherman Alldredge,'Charles H.Boggess,C. No.67 BANS TROJAN POWER OPERATION UNLESS. Halvorson,Richard Tarnutzer,Deborah M.Thomas,Edwin EARTHQUAKE,WASTE STORAGE CONDITIONS S.Thomas,William J.Welch MET'QUESTION: Shall law ban Trojan nuclear'. UNITED b STATES SENATOR—(Vote or One�Les AuCoin'1 t power plant operation unless plant meets earth earthquake,, f standards,and until permanent waste storage site UNITED STATES REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS, available?(Vote'Yes or No) "` ' ' '' `' ' SECOND DISTRICT-(Vote for One)—Denzel Ferguson ,• No.7-RAISES TAX LIMIT ON CERTAIN PROPERTY, (D);Robert F.(Bob)Smith(R.) UES- SECRETARY OF.STA TE-{Vote fo Q r Ones-Phil Keisling(D); RESIDENTIAL RENTERS'TAX RELIEF TION:'Shall constitutional property tax limit for prop- Sarah D.Lyons'(New Alliance Party);Randy Miller(R), erty other than owner-occupied residential property be Shaun Savage(L) ?? increased,residential renters receive tax relief?(Vote STATE TREASURER-(Vote for One)—Rose'Marie Borchers: Yes or lVo) s;. (New Alliance Party);David Chen(R);Jim Hill(D) No.B-RESTRICTS'LOWER COLUMBIA FISH HAR- ATTORNEY GENERAL--(Vote for One)-Ted Kulongoski VESTS TO MOST SELECTIVE MEANS AVAIL,' ` (D);Fred Oerther(L);Rich Rodeman(R) "' ABLE;QUESTION: Shall state law restrict lower STATE SENATOR,TWENTY-SEVENTH DISTRICT— Columbia River fishing to most selective means avail- (Vote for One)-Neil R.Bryant(R);Bob Pickard(D),- :..• able,to allow release of non-targeted fish unharmed? STATE REPRESENTATIVE,FIFi`Y-FOURTH (Vote Yes or No) DISTRICT--{Vote for One�Marge Garrow(D);Dennis R. No:9—AMENDS'CONSTITUTION:GOVERNMENT CAN- Luke(R) NOT FACILITATE,MUST DISCOURAGE HOMO- STATE REPRESENTATIVE,FIFTY-FIFTH DISTRICT— SEXUALITY,OTHER"BEHAVIORS";QUESTION,.-Q -(Vote for One)—Beverly Clarno(R) -Shall constitution be amended to require that all gov- ernments discourage homosexuality;other listed"' ' "behaviors,".and not facilitate or recognize,them?(vote' NO PARTISAN :CANDIDATES Yes or No) JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT,POSITION SEVEN--(Vote for One)—Susan Graber JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS,POSITION FIVE—{Vote for One)—Robert D.Durham _.. f 4 . • N�a 4 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet r - • i 1 Y xY 1 r 1 1 r :z 1 S s( r r w The State of Oregon has attempted to•correct spelling errors, but is not-responsible for grammar, ', syntax or inaccuracies of measure arguments- 5 : >s tti�T. wIt V PAT- �' '' uOtfiaal 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet 0 W. N aINUED . ,STATE OF:' WasureN,0. 1 ` >OREGON • . SENATE JOINT'RESOIAMON 13—Referred to the"Electorate SECTION 4.Ad valorem taxes shall be levied;annual] of Oregon by the i991!Legislature;to be voted on at the General upon all of the taxable property ini the State of Oregon;in s�iffi ` Election,November 3' 9WRI, cient a mounts to provide for payment of principal and�� •of the bonds issued pursuant to this Article..Revenues oBALLOTI��Et: State Parks and Recreation Department, s ants P t,!3 .grants from the -TF Federal Gdvernment and other user charges and assessments may be used for the payment of indebtedness incurred b the .;..:..:....:... .:,•. N C 1) RI 'lJTI4ly< :::::::«:>::::.:::.. state,and the interest thereon.The Legislative Assembly may �: ::: :;'. ''::`?': provide other revenues to supplement or replace,in'whole or in t. •:..........:., such 'e `� ..•;..!:.�:.;:::.,::..:;:r;:.:.;:.:::;::..::.::.::.;:.:.:.::.;;:;.. art tax levies. .;,. s£ 3`ldstitlit9ditl aUG4v;mite :' ►".�� SECTION 5.The Legislative Assembl shall en ::........,.<,o�x::..;..;... Y act legisla .......... #Lp iCOs$ j*E3uloa: n tion to carry out the provisions of this Article. This Article liL►111t1&1 j9 k I 1@GKfiA ki f#G119tleS� su rsedes an conflicting provision of a county or city charter Pe Y g 1� nde Oren C,cy' gotztutiosa :1. oul TQ or act of incorporation. :, <i S ;:: ►Y: A�84E�:: p 'l�oWc gees >:>.<>'> : PARAGRAPH 2.The amendment proposed b this resolu- tion shall be submitted to the people for their approval or rejec- ` 1t nt l «? d<tiri v]t ►nl�±be tied ti on at the next regular general election held throughout this ' e �npnaepk of:ate & !stem and :< state. t:atn #ra dad xecratonal fatte :aeaouat � 1eWusg0as Ad valorem taxes ors all taxable prop: EXPLANATORY,STATEMENT e #u te, ate: !?rld.:ggaxaptee bond repapinent R biutt.L xt"fEtli;...t�k...... This measure amends the Oregon Constitution to allow the g €aetvdingparTcu,�erfees state to incur debt by selling general obligation bonds for up to aTp1 I '-1'Tuimtxte nd.million for a State Parks and Recreation Development �ippat*e erfss?Rdi?#es:an: : ari ;auorl $ The money m this fund would be used for iris developing, acquiring, P g, at+paypxul ato i n b detsrrtaed maintaining or improving: Be It Resolved b the Le Areas of natural, scenic, cultural, historic or recreational of Oregron. . . . y Legislative Assembly of the State ;`value; • State parks and overnight camping and recreational facili PARAGRAPH 1.The Constitution of the State of Oregon is ties; amended by creating a new Article to be known as Article XI-K Fish and wildlife habitat and spawning areas;and fish and ' and to read wildlife viewing areas. ARTICLE XI-K One goal of the measure is to assure an easily accessible state SECTION 1.(1)Notwithstanding the limits contained in camping and recreation facility section 7,Article XI of this Constitution,the credit of the State Pm8 ty in each county in the state. of Oregon may be loaned and indebtedness incurred in an if bends are issued,the measure authorizes repayment of the amount not to exceed$250 million,for the purpose of creating a, principal federal and interest on the bonds with park user fees,gifts, fund to be known as the State Parks and Recreation 'federal grants,or general state tax revenues provided by the DevelopmerstFund. Legislature.If those monies are not available,repayment of the (2)This fund shall be used to provide funds to be advanced, bond principal and interest is guaranteed by a statewide prop- (2) ax,as is the case with any general obligation bonds issued by contract,grant,loan or otherwise,for the purpose of finance by the state. mg The measure directs the Legislative,Assembly to enact laws .z (a)The acquisition, development and maintenance of sites necessary to carry out the provisions of this amendment. The and areas of outstanding natural,'scenic,cultural,historic or terms of issuing the bonds relating to interest' duration and recreational value; • refinance will be controlled by state laws applying to all bends { (b)The acquisition;development and maintenance of the issued by the state. ; state park,system, and the creation of overnight camping and recreational facilities in each county'of this state,with empha- Committee Members: sis on easy access to all the people of the State of and Appointed by: (c)The aaluisition, development`and enhancement of fish Senator John Kitzhaber President of the Senate and wildlife habitat and spawning RePre sentative Bob Shiprack Speaker of the House p ning areas and"fish and wildlife Representative Liz VanLeeuwen Secretary of State viewing areas in cooperation with the State Department of Fish Marjorie Ehry Secretary of State and Wildlife. Dave Moss Members of the Committee SECTION 2.Bonds of the State of Oregon containing a direct promise on behalf of the state to pay the face value there- of,with the interest therein provided for,may be issued to an ' amount authorized by section of this Article for the purpose of creating such fund.The bonds shall be a direct obligation of the (This Committee was appointed to provide an Impartial explanation of the state and shall be in such form and shall run for periods of time ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251215.) and bear such rates of interest as provided by statute. ; SECTION,3. Refunding bonds may be issued under authority of sections,l and.2 of this Art icle:There may be ` issued and outstanding at any bonds aggregating the amount.authorized by section,l'of this Article but at no time + shall the total of all bonds outstanding,including refunding bonds,exceed the amount so authorized 6 ; • Offiaal 1992 General Voters'Pam hiet • , CONTINUED. t Measure No,,, I STATE OF ,OREGON l C ;ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT ARGUMENT IN'FAVOR OREGON'S HERITAGE—OUA JpARKS—ARE WORTH t PROTECTING KEEP OREGON LIVABLE, VOTE"YES"ON MEASURE i In an effort to preserve some of Oregon's most scenic,historic and natural landscapes for public recreational use and wildlife. Oregon remains one of the nation's most livable states..We, enhancement the Oregon Legislature is askin for bondin maintain this livability because of a strong commitment�to"an. g g adequate infrastructure system,including'our admired,state. authority in,the,amount of$250 million on behalf of State Parks. parks. Oregonians . .' . Oregonians have pioneered innovative and aggressive methods of protecting our state's heritage and natural be auty. Several Maintaining Oregon's system of state parks is just a'important initiatives,like Oregon's Beach Bill;are now the hallmark of to the economic and social growth of the-state as maintaining' , this tradition and ensure recreational opportunities along the our highways,roads and bridges. Our parks system provides state's entire 362-mile coastline. people access to the natural beauty of the state—allowing a bal Unfortunately,Oregon's park system is'at a crossroads. The ance between appreciation,preservation and utilization. state hasn't added a major new park in over twenty years,yet park use has increased by over 75 percent,,Federal and state For more than a decade,Oregonians have maintained their general fund support haven't kept pace with the deterioration highways,.roads and bridges through a dedicated Highway" and maintenance needs of state park facilities. Trust Fund. Ballot Measure 1 will provide money to rehabilitate our park system and meet future needs in all parts.of the state. These A similar commitment to the State's Park system is now need- fVnds will be used for: ed, with the approval of dedicated State Parks and Recreation • Improvement and restoration of existing park facilities Development Fund • Acquisition of outstanding natural,scenic, recreational and historic areas Vote M on MEASURE i to complete our commitment to Increased public access to rivers and other water-related Oregon's infrastructure. recreation • Development of new parks,campgrounds and trails Acquisition and development of fish and wildlife habitat (This Information fumished by Jay'M'hor,'Chair,Oregonians For Good State parks are an important component of Oregon's economic Roads.) health.State parks draw over 40 milli on.visits per year,gener- ating more than$350 million in annual visitor spending.Yet, our state parks operating budget per.visitor ranks 49th out of the 50 states. 'Now is the time to act.Oregon needs to preserve its natural and historic heritage.The parks system has been neglected for twenty years. Ballot Measure 1 is our best opportunity to reverse this decline: We have a chance to reinvest in Oregon's heritage--our parks. Let's continue the vision,protect our future,and create a livable atmosphere for our children Committee Members: / Appointed by: Senator Paul Phillips. President of the Senate Representative Jeff Gilmour Speaker of the House; Representative John Schoon Speaker of the House (This Joint Legislative Committee appointed to provide legislative argu- ment in support of the ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251.245.) (This space purchased for,$306 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse-. ment by the State of Oregon.,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 7 ' x A,04Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet s� CONTINUED �G�.STATEOF rg MeasureNo1 ¢ "OREGON n . y ARGUMENTIN AVOR ARGUMENT INFAVOR`' MEAS ,-X"S OREGON JOBS STATE PARKS ARE BIG MONEY-MAKERS r� zio s< FOR OREGON Every year;there are`.40 million visitors to Oregon State Parks. '' In fact,two-thirds°of'all;Oregon pleasure travelers visit a state As the former Director of Tourism in the Oregon Department of park:Ancl,svey�visit'pnts`needed money into the economy.The Economic Development,I know how important our State Parks average'idutof-state"'visitor'to'a state park spends $44 a day, are to the wellbeing of the Oregon economy.An impressive Within+2Smiles of the park. Overall;the average out-of-state two-thirds of,all pleasure travelers in Oregon visit a state park. travelingp'arty in:;Oregon spends a total of$135:every day In fact,State Parks host 40 million visitors a year.And Park (1989 Oregon,Travel'and Tourism Report).That money means visitors end money—well over$Soo million a ear—in ,lobs for Ore�omans �' y y � communities all over Oregon. I STATE PARK VISITORS SPEND MORE THAN ,t PARK CROWDS ARE UP MLL.LION IN OREGON'S COMMUNITIES BUT MAINTENANCE IS FALLING BEHIND While the number of visitors to Oregon Parks 6 jumped Nearly all State Parks'reservation campsites are booked by million,m I0.years,Park maintenance hasn't kept up.Not one June 1st of each year.Because day use has increased dramati, major'new State Park has been added in 20 years, so many cally in recent years,Park maintenance is falling behind.The Parks must'now turn visitors away.It makes no sense to let State Parks'operating budget per visitor ranks 49th out of all Parks that put more than$300 million a year,into the 50 states.There has been no new major park development in 20 I go downhill, years.Projected population growth of 700,000 in the next 20 years will increase demand for parks and natural areas even` MEASURE 1 IS A WISE INVESTMENT IN more.It makes no sense to turn our backs on a park Sys-' PARKS AND NATURAL AREAS tem that puts more than$300 million into the economy, every year,because many of these needed dollars go'into Measure I allows,bonds to be sold for investment in a 20-year communities hard hit by the decline of other industries. plan of maintenance and improvements to camping and recre- ational facilities statewide.I MEASURE 1 Important fish and wildlife habitat WIM KEEP PARKS' a would also be purchased and protected before it's too late. WORKING FOR US AND FOR OUR CHILDREN VOTE YES ON MEASURE 1 Measure 1 permits State Parks to sell bonds to support a care VOTE YES FOR THE ECONOMY fully-developed 20-year plan to protect,and develop parks"nat- ural areas and wildlife habitat. Support Oregon State Parks. John D.Gray We owe it to ourselves,to our children and to our grandchih dren: Chairman,Grayco Industries,Inc. L.L.(Stub)Stewart �' VOTES ON MEASURE 1 Former Chairman,Bohemia,Inc.(Forest Products) Deborah E.Kennedy Former Tourism Director Don C.Frisbee Oregon Economic Development' Chairman,PacifiCorp, 1 (This information furnished by Debby Kennedy,YES on A�1 for Parks and (This information furnished by Don C.Frisbee,Chairman,PaciriCorp, Jobs.) YES on#1 for Parks and Jobs) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) e The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The rinti argument j; ment 6y the State,of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the P ng of this does not constitute an endorse- acouracy or.truth of any statement made in the a ment�'the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the rgumend• accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. + $ vial 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUEb ' Fe asure No. 0 EGONF 9 ,, �i ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN,,FAVOR OREGON'S FISH AND WILDLIFE ; HABITAT IS THREATENED The Friends of Oregon State Parks urge you to When Lewis and Clark travelled to Oregon„much of the VOTE��ON11�ASiE'l for 3 good reasons:; + Willamette Valley was wetland habitat. Today, 98% of the native habitat in the Valley has been lost,and half of the state's REASON#1:MEASURE 1 MAKES GOOD wetlands are gone.Many species of wildlife have also disap- ECONOMIC SENSE, ; peared.We must preserve our scarce fish and wildlife habitat now. State Park visitors spend over$300 million in Oregon each year. This boosts local economies and creates jobs. Measure 1 will allow Oregonians to purchase and develop fish and wildlife habitat,save natural areas and improve the State Oregon State Parks are crowded. They get'more use than Parks system, parks in 46 other states. In fact,75%of State Park reservation campgrounds are booked by June 1st. WHATS GOOD FOR WILDLIFE HABITAT_ is GOOD FOR OREGON'S ECONOMY. Without Measure 1,Park facilities will remain overcrowded. Quality habitat offers numerous recreational opportunities, Aging structures and facilities will deteriorate further. Prime from fishing and birdwatching,to hiking and wildlife viewingproperty, will be sold or lost forever to development as land'costs ' Coastal estuaries serve as nurseries for our native salmon. soar'and increased costs will make future park construction too Freshwater wetlands provide nesting habitat for ducks and expensive. geese and a resting place for migratory birds. • REASON #2o MEASUREi WILL PRESERVE OUR According to a recent survey RESOURCES r' y(Intercept Research Corporation, 1988),Oregonians spend$522.9 million a year'for recreational activities related to the enjoyment of fish and wildlife.By pre- State Parks preserve Oregon's landscape,its rich pioneer histo- y` serving our wildlife habitat, Measure 1 will also enhance ry,and fish and wildlife habitat. Oregon's population is expect Oregon's ecenomy. ed•to grow by over 700,000 in the next 20 years,putting adds tional demands on facilities that, in many cases,are 3045 ` Oregon's natural resources are the state's greatest tourist years old. Measure 1 will provide funding to meet the challenge attraction. Two-thirds of all pleasure travelers visit State of both in-state population growth and out-of-state tourism Parks.State Park visitors contribute over$300 million a year to growth.'We must protect the best of Oregon. Oregon's economy. .i , REASON#3:MEASURE 1 SAVER PARKS AND Measure 1 is good for Oregon's fish and wildlife— NATURAL AREAS FOR FUTURE GENERAT IONS and good for Oregon's economy. Our generation has a responsibility to our children and grand- VOTE ON MEASURE 1 children. We must act today to protect parklands,.fish and Wildlife habitat, and outstanding natural, scenic, recreational, cultural and historic-areas. - Sara Vickerman Tony Lasko Defenders of Wildlife Wetlands Conservancy VOTE YES ON MEASURE 1 , Paul Ketcham Anna Goldrich Ruth Pennington Audubon Society of Oregon League of Oregon State Parks Friends Groups Portland Conservation Voters (This information fumished by Ruth Pennington,Representative,Oregon (This information furnished by Sara Vickerman,Director of State State Parks Friends Groups.) Conservation,Defenders of Wildlife.) i r (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS.251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255) 3 The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- /17te printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse i ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the,. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of anystatement made in the argument,,;=n* Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet a: CONTINUED Me asure I�IO OREGON . :1 STATE OF ` ARGUMENT]WFAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR PROTECTFISHAND WILDLIFE HABITAT VOTE YES FOR STATE PARKSI, .�.BT�'ORE IT'i4 GONE FOREVER - • ;, The Trust for Public Land supports Measure 1 to protect our Oregon's'p.pulation'i@ expected to Lmcrease by another 259'0'in natural areas and create parks for public enjoyment.We, just 20 years;.i tting,'additional"demands on-wildlife habitat, haven't created a single major new state park"for,our''State m parks;*and+6ther'"natural.resources. Our•generation has a 20 years.Now is the time to protect the best of Oregon before it ' respo )6`'adequately maintain our existing parks and to sli ps away forever. purchas;;,A evelop`mpre natural areas and parks for our 'chit and grandchildren to enjoy. r PASS ON THE OREGON WE'VE ENJOYED TO , THE NEXT GENERATION MEASURE"i SUPPORTS A PLAN �� ` ` ITOPROTECTNATURALAREAS Oregon's population is expected to increase by another 259'o in ' ............ , " ' xox' * , just 20 years—putting additional demands on parks.We're the Measure 1 supports a ]an that will restore and ac beneficiaries of a alit of life created b p quire fish Y y previous generations. rF, =and;%ildlife,habitat,develop visitor centers and wildlife inter- It's our turn to create the additional parks needed by our chrl- *.� $pretive'programs.Aging park,facilities'will be repaired, and dren and grandchildren. addrtional outdoor recreational facilities'will be expanded.We �ws ,f; need to prefect the best of Oregon before it slips away forever. OREGON PARKS ATTRACT. P ' OVER 40 MILLION VISITORS EACH YEAR :OREGON PARKS VISITORS SPEND OVER F $300 MILLION A YEAR That's an impressive statistic.Measure 1 will support develop- ment of visitor and wildlife interpretive centers.Creating more That's right;Parks and natural areas are among Oregon's most parks and repairing aging facilities means we can preserve our - popular tourist attractions. It makes no sense to turn our best places and continue to attract visitors who help create,jobs. backs on our State Parks, when park visitors spend more than$300 million every year in Oregon communi- OREGON PARKS VISITORS SPEND ties. OVER$300 MILLION A YEAR`l VOTE FOR WILDLIFE HABITAT PARKS fl -AND THE ECONOMY That's right!Parks and natural areas are among Oregon's most L' popular tourist attractions.It makes sense to support our State pi Parks when park visitors spend more than$300 million every VOTE ON MEASURE 1 year in Oregon communities.A Xgg.vote on Measure 1 is a'wise ' - investment for Oregon's economy. Stan Geffen President . . VOTE YES FOR PARKS,PEOPLE, Geffen,Masher&Company,P.C. AND THE ECONOMY! VOTE XM ON MEASURE 1 (This Information furnished by Stan Geffen,President,Geffen,Masher& Bowen Blair Jr. Company,P.C.,YES on X71 for Parks and Jobs.) Director Oregon Field Office The Trust For Public Land (This information furnished by Bowen Blair,Jr.,Director,Oregon Field O/Bce,The Trust for Public Land) (This space-purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) ` (This space Purchased for$3o0 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the rent by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 10 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet f 1. CONTINUED STATE OF Wasure No. 1 z OREGON IV ARGUMENT IN,FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR WE HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY TO OUR CHILDREN MEASURE,1 IS AN DNESTMENT IN OREGON.+ Earlier generations of Oregonians had the foresight to create .Measure 1—placed on the No 1992 ballot by the Oregon one of the forest State Park systems in the nation.It's up to us Legislature—is an investment in the Oregon State,Parks sys- to ensure that our children and grandchildren will have the tem.As members of the South Coast business,community,,we same opportunities to enjoy and use what we take for granted. urge all citizens to vote Our generation has a responsibility to-preserve and protect on Measure,l: »� these natural areas for our cgdren and grandchildren to enjoy. The Parks system is at a crossroads.The State hasn't added a major new park in over 20 years,yet park use has increased Now Measure 1 gives us a tremendous opportunity to meet this by nearly 70%. State general fund support hasn't;kept pace responsibility. Funds will be used to purchase and maintain with the deterioration and maintenance needs of State Park `} natural areas,parks,and fish and wildlife habitat. facilities—and projected population increases of over 700,000 in the next 20 years.will only make matters worse., PARKS ARE GOOD BUSINESS State Parks are an important part of the"economic'healthof our Ranked as the"number#1 tourist attraction in Oregon,'State local wmmunities and our state.State Parks draw over 40 mil- Parks had 40 million visitors last year.Park visitors spend over lion visitors every yeah—with the majority of pleasure travelers $300 million every year.Yet overuse and lack of funding threat siting the Oregon Coast:Parks visitors'generate more than en this vital economic resource.If visitors don't have a,quality $300 million in our communities every year.With the decline in experience in our parks they'll go elsewhere.We can't ignore timber and fishing, we need a strong tourism industry more this important economic resource. than ever. VOTE=ON MEASURE 1 We must act now.We must preserve Oregon's natural,and his- VOTE=FOR OUR ECONOMY TODAY AND toric heritage.We must reinvest in Oregon's,heritage—our, ' parks.Let's continue the vision,protect our future,and provide OUR CHII.DREN'S TOMORROW a high quality life for our children. T' John R.Emrick VOTE YES ON MEASURE 1 f Former State Parks Advisory Committee Member Chairman of Norm Thompson Outfitters , Zricia Shreck Bay Area Chamber of Commerce House of Myrtlewood,Coos.Bay (This information furnished by John R.Emrick,"Chairman,Norm Esther Reynolds Beverly Saukko Thompson Outfitters.) Yn Y Carl's Jr.of Coos Bay Red Lion Inn,Coos Bay Ann KoPPy Beverly Rice. r North Bend Coos Bay (This Information furnished by Triaa Shreck,Bay Area Chamber of Commerce.) f (Th/s space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or,truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth'of any statement made'in the argument.. i I Offiaal 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet - ..x , CONTINUED "STATE OF Measure' No. 1 ,',OREGON , ARGUMENTwIN FAVORS �° ARGUMENT IN FAVOR TEN_GOOD REASONS TO SUPPORT MEASURE 1: OREGON'S PARKS-OREGON'S PRIDE THEY DESERVE OUR SUPPORT L PubhGOCeaa beaches and beach access How often do ou have the opportunity ' � '�"`': a�a' �'�� •� Y pportunit to make areal differ- 2 Ht7ung,bilnng and horseback trails.; ence?A difference for your state, a difference for you and,per ha s most i m p ortantl y ,a difference.for generations to come? r�3^*Cam unda'and camping sites. Your support of Measure 1 will make a real difference by:.' -40Y �areas and shelters. w Protecting and enhancing a$300 million'econo' asset in � °`.5lashing,boating,canoeing and windsurfing facilities. Oregon . x'r 1 Investing in fisheries and wildlife habitat so important to f 6.b�iistonc sites and lighthouses, Oregon •• Providing the needed resources to improve Oregon's valu- able Park system ,Special scenic and natural places. Demonstrating your personal pride in Oregon Willamette Greenway sites and protection of 20 State, State Parks have a tremendous impact on`Oregoes livability Scenic Waterways,including 19 rivers and one lake. and economy. Oregon's great parks heritage generates both ; k f pride and money. 9 Wildlife viewvig areas. x;.!L Passage of Measure 1 will allow Oregon to re-invest in our itl.flew parks in urban and rural Oregon to preserve Parks system, generating'a greater return,and providing for scenery and provide recreation badly needed improvements: a II , "Protect the Best of Oregon',,NOW, Please join us in protecting Oregon's most valuable cemmodi- If before it's too late. ty—its natural beauty and resources.'Re-invest in Oregon to `= protect a key economic resource for Oregon.Vote YES for PLEASE VOTE Measure 1 to demonstrate your pride in Oregon. M ON MEASURE 1 a FOR OREGON STATE PARKS. Oregon;can't wait.A _ IM vote for Measure 1 will result in a more livable,economically competitive state. .' ' Brian Booth Gwyneth Gamble Booth Senator Paul Phillips Portland Senator Dick Springer Representative Bob Shiprack Senate President John A.Kitzhaber (This information furnished by Brian Booth and Gwynath Gamble Booth.) (This information fumishad by Senator Paul Phillips.) (This space purchased foi S300In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this a�g,ment does not constitute an endorse_ The rind ment by the State of on,nor does the state'warrant the printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse accuracy or truth of atererit ma de in"the a ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state tuarmnt the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. `12 ` Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED } STATE OF" Measure N x O. 1 OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR, ARGUMENT IN FAVOR, Y ; TIC STATE PARKS SYSTEM IS OREGON'S Measure 1 is important for Oregonians to support for two major NUMBER#1 TOURIST ATTRACTION. ` _ economic reasons:1)The Oregon State Parks system repro. ; sents a multi-million dollar investment that currently Two-thirds of all out-of-state tourists visit at least one park dur- generates over$300,000,000 every year in visitor spend- ing their stay. Combined with other state park visitors, they ing; 2) Park visitor spending has a huge"multiplier spend over $300 million every year in Oregon communities. effect, at-over$500 million—in cities and Tourists,and the dollars they spend,are especially important in towns all over Oregon., Protecting and'enhancing this eco- coastal communities like Seaside—hard-hit by the decline of the nomic resource is vital if Oregon is'to be successful in diversify. timber and fishing industries: ing our economy and meeting the state's multi-billion dollar tourism objectives., OUR STATE PARKS ARE IN JEOPARDY State parks are a major tourist attraction for Oregon, drawing over 40 million visitors per year. Oregon Tourism Because of Oregon tourism has grown at the remarkable rate of Division's,1989 Oregon Travel and Tourism Visitor Profile con- .53%from 1987-90(Oregon Tourism Division 5-Year Strategic firms the,popularity of State Parks reporting that over 6230 of Plan, 1992),the;very thing that tourists come to see is being Oregon visitors travel to or through at least one portion of the threatened by its popularity, coast. State'Parks, through the Beach Act, provides'public access,protection and management of this,vital,Oregon Usage of State Parks has increased nearly 70%over the last 20 resource, years,yet,not one major new park has been added during that same time period. The pressure on existing facilities is enor- In addition to providing the State's key tourism infrastructure, mous. Many of them are 30-35.years old.and are suffering the State Parks and Recreation Department protects and mangy from the strain of increased demand, ages over 1,600 miles of the state's scenic waterways and 400 miles of ocean beaches,habitat that is critical to the State's bil- ^ The problems of overcrowding and inadequate space will lion dollar fishing industry. Proper,management of these become even more dramatic as Oregon's popAlation increases important resources is vital to Oregon's,economic future.'.;, by 700,000 over the next 20 years. The population increase will accelerate the need for maintenance and repair. ,It also means As illustrated in the Oregon EconomicYDepartmenes 1989 ' added responsibilities for Parks in preserving Oregon's Coast Oregon Shines report, our state's"attractive physical environ- and rivers. ment and quality of life are a major competitive advantage in attracting entrepreneurs,professionals and firms that will MEASURE 1 IS GOOD FOR OUR ECONOMY drive Oregon's economy in the future." AND WILDLIFE. Finally,building capacity for our State's increasing population and catching up on twelve years of deferred maintenance of Oregon Parks also provide critical habitat for Oregon's fish and parks buildings,roads and facilities will result in the creation of wildlife. By voting IM on Measure 1 you will help maintain jobs and increased economic activity across the state.which is Oregon's rich diversity of plants,flowers,and fish and wildlife. good for the parks system;the Tourism Industry and Oregon's By voting IM on Measure 1 you will help provide jobs and a economy. strong economic base for Oregon. By voting IM on Measure `r 1 you will help provide the opportunity for our children to enjoy '! '> the same VOTE quality of life Oregonians have today. XM ON MEASURE 1 y ' VOTE ON MEASURE 1 Barbara Walker,2010 Committee FOR OREGON STATE PARKS. Lynn Newbry,2010 Committee Jane Hardy Cease,2010 Committee Doug Ray ,. Sandra Lazinka,2010 Committee Seaside Merchants Lucille Beck,former Member State Parks Advisory Board (This information furnished by Doug Ray,Seaside Merchants) (This Information tumished by'Barbara Walker,2010 Committee,YES on #1 for Parks and Jobs.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not Constitute an endorse- 'The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.". rA 13 j 1� 1 IT Olfidai 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet ,. h CONTINUED MrC�Sf' h R `STATE OF •\t A y U Pr NO■a J' OREGON ARGUMENT.INFAVORi " . i' ' ARGUMENT IN FAVOR x.: r The Nature Cohpservancq`Urges You to MEASURE 1 NEEDED ;OTE�an Measure 1. FOR LAKE AND STREAM ACCESS The Nature'.Conservancy:is a science-based,non-profit,conser- FOR FISHING AND BOATING vation`orgapi2atwn.We,.protectland in the most direct manner ' possibl -�.0my#'..The,Con$ervancy'currently owns and man. ages 5,61 preserves-t he'largest�private nature sanctuary:system As Oregon's population grows, so does the pressure on all our, ' in st :our ate :OPr'work is supported by 16,500 individuals and favorite outdoor recreation,spots. More"Private Property corpo rations across Oregon ' Keep Out signs have gone'up in places we thought;we'could j always use for access to our favorite lake or.stream Measure 1 ' is needed to protect access for fishing and boating. ,, Oregon is Losing Its Fish and Wildlife Habitat. We=�{nderstand the critical need to preserve Oregon's rich nat- VOTE FOR MEASURE 1 Ural heritage-'The diversity of,wildlife habitat—riparian areas $wetlands;--native grasslands and temperate rain forests-gives FOR FISH AND WII.DLIFE 'rs ;Aregon'thedistinction of being the fifth most biologically az ;diverse,state.in'Ahe nation. This natural diversity forms the Measure, will protect key areas'of fish'and wildlife habitat and basis,for what°makes Oregon special.Yet 0 mn's fish and spawning areas.If we don't not act now,the opportunity to pro- wildlife are declining and need our hgl'.'. tect these special places may be lost forever.Or'the cost years later to provide habitat will be'much higher.Oregon's wild fish :Oregon's economic strength is founded upon these diverse nat- and ansmals are depending on us to protect their homes. Ural resources:For example,our existing state parks contain an abundance of wildlife habitat while its visitors contribute more OREGON NEEDS MEASURE 1 ,than$300.million each year to the state's economy. Hunting, FOR TOURISM JOBS fishing and wildlife.'viewing contribute millions of additional dollars.Yet it's been more th n 20 y� re S'n a m{Ejor�ew n rk has been added to the Bute Park syqt_em. More and more people want to visit.Oregon just for the opportu- nity to see our bountiful fish and wildlife.Measure Twill be used to create fish and wildlife viewing areas.More visitors W"- y J^Measure 1 Will Protect Valuable means more jobs for Oregon's economy. Fish and Wildlife Habitat VOTE YES to'take`control'of the future of our state's natural PROTECT OUR FISH heritage.VOTE YES to build a portfolio'of fish and wildlife AND WII,DLIFE natural areas second to none in the nation.VOTE YES to pro' R THEY GONE teat the economic stability,our natural resources provide,for all Oregonians.VOTE YES to pass this rich natural legacy to our BY Passing Measure 1,Oregonians will help avoid the last ditch children and their children _ attempt' to save threatened species.We can save jobs and pro- ". vide a priceless Ad heritage for generations to come. For The Sake of Our Environment,Our Economy, OUr Fish an,d Wildlife,and Our Children and Ray Hemmingway, Grandchildren,VOTE=on Measure 1. President Oregon Trout Russell Hoeflich,Vice Presidene&State Director The Nature Conservancy (This information furnished by Roy Hemmhnghyay,President,Oregon I' Trout.) Director,oThe Nature furnished by Russell Hoeffich,Vice President&State Conservancy.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) � (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) } The printing of this argument dues not constitute an endorse x°°•. meet by the'State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the The Printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argumenl` ment�' State of Oregon;nor does the state'warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument., 14 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet f STATE OF M easure No. 1 OREGON [ ARGUMENT, IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION.; Jr' • SUPPORT STATE PARKS FOR Vote'M on Ballot Measure No.'l until state government can ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT meet its obligations without incurring long-term debt,and until there is a real need for more land for public,recreational uses The,Board of Directors of the Baker County Chamber of L Is there really a of O ., Commerce, representing 319 rural Ore more ark land?• t individuals full supports Oregon businesses and Y Pports Measure L 2. Who Wi114n�w for the amuisition_ development nn r,;;. tined maintenance? Maintaining,upgrading and establishing new-0regon State (User fees have never,to our knowledge,;paid for the Parks is important, not only as a recreation resource for cost.) Oregonians,but also as an economic development tool that helps our entire state. IS THEl?>•A NFF,TI?According'to official reports,'in Oregon there are: Oregon State.Parks are now drawing over 40 million visitors 223 state parks(90,000 acres) each year,generating more than$300 million in annual visitor `700 U.S Forest Service picnie areas and camp expenditures..These dollars help stabilize Oregon's rural econo- grounds my—an economy that is suffering due to diminished timber harvests and other industrial downturns. 97•:BIM picnic areas and campgrounds 20,412 acres of city yparks. Now is the time to i 33,675 acres of county parks nvest in the future of Oregon!s State Parks. N; Since tourism is the fastest growing industry.in the state, 1,829 miles of wild and scenic rivers plus"millions of Oregonians have an opportunity to capitalize on our state's, acres of federal land,available for recreational, u. greatest resource. use. Total public land available for'r creation'ia 10 74 acres for The development of tourist attractions such as the National every man-woman and child in the state, Historic Oregon.Trail Interpretive Center at Flagstaff Hill— which is drawing over 1200 visitors every day—is just one example of recreation and tourism working for Oregon: While WHO pA ?—Carefully read Section 4 of Measure No 1 which says that property taxes(ad valorem)SHALL BE levied'annu these visitors bring needed dollars to Baker County,they place: ally provide for payment of principal and interest:and that ' additional demands on the State Park system. fees,gifts,grants or the general fund ,,used, This prep erty tax would be in addition to the taxes you now pay because Let's invest in Oregon for Oregon! VOTE I=ON MEA- such bonding is not limited by Measure 5., The supporters of " SURE 1—give Oregon State Parks the ability to invest in our Ballot Measure No. 1 bonds are counting on diverting gas.taxes parks,natural areas and wildlife habitat. to'pay for the parks bonds. DON'T YOU COUNT ON IT! Lawrence D.Griffith Ballot Measure No 1 coupled with other legislation,passed to Executive Director implement it would authorize the state to issue.$250 million in Baker County Chamber of Commerce general obligation bonds continuously. Approval,of this mea- sure would make available in excess of$75 million continuously to the state to buy property..,This could remove a'great deal of ' land from private ownership and the'tax rolls and allow the (This Information furnished by Lawrence D.Griffith,Executive Director, state to condemn land in private ownership which the owners Baker County Chamber of Commerce.) may not wish to sell. , IS THIS THE TIME TO TAKE ON ADDED TAXPAYER OBLIGATION? Let's put our state on a sound financial footing ' before starting more spending programs. (Oregon Blue Book 91-92,'Legislative Library 8-92, Oregon Forests 90-91) 1 (This information furnished by Liz VanLeeuwen,State Representative, District 37,and O.E.(Denny)Jones,State Representative,District 60.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance Wth ORS 251.255) 1 � The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse-- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the 'ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in'the ergument • 15 i Offiaal 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet m CONTINUED easu rez OREG ON . it r 4"! SENATE JOINT RES04bTION412-Referred to the Electorate used for the propulsion of`motor vehicles,in,any one ` of Oregon by the 1991 LegisTature,'to be"'voted on at the General biennium. j Election,-November,3,1992,� PARAGRAPH 2.The amendment proposed by this res BALLOT TITLE a i f" olution shall be submitted to the people for their approval or �a r',t rejection at the next regular general election held throughout this state. .::..,(�.:::: p��:.;{':/:�•.7v��:{::/i A�-AQJG�Fr�1�VF..K. AVA\WJt�4V#FWli{ .. F1p Fl<lEL TAB MAY G4)TO % < NOTE: Boldfaced type indicates new language;[brackets –Us.q i;$, L"A1�►5t3tutf4Y►b£&me[id '�,+,�'[� and italic]type indicates deletions or comments. tali di tee edtQ allots Ysslature to dedicate futuremotar vehr� x. cle psi ta>�incxsaaaes Ti state park puxpesea7 SI)'M11 i A1......NA4menda f3regan Constitutzon, the NQ G4ti$tlstu► A4oW lnxut�us¢of motor vebrcle Iuei ytcas,tao>xatruction a>xda��t � Ge of public' EXPLANATORY STATEMENT oa aid rodside rest areas..:'1'Izts:chemge..vpuld ailsW�W 000-aWr #o dedicate future rxicreases ua #ltel tAUtes for a pz...... e,development aad care 4f Motor fuel tax revenues are presently reserved in the :$tpte packs ap$necreatran sites sl tax mefeases State Constitution for,highway construction,reconstruction, f4xpaYlc&1tUxpoaB wouldbelaxni#edto two oekttS per improvement, repair, maintenance; operation and use, for gallon every two s 'I"he eh.... tivould not apply administrative expenses and for the retirement of bonds.With fuel taxesnorx:olleeted, the passage of Ballot Measure 2, some future motor:fuel tax ESTIMATE O>< INA�TCAL IMPA Nd utinueda re ete•fmancial xmpaet "The effect on re venues and venues could also be used to fund state parks and recreation- e�cpeudtres is depetldent uport legislative areas.Measure 2 itself does not impose a tax i ;...xx:::;; Po t would allow the Legislature the flexibility to increase future motor fuel taxes--a f Be It Resolved b the Le maximum of 2 cents per gallon every two years—for,the acqui- of Oregon:, Y . gislative Assembly,of the State ;sition, development,maintenance, care and use of state park ` g° and recreation sites.The tax revenue would have,to be specifi- µ PARAGRAPH 1. Section 3a,Article IX of the Oregon cally dedicated to parks and recreation sites by the Legislature Constitution;is amended to read: and be in addition to other fuel taxes. E, C,3a.(1)Except as provided in[subsection]subsec- tions(2);and (3)`of this section revenue from the following shall be used exclusively,for the construction, reconstruction, 4 improvement;repair,maintenance,operation and use of public Committee Members: Appointed by: highways,roads,,streets and Representative Bev Clarno Speaker of the House roadside rest areas in this'state. Senator Paul Phillips President of the Senate (a)Any tax levied on;with respect to,or measured by the Dell Isham, Secretary of State storage,withdrawal, use, sale, distribution, importation or Ray Phelps - Secretary of State receipt of motor vehicle fuel or any other product used for the Lynn Ironside Members of the Committee propulsion of motor vehicles;and (b)Any tax or excise levied on the ownership,operation . or use of motor vehicles. (2)Revenues described in subsection(1)of this section: (a)May'also be used for the cost of administration and This Committee was any refunds or credits authorized by law, appointed to provide an impartial explanation of the (b)May also be used for the retirement of bonds for ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251.215.) which such revenues have been pledged. (c)If from levies under paragraph(b)of subsection(1)of this section on campers; mobile homes, motor homes,travel trailers,snowmobiles,or like vehicles,may also be used for the acquisition, development, maintenance.or care of parks or recreation areas.' (d)If from levies under paragraph(b)of subsection(1)of this section on vehicles used or held out,for use for commercial Purposes,may also be used for enforcement of commercial vehi- cle weight,size,load;conformation and equipment regulation. r (3)Revenues described in paragraph(a)of subsec. tion(1) of this section may also be used for,acquisition, development,maintenance,care and use of state park and recreation sites if the revenues result from a tag that is specifically dedicated to those purposes and that is additional to any.tax described in paragraph (a) of rt. subsection(1)of this section that is in effect on the effec. k .tive date of this subsection- The Legislative Assembly. may.not;increase the tax described in. ara subsection(1)of this section for the P fPh.(a) of ; Purposes described ;e in this subsection by more than two cents per gallon of gasoline,and.an equivalent amount for other products 16 f AWL 1 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OF + b Measu e OREGON t� ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT . . - . ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ' The number,of people visiting Oregon State Parks nearly THEY ARE AT,IT AGAIN. The sis t to confuse hoMd. doubled from 1970 to,.1990(from,23.3 to 40.8;million visitors), owners, renters,farmers;and businessesmto'use HIGHWAY making our state parks system the largest tourist attraction in GAS TAXES FOR OTHER PURPOSES,than roads.Vote NO. the state.In that time,Oregon hasn't built or expanded a single Currently some Homeowners are',driving more than 92 miles park. to fill up with gas r Oregon's parks were built and maintained from the Why tax all of us 2 more cents per gallon?VOTE NO on 2.r. 1930's to 1980 with money from the gas tax.In 1980, voters required that y Your STATE LEGISLATORS WANT TO�'crack'the;constitu- requ' gas tax revenue be used only to build and main- tional safe"by CONFUSING us for use other tain roads. Ballot Measure 2 restores the historic source of than roads and funding for parks,without affecting the fun bridges•VOTE N0. g ding source for our roads.:-; THEY have tried to confuse we VOTERS to use gasoline taxes State parks are central to important tourism indus- for light rail,police,parks,and who knows whatelse Vote NO try.Nearly 213 of out-of-state travelers visit one of our 225 state on 2. ' parks during their trip,making our state parks the fourth heav- WHY are we homeowners,renters, farmers, and businesses .' iest attended in the nation.The.economic impact,the hard dol always picked on to levy$250 million in,higher property taxes lars.put into Oregon's economy by campers and visitors,.is over 'and GASOLINE TAXES?VOTE NO ' $350 million. Oregon has long supported"USER FEES",`so let the State Much ofahe variety unique to Oregon is found in our Legislators refer this to the Voters as a`user.fee".VOTE NO. 2. •state parks.From the beach wayside parks on our coast to the on '� : ' �'r, ` . •. .?� � � " ' '' scenic eastern Oregon campsite's,our state parks system makes ''Portland,Oregon;in July,1992,was as oiie of the high- what is best about Oregon accessible to every visitor who choos- "est priced gasoline per gallon cost in the STATE:OF OREGON. es to enjoy them.We must,however,care for our scenic and his- Why 2 more cents per gallon? toric parks if visitors are to continue to make that choice. VOTE NO ON 2, and stop tax increases on gasoline for Only'three other states;have more people using their parks.VOTE NO ON 2 and prevent:THEM from"cracking the parks,'yet our operating budget per visitor ranks 49th out of 50 'constitutional;safe"which keeps gasoline taxes:forhighways, states. Overcrowding coupled with the reduction,in,funding market roads,and bridges::., :over the last decade place a great deal of stress on our parks. VOTE NO'on 2 and keep gasoline taxes,for'the`u`se approved , Ballot Measure 2 gives,us a real chance to support our by homeowners,renters, farmers and businesses:years`ago: i park system. On the`average, park systems,in other states ,Vote NO,stop the"constitutional safe crackers",and protect our receive half their dollars from'general fund sources. Oregon's dedicated Highway Tax Funds. spark system gets 15 percent of its budget from our general a fund,and there is little hope that will increase. In recent years we have seen this lack of fiinding take its (This information furnished by Clyde V.Brummell,President,'Oregon'�' toll on our parks.Some of our parks are on the verge of being Homeowners Association.) °abandoned in terms of simple maintenance and upkeep. We must secure the future of our parks,the centerpiece of our tourism industry. Please vote YES on Ballot Measure 2. Committee Members: Appointed by: Senator Dick Springer President of the Senate Representative Tim Josi Speaker of the House Representative Michael Nelson Speaker of the House (This Joint Legislative Committee appointed to provide legislative argu- ment in support of the ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251.245.) NO.ARGUMENTS IN FAVOR OF THIS BALLOT MEASURE WERE,FILED WITH THE SECRETARY OF STATE. (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this a rgu ment do es notconstitut e^ aneidorse-' ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state-warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 17 `Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No :2 STATE OF + r OREGON ARGUMENTIV OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ` ? ' MARE OUR HIGHWAYS SAFER_ DEDICATED GAS TAXES SAVE At1VOTE"NO"ON MEASURE 2 OREGON MOTORISTS'MONEY A"NO"voteo Measure 2 is a vote fa in safety. Don't turn the clock back on Oregon's roads and bridges.Vote In 1980,Oregonians voted NO"on Measure 2. fed to protect the state's dedicated fund constitutionally'Voters're-affirmed this commitment this past In 1980,the average Oregon driver spent an extra$233 each May inthe 1992 primary election by nearly a 2-to-I margin, year.in wasted motor-fuel, excessive tiro wear and vehicle repairs because 70 percent of the state's most heavily traveled Since 1980,Oregon's traffic accident rate has dropped by more roads were substandard(according to the Road.Information than 31 percent'and fatalities have declined more than 35 per- Program-TRIP.) cent- By voting to protect the state's dedicated Highway Fund consti- The timely maintenance of roads and bridges has a tremendous tutionally in 1980,Oregonians substantially improved the con' impact on traffic safety. dition of our roads.TRIP reports that over the past'10 years, substandard roads have decreased by 20 percent and,as a Resurfacing rough roads can reduce wet-pavement accidents b result,the annual cost to the average Oregon motorist has' ' 20,percent and widening road lanes b Y dropped to$111. �8 y just one foot decreases accidents by 23 percent, according to the Transportation "Research Board. But the job is far from complete.Nearly 50 percent of Oregon's most heavily traveled roads are still substandard.With high- As traffic demands on Oregon's road and bridge network grow, way travel growing by 35 percent the past decade and with fur_ r' so must the funding to meet,those demands.Measure 2 would ther growth forecast for the 1990s,Oregonians can ill afford to - allow state lawmakers to take'dedicated Highway Trust allow lawmakers to take dedicated Highway Trust funds from ` funds— g Y needed road and bridge improvements. your gas taxes- away.from needed road and bridge improvements..The impact on highway safety in Oregon would 'be dramatic.. Adequately maintaining our roads and bridges costs less than k' having to completely rebuild new ones. Improving Oregon's roads and bridges saves lives.Vote"NO" ' on MEASURE 2.and help protect your investment in Oregon's Vote"NO"on MEASURE 2 and keep our gas taxes working '+ highway safety. .. Y• for better roads. .'. y.. (This information furnished by Jay mini Chair,Oregonians for Good (This information furnished by Jay Minor,Chair,Oregonians for Good Roads.). Roads.), P L L i (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with OAS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance With ORS 251.255-) z The printing of this argument does not c=nal, 'Went by the State of Oregon,nor does tFpr:ng of this argument does not constitute an endorse. accuracy or truth of any statement made e State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the r truth of any statement made in the argument. 18 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ... STATE OF M easure No. 2 Y OREGON ��� � 3! ' `ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ` GOOD ROADS EWPR,01 OUR QUALITY OF LIFE ° A-NO"vote on Ballot Measure 2 is a vote for improved mobili- ty and abetter quality of life in Oregon.Since constitutionally w Protecting the state's dedicated Highway Fund in 1980,Oregon has been able to accommodate a 35 percent increase in highway travel over the,past 10 years while increasing highway.invest- ment byover 50 percent.This investment in.our future centin- , ues to create jobs and stimulate economic growth. Oregon's`population will grow$y 500,000 in the"next'decade. We need to insure the state's ability to provide safe and'efficient highways and maintain our current infrastructure.Road and bridge funding must be able to keep pace with the increased demands we are placing on the•system By'"allowing statWlawmakers to take dedicated Highway Trust - funds away,from road and bridge improvements, Oregonians could,face the kind of gridlock.,motorists face in other major r. cities. Clogged roads and bridges would result in longer com- r mutes,higher prices for,.the delivery of goods and services,and -reduced traffic safety. A-NO-vote on Measure 2.,does not reject the need to fund our state park system and this group supports the,previous mea- sure for setting aside dedicated bonds to fund state parks.' Vote'"NO"on MEASURE 2"and help'ensure the mobility and quality of life we have come to expect in Oregon. (This Information furnished by Jay Minor Chair,Oregonlans'for Good Roads.) (This space purchased,for$3001n accordance with ORS.251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by,the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 19, Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet y,:,.T CONTINUED' I M F STATE O F`OREGON Proposed by initiative petitaon to be voted on at'the General elected office or be appointed to. Elections November 3,1992 ` a a full term in such office would cause them,to violate th$limits' BALLOT TITLEk in this section. ; PARAGRAPH 2.SEVERABILITY.If an oft Act is r 'l his- held to be invalid for any reason,then the-re maining'parts shall L`ONB' 'O'1`1CQ1Vt�.Y11 Y't`f not be affected but shall remain in full force;and effect.-lf any:. TRRMB]�C)R part of this Act is held to be invalid;it is the expressed intent' the People of Oregon that their elected officials should res ct >BTATEWQI pFFX�'ES,COI�GRE>dSION the limits within this Act. PARAGRAPH'S. CONFLICTS WITH"OTHER BALLOT rs onstitutioXi amend' MEASURES.If there is an irreconcilable conflict between any l ed toii fqr jregoa legislators,statetv�de provision in this measure and a pro vision in'any other measure eft d.��.... axed Oregon's U s tnada tU amending the Oregon Constitution and passed-at the same elec. b tion then the provision contained in the measure receiving the S . !# "`lelpls Oregon Cot►stttutiojs pmts higlaestnumberof affirmative votes shall prevail. cleated offices duriir�g person's hfa PARAGRAPH 4.STANDING.Any person residing,iii.Oregon tines 1f:e app1 only to terms star tang afYaer mea• , X. ott.C or non-profit entity doing business in Oregon has standing.to, ] l t'B.gOkt legislature li ..t& 6 y0A1C8 r bring suit to enforce this measure in �►r>sa ol"..... entattx!. , 'k Senate.l2 total 8 xt is$years'f r,j ch state�vs elected nfI'ice ::...::..,.. Oregu��aa;ail�zu Ql;iT;S Oaa ycax s i b Ffottse ofEapresentatives,12 fieiiai e.No faints ? Tr�ua v# ces l3axs � rreW would eat�ead lbrlts AZ�ntztt s�z al: iern to f5ll vaca�acy f oounts.ns.fvll?term ESTATE OF b�I+TAI1iC I�I:E"A�Na#3aaai•:t�iai effect.... t ,AN ACT r 'Be It Enacted'bythe People of the State of Ore gon: PARAGRAPH-1. TERM LIMITS.The Constitution of the , State of Oregon is amended by creating new Sections 19 and 20 in Article II,to read: SECTION 19.Limits on Oregon Terms:To promote varied. representation,to broaden the opportunities for public service, # and to make the electoral process fairer by reducing the power of incumbency,terms in Oregon elected offices are limited as follows: `(1) No person shall serve,more-than six years in the Oregon House'of Representatives, eight years in the Oregon Senate, and twelve years in the Oregon Legislative Assembly in his or. 'her lifetime. (Z) No person shall serve more than eight years in each Oregon statewide_office in his or her lifetime: (3) Only terms'of service beginning after this Act goes into effect shall count towards the limits of this Section. (4) When a person is appointed or elected to fill a vacancy in office,then such service shall be counted as one term for the purposes of this Section O b A person shall not appear on the ballot as a candidate for elected office or be appointed to fill a vacancy in office if serving a full term in such office would cause them to violate the limit in this Section { (6) This Section does not apply to judicial offices. SECTION 20.Limits on Congressional Terms.To promote varied representation,to broaden the opportunities for public service,and to make the electoral process fairer by reducing the power of incumbency,terms in the United States Congress rep. resenting Oregon are limited as follows: '(1) No person shall represent Oregon for more than six years in the U.S-House of Representatives and twelve years in the U.S. Senate in his or her lifetime. (2) Only terms of service-beginning after this Act goes into effect shall count towards the limits of this Section. (3) When a person is appointed or elected to fill a vacancy in ,office,then such service shall be,counted as one term for thg purposes of this Section (4) A person shall not'appear on the ballot as a candidate for r 20 ^ Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet + .- M CONTINUED k Measure. No. 3 ORETE OF a 4✓ y GON EXPLANATORY STATEMENT ARGUMENT IN FAVOR: i This measure would amend Oregon's Constitution to add, National polls reveal that about 80%00 of voters favor limiting two new sections in Article H,which deals with"Suffrage and terms of politicians(Wall Street National Poll_April 17;•1992 ' Elections". One of the more'popular arguments of those oppos limits New Section 19 would limit the number of years that one is,"we already have a way to limits terms, we can just vote c person may serve in various Oregon elected bodies or offices. them out."But can we?The truth is that incumbents simply ' One person would not be able to serve more than six years have to many advantages over the lesser knownchallengers: ,. (three terms)in the Oregon House of Representatives, eight Consider these advantages;name recognition,extra media' y years(two terms)in the Oregon Senate,or more than 12 years attention,professional staffs, free travel,free mailing,(both of combined service in the Oregon Legislative Assembly(House paid for by the taxpayer)promises to bring"pork-barrel"pro- and Senate together)in his or her lifetime. One person would jects to the state, and probably most important,the ability to not be able to serve more than eight years(two terms)in each attract"special interests"campaign contributions.A study by Oregon statewide office in his or her lifetime.These limits do Common Cause reveals that Congressional incumbents each not apply to judgeships. received an average of$88,330,899 from special interests PACS a; The Oregon Constitution currently limits the Governor, while the average challenger received only$6,89$,631(News s Secretary of State, and State Treasurer to no more than eight Release, Common Cause,March 26; 1991). Special interests years of service out of 12.The Oregon Constitution does not cur- back winners not losers.Last election 96% of Congressional rently limit service by the Attorney General,the Commissioner House(The Heritage Foundation#291)members were re-elect- of Labor and Industries, or the Superintendent of Public ed,yet polls show only 17%of voters think Congress is doing a Instruction. The Oregon Constitution does not currently limit good job(Insight, November 26, 1990).So much for the"just service in the Legislative Assembly or in the U.S. Congress vote them out"theory. from Oregon., Surely abetter.educated electorate would help solve the New Section 20 would limit the number of years that one problem of entrenched incumbents but the voters are simply person may represent Oregon in the United States Congress. "turned off"to a system in which they feel their vote'doesn't One person would not be able to represent Oregon for more count for much.Nationally,less then 35%of eligible voters even than six years (three terms) in the U.S. House of bothered to go to the polls last.Congressional House election. Representatives and 12 years(two terms)in the U.S.Senate in (Vital Statistics on Congress,1991-92. his or her lifetime. Enactment of Term Limits will create'a re newed interest in . The following provisions apply to both new sections: the electoral process once again as candidates with fresh new • The term limits only apply to terms of service begin- ideas,to solve problems,compete for vacated seats. ring after this measure takes effect. VOTE YES ON MEASURE#3 • ` If a person is appointed or elected to fill a vacancy in Paid for by 12 Woodburn family owned businesses an office,then such service would count as one full term for the purposes of this measure. • A person could not appear on ballot as a candidate (This Information furnished by Clarence Volivs.) ' for office or be appointed to an office if their serving a full term in the office would violate this measure's lim- its. This measure would take effect December 3, 1992. For example,an incumbent or newly-elected member of the Oregon House of Representatives could serve three terms,the first beginning in January 1993.An incumbent U.S.Senator not up for election until 1996 could serve an additional two terms.An Oregon Secretary of State appointed to fill a vacancy in 1995 . could serve one subsequent full term. The measure provides that if any part of the Act is held to be invalid,then the remaining parts shall not be affected and shall remain in effect. i, Committee Members: Appointed by: Martin Buchanan Chief Petitioners Frank Eisenzimmer Chief Petitioners Ken Allen Secretary of State Cappi Eaton Secretary of State John Mitchell Members of the Committee (This Committee was appointed to provide an impartial explanation of the ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251.215.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 21 "Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet T CONTINUED M 3STATE OF OREGON , 1 ARGUMENT IR',YOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR i Opponents of Term`';Lzzmts,.xthe politicians,union lobbyists , This year,as in every election year,we hear the politicians and bureaucrats and all,who make their living t the expense of the a ers` g xP promise us change.Just re-elect them,they tell us, and times < taxp y ,aarguethat zf O.regon passes Term Limits on its will get better. But we have been re-electing them year after Congressional�'dale attori`the state will lose clout in Washington,D,Cy �' '` rn:� year and times are not getting better.For many,times are get ,.,,� r,.• ting worse, They are using scare tactics by trying to get voters to believe We can attribute most of our problems to the la that if Term Limits asses Ore P lack of political P Oregonians will be left at the mercy leadership at both the state and federal level.Our current elec- of those states'which have"not imposed similar limits. This is toral system is not working because today's career politicians simplyYa„tactic to`create a,'political perception and exploit the lack the courage to take creative,bold steps towards solving process to'their advantage, society's problems.They fear that they may offend one or more The;�way our cuzrent political system is set up,the longer a of the special interests that they depend on for financial contri_' Congressman is in o8ice the more seniority he/she accumulates. butions. The professional.politician's primary goal in life is to p :This'often:quilifies them to `serve on an important committee 'get re-elected at any cost. :which gives them the power,to direct pork barrel projects to If America is to remain a world leader we must get new lead- their'home"state,paid for by federal taxes,' with the money ers for America.'We simply cannot continue to allow the self taken from the other states. serving.professional politicians to raid the,treasury in order to ;,Oregon:ranks 50th in the nation on;the amount of money t buy the support of the Y PPQ special interests who get them re-elected. f� gets back from the Federal Government! So much"for clout. We cannot tolerate a$4 trillion national debt that is growing (The Oregonian,January 24,1991). at the rate of$l billion a day! + Term Limits is a national movement. It is expected that Enactment of term limits will get our political system out of 42,15 states will.be voting on Term Limits this election,includ- ”gridlock"! It will replace the self-serving professional politi- I ing California.Because national'polls'indicate that 803'o of vot cians with paid citizen volunteers willing to serve for a few ` ers`favor Term Limits;indications are that it'could pass is years and then return to their homes and businesses to live, every state where it is on the ballot.If this happens,about one- under the laws they pass.This was the vision of our Founding '. third of Congress will be limited They will use all the tools at Fathers. their disposal to see to it that the rest of Congress is brought Opponents contend that olitical e into line.When happens senioritywill meanlittle P xperience would r lost, that new members would not understand the system.Our reply Even after voters pass Term Limits they will not begin to go is that it is better to have experience at working within the day t into effect until after passage.Incumbents will still have several to day system of the real world than it is to have experience at years in office before they reach their limit.This will allow time wheelie and de for adjustment as we phase into a political system better suited hers will change tthe ssystemssomit works for all Americcans,zzmot to,twenty-first century politics in America just the powerful special interests. Vote Yes On Measure 13 'Change is coming,not from the politicians,but from the peo- ple.Support term limits.Vote Yes on Measure#3-' (This information furnished by Frank A.Eisenzimmer,Chief Petitioner, 'LIMITS'.) (This information furnished by Frank Eisenzimmer,Chief Petitioner, ` m/Ts..), h r A (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) This space Pace purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the,state warmnt the The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- accuracy or truth,of any statement made in the argument. �'the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the moment• accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 22 Official 1992 Goneral Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED ' No. 3 ' STATE rR�M r,., .E r a ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR— AN OPEN LETTER TO OREGON VOTERS NEW BLOOD OR STALE IDEAS— ' From Alan James When Oregon voters approved Measure Five two years ago a Candidate for Clackamas County Commissioner process was begun.The people began to take back their govern went from special interests and career politicians: Dear Oregon Voter: This year we`can continue that process by passing Ballot Measure#3. �+ My name is Alan James and Lam an Oregon businessman.I AYES vote on M easu re#3 will end government`ruled by the am also a candidate for Clackamas County Commissioner this same old crowd,of entrenched special interests and their old, November.Since I am running for public office,why would I use stale ideas.Measure#3 will bring a fresh"real world°perspec- this space to publicly urge your support of term limits for politi tive to government. clans?First,some background. But Measure #3 is more than'a statement aimed at career politicians.It's a statement of hope,and recognition that many Oregonians are well qualified and deserve the chance to serve.' I am not a politician.I have been a successful businessman for the last 30 years.While I have done lots of volunteer work,I have never run for public office.Over the years I have become WE NEVER PROMISED THESE GUYS A CAREER more and more dissatisfied with how our elected officials have ANYWAY— been running things., When our nation and state were founded,it was clear no one In Clackamas County it.seems like the politicians are more intended that anyone should-make a career of being a legisla- interested in winning the next election than in doing what is tor.But somewhere along the way we lost sight of that idea,and right.Time and time again the voters send a message that gov now have career lawmakers whose sole interest is self preserva- ernment needs to get by with less, only to have their elected tion.,With the election won,the concern becomes finding the officials increase taxes and expand budgets.Over and over citi- money to pay for the next campaign.The special interests with tens demand different priorities,only to find the politicians piles ofmoney find these cash-starved candidatehawmakers to ignoring their wishes. be easy prey._ Existing politicians have all the advantages.Elected officials MEASURE#3 MAKES YOU THE SPECIAL INTEREST— get free media coverage and have paid staff to keep their name before the public.Getting reelected is always their top priority, " with the people's needs lost in the shuffle. Good people don't There is a place for people who want to make government a run for public office because office holders hold all the cards. career...it's called civil.service.We owe a lot to those who have selflessly dedicated themselves to making•our governments So what do we do about this problem? run...but career legislators don't make the list. I Yes,there are career legislators who have given years of out- standing service to our state and nation.There are many oth- { As chairman'ofthe board of a major,Oregon transportation and ers,though,who have long forgotten from where they came. II manufacturing company I decided I.had some management Measure#3 tells these arrogant,out-of-touch career legisla- skills to offer the citizens of Clackamas County.I have taken a tors the free ride's over and,best of all, we,get'another little. leave of absence from my company to run for Clackamas piece of our government back. County Commissioner. But many other well qualified Oregonians won't take this step,unless the well entrenched career politicians are forcibly retired from their jobs. VOTE YES ON MEASURE#3 To solve this problem,to bring fresh new blood to Oregon gov- ernment and to keep current politicians from continuing to (This information furnished by State Representative Randy Miller.) ignore our concerns,I urge you to support the term limits ballot measure. Alan James . Businessman and Candidate for Clackamas County. Commissioner (This Information furnished by Alan James.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does`not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse-; ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state war ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the` accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. ` 23 ' Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet �!it rte' z. M o: ;3 oR GoN r 4 9 ARGUMENT INDOPPOSITION TERM LDUM VS.DEMOCRACY {,I We already.have,`term,limitations U.S.'Representatives' 'terms end'every two years;U.S°'Senators'terms end every six years, Stats':Representatives',terms end every two years, and State Senators'terms'end'every four years.At'these intervals, incumbentil must face the`voters and win their'active approval to return'to.office: Citizens who dislike their incumbents already have'the'tool neededtb'remove th6m'from'office—Ihft vile That's democracy. In'190$the Oregon Constitution was amended by our citizen 7tnitiative process to also include xv=U.of public officials'during :a term°of P B o&oe:':Toda "Ore niso e n of o Y� fifteen states in go only'fifteen �which the ofr apowerfuIinstrument gg�exists. `Artificial term limits are inherently undemocratic because they:deny voters a choice that is rightfully theirs.Restrictions on the freedom of citizens to;run for office and to vote for candi- dates they favor—and to do so as often as they care to-weaken two basic democratic rind les:nontiar consent an4 maiori- P �P ty rul8 Citizens'growing authority over their•own government has included extending the vote to former slaves and their heirs,to women, and to 18-..year-olds. The elimination',of property. requirements,poll taxes,and literacy tests for voters were also significant benchmark events.So too was the decision 80 years ago to permit voters rather than State Legislatures to elect U.S. Senators.The adoption of legislative term limits would oonsti- tuts a surrender of citizenat onatit utionally-yrotected electoral freedom. Rights freely given up arc never easily reclaimed LOSS OF EXPERIENCE By limiting terms of elected officials we will likely end up with a Congress and State,Legislature comprised of novices and trainees,Our elected representatives would lack the expe i rience,institutional memory,,wisdom,and judgment needed to govern effectively.Inevitably,this deficit would be reflected in the performance and work product of lawmakers which would become alarmingly less co�mnete_t; With Congressional and Legislative term limits, political dpower would flow away from our elected.representatives and toward experienced special interest j�gtg and_. NOTHING NEW More than 200 years ago our nation's Founding'Fathers unanimously rejected Congressional term limits.You can too— Vote NO on Me a,,,,,,No (This Information fumished by Steve Lanning,Political Education Coordinator,Oregon AFL-CIO,Committee on Political Education.) (This space purchased for S3oo in accordance with ORS 251.255.) ETP inting of this argument does not constitute an endorse- y the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the cy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 24 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No■ 4 STATE OF OREGON , Proposed by initiative petition to.be voted on,at the General length not in excess of 105 feet.The self-supporting trailers or," ' Election,November 3,1992. semitrailers must be reasonably uniform in length] : ''. BALLOT TITLE [t'3)](2)Vehicles or combinations of vehicles having a length C in excess of that permitted under ORS 818.060 or 818.090. [W](3)Any self-loading log truck.In the granting of permits' g `a � �...... ::,: : to vehicles descnbed.in this subsection, a granting authority shall observe and be governed by the following mum GON H[GHWAY�S AA'`IQTS 4N OIL loaded weights: " (a)The loaded weight of any individual wheel,:-axle or'tan- � STI4N-�"hsll 4regoxi luw be amended to biAt3 ::'<:#::;:: dem axles of any vehicle-or combination of vehicles shall the gr'ig*.of. ... is fortriple ira lr-tra ercaral i `` ` ..:..... exceed the maximum loaded wheel, axle and.tandem axle gations q11 Ore n ht w ? K The loaded weight of any group of axles of any vehicl go �7$ � weights set forth is Tables I'and II of ORS 818,010. ST �RX A e d�ct► u..law hat1 �+av�ld o ban thurantmg of var:anrs rmtts far veliele eam: :;.; (b) e r . Pe combination of vehicles,when the distance between the first Al tne#ude a motor truck weighing gver ................ :: ::::>.. and last axles of any group of axles is 18 feet or less, and the 13,400 po A.....ctt€twa$elf sub orting trailers,a a' <'> loaded weight of any vehicle when the distance between the truck tractor sn3 senutra�ler amng two self sap :. first and last axles of all of the axles.of the vehicle is 18 feet or" poxtmgtraiters ur sexaitxars AIJ varlaxl«e pertnxts Tess, shall not exceed that,set forth in the following table of' suthar�ait camb#WA.ift" : ...by ihxs:A�vu�il� weights, or the sum of the"permissible axle of tandem axle lie:ciacellec€oae Act's effective date The effectii ;'. :':;:«:: weights,whichever is less: :ths it eG tYOUId be ib farbrd the operatxoaa of trlipXe tr:icle frailer combmatuyns on( gon h:glways :<„: Distance in feet between Maximum loaded weight, €i].I I k'r�JP:k M..cr II�II'ACT art ��gd 94f :';:'.`.:;::.:.::;, the first and last axles in pounds,of any And paclteeT t'101fftex,8 aft Y11Cfeax9.Si3 reveruee >"' of any getup of axles of group of axles of any°. R..$330,.000 is d Alth l $40 000 of any vehicle or combination vehicle"or combination .fees would ba lost trlkple$r r ::were laaxinad Oti of vehicles or between the of vehicles or flregCwn lighays,tlxe tidditianalvVar tiiafts xi@esl ed first and last axles of all of any vehicle to haul gipgeail aoub$e traders caulcl'ge�era# '` ::«'>'` >: I alrit$ TO,©D 0h: regis�rttorx fie xevezrue fci the the axles of any vehicle: ibltc Vtil�ty Gbuim�ss2an The addR. aT truck 6 34,000 1T�ile&ale Expected tiD t08Ult laR$2 tilTlliS?Jk of raid ::':`': q 34,000 repair ennd mautsnar�ce casts Y the Depar#me�at'at ><•; ;:::::::::, (Transportation gash year,which.will be finsnaed.by 8 34,000 as ..aqua] unb--$2. aAtllxor -tyf welSltt•nne t ...::... 9 39,000 re��renu cvllectedbythe Pubhal ..:htl+..........v �ssion <: ': :: 10 40,000 .... :.. .. :.::.. .: .... 40,000 AN ACT 12 40,000 Relating to motor vehicles;creating new provisions;and amend- 13 40,000 ing ORS 818.210. 14 43,200 1 Be It Enacted by the People of the State of Oregon: 16 44,000 is " 44soo SECTION 1.Section 2 of this Act is added to and made a 17 45,600 part of ORS chapter 818. 18 50,000 ; SECTION 2.Notwithstanding any other provision of law,a road authority shall not issue a variance permit for any wmbi (c)The loaded weight of any vehicle or combination of vehi-. nation of vehicles that consists of a motor truck with a registra Iles,where the distance between the,first and last,axles of the, tion weight of more than 8,000 pounds and two self-supporting vehicle or combination of vehicles is more than 18 feet,shall not trailers or a truck tractor and semitrailer drawing two self-sup- exceed that set forth in the following table of weights,or the porting trailers or semitrailers mounted on dollies equipped sum of the permissible axle, tandem axle or'group of axles' with fifth wheels. weights,wh►ichever.is less: SECTION S.ORS 818.210,as amended by section 1,chapter Distance in feet Maximum loaded weight,., 261,Oregon Laws 1991(Enrolled Senate Bill 1201),and section between the first and in pounds,of any 5,chapter -Oregon Laws 1991(Enrolled House Bill 2223),is last axles of all the vehicle or combination amended to read: axles of a vehicle or of vehicles 5 axles 818.210. Except as provided under ORS 818.220, a road combination of vehicles: or more authority shall not issue a variance permit under ORS 818200 for any vehicle or load that can readily or reasonably be dis- 19 50,000 mantled or disassembled.The limit under this section does not +. apply to the followings 20 50,000 (1)Any single vehicle engaged in the transportation of peeler 21 50,000 z bolts,blocks,cores,railroad ties,logs or poles loaded crosswise 22, 50,000 of the vehicle,having an overall width of load thereon not in 23 50,400 excess of eight and one-half feet. 24 61,200 [(2) Combinations of vehicles consisting of not more than a 26 55,250 motor truck with a registration weight of more than 8,000 26 ;; :.56,100 pounds and two self-supporting trailers or a truck tractor and 27 56,960. semitrailer drawing two self-supporting trailers or semitrailers mounted on dollies equipped with fifth wheels having an overall 28 57,800” 26 Otfidal 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OF Measure NOREGON 29 30 ' �bt?59,500'` EXPLANATORY STATEMENT 31 32 g "N ytx :ar , Current law allows tractors pulling three trailers,'or 33 zr,,a 3 r 62,050 "triples,"to operate on highways under special permits issued b a 34 � ,ast a t t Gs,62,900 Y Oregon go road authori ty.These special permits place restric- 3SA=�"A tive conditions on the operation,of triples.,The Oregon 63,750 Department of Transportation definition of"triple"is a truck :5 ; r 64,600 pulling two trailers or a truck tractor pulling three semitrailers.' f :=may 37''' 65 450 s Without a special permit,such combination violate statutory. 38 = r 66,300 limits on length and number of vehicles in a'combination." 68,000 Measure M 4 prohibits the issuance of special permits for F . 40 ?0,000 73,000 triples..If passe Measure 4 will become effective 30 days after th 41> 72,000, 73,500 .. eelection. 73,280 t 74,500 Committee Members: Appointed by: 43 :' +,:. 73,280' ` 75,000 Julie Dawson Chief Petitioners r i 44 ' 73,280 ., 7b 500 Paul McCoy Chief Petitioners r'a. Jim Patterson* Secretary of State 45' ?3,280 ?6,000 John SaRak* Secretary of State 46 73,280 77,000 Joan Smith Members of the Committee 47 73,280 77,500 r 48 73,280.,. 78,000 *member dissents(does not concur.with the explanatory 4g 73,280 78,500 statement) a, . .. ,.. 50 73,280 .79,500 73,280 80,000 52 73,600 80,000 . (This impartial explanation was prepared by a comminee pursuant to ORS 251.215 and certified by the Supreme Court of the State of Oregon 53 74,400 80,000 pursuant to ORS 251.235.) b4 759200 80,000 } 65 qr over 76,000:, 80,000 , [(5)l (4)Any,vehicle,',combination of vehicles,' load, article, {; Property,machine or thing that: (a)Is used in the construction,maintenance or.repair of pub- lic highways;and (b)Is either not being used by the Federal Government,State ' of Oregon or any county.or incorporated city or not being used at the immediate location or site. !' " ,[(6)1(5).Combinations of vehicles having a combined'loaded weight in excess:of thatauthorized under Table III of ORS 818.010. [(7)](6)A vehicle engaged in the transportation of secondary wood products,which may be issued a permit for an overlength load..As,used;in,this subsection„"secondary wood products" means laminated wood products and wooden I-beam s.A vehicle engaged in the transportation of secondary wood products may t also transport a divisible load of secondary wood products that otherwise exceeds'allowable load length limits if ` (a)The load contains a permitted, nondivisible secondary wood product that exceeds the length allowed in ORS 818.080 or 818.100; '(b)The divisible load does not exceed the length allowed for b _ the nondivisible"wood product in the permit,and (c)Not more than 49 percent of each divisible load item,by length or weight, authorized by this subsection overhangs the vehicle transporting the load. { [(8)](7)A vehicle transporting an overheight marine contain- 'er to or from a marine port facility. SECTION 4.All variance permits authorizing combinations Prohibite Act.d by this Act shall be canceled on the effective date of NOTE:Boldfaced type indicates new language;[brackets and italic]type indicatesdeletions or comments:. • 26 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED Measure No. 4 STATE OF OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN'FAVOR ' AAA urges you to Vote"YES"on Ballot Measure#4 Trucking professionals oppose triples. > ,r A question of Safety. >` ' As people who work in the trucking industry we'know triple ` A"yes"vote on Measure#4 is a vote to get unsafe triple trailer trailer rigs should not,be,permitted on Oregon roads.We're trucks off Oregon roads.Motorists have a reason to be con- deeply concerned about safety, for other motorists and ourselves. cerned about sharing the road with extra long trucks.The rea, .Many truck-drivers we talk with agree that hauling a third son is safety..That is why Oregon AAA spearheaded the initia- trailer is not worth it. tive drive to get these huge and hazardous trucks off our roads. A growing number of Oregon AAA's 440,000 members have Some of the reasons we support Measure#4: written or called us about their"experiences with triples."We all are aware of the tragic accidents and deaths that have Virtually no control of$be third trailer.'Driving a set of occurred involving triple trailer trucks in Oregon.Our members - doubles is not especially fun,but at least a driver has some report triples swaying out of their lanes and creating near colli- control over one or two trailers.That's not the case with•a sions.They have told us of near rear-end collisions with these third trailer.It's continually swaying as much as a few feet ' huge trucks.because of the slow speed of triple trailers on hills side-to-side,And the third trailer actually climbs out of ruts and in mountain passes.Members have also told us about and into another lane or the shoulder. frightening experiences and"close calls"when they have tried to pass these huge trucks on two-lane roads and coastal high- • Bad weather is bad news for triples.'Gusty'winds and ways. rain in the gorge,fog at Rice Hill and unexpected icy condi- Triple trailers are incompatible with regular traffic: tions heading into Bend are just a few•weather problems we experience in Oregon.When we run into these situations we will find a place to safely drop the third trailer;•however, AAA believes the safety'of motorists is at stake.A triple is a commercial tractor trailer truck combination which is more sometimes companies"encourage" drivers to continue any- than 100 feet long.It is comparable to laying a 10 story building way. on its side and hauling it down the road.As long as triple trail- ers remain on Oregon roads,motorists lives are being compro- Passing a triple is dangerous.Triples are just not compat- mised.Triple trailers must be banned to ensure the safety of all ible with other traffic:On some hills triples are lucky to do 15 who use Oregon's roads. miles-per-hour. More than one rig has been rear-ended because of this.On two-lane roads cars passing triples are When these huge trucks"were first permitted in Oregon they forced to spend several additional precious*seconds in the were restricted to runs on I-5,only in the daylight,when it was oncoming traffic lane trying to get around a set of triples., ; not raining and only from May through October.All of that has changed. Triples now are allowed to run throughout Oregon, We are upset with the"folks behind the'multi=million'dollar year-round,24 hours a day,even in heavy rain. campaign against this measure for•trying to scare'voters into Follow a triple and decide for yourself. thinking more trucks are bad.As professionals we will tell you ` we would rather have more controllable trucks on the road tlian If you have any question about this being a safety issue,all you unsafe longer,heavier rigs. Besides,having;more, smaller have to do is follow a triple trailer truck—from a safe distance. trucks on the roads throughout Oregon means more jobs. Ask any truck driver how they feel about the safety of triples versus regular trucks.Eighty-five percent of professional truck We're not alone in our stand against triples."There are drivers do not want to drive triple trailers, according to the many trucking professionals who want Measure#4 to pass.But' December 1990"AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety"report and they cannot say so publicly for fear of losing their jobs many complained that they cannot see or feel what the third trailer is doing. For all of us—motorists and truckers alike-vote"yes" Oregon AAA endorses a"YES"Vote on Measure#4. for Measure#4. Vote YES For Safety. Roger L:Gra beal (This information furnished,by John G.Simpson,-Tlreman,Consolidated y Frelghtway;George L:Knop,Truck Driver,:ABF Freight Systems Yes on President #4 Truck Safety Committee.) Automobile Club of Oregon (This information furnished by Roger L.Graybeal,President,Automobile : r Club of Oregon.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the state'warrant,,the. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 27 f Official 1 992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No >'4 STATE OF 11�) OREGON I, ARGUMENT:INFAV,OR r , ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION,4"Yes"for Measure#4 says"yes"for safer,roads. FORMER STATE POLICE SUPERINTENDENT 1 Nearly 100,000 Oregonians signed petitions this spring so all of OPPOSES MEASURE 4 US could vote for this important traffic safety measure.Passing I've been in law enforcement my entire working life including Measure'#4`,'pr6hibita trucking companies and other big busi- more than four years as Superintendent of the Oregon State nesses,fromrunning triple trailer trucks on our roads. Police. It was always my job to ensure the safety of Oregon Washmgton,'Caltfornia and 33 other states prohibit triples-so motorists. should we M Measure i4-is about safety for motorists and truck"dri- If I thought Measure 4 would make Oregon highways safer,I I vers::This measure is not about the cost of groceries, "hidden would support it. taxes';small businesses,or pollution.It is,however,about acci- dents caused;bythese struck trains".that can weigh.over 50 B> TITWOE, tons and l . 4 Some strbe aightforward facts ong triples: I understand triple trailer trucks can seem intimidating.But •' `r if Measure 4 passes,they will be replaced with more trucks-- ?Over..80,percent of.truck drivers interviewed in a thousands of them .,.national survey say triples are not as safe as their reg- ular trucks(AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety,"A Study of The Operating,Practices of Extra-Long Vehicles",December And more trucks on the road;more of any vehicles on the t 11990) . " road for that matter, WILL RESULT,IN MORE ACCI- 1 DENTS. • Defective braking systems were found to be the most common'problem:discovered during safety inspections of triples by the Oregon Public Utilities Commission between There's another fact you should know about triples.AFTER 1985 and 1990(Oregon'PUC,"Triple-Trailer Combinations OPERATING MORE THAN'25 YEARS ON OREGON Accidents and Inspections in Oregon",March 1991): HIGHWAYS, TRIPLES HAVE ACHIEVED A SAFETY RECORD WHICH IS SUPERIOR TO ALL OTHER COM • Between 1985 and 1990 triple trailer"truck accidents in MERCIAL TRUCKS. ',Oregon r resulted in 42 injuries and two fatalities.The most recent fatal accident involving a triple trailer truck occurred May 6, 1992"and blocked traffic for over ten hours What it comes down to is this:Measure 4 WOULD MAKE near,Salem:Just a week before this fatal accident a triple OUR HIGHWAYS MORE DANGEROUS,by replacing 'crashed near Wilsonville dumping fuel in the'river and clos- triples.with thousands of more trucks. ing I-5 for hours: ' Passing a triple is dangerous for motorists—especially And that's why, as someone who has devoted his career to y in the rain. Triples are over 28 feet longer th making and keeping Oregon highways safe,I ask you to join " an regular me in opposing Measure 4. trucks and they are allowed on two-lane coast and mountain h roads in Oregon. `` Emil E.Brandaw,Former Superintendent Oregon's Department of Transportation estimates that OREGON STATE POLICE banning triples could add less than one percent more trucks throughout Oregon. (Oregon Department of Transportation memo,August 18,1992) •"In Oregon, there seem to be two areas where triples (This information famished by Emil E.Brandaw,Former Superintendent, P Oregon State police.) accidents stand out.These are incidents of nighttime rear. end accidents and unit separations, according to the Oregon PUC Report,March 1991, Oregon used to have severe restrictions on where and how triples operated.But today these"truck trains"operate on high- ways and two-lane roads throughout Oregon. j Join'the grassroots committee of thousands of Oregonians who 'know it's time to stop these,rigs.Vote"yes"for Measure#4. For safety. I , (This Information furnished by Scott L.Thompson,Treasurer,Ban Triple Trailer Committee.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The Printing of this argument does not constitute an�endorMse- The rind men, the State o P ng of this argument does not constitute an endorse-,by f Oregon,nor does the state wa ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the acctirrary or#ruth of any statement made in the argu accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 28 i Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED. measureLNo, STATE OF OREGON J NW i. ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION " MEASURE 4 WOULD MAKE OUR THOUSANDS MORE TRUCKS:ON THE ROAD:, , ROADS MORE DANGEROUS Triple trailers can seem intimidating-but take a look at what State Police Officer Speaks Against Measure 4 happens if we ban them. I have been a state police officer for more than IS TRIPLE TRAILERS ARE LIKE MASS TRANSIT'FOR years.In that time, Pve seen my share of accidents.It's the FREIGHT.One triple does the job of two or three other trucks. part of my job that is the most distressing—and sometimes the part that I can do the least about. If we ban them,something else has to deliver the food,medical supplies,clothes and other essential consumer products cur- That is why I am speaking out AGAINST MEASURE 4.I rently carried by triples. firmly believe it will make our roads more dangerous by causing thousands of unnecessary accidents. I urge you to vote no,for It won't be trains.They don't'deliver to'two thirds of Ore gon safety's sake. communities nor do they deliver to your local grocery, depart- ' went store or pharmacy.No, it would be MORE TRUCKS. • OREGON DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION More doubles and semi-trailers—thousands and thousands records show that triples are the SAFEST COMMERCIAL more.' TRUCKS ON THE ROAD. I. And with MORE trucks,comes a host of undesirable cone- • During the 25 years that triples have been operating in quences: Oregon, they have a proven safety record FOUR TIMES BETTER THAN OTHER TRUCKS. MORE TRAFFIC CONGESTION.' • MORE POLLUTION • The National Transportation Research Board says that . MORE ACCIDENTS replacing longer combination vehicles,such as triples,with a . MORE ROAD DAMAGE o i7 greater number.of other trucks WILL MEAN A SUBSTAN- TIAL INCREASE IN ACCIDENTS.. • HIGHER CONSUMER PRICES ; • Triple trucks are operated under much TIGHTER REGU- Do we really want MORE trucks on the road? LATIONS. They must have SPECIAL PERMITS, and TOUGHER SAFETY RULES APPLY TO THEM. For VOTE NO ON MEASURE 4. instance,triples CANNOT BE DRIVEN IF THERE ARE HIGH WINDS,FOG,SNOW or ICE. Richard L.Verbeck is • The OREGON TRANSPORTATION.COMMISSION Lieutenant Colonel,Retired ;OREGON STATE POLICE, 4 ' SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED USE OF TRIPLE I TRAILER TRUCKS. 1 All this adds up to one conclusion: If we prohibit the use of (This Information furnished by Richard L.Verbeck,Lieutenant Colonel, triple trucks on Oregon's highways,we must replace them with Retired,Oregon State Police.) thousands of additional trucks.And all those additional trucks would make driving more dangerous.not safer.There would be more accidents,and fatalities—not fewer. I hope you'll join me and VOTE NO on MEASURE 4. Senior Trooper Greg Shipley STATE POLICE (This information furnished by Senior Trooper Greg Shipley,State Police.) , k t E (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) m The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meet by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the I, accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 29 �u Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED s L. STATE OF I� Measu rP: .I .O. OREGON ARGUMENT IN!, -ARGUMENT INOPPOSITION �' AAAF,OUNDATIONFORTRAFFiC SAFETY SUPERIOR SAFETY RECORD 1' r ON THE ISSUE OF TRIPLES Triples are safer than other commercial trucks on Oregon highways.Here's the facts: I've been s'AAA member for 20 years.I think the Automobile Club forgot t�Q,do their homework before promoting Measure 4. Accidents Involving Trucks in Oregon (1985-1990) Their own national AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety spon- sored a.'study in 1990—"A Study of the Operating practices of TOTAL ACCIDENTS 10,476 %Extra-Long Vehicles"and here's what it said: , Tractors/Semis 6,588 63% Trucks 1,509 14% •''ELV's 3(extra-long vehicles)have a superior safety record. Tractors/Doubles 1,144 11% Their accident involvement rates are superior to those of 5-axle ', ;semis•� Trucks&Trailers 974 Bobtails 165 23'0 AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety Other" 31 0.3% Triple Trailers 66 0.696:1 "Triples are by far the most attractive ELV on the highway." AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety Source:Oregon public Utility CommiQaion March 1991 "Triples are generally driven by better paid drivers with longer average'experience and a more stable employment histo- VOTE NO ON MEASURE 41 ,y, AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety Major Cliff Duman,Retired OREGON STATE POLICE The study concluded that triples should be utilized through- out the country. : (This information furnished by Major Cliff Duman,Retired,Oregon State ' Do your homework before November 3• Police.) I' VOTE NO ON MEASURE 4. (This information furnished by Betty A.Hittie,20 Year AAA Member, Retired Teacher.) ; j (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255. (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute anendorse- The rind _ ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment.by Me State of Oregon anor rgument the state warm the aocurary or.truth of any statement made in the argument. actor or truth ? of any statement made in the argument. 3 i , i 30 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam 6h let CONTINUED Me' a' sure STATE OF .' : �4 OREGON ; . . , ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITIaN t �"' `` MEASURE 4 MEANS MORE POLLUTION: MEASURE 4 MEANS HIGHER COSTS TO 6 MILLION MORE POUNDS OF BUSINESSES AND CONSUMERS EXHAUST EMISSIONS Here they go again! Without question,if triple trucks are banned, there will be r It's a tired old gambit A special interest group with as axe to thousands more trucks on the road.Thousands more engines grind using the initiative process to regulate business:'This will burn millions of gallons of diesel fuel annually, and that usury spells trouble and higher costs to consumers.Measure 4 r will increase air pollution. is no exception: :, .i . For the environment,Measure 4 will mean: $100 Million Plus A Year Price Tag According to an economic impact'study prepared by an Oregon • 6 MILLION POUNDS MORE EXHAUST EMISSIONS transportation economist,MEASURE 4 WOULD COST ORE- 5 r_.oN BUSINESSES ONSUMERS MORE T 'ATI 8100 MILLION PER TEAM EVEN UP TO 98 JJON PER YEAR! • 78%INCREASE in CARBON MONOXIDE,NITRO- GEN OXIDES and HYDROCARBONS over earisting A Hidden Sales Tax truck emissions. The economic cost would be the equivalent of a"sales tax of up to 4%. • DRAMATIC INCREASES IN PARTICULATES (the A Bullet Aimed at Small Business BLACK SMOKE) and SULFUR OXIDES (the SMELLY FUMES). Measure 4 would particularly hurt small and faniilyowned, businesses which comprise 75%of Oregon's economy.. Some folks think banning triples will force more freight to go But make no mistake,Measure;4 also will increase shipping by rail.That won't happen. Trains don't deliver to the vast costs for all businesses across the board by at least 10%majority of Oregon communities. according to transportation management experts AND THOSE COSTS WOULD RESULT IN JOB Banning triples will just mean MORE trucks, and MORE i OSS_ES.HIGHER CONSUMER PRICES OR BOTH, TRUCKS.MEAN MORE AIR POLLUTION. It-makea absolutely no sense,economically or environmentally,to burn The Bottom Line:` Measure 4 just doesn't make sense. , MORE FOSSIL FUELS to haul the same amount of freight! Measure 4 WOULD: 4 �. SAY NO to MORE AIR POLLUTION! Increase truck traffic,air pollution and accidents. VOTE NO on qI Devastate Oregon businesses"and consumers,.at a cost of more than$100 million year after year after year. Paul Lepinski President Impose a hidden state sales tax of up to 4%. A&P RECYCLING The choice is clear.No on Measure 4. i (This Information furnished by Paul Lepinsld,President,A&P Recycling.) E.Joe Gilliam,Jr. State Director NATIONAL FEDERATION OF INDEPENDENT BUSINESS (Represents 16,000 Oregon Small Businesses) 1 , (This Information furnished by E.Joe Gilliam,Jr.,State Director,National Federation of Independent Business(Represents m coo Oregon Small Businesses).) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with'ORS 251:255.) The printing of this argument does not constitutean endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an`endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument, accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. ' L 31 i. OffidW 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OF r Measure ,'� NO.54` OREGON ARGUMENT I,N OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION GETTING US OUB DAILY BREAD MEASURE 4 IS BAD FOR OUR SCHOOLS HEALTH CARE FACILITIES,LAW ENFORCEMENT,CITIES, Think about the bread.. YOU eat every.day. COUNTIES AND OTHER PUBLIC AGENCIES Williams Bakery is an Oregon company and we're proud of it. Measure 4 will cost state and local governments millions of For more than 90 years webebrought Oregonians good,locally- dollars each year in increased shippinar costs. baked fresh bread at reasonable cost.We also keep transporta- tion costs low with triple trucks. Who relies on the freight carried economically by triples?In' addition to most consumers, Oregon's cities, counties and h; We have 1S trucks;nine of them are triples.We've run triples schools also benefit from the efficient and fast delivery system j served by triples. for 17 years,for,millions'of miles—with NO reportable acci- Y` 1 dents ECONOMIC STUDIES SHOW passage of MEASURE 4 ' In a recent month,we shipped ahnost 80%of that bread to could INCREASE SHIPPING COSTS AND IMPACT OUR market on our triple trucks.The low transportation costs allow ECONOMY BY AS MUCH AS $398 MILLION a year! us to stay competitive in markets that are far away from our Taxpayers will bear the burden of those increased costs. Eugene ovens. HUNDREDS OF PUBLIC AGENCIES currently RELY !' If Williams Bakery were forced to buy MORE trucks to ship ON TRIPLES and will experience increased shipping costs as would increase our a result of Measure 4. the same amount of bread to market, it transportation costs by about$250,00Q.a year.Just think what. would happen And the more money our schools, cities, counties, law enforcement,hospitals and state government have to spend on, We'd have to use 38,000 AIORE GALLONS OF DIESEL shipping costs,the less money there will be available for impor- FUEL, and CREATE MORE POLLUTION. With more tent services. trucks on the-road, we'd expose ourselves and others to more highway accidents,injuries and deaths. EVERY DOLLAR.SPENT ON THE COSTS ASSOCIAT- ED WITH MEASURE 4 AND MORE TRUCKS, IS ONE Those cost increases would have to be passed along to con- LESS DOLLAR SPENT IN THE CLASSROOM, THE ' sumers.And we're just one company.'Imagine what the costs EMERGENCY ROOM OR POLICING OUR STREETS. - would be'to all of Oregon when you expand that across the board. VOTE NO ON MEASURE 41 Ei Bread can't be shipped by rail.If our triples are banned,we Supt,Darrell Shepherd II will have to.ship them=bread on mm trucks.Measure 4 Sandy Elementary School District won't help us produce or sell one more loaf.,BY INCREASING r TRANSPORTATION COSTS,WE WILL BE LESS ABLE TO COMPETE, in distant markets and that will G.Marc Choate JOBS HERE,IN OREGON.• Hospital Board Member&Past Chair is We ask Oregon voters to consider the facts,about triple Councilmember Jo Haverkamp trucks—they are the safest truck on the,road,they are efficient, Gresham City Council they keep pollution as low as possible.. Please vote NO ON MEASURE 41 (This informadon furnished by Supt.Darrell Shepherd,Sandy Elementary School District;G.Marc Choate,Hospital Board Member&Past Chair,• Councilmember Jo Haverkamp,Gresham City Council) Dave Kintigh,Director of Transportation WILLLIAMS'BAKERY,Eugene (This information furnished by Dave Kindgh,Transportation Director,'s' vkfflliems'Bakery,Eugene.) t (This space purchased for 53001n accordance,with ORS 261.255.� (This apace purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing'of this or does not constitute an endorse- r d ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- accuracy or truth of any statement made.in the o ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant.the f >gument• accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. . a` ,. 32 ; Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED k STATE A Measure No. 4 0 EGONFArt `g�g.'" �'�.`� `; ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN'OPPOSITIONa.�,,,; IF IT AINT BROKE,DON'T FIR IT: ATTENTION ALL WORKING MEN AND WOMEN For as long as I can remembe r,(which is quite a while since Whv should any workers have to gdve ,R their ioba'for' I'm now in my seventies),those words have made sense to me. no reason? Now,some people want to change the way we get things done— , moving things from here to there.Why?Who stands to gain? That's exactly what Measure 14 is asking of Teamster drivers Who stands to lose? and other working men and women in Oregon. Well,I'm not sure who will gain but I DO KNOW WHO Some claim that banning triples means more jobs for truck WILL LOSE—ALL OF US,THE CONSUMERS AND TAX- drivers PAYERS OF OREGON.And that's why I'm Voting NO on Measure 4. Think about it.More jobs for whom?Maybe some'out-of-state Consider this:Economic studies have predicted that by elimi- wildcat truck drivers might benefit,but only at the expense of nating.the use of triple trucks, COSTS TO CONSUMERS Oregon Teamster drivers,dock workers,salespeople and others. The Ove AND BUSINESS COULD RISE MORE THAN$100.MIL- Overton Jobs belonging to n workers would be LION A YEAR.EVEN UP TO$398 MILLION A YEAR. ' And that's the equivalent of a 1%to 4%sales text. As a concerned Teamster,I know that no company ever got How can that be? Simple. If you can't get your produce, better by becoming less efficient.All across this nation,labor is in clothing p y y finding ways to work with companies to make them more effi- medicine and other inducts in one wa —sa cient and more competitive.That's the real way to insure more by,using one triple truck-you have to pay for the other decent-wage jobs for working men and women. option—more trucks to replace them Labor has learned that jobs can't be created out of nothing. The promoters want you to believe their schemes all in the That's especially true for something as vital to business:as name of safety.Well,its not.Its about money—yours and transportation. mine. If transportation costa uo ui 3.smaller more marginal !I don't know about you but I've had my pocket picked enough businesses could close.It's one more unneeded cost they in this lifetime with higher prices and higher taxes. can't absorb and possibly the final straw that makes them' uncompetitive:It also means that consumers will pay more for As 0000sed to what certain goverm-ent bureaucrats everything—from medicine to food to clothing. think,my limited income is not gtowinor with inflation. And extra cost—no matter how small—is something nobody I just cannot afford increases—consumer or otherwise. Can needs: you? 1 To save Oregon jobs,I urge a NO vote on Measure 4. Like I said IF IT AIN'T BROKE DON'T FIX ITI Dwight Smith VOTE NO ON MEASURE 4. Member International Brotherhood of Teamsters,Local 126 Howard B.Patterson AAA Member Retired (This Information furnished by Dwight Smith,Member,International Brotherhood of Teamsters,Local 126.) (This information furnished by Howard B:Patterson;AAA Member, Retired.) L i (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251-255.). (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not constitute,an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 33 ry Ii `Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED :STATE OF Measurer, OREGON ARGUMENT INO.OPPOSITION ARGUMENT.IN OPPOSITION WHY RECYCLING CENTERS OPPOSE OREGON TRUCK DRIVER SPEAKS �i f. MEASURE 4 �t ABOUT TRIPLES m. 1r IM OPPOSED TO MEASURE 4 BECAUSE IT COULD "Safety Comes First" PUT MY RECYCLING CENTER OUT OF BUSINESS. As a NATIONAL DRIVER TRAINING SCHOOL INSTRUC The fact is recycling centers like mine must keep their costs TOR for United Parcel Service (UPS}—and a truck driver,`I to a mmin}um have driven triple trailers and trained triples drivers for more than 21 years. t, But Meamnlre 4 would dramaticaft incre nse the cost of shinninct recycled newspapers, ai>umintm cans. arlass. rm someone who doesn't take risks.My family is too impor- tant to me.If triples were dangerous,I wouldn't drive them.It's that simple. £r The result Measure 4 could put recycling centers out of busi- ness.` But you don't have to take my word for it.Triples have a 25- s. year track record of safely operating in Oregon. - Me reason is simple:Recycled materials move by truck.By s banning triple trailer trucks,it means the same amount of recy- • OREGON DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION cled goods now shipped on Qag triple would have to be shipped RECORDS SHOW THE SAFETY RECORD OF on I=or gum trucks.,: . ._— TRIPLE TRAILER TRUCKS IS SUPERIOR TO THAT OF ALL OTHER COMMERCIAL TRUCKS.* SHIPPING THE SAME AMOUNT OF GOODS ON MORE TRUCKS MEANS HIGHER SHIPPING COSTS THE ACCIDENT RATE FOR TRIPLE TRAILERS FOR RECYCLERS. WAS ONE-FOURTH.THE RATE FOR OTHER *; TRUCKS.* It also mean's increased diesel fuel consumption and more air r pollution.because of all those extra trucks on the road.' *Statement by Oregon Department of Transportation, f March 19,1991 And that adds up to three environmental strikes against Measure 4: The reason for the superior safety record for triples is'simple. They must be operated under more restrictive conditions than • PUTS RECYCLERS OUT OF BUSINESS• other trucks.For example,trigles are not permitted to operate in fog, high wind or snowy weather. • WASTES GAS. 4t I understand triples can seem intimidating,but before you • INCREASES AIR POLLUTION. vote on Measure 4,please consider their 25 year superior safety record in Oregon. Please help recycling centers like mine stay in business. VOTE NO ON MEASURE 4, VOTE NO ON ,ARf11tF a Doyal Seale Paul Lepinski NATIONAL DRIVING TRAINING SCHOOL ' President INSTRUCTOR A&P RECYCLING United Parcel Service (This information furnished by Doyal Seale,National Driving Training " (This information furnished by Paul Lepinsld,President A&P Recycling.) School Instructor United Parcel Service.) n �s (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255. (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The rind r. men'by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- accuracy or truth of any statement made in the a ment�'the State of Oregon,nor does the state prat mnt the try >lment to or truth of any statement made in the argument. ' 34 AML Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet . CONTINUED STATE OF Measure Not 4 OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT'IN OPPOSITIONti MEASURE 4 WOULD INCREASE COSTS TO OREGON AGRICULTURE HURT BY MEASSURE 4 CONSUMERS AND BUSINESS BY AS MUCH AS $398,000,000 PER YEAR! FOUR REASONS TO VOTE NO on 4:6 , .• What products do triples carry?Hundreds and hundreds of Reason 1 BANNING TRIPLE'TRUCKS WILL ELIMI items Oregon consumers rely on everyday.Just about every- NATE THE MOST COST EFFECTIVE WAY OF thing you can think of including: TRANSPORTING PRODUCTS WE RELY ON , EVERYDAY. Food Electronics Reason This, in.turn, WILL LEAD.TO INCREASED Books COSTS TO OUR FARMERS AND TO CON. Medicine SUMERS WHO PURCHASE OREGON'S AGRI- CULTURAL PRODUCTS. Toys Paper Reason 3 OREGON'S AGRICULTURAL COMMUNI- i Video Products TIES-Like Pendleton, LaGrande Baker City, ' Furniture Enterprise,Bend, Hood River, Redmond, Klamath Building Supplies Falls,Ashland, Roseburg, Tillamook, The Dalles, Recycled Cardboard Astoria, Lincoln City,Newberg, Coos Bay,North Auto Parts Bend and Brookings—WILL BE THE MOST AFFECTED. Popcorn Computers Two thirds of Oregon communities are not served by Computer Hardware rail and the potential reduction in prompt-deliveries' Recyclables of necessary supplies to our farmers in these areas Athletic Shoes could be devastating. Exercise Equipment Wood Products Reason 4`USING A BALLOT MEASURE TO REGULATE Construction Products BUSINESS AND AGRICULTURE USUALLY SPELLS TROUBLE AND IS ALWAYS COSTLY- `r` Paint Flashlights FOUR REASONS TO VOTE NO ON 4.They represent agri- i Liquor culture's concerns.We hope you'll keep them in mind when you Paper Bags vote. Sportswear ' Aircraft Parts Please VOTE NO on Measure 41 Tires Medical Equipment Marjorie Ehry,President Cleaning Compounds OREGON WOMEN FORAGRICULTURE Automobile Parts and Accessories Sundries Terry L.Witt,Executive Director Fertilizers OREGONIANS FOR FOOD AND SHELTER School Supplies, Scott Hutchinson,Executive Vice President Before you go to the polls,check your pocketbook. Do you OREGON WHEAT GROWERS LEAGUE really want to pay more money for the same goods? I VOTE NO ON MEASURE 4. (This information furnished by MarJorie Ehry,President,Oregon Women, ? for Agriculture,-Scott Hutchinson,Executive Vice President,Oregon Wheat Growers League;Terry Witt,Executive Director,Oregonians for, Food&Shelter.) (This information furnished by Richard M.Butrick,President,Associated Oregon Industries;and its divisions:Oregon Retail Council,Oregon Forest Industries Council.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse merit by the State of Oregon,'nor does the state warrant the merit by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. i 35 �; Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet STATE OF t " OREGON Measure N6� 4 ARGUMENT�IN OPPOSITION 'ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION • MORE TRUCKS MEANS MORE ACCWMfrS WHO IS REALLY BEHIND MEASURE 4? ' We'd rather prevent"an igjury than treat one.Through bitter The promoters of Measure 4 want you to(believe they'are a experience..'we've learned that prevention is the best prescrip- bunch of high tion for sav minded citizens who are concerned only about ing lives your safety.DONT BE FOOLEDI Take a look at just WHO is behind this initiative,and ask yourselves who gains if it passes. l So we222212 Measure 4—because we want to prevent highway accidents and save lives. THE EASTERN-BASED RAILROADS HAVE POURED TENS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS INTO AN IN'C'ENSE, I ",Measure 4 wffmake the roads morelong ro s not less. NATIONAL LOBBYING CAMPAIGN TO BAN TRIPLES, ' Why is this so? Why?Their motive is pure and simple:GREED Banning triples will put thousands more trucks on the road. In fact,railroad industry officials conceded more than a year ago that ECONOMICS,NOT SAFETY, was their primary And we know that the more tra8'ic on the roads the posing the use of triples. � reason for op greater the certainty there will be more accidents. How would the nation's railroad monopoly stand to make bigger That's a fact from the National Academy of Science's profits if triples are banned? Transportation Research Board It works like this:Banning triples makes it more expensive to ship freight:The more expensive it is to ship,the more trucking We don't want the business. companies must charge businesses.And when the,trucking us prevent more accidents.Join companies raise their;prices, the railroads can raise their Please help P us in vot- prices,too: ing NO on Measure 4. So DON'T BE A VICTIM OF THE EASTERN RAILROAD Senior Trooper Donald K.Campbell MONOPOLY'S SCARE TACTICS.THEY ARE INTEREST- STATE POLICE ED IN ONE THING,AND IT Is4ri'T YOUR S FFTVr ITS THEIR PR.OFITSI Dr-'Gretchen L.Kittle Neurologist' Measure 4 means MORE TRUCKS on the road,MORE TRAFFIC,MORE AIR POLLUTION,MORE ACCIDENTS and—something the railroads would like to see—HIGHER SHIPPING COSTS.AND HIGHER SHIPPING COSTS (This information furnished by Senor Trooper Donald K.Campbell,State MEAN HIGHER CONSUMER PRICES, Police Officer,•Dr.Gretchat L.Hittle.) DON'T BE POOLEDI DON'T LET THEM GET AWAY WITH ITI VOTE NO on MEASURE 4. f Barbara J.Solheim AAA Member (This information fumishad by Barbara J.Solheim,AAA Member.) n (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space Purchased for$300 in accordance with DRS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The rind meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warr ant the p of this argument does not constitute an endorse- accuracy or'truth of any statement made in the a went b'the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the " • rgument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 36 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet 4° CONTINUED. STATE OF Measure N 5 � � � rt OREGON i Proposed by initiative petition.to be voted on at the General the operating nuclear fueled thermal power.plant,,to identify;' Election,November 3,1992. and evaluate all geologic faults underneath and in the vicinity BALLOBALLOT TITLE of the plant,the potential magnitude of subduction zone earth- T and their effect on the plant and the adequacy of the plant design to withstand major earthquakes;and , CLOSp:S,�, N1fC (d) The health effects of radiation releases up to the maxi mum allowable levels from any nuclear fueled thermal power W. Gt?fa'1`t TARTHQUA>lfE, plant, including the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant,are without CONDITIONS 141ET' :•.. ,..• ,..::,..::..::... ...... .:.::.::::..::>;:>:> harm to the public. . go Y QCIPr5'l'f01 -•$tlall'lko�ai�n elgar power plant open 0 (2) If the Oiregd for electric power which that ere is an atlt�n be barred until i aa>Ye nt federal.waste sit+a is obtained lfelensed,other eonditi"M.O.-O-5... from any alternative energy,resource,including conservation, StRX Ens�ts nar ii r5pe11ds:opel#ii4 4f � without violating Section 2(1),then'the temporary sbspension ..::::.......... Trolait 1?'rovsdes that ucr Oregon nuclear power ::;;':: : ;; or repeal of Section 2(1)shall be referred to the voters of this plat,}peluduag'j'xa�an, shall operate uml�s$the state for their approval or rejection. Eby Facility*Siting Council finds,after a hearing SECTION 3.'EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS ACT.The effec- a perpaaaent radioactive Waste repository has been five date of this act shall be 120 days alter its passage. f4tler�illy]i9 1&e4I 13s l?tmg rX"... tha Is4rit 18 , SECTION 4.SEVERANCE CLAUSE.If an section portion, thin costffective;the lrlaaat can withstamator : '`>{i '.; Y P� , eaitbcalc+ee w1t$auut ►arm}trgtl►a pubic,and allow clause or phrase,of this act is for any reason held to be invalid ably radTatxau relaas do xso I►axu3 thenbltc Tl IB or unconstitutional,the remaining sections;portions; clauses islaturo declares elec a.p6yVe3#emergency..... fangs. and phrases shall not be affected but shall remain in full force :.;:.;.. i::;r: and effect,and to this end the provisions of this act are sever- theq�est�U 'x �s; Yk? id: t*:repealth :lav�<: »: <: ... able. : ESTIMATE .�'INANC,CA�IMI'1i:CT-fin 199b 96r :»>:>:>>' local schacls Pmpe3`teat revenueswill)ae reduced < '. <' A .mtlhon and Qther t ug diat00,.t erty EXPLANATORY STATEMENT tax raysnuea Wi,ibe reduced 000 In 1995 96, thO:Stites ubl}gated#�ap1a+e,p,pPertyv : :>>;: < . . etlueslosl#o th¢pablihOt�] t7n :: :; ::>:::':: :; : This measure would close the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant on March 2,.1993,until certain conditions are met.Before a AN ACT nuclear-fueled thermal power plant is allowed to operate again SECTION 1.FINDINGS.The people of Oregon find that,if in Oregon,the Energy Facility Siting Council must hold a hear- ing and based the evidence received at the hearing,make the United States Government fails to provide a permanent repository for the safe disposal of high-level radioactive waste, four findings.These findings are: including irradiated fuel from nuclear fueled thermal power (1) There is a permanent disposal site for high-level plants,then the people of our state will face potential adverse radioactive waste licensed by the Federal Government and able health effects, environmental degradation, increased electric to accept high-level radioactive waste,' rates,;and the undue financial burden of paying for the con- (2) The operation of the nuclear-fueled thermal power struction and maintenance for the indefinite future of a.high- plant is cost-effective. level radioactive waste repository in Oregon.Furthermore, the (3) The operating nuclear-fueled thermal power plant can people of Oregon recognize that efficient energy alternatives withstand major earthquakes without harm to the public.The and renewable energy resources are immediately available to plant must comply with earthquake'protection requirements of replace.the Trojan Nuclear.Plant. Therefore, we the people of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission that are in Oregon enact the following effect when the plant begins to operate.Before making the third SECTION 2.CONDITIONS FOR THE FURTHER OPERA- finding,the Energy Facility Siting Council must have an inde- TION OF NUCLEAR FUELED THERMAL POWER pendent geologic investigation and engineering study per PLANTS.(1)No nuclear fueled thermal power plant,including formed to identify and evaluate all geologic faults underneath the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant,shall be allowed to operate in and near the plant,the potential magnitude of subduction zone Oregon until the Energy Facility Siting Council(EFSC)finds, earthquakes and their effect on the plant and the adequacy of through an evidentiary proceeding,that: the plant design to withstand major earthquakes..The operator (a) The operation of a repository for the disposal of high- of the power plant must pay for this study. level radioactive waste produced by the plant,including irradi- (4) The maximum.amount of radiation release allowed ated nuclear,fuel,has been licensed by the United States from any nuclear-fueled thermal power plant does not harm the Government and provides for the immediate acceptance and public. terminal disposition of such waste with'or without provision for This measure can be suspended or repealed if the retrieval; " Legislature declares an emergency need for electricity'which (b).At the time a waste repository becomes available,opera- cannot be obtained from any alternative energy source,includ- tion of any nuclear fueled thermal power plant,including the' ing conservation, and the voters approve the operation of the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant,is cost effective,as defined by ORS Trojan Nuclear Power Plant- 469.020(3); Committee Members Appointed by: (c) Any operating nuclear fueled thermal power plant, Greg Kafoury Chief Petitioners including the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant,can withstand the Mark McDougal . Chief Petitioners maximum credible earthquake without harm to the public acid goy Hemmingway* Secretary of State complies with the current seismic protection requirements of Steven Sautter* Secretary of State the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission(presently Sid Lezak - Secretary of State' set forth in 10 CFR Part 100,Reactor Site Criteria)or any sub- sequent modification of those criteria to establish more strin gent protection requirements.Prior to any such finding,EFSC statement) ; shall cause an independent geologic investigation and engineer- (This Committee was appointed to provide an Impartial explanation of the ing analysis to be performed,paid for by the owner or owners of ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251.215.) i 37 i ' Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED e M eaS STATE OF u re No. OREGON. Y ARGUMENT,-REAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR F' -TO CLOSE TROJAN; FROM THE BU NFS S 70 IRATA T "YES"ON 5' 6 TO RALPH NADER. � do' . THE VERDICT ON TROJAN IS UNANIMOUS "Plagued design flaws, This year there are'twory measures on the ballot to close e y gn faulty equipment and mcon Trojan„measures'5`&6.If both pass the strongest elements of sistent management, Trojan...[has become] a symbol of each will,become,law,This will provide the greatest protection that was wrong with nuclear power.”The Business for the.safetv:of our community and the greatest protection for Journal,8/17/92: our pocketbook.,The sponsors of Measure,5 urge,you to vote 'Ir'ojan nuclear plant has been A DISGRACE...one of "Yes on both Measu70=d6. the worst safety records..." The Oregonian,'Editorial, 10/16/89 NOW,THEY TE Us�; "Not only is the plant rated over its lifetime as THE After,'years of denying that Trojan was in trouble,and after WORST performing pressurized-water reactor in'the years of proclaiming that Trojan was vital to the Northwest, nation,but it is;also aging fast.We'see more problems POE has=on the eve'of the election=admitted that'Tmjan's ahead—more and longer downtimes. Trouble:'The power'is unnecessary, and that the plant is falling part.Yet Oregonian,Editorial,8/9/92 they still want'to run Trojan until 1996, when its continuing "The problems[at Trojan]won't go away,they'll only notation will make it useless:' get worse...'Medford Mail ribune,Editorial,10/26/90 dete "...UNBELIEVABLE safety violations.' wouldn't �,A 1 OX trust the company to run our copy machine,let alone a Tro an's nuclear reactor."Willamette Week,10/25/90 � power is now more than twice as expensive as power a available on the open market.The only reason they want to run "...Trojan's plant safety record has an IGNOAUNIOUS 'the plant is so that we will have to pay them more money than list of violations and citations .". KATU Editorial,10/4190 they deserve.The yhaseout is a b ;to,:. ; "Trojan was not designed for massive earthquakes. Yet in is how geologists describe the kind of IT TARES ONE BAD DAY... earthquake Oregonians may face."KGW–TV Editorial, Because,of its placement in an earthquake zone, faulty 10/22190 design,and bad management,Trojan is,a particularly danger- " •Tr'ojan.Jins been operated with the intelligence of ous nuclear plant'Iiow much more dangerous will it be over the a telephone post..."The Business Journal,Editorial,4/2/90 next four years,now that it has been announced that the plant will be abandoned?Won't the best workers leave,and the rest "PGE's management of Trojan has„been REPREHEN- lie demoralized? SIBLE .DailyAstorian,Editorial,816190 .' 7, "...Trojan has a litany of problems, from broken I WE LOST—AND WE PAID FOR 1T. . Promises to poor construction..:to wildly escalating l� operating costs and GROSS NEGLIGENCE.” The In 1990, the Trojan Initiative lost, despite late polls that Springt?eldNews,Editorial,10/16/90 showed voters were ready to,close Trojan.Some,election ana- " ` lysts blamed confusing ballot language for the loss .Others "...the world has turned nasty for Trojan...now Point to the million dollars spent by PGE in the final weekend. Canadian gas supplies glut the West Coast,making gas a The defeat of the ballot measure was,a defeat for ratepayers. cheaper Power source than a wheezing reactor."New Trojan broke down shortly after the election,and was flat on its York Times Financial Analyst Matthew L.Wald,8/16/92 back for a veer.$acti llv no on no i d Replacement power "We have information there is power out there avail. wasreadily available at a fraction of Trojan's cost,The failure of able at under 3 cents per Hwhr." the 1990 Trojan Initiative has cost ratepayers more than$200 Oregonian,8/15/92 BPA, cited in The million. ONCE IS NOTENOUGH—VOTE "ZrOj-n is a DANGEROUS nuclear lemon.It should be closed down now r Ralph Nader,News Release,8/12192 Make sure that your friends and family know how to make Would you go to a movie that had these reviews?Would you their votes count,We cannot afford four more years of Trojan's hire a babysitter that had this reputation?Think about it,and , risk,nuclear waste,and mushrooming costs.Nor can we ia afford 1O°° r °"'p" "•Phone:(503)228-6657. confusion on how to vote to close the plant.We must vote egg" on both Measures b and 6.vote"Yee twice, (This information fumish Committee.) a4 by Colleen O'Neil,Don't Waste Oregon (This information furnished by.Y Gr e9ory Kaloury,Don't Waste Oregon (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255. (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- meat by the'State of Oregon,'nor does the state warrant the The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- occuracy or trtcth of ant statement made in the a meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the rg±�ment... . accuracy or truth of any statement Horde in the argument. ' 38 ,r i { Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED MeasurSTATE P O5 OREGON OF • . , ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR •PHASEOUT BAILOUT!CLOSE TROJAN NOW LET THE VOTERS DECIDE After 16 years,of telling us Trojan was safe, economical and PGE has made its decision to close the Trojan nuclear plant needed,,PGE now wants to phase it put by 1996.What do we get with PGE's phaseout of Trojan? in 1996.Is that good'enough?Should Trojan operate four more years or be forced to an immediate shutdown? MORE COSTS! In 1991-92 Trojan failed to operate for a year due to deteriorat- LOON AT THE FACTS ing steam generators built by Westinghouse Corporation.Even though-it was unable to produce aU power, PGE charged Within two years of going on line to,preduee power in 1976,. ratepayers over$200 million for Trojan.Now PGE wants to Trojan began showing the effects of construction design flaws operate Trojan another four years and charge ratepayers up to and faulty equipment.During its 16 year life,Trojan has been $700 million,.to be followed by an additional$350 million in fined repeatedly by the U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission sunk costs when PGE finally shuts Trojan down.Add this to for safety violations.In 1989,the Oregon Department of Energy the unknown costs of decommissioning and it brings the threatened to shut the plant down for safety reasons.More total cost of Trojan to way over a billion dollars! recently,Trojan has been off line more than on due to cracks in its steam generator tubes.. NO ACCOUNTABIIITY! Westinghouse built Tro'an's failing steam generators.Fourteen The costs of operating Trojan have become prohibitive. ing J 8 $ Trojans history of breakdowns and shutdowns paints a clear other utilities in the.United States have sued Westinghouse for picture of a mechanical lemon,and,just like'a defective car,it is damages they have suffered from defective steam generators- not only costly but dangerous to operate. Yet,PGE has never filed a lawsuit against Westinghouse. Instead PGE proposes to stick it to ratepayers!We pay the costs—Westinghouse walks! WHY WAIT FOUR YEARS? MORE RISSI The question of"Who pays and how much?" can only be resolved after the plant"stops producing power.Trojan may Four more years of waste.Four more years of failing steam gen= cease to operate,but expenses—disposing of the nuclear waste, erators.Four more years of earthquake risk.Four more years of decommissioning the plant itself, and recovering the already- radiation releases.At Trojan,if it can go"wrong,it goes made investment—will continue well into the future. wrong! NO ENFORCEMENT! The plant's impending closure will,force many of its top employees to seek employment elsewhere:Low,employee PGE has made an election year promise! They say shutting morale and a lack of key personnel will lower safety standards down Trojan is part of their planning process,but there is noth- and increase the potential for.equipment failure. The result? jng to prevent them from changing their mind.There is no legal Higher costs and lowered efficiency. requirement that they keep their word,and no legal recourse if they don't. Ballot Measures 5 & 6 create'laws closing Now that the decision to close Trojan has been made,PGE Trojan which are legally enforceable! " will need all its talent and energy to pursue a responsible ener- gy Policy.The sooner PGE can turn its efforts to encouraging ITS WORTH SHUTTING DOWNNOw! sconservation bead producing safe and efficient ever P B W' sources,the better. During the 1990 Ballot Measure 4 Campaign, PGE told Oregonians that shutting down Trojan would bring blackouts 17S'UP TO YOU and rate increases, and PGE would need to build coal plants and dams.We lost the election and PGE ended up shutting Even PGE agrees that Trojan should be closed.Now the down Trojan for more than a year because it needed expensive question is,"When?"Both Measures 5 and 6 send a clear mes- repairs. There were'no blackouts! The cost of'replace- sage to PGE—shut it down now and get on with the business of ment power was actually r than Trojan's cost of building a cost effective energy future. powerl And now PGE finally tells us that efficiency improvements and natural gas are cheaper than operat- ing Trojan!This plant is a menace If its worth shutting down,its worth shutting down"now! (This Information furnished by Christeen O'Shea,Administrative Director, Citizens'Utility Board of Oregon.) EUE&IM VOTE YES ON MEASURES 5&6! (This information furnished by Lloyd K.Marbst,Activist.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This-space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255:) this argument does not constitute an The printing of endorse- 017se printing of this argument does not constitute an'endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. aceuraey or truth of any statement made in the argument. 39 r �. Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet 1 CONTINUED M eaSUCe NdSTATE OF OREGON. ply ' i ARGUMENT IN'FAVOR . ` ARGUMENT IN FAVOR I1]OCTORS AND HEALTH P$OFESSIONAIB Q AND A i FOB MEASURES 5&e ,a e r Q: How important is Trojan? PGE'has spent'tens of millions of dollars against previous A Its a drop in the bucket.Trojan supplies le,ss than 3%of the ballot measures,that would have'closed the Trojan nuclear Northwest power system.And since it only runs half the time, plant-until?a'permanent'storage site for the plant's high-level we can never rely on it. F radioactiva`waste becomes available.This time,PGE has stated its intent,to close Trojanin.1996.The statement is not binding, Q' Trojan's power cheap? ' nor does ft''Address'citizens'concerns about the safety of Trojan A hardly.Because of it's deteriorating performance and costly TODAY.�PGE's argument—that a gradual phase-out would repairs,Trojan is the most �nsive supposedly.save ratepayers lots of money—not only proves their — Power in the BPA system., upside-down priorities(unsubstantiated,promises of savings, Q: How can we replace Trojan'$power? against serious,neglect of public safety),but is a cleverly veiled attempt to have.the ratepayers and tax a e.rs. A Cheaply and easily.The BPA has just acknowledged that shareholders and`man P Y �PGE 'replacement power is available on the open market at less than agement from the consequences of years , of Poor decisions, : , 3¢per .Kwhr.This year,Trojans power costs ratepayers more a , than 6e,and last year it was an astonishing 21c per Kwhr. •" Inadequate actions by PGE to deal with a progression of Q' I don't get,it. If replacement power is available at' defects in the steam generator,both from a point of view of safe- half of Trojan's cost,why won't the utility buy it for us? ty and of efficient power generation.Makeshift plugging of A That's what this is really all about.In 1978,voters passed a steam generator,tubes can lead to power excursions and insta- ballot measure which said that no utility could charge ratepay- bilities in the operation of the plant.Southwest Washington ers for any plant"not presently used for providing utility ser- e and Northwest Oregon.populations'are being held hostage to vice".In other words,once Trojan is closed,the utility cannot PGE's assignment of lowest priority to public safety.Remember make us pay for their losses on Trojan. To be able to`charge Three Mile Island and Chernobyl? ratepayers the hundreds of millions of dollars they have sunk into this lemon,the utility must continue to try to make it run. $ • A series of safety violations involving the.critical emer- ` gency core cooling system, resulting in a string of very large the utility says Measure b won't do anything about fines,since the start of its operation ry g the nuclear waste,that it will have to stay.on site when-' ever the plant is closed. • Omitting effective measures to safeguard the plant A' True,but'misleading.New,hot waste from the reactor is against ruptures under conditions of severe earthquakes, Put into the waste pool each year.During an accident in the +' recently predicted near the Portian&Lower Columbia fault reactor'this hot fuel could ignite,creating a nuclear,fire that lines by,respected scientists. would resemble Chernobyl,except that it would have more fuel and less containment.To allow the fuel to cool,we need to stop putting hot fuel in.This While failing to provide chea and safe requires closing the plant-the sooner P power, the Trojan the better. nuclear power plant,including its large,inadequate safeguard- I safeguard-ed,temporary high-level radioactive waste storage facility(con- Q: When will someone come and take this nuclear waste taining spent'nuclear fuel rods),presents a clear danger to the off our hands? ix hundreds of thousands of le living , PeoP in its surroundings,In A. •Good question.PGE originally official reports,the numbers,expressing predicted deleterious Promised that the waste health effects per unit of radiation dose(exposure),both from Would only be stored on site for six months.That figure has now external and internal sources of radioactive contamination stretched to 35 years.The likelihood is that we will have to be responsible for storing this deadly stuff into the far,far future, have been increased by factors up to to in just adecade-.Yet these official risk evaluations are underestimates,specifically in The less we have,the better off we will be. the low-dose r ; sage-most relevant to nuclear accidents in Q: Trojan's owners claim that they will be entitled to they ignore a rapidly,increasing body of scientific studies that compensation if the voters close the plant.True or false? point toward considerably higher health hazards, A False.The alternatives to Trojan'are cheaper,so the plant Therefore,vote YES on Measures 6 has no'value. When Margaret Thatcher tried-to sell five of and e. England's nuclear,reactors, she found that she could not giyg them"away. WorldWatch, 6/17/92. Furthermore, the U.S. Supreme Court recently declared that no such compensation (This Information fumishad by Charles M.Grossman,M.D.,President, would be owed to"the corporate owner of a nuclear'generating Portland Chapter,Physicians for Social Responsibility.) . plant...upon discovery that the plant sits astride an earthquake fault.-Lucas v . Lth p.rlina,The description fits Trojan, VOTE YES ON 5&e (This information fumished by Mark McDougal,Attorney.) . (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.. . 1 (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) [The printing ojthis argument does not constitute an endorse- nt by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the Fr ing of this argument does not constitukan endoJthe uracy.or truth of any statement made in the argument. he'State of Oregon, nor does the statrant or truth of any statement made in the ent. 40 A. Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ,. .. ` CONTINUED . STATE OF M easure No. OREGON �... ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR' TROJAN'S SAFETY RECORD:"A DISGRACE" MOTHERS AND FATHERS FOR A SHUTDOWN HM, ^ Q:Why was PGE fined a record$280,000 in October of •' �•,, ':' ,!::: 1889? We are a handful of the 400,000 Oregonians who voted in A: The emergency core cooling system—Trojan's last line of 1990 to close Trojan.We are all parents of young children:We defense against a catastrophic reactor accident—was found to have studied the nuclear industry, and have come to:our�.own have been clogged with massive amounts of debris. conclusion:This plant is a menace,and we want it closed:n°w.';;; Q:How•much debris would it take to disable the system? Many people think that.the history,of'nuclear•'accidents A:A single chunk,half the size of a dime,could"render the sys- begins with Three Mile Island, and ends with Chernobyl:Iti tem inoperable.", fact,there have been other dramatic catastrophes,such as'the nuclear waste explosion at Kushtum in the USSR,which wiped Q:So what was in the system? 20 villages off the map'and left a vast"dead zone":There was i massive contamination from a fire and.partial meltdown at A:A section of scaffolding,a two-foot by three-foot flat iron bar Windscale in England.There have been'near-misses at Fermi metal frame, fiberglass and chalk insulation,,metal banding in Detroit,and Gina,in New Jersey.An electrical fire at Browns and clips,pens,a spool of stainless steel wire,a bundle of stain- Ferry brought the state of Alabama close to the edge:In 1991,a less steel wire,a roll•of duct tape,Massilin cloth;18-inch wire nuclear plant in Japan had a brush with disaster when a defer wraps,weld rod stubs,a 50-count bag of 30-inch long'nylon'tie give steam generator tube ruptured, and operators refused to wraps,a one-eighth-inch screw,three one-fourth inch washers, believe what their instruments were telling them. two pop rivets,and insulation covering sheetmetal band. Q:Aren't there screens to keep junk out of the system? Chernobyl left vast areas uninhabitable, some as far as 360 A•Yes,but the most vital screen was never.installed.It would miles from the plant. Estimates.of the eventuaV death toll i resemble those of a major regional war.TIME magazine~on not have helped much.In 14 years,the system had never been cleaned. April 9, 1990, cited estimates of property damage of$3" . hillisn. _ Q:Aren't PGE employees supposed to certify'that,the system is safe? Our home insurance policies=like`your's�leclare that in'the A:Yes,and every year the required inspection forms were Sled: event of a nuclear accident,our insurance will pay nothin 'We know why this is in the policies:The insurance companies; Q I don't understand.Why didn't PGE's inspectors'find aren't stupid,and neither are we. the debris? A: The Nuclear Regulatory Commission(NRC letter to PGE This Trojan plant is an accident waiting to happen:-It was dated September 1,1989)concluded:"Personnel signed the sur- built with major defects, has been badly maintained, and its veillance forms for inspections that were DA done." operators have repeatedly shown that they do not comprehend the workings ofmajor safety systems.Worse yet,the plant has Q. Has Trojan management done any better lately?I cracks in the base rock directly underneath the reactor,directly heard they were recently caught trying to cover-up underneath the nuclear waste pool.In just.the last few years another safety problem: we have learned that the entire area sits on the edge of a great A:True.The Oregonian on 7/23192 described how a PGE news earthquake fault,and that the next quake is overdue. release about an unplanned shutdown"did not mention the backup system's failure".The systems that failed"are supposed The utility is willing to gamble our lives in order to increase. to cool the hot nuclear reactor during a shutdown! their profits.The politicians get big money from the utilities, Q:•I heard,PGE was giving up trying to run the plant, and will never bring them to heel:Children cannot comprehend and turning responsibility over to Westinghouse. Isn't the danger.Teenagers always think that they'are immortal.It that the outfit that has been covering up the truth about falls upon all of us citizens to take responsibility.We are grown= the ghastly nuclear waste tanks at Hanford? ups,and we need to be serious about this. A:You've done your homework.On June 15, 1992,PGE signed If we allow this plant to continue operating and the worse such a deal'with,Westinghouse. Critics,pointed out that should happen,what will we say to our children?Should we tell Westinghouse had never run a nuclear power plant,that it had them that we allowed the plant to run so that the utility could built the steam generators which are now crippling Trojan's make up some of the money it had lost by,buying a defective operations, and that about one-third of the nuclear industry plant?Should we tell them that we lacked the courage to stand 'was suing Westinghouse for fraud.Whether Westinghouse has up to the big utilities?Or should we tell them,perhaps,that we a possible future at Trojan may be decided by Oregon voters in didn't know that this could happen? . November. PHASEOUT=BAILOUTI CLOSE TROJAN NOW (This Information furnished by Gregory Kafoury,Attorney.) (This information furnished by Mark McDougal,Attorney.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.), The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse= ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the me-nt by the State of Oregon,nor does the state uxtrrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument: 41 �i ' Officlal 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OF r � Measure N3 5 OREGON , • k ARGUMENT INgAVOR� ; , w ARGUMENT IN FAVOR The following c(isttu�F"businesses,,individuals and THE TROJAN TEST THAT PGE WANT organizations endorse the immediate shutdown of the YOU TO TAKE..., Trojan Nuclear Power Plant and encourage you to vote 11+] `•�°« 'tvYEB on measures 6 and 6 . 1•Bechtel Corp.designed and built Trojan for PGE What ,• „ �Yk1 r; J�t•, kind of guarantee did PGE get? �t�l�{^it •,'h+Fk a!:; b r.;rE:�. a.25 year guarantee • b.10 year guarantee (This information tum/shad by Kellle M.Petersen,Don't Waste Oregon c.30 Ay guarantee(parts&labor only) Answer;c Commltlee;Charles 0. Porter,'Former Congressman,Edmund G.(Deny) t Brown,Former Gov:of Calif. Emerald People's Utility District,•Conde's (Oregon Statesman,10/25/78) Redwood Lumber Solar Information Center,Paul Nicholson,City Council, E. Eugene;Physicians/a Social Responsibility,William Carpenter Attorney,• 2. How experienced was the Chief Engineer of the I Goose Hollow Window Company,Marshall Engineering;Coberg Hi11 View Trojan Project? Farm,Friendly Foods and Deli;Solar Design and Construction;Charles a.He had designed 10 nuclear plants. E.McLain,Juke Bar,Ecoweb Graphics,Carl Markle,Attorney,N.W. Y b:He had designed 2 nuclear plants. Integratedj'est Management;.Second Nature Bicycles;Marna Fletcher, c.He had never designed a building,in fact,he had never LMT,specials,Care Products,Conant&Conant,Booksellers,La Tlandita; de sign ed a wall. School of Earthy Arts;:Cafe Lena,Inc.;Red Barn Grocery,Happy Harvest Answer:c Co.,Re/lectlans In rme;Emerald Valley Kitchen;Paul's Bike Shops; Riverway Inn;Sandpiper Import Service,Larry Natwick,Musician;Peter 3•In 1986,PGE wrote Bechteli requesting"all'seismic Sorenson,Attorney;MotherKali's Books,Light Magic Productions,The (earthquake) calculations"performed for,Trojan. Third Eye,Greater Goods,Inc.;Peace Economics;Save Our ecoSystems Bechtel s response was: Inc(SOS);Circle of Hands,Eugene Peaceworks,Southern Willamette a."We are unsure whether the transmittal of the.raw seismic Alliance Newspaper,World Peace Univers4,Escape From New York, calculations themselves is in our mutual best interest." Books, b."These calculations could easily mislead Or�onlly Gardens;Plato,Factory Graphic Design;Longfellow s ,one to'a wrong con- Steven MAler,'Mayor of Riveigrove,Judy Saperstone;Wheel Press, elusion." Second Story Books;Laughing Horse Books;Samm Photographer,• c.`The to Sunflower Recycling Co-op;Cup&Saucer Cale;Music Millennium; " ng range effect of such conclusions are ve difficult to Lawelthirst Public House,The Pied Cow Coffeehouse,Think Good ' Answer.,ar 'c, 3 Thoughts,,El Mundo For Women;Man's Best Friend,Hawthorne Auto Club,Inc.;Oregon Chapter Sierra Club,King Harvest,•Peoples Food `.After Bechtel refused to provide the earthquake data Store Coop,,Northwest Merchants,LTD.;Vicky Lien Design and what did PGE do? Advertising;Design Litho Images,Inc.;Richard Greene,Optician;Kathy a.Reported the matter immediately'to the Nuclear Regulatory Ging,Realtor,Astrografix,Anatolia,Monte Marshall,Designer;The Commission. Howling Frog CafaiGallery;Hey Joe Used Books and Records,Ecoprint, b.Announced that they were shutting down the plant until Happy Tralls Records Tapes&'CD's.) safety could be assured. c.They took the hint and did nothing. Answer:c b. Later,the NBC learned Trojan was built;to."half I'1 strength"and Trojan was closed.PGE sued Bechtel,An independent engineering firm PGE hired concluded: a:"The commitment...to use block masonry::was the grossest k kind of error." e b:'"The walls of Trojan did not,comply with the Uniform Building Code for masonry." c."The designers were either naively ignorant or intellectually dishonest. Answer:a,b,c PGE v.Bach Ql (U.S.District Court,Oregon settled 3/18191) never went to trial.PGE and Bechtel asked tie Court to Al thethe file forager•and order everyone connected with the case to never disclose to anyone what they had learned about Trojan's design or construction on pain of going to jgi1.The judge signed the order and the file remains sealed•part of the secretes was obtained and publicly released by the sponsors of this Measure. a Not a single one of these facts has been disputed by PGE.PGE routinely refuses to debate the sponsor of this measure. In 1987,earthquake scientists learned that the Trojan site is periodically subjected to giant earthquakes,vastly greater than f Trojan was originally designed to handle.The last was 350 Yew ago,and the next is likely to happen within the next 50 - years. (This information tumished by Gregory Karoury,Attomey.) (This space purchased for$900 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for 1300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) [Tt;Pr�4g`of this argument does not constitute an endorse_ The rinti State of Oregon,nor does the state warr�artt the A '�°f this argument does not co=argZument.truth,of any Statement made in the a rat�' State of Oregon, nor does th rgument. accuracy or truth of any statement made i 42 _. 4 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED . Measure NO' STATEN *OREGON z •�: ,a+ ARGUMENT INIOPPOSITION ' ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITIONyti'� � 1,000 Neighbors of Trojan Opposed to Measure 5 Measures 5' 6'wouId immediately shut`do twn'Orejon's ( single largest electric'generating plant—just when the MEASURE 5 WOULD SHUT DOWN OREGON'S Northwest needs even ale ctric:power.�For*lover 16 LARGEST ELECTRICITY PLANT.The Trojan Electric yew,Trojan has provided electricity.for Oregon homes&busi Plant has provided safe and economic electricity to Oregonians nesses.Trojan has,contributed to Oregon's economy by produc- for over 16 years.If Trojan is shut down now,power would have on average,as much power each year as Bonneville Dam ' to be purchased from other sources immediately. Measures 5&6 would shut Trojan down^just when the power` TROJAN IS A GOOD NEIGHBOR We are the people who surplus of the last decade is gone. In an August 18, 1992; live around,Trojan,and.we know it is a safe plant.:The profes- Oregonian article, BPA announced it will cut,back power to sionals who operate Trojan are our friends and neighbors.The many industrial customers.,This is•a-prime example of our Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the Oregon Department of energy supply problem ' Energy have full-time inspectors at Trojan. They have the authority to shut the plant down if they believe it is unsafe. As electricity cpnsumers,we are concerned about higher utility bills that would result Timm the immediate shut- TROJAN IS AN ENVIRONMENTALLY RESPONSIBLE down of Trojan.Shutting down Trojan'before`replacement ,. PLANT.Environmental scientists monitor the plant regularly. resources are built would,;damagethe state's economy in many As Trojan's.neighbors,ve enjoy the plant's recreational parka ways in addition to'causing higher utility rates Over 200 wildlife species thrive in the forests, ponds and marshes around the plant,including bald eagles, great blue A plant shutdown would'unmediately cause about 1.000 men herons, and Canada'geese. Trojan is featured in the Oregon and women to lose their Jobs.Small and large businesses would Department of Fish and Wildlife's"Oregon Wildlife Viewing pay more for electricity,making Oregon products and.services Guide". cost more and endangering even more jobs. A SHUTDOWN WOULD CAUSE OVER 1,000 LOST JOBS Oregon is already in a recession. Shutting do wn our single AND HUGE TAX COSTS.A Trojan shutdown would cause largest electricity plant before we have replacement power over 1,000 men and women to lose their jobs.Ratepayers would sources in place.would hurt our efforts to maintain and foot the bill for expensive new power plants to replace Trojan's strengthen our economy. t electricity.This would increase rates and.create major new bud- get problems for local governments at a time when Oregon We urge you to VOTE NQ ON MEASURES 5&S. already faces serious budget deficits. STOP THE DRASTI C SHUTDOWN OF TROJAN. One way or another,utility customers will pay more with an immediate shutdown,A recent study by Oregon's Attorney James M.Wright Cheryl L.Wilson General concluded that plant compensation costs to Trojan's Chairman,Oregon Vice President owners,an amount'in I6 hundreds of millions of dollars,could Economic Development Oregon Resources Corp:' ` be paid by all Oregon taxpayers. Commission f Iry Pletcher', Richard Butrick President We live,with our friends and families,within a few miles of the President Oregon AFL-CIO Trojan plant.We oppose a Trojan shutdown.We urge you to Associated Oregon Industries join us in voting No on 5. James E.Reinmuth. ; Ronald E.Fortune Dean,College of 1,000 NEIGHBORS OF TROJAN URGE YOU TO VOTE"NO" Executive Secretary-Treasurer Business Administration ON MEASURE 5. Northwest Oregon Labor University of Oregon ; Council,AFL-CIO Ed Balsiger (This lnformatlon furnished by Bet§y R.Johnson.) General Manager Pendleton Grain Growers The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations are included for identification only. (This Informatlon tumished by Paul,,Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) (This space purchased."Ith a pet/tion containing the signatures of 1,000 voters eligible to vote on the measure In accordance with ORS 251.255.). (7711s space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does riot"constitute an endorse-' ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument: 43 I F Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet "7 CONTINUED M � STATE OF OREGON ARGUMENT IN",OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN 0PP0SIT10N SCIENTISTS AND ENG RS URGE Na VOTE ON 5& Educators Oppose The Drastic Shutdown Of Trojan 6.We have studied Measures:b&6-and urge Oregon voters to Caused By Measures 5&6. carefully review the facts before voting: WEBSTER'S NINTH NM O EGIATE DICTl01�?=. 1 TROJAN:OPERATES SAFELY:Trojan is operated by DRASTIC\'dress-tilt\adj-radical in effect or action licensed professionals who are trained and tested annually.The Nuclear Regulatory Commission(NRC) and the Oregon DepartmenCof,Energy,(ODOE)have full-time inspectors at the Measures 5 &6 are drastic measures. Their radical effects plant. Trojan must also,meet requirements of the Oregon would cause the immediate shutdown of Oregon's single largest Department of Environmental Quality and the Oregon electricity plant. This unreasonable and unnecessary action De partment of Fish and Wildlife. would cause an immediate power deficit equal in size to half the City,of Portland's annual'electric use. TROJAN'S POWER IS NEEDED FOR OREGON UNTIL NETSOURCES,CAN BE DEVELOPED.The electricity sur- WE HAVE EXAMMED THE EFFECTS OF THESE MEA- plus'.of the"last decade is gone.Trojan'produees on average as SURES AND SUPPORT THE PLANED, GRADUAL, much power as Bonneville Dam.'Developing the resources and AND RESPONSIBLE ALTERNATIVE—THE FOUR-YEAR f needed to replace Trojan will take time. PHASE-OUT PLAN. An orderly phase-out of Trojan over the next four'years will FROM A SCIENTIFIC STANDPOINT, INCREASED allow adequate time for the careful planning and development RELIANCE ON FOSSIL FUELS POSES RISKS TO THE of responsible,low-cost energy resources needed to'replace ENVIRONMENT.Even with additional conservation,burning Trojan's electricity. This transition will provide time to make more coal to generate electricity would be necessary if Trojan.is the right energy choices for Oregonians immediately shut down.Mining-and burning coal can have adverse environmental consequences. A drastic shutdoorn will create higher power costs for schools, colleges,and universities which are already struggling on tight Coal-fired electric plants add large amounts of carbon dioxide budgets. and sulfur dioxide into the air.These by-products from electrici- ty production contribute to"global warming".or the"greenhouse Please study the costs of Measure 5&6 for all Oregonians,and effect", which may raise a major threat to our planet's ecosys- vote"NO"on Measure 5&6. tems. The views expressed are our ow An 'mmad are included for identification o n and our titles and atliliations ,a+p' h down of ha T. na�le• nor-plant world b� nly. had public nohev with adyeraa Pnt ronmg; gl ce quences• Ix From a scion ifi g rsDec ive. a planned phase-out makes Gene sense—a drastic Carlson ' Gerald E.Young Superintendent Dean of Arts&Sciences Rainier School District Eastern Oregon State College f JOIN US IN VOTING N,2( ON MEASURES 5&6. 1 STOP DRASTIC SHU MO m r Dr.Julian Battaile Lori D.Mayo Professor Emeritus of Chemistry Teacher j The views expressed are our own and our titles'and affiliations Southern Ore.State College Bayith Academy are included for identification only. d Judith A.Cochran Charles A.Clemans d Director of Student Thomas Nelson Former Superintendent, Dr.H.Chik M.Erzurumlu Development, Oregon City Schools .. Dean,Sch ool'of Engineering Dean of Engineering Columbia Gorge University of Portland Portland State University Community College Alan H.Robinson Cyrus W.Field g' Head,Dept.Nuclear Engineering, Professor of Geology (This information furnished by Paul W.Voge%NO on 5&6 Comminee.J Corvallis Philomath . (This information furnished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) t t (This space purchased far$900 in accordance with ORS 251.255. (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an e4&r se- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- accuracy or truth.of,any statement made in the argument. by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the ' t• accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 44 , NMI Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED Measure No 5 STATE OF ■ OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION.` ARGUMENT IN::OPPOSITION I ' AN IMMEDIATE SHUTDOWN OF TROJAN CAUSED BY WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE"ENVIRONMENT; MEASURES 5&6 WOULD CREATE HUGE COSTS AND AND WE OPPOSE MEASURES 5&6. y DAMAGE OREGON'S ECONOMY. An immediate shutdown'of Trojan by measures 5 &6 Measures 5 &6.would be very expensive for Oregonians. would force poor energy replacement choices that could , Bonneville Power Administration has announced that electrici- damage our environment.,—,w+' ty rates will increase as much as 20 percent over the next two years due to drought conditions,endangered salmon species, BPA recently announced'that our region is now facing power and the need to build new generating resources. 1. deficits and that they must start buying new'energy resources immediately:to fill the gap(BPA Press Statement,6/22/92) Trojan is a`resource equal in size to the Bonneville Dam.The immediate loss of Trojan's power would,increase electricity Cutting off Trojan's electricity now would not allow the needed »" rates.Local governments would be forced to increase taxes or time to bring on environmentally responsible new energy j fees in order to finance the higher electricity vests of schools, resources such as conservation programs.cogeneration plants. sewage and water,treatment.facilities, street lights,and other and renewable resources like wind and geothermal Rower, basic services. „ These drastic shutdown measures would cause about 1,000 MEASURES 5&•6 WOULD RESULT IN AN IMMEDIATE Oregon men and women to immediately lose their jobs.This SHUTDOWN AND HURT OUR NORTHWEST ENVIRON- �. would hurt our economy—when we face a continuing emission. Y s,: r It would cause a ripple effect throughout our state's economy r and increase operating costs for thousands of small and large Closing Trojan immediately could force the purchase•of more businesses. Higher electric rates would also discourage new hydropower,increasing the Rressure on our hydroelectric dams. businesses from locating here: at a time when our state may still be in a drought condition. This would also further threaten our endangered salmon popu- We are concerned about Oregon's job market and economy. lations. f J�Q ON Nothing can take the place of good energy planning We We urge you to study these issues carefully and VOTE care about the environment,and we support a responsi- MEASURES 5&6. ble four-year phase-out of Trojan to allow time to devel- op environmentally sound replacement resources The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations are included for identification only. JOIN US.VOTE"NO"ON 5&6. STOP THE DRASTi_C SHUTDOWN. Elsie Stubr Raymond Barnwell Senior Advocate President,Southern The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations Washington County Oregon Central Labor Council are included for identification only. Jose Alberto Nunez Thomas M.Zepp President Energy Economist Gerald W.Herrmann John R.Donaldson Farmworker Housing Utility Resources,Inc: Naturalist&Environmental Executive Director, Development Corp. Educator,Oregon City Columbia Basin Fish& • . Wildlife Authority Bob Montgomery Gerald R.Edwards Vernon L.Rifer General Manager Mayor Past President Gail Achterman Port of Cascade Locks City of Tigard Oregon Environmental Council Attorney Former Assistant to the Lt.Col.U.S.Army(Ret.)Sammy E.Radow Allen&Louisa Bateman Governor for Natural Board Member,Clackamas County Children's Commission Environmental Activists Resources Former Chair,Clackamas County Community Action Agency Klamath Falls (This information fumished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) (This information famished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does n&constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse-' ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 45 } Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet -�• CONTINUED ` STATE OF Measure,.-No. OREGON ARGUMENT LIV OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION 'r Ballot Measures'16�&}6'Could Become Tax Increase Farmers Oppose Trojan's Immediate Shutdown Measures. Oregon farmers face serious eoonomic'challenges.We can"ill- °�' afford the drastic;immediate shutdown of the Trojan electric. If Trojan is immediately shutdown by passage of Measures b& Plank caused by measures b &6.We urge"you.to consider the 6,do you know itoould result in a tax liability to.Oregon's tax- cost impacts these measures would have on farmers. payers?We urgeyou'to learn about these costly measures and VOTE"NO°,*„ Oregon farms face serious drought conditions:Many of us have already lost the ability to irrigate our fields.An According to a recent opinion by Oregon's Attoripey immediate Trojan shutdown would create the'need to work the General,:(Letter of Advice, 6/8/92," to OPUC 'hydroelectric generating system harder to make up for the loss Commissioners);'if Trojan is forced to shut down, of Trojan's power.If additional water is released from the reser- Trojazes owners could seek compensation from the State voirs to generate electricity this winter, we will be unable to in'a court proceeding.That compensation would be borne by water our,crops next summer. all Oregon taxpayers.Oregon taxpayers do not need more taxes. We depend on.stable,low-cost electricity rates.We can. Phasing-out Trojan and replacing it with more economic not aPford'the large increases in power costs"caused by resources is the"least-cost option"for Oregonians. an immediate Trojan closure.Most of us have family farms Trojan's owner's will be conducting an orderly phase-out of the and need to watch our costs closely.Increased energy costs from . plant by-1996. Over the next four years, new, more economic a Trojan closure would threaten the survival of many small generating resources will be acquired.But without'adequate farms• time to plan for these new resources,'our energy future is uncer- tain. The impacts of saving threatened salmon populations on the Columbia River Basin will make irrigating our crops We urge you to examine the potential costs for electricity con-t and barging our products more difficult.An immediate sumers and Oregon taxpayers of an immediate shutdown of closure of Trojan would place even more'pressure on the Trojan.Join us in voting XQ on measures b&6. already stressed hydro system and increase the costs of operat- ing our farms. The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations ti are included for identification only. We support the responsible, orderly phase-out plan for Trojan in order to ensure adequate power supplies over the next four '! Stan W.Baumhofer Terry L.Cochran years while replacement resources are being planned and built.. Oregon Tax Research President Please Join us and Vote M on Measures 5&6 h,! Former Executive Director Columbia River Bank STOP THE DRASTIC SHUTDOWN MEASIMS p, Marvin Abeene Martin D.Alter Past President, Partner, The-views.expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations oo f Commerce a amber Rookstool&Alter �included for identification only. Certified Public Accountants �j Bruce Hugo Vernon White Stafford Hassell Doug Breese . Oregon State Representative Oregon Tax Research Award-Winning Conservationist President Columbia&Washington Former Research Director Boardman Oregon Farm Bureau t Counties Bruce Lovelin Hugo Shibahara Robert G.Holdridge Executive Director Shibaahara Ranch Commissioner Governor's Commissi Northwest Irrigation Utilities Hood River on on - Senior Services Hector Macpherson David Henzel Farmer Director Linn County Klamath Agricultural and (This information furnished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) Business Assistance Corp. (This information fumished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5:&6 Committee) (This space purchased for$3oQ in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this artcment does not constitute an endorse-' meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the : ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the.state warrnnt the aoruraey or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 46 Official.1992 General Voters'Pam hlet STATE OF Y Measure No 5 � ,. ■ OREGON i ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION i PHYSICIAN'S STATEMENT AGAINST MEASURES b&6: RECOMIVVIEEND"NO"VOTE. As physicians and health care professionals,we want to con- tribute to the public discussion of Measures b &6, since sup- porters of these measures often raise health and safety issues. t We have concluded that the immediate shutdown of the Trojan electric plant makes''no sense from a health and safety stand- point.Moreover,'an immediate shutdown of Trojan would, environmentally damaging and very expensive. # Trojan has been safely producing electricity for Oregon for more 3 than 16 years.If Trojan is immediately shut down,replacement power would be generated by increasing our reliance on fossil fuels.Fossil-fuel burning plants,such as coal-fired plants,pro- , duce by-products that can have adverse health and environ- mental impacts. t From a health perspective, an immediate Trojan shutdown is drastic and unnecessary. Trojan should continue to operate until responsible replacement resources are developed under the current 4 year phase-out plan.We urge our fellow Oregon citizens to vote against the shutdown of this safe plant. Pisses join,us iii voting"NO"ON b&6. a Gary F.Gates,M.D. Director,Nuclear Medicine Department St.Vincent Hospital&Medical Center Oliver N.Massengale,M.D. Pediatrician,Beaverton. Stephen Weil;M.D. Surgeon,Lake Oswego David R.Arnold Chairman of the Board Merle West Medical Center Richard Allen,M.D.,I Past President,Oregon Medical Association James A.Cross,M.D. West Hills Womens Clinic The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations are included for identification only. (This Information furnished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.), r (Th/s space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.th! r�i'a +4f, tlr`a1s" n.a..».rm..m++v..HwY.-.tin.+rh+wt[ti •' .. ': 4 °l •' -i � Otfidal 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED r a - w. `STATE OF Me' asure N ;�. . OREGON Proposed b y im tiative'petttioa�, to be voted on at the General energy. For this additional reason, the uncertainties in the Election,November 8;1992 nuclear waste cycle make nuclear power an uneconomical and, I` BALLOT TITLE uncertain source of energy. ; Now therefore the people of the state of Oregon enact this Oregon Nuclear Power Plant Regulation Improvement Act, notwithstanding any other provisions of law:` ........ V":`>:'• >..':;; Section 2. ; , (a) REVIEW,OF ABILITY TO WITHSTAND EARTH UARES AND APPROPRIATE REGULATION. $ 1b 171rsCOa )awa�a: ! nteu► ►vapWey ' 'g1 plaAt aperatlor unlass.plant n►eots eart quAli state (i) For purposes of this Act, lords :. I ! and. itilp rmanen Wa#esito;:" ..:�nte;6i l»:>?«:>.:>:' >:«> (t1)"inde ndenemeans :..::::_:>;:.::>::<•.•:::,:.::::: f .....:fie::::.... .. Pe : O conducted by arsons and firms which have C) 'Y.» Ct retllaires lndegendertt stt:dyo : : employed by or ever contracted with the Energy Facility Siting e Txojap s#t$,p '. tty Council; nor been employed by or ever contracted with any ` ti1<iVjtllstAtc) a1tl►gi18fJti18&:�u f.'A11ttC#I. ; operator of any nuclear-fueled thermal power plant being fi?t►iEas'Trc�jan;plan: at Withtai3>pls§b :eait#i reviewed pursuant to the provisions of this act or,an enter av- ` :::::i:'s::>... p Y h clutak w1tl pu E, u itv :' :' :`.'. ' ing an ownership interest m such a plant;and xee0ues.plant ti1.u8G tease oY3ttYA#L.011klXAt4t (2) not subject to control by the Energy Facility Siting must pay fp;F cooperateea j Council nor any operator of any nuclear-fueled thermal power: op�zatior�dQ days air A�c ;' t ulal:fit' > ': ':':>»: plant as to the conduct of any investigation and analysis,except rmanent W ra .:...;:;.::.:.:::;:.:::•:<rr:::..::>:..:< .avu> : te <>:'::::._:: that Council shall insure that any investigation or analysis storage does npt eaeed plant*a agnpalductxq�q is carried on to meet the objectives of this Act; Plant elusing Costs not inClttdulkle itr xutsa.C:itl #x8, (B)"plant"means all physical structures and components coin mad+iIIterveis.is rizleaaku ciitteatied.cash„isd ::;'.: :.:::::....... prising the nuclear-fueled thermal power plant, including,but f not limited to,the plant's nuclear waste and spent nuclear fuel ESTIMATE dF FR�Al SILC7JL'1A�L� :iAr7f?i�7pfii:::.c:i'iii!i`: i`>i;i Energy Facility SitinC cancel shall commence local sebools P7 Pe revenues W ]be reduced (ii) Wit of this Act,the by .5 xutl on and other F�uwag dzstriets propex y rgy il Y g review by con- 0.00,Yn,I99f�;96;:: tested case'proceeding of the suitability bility of the site of any the State zs ob$gated#o replace pxnperty jev nu clear-fueled'thermal power plant having'reoeived a'site oar enueslost tithe.Irxsltaehool3! ;::::::>:<:>: :><«::; tin cate too rate in Oregon.. As art o i Pe f is review, Council 8 cil ” P , OREGON NUCLEAR POWER PLANT REGULATION shall cause an independent geologic and seismic investigation NUCLEAR P ACT to be performed to identify and evaluate all geologic and seismic,, faults underneath and in the vicinity of the plant, including ` evaluating such faults for the potential for earthquakes and the' SECTION 1.FINDINGS. magnitude of such earthquakes, as well as'evaluate the poten- (a) The people of the State of Oregon find that increased care teal magnitude of subduction zone earthquakes that might must be given to the regulation of nuclear power plants in affect the plant. The Council, as part of its review, shall also Oregon because the current level of regulation is inadequate. 'cause independent engineering analysis to be done of the p Inadequate regulation threatens the people of Oregon and their Plant to determine'the adequacy of the plant,including its government with immense health,property and financial loss- design and actual construction,to withstand major earthquakes es.In particular,the people find that: without harm to life,property or natural resources,including earthquakes of a magnitude of 9.5 on the Richter Scale. Such (i) New scientific research shows that Oregon is subject to studies shall be paid for by the operator of the plant on each site earthquakes of great magnitude. Therefore,the unsafe siting reviewed, as an additional fee for operation.'The Council's and construction of a nuclear power plant in Oregon,particular_ review, including the contested case proceeding before the y ' an area subject to earthquake activity,can lead to cats- Council,but not including appeals or remands thereof shall be strophic loss of life,property and natural resources,and makes nuclear power an uneconomical and uncertain source of energy, Completed within 300 days after the effective date of this act. particularly when hundreds of millions of dollars must be spent (m)The Energy Facility Siting Council shall only find suitable a to upgrade and repair steam generators and steam generator site which is susceptible to an earthquake of a magnitude of 9.5 tubes;and on the Richter Scale,or such other earthquake as to which it (ii) continuing to add spent nuclear fuel and high level nuclear may be found to be susceptible,if the plant constructed thereon 'waste to temporary storage facilities,when the federal vern- can withstand such earthquake without harm to health;safety, went can not assure that's, go property or.natural resources. Conclusions as to any matter permanent storage facility will a regarding suitability contrary to conclusions in the independent made available within a reasonable"time, increases the, ,studies provided for in Section 2(aXii), may only be made if extremely large sums of money that Oregon ratepayers,if not all the taxpayers of the State of Oregon, will possibly end up established by clear and convincing evidence. Paying to Provide for indefinite or permanent storage and secu- '(iv)No nuclear-fueled thermal power plant constructed on a site rity for such wastes.Moreover, once its temporary storage is which, after the review provided for in this Act, is not found filled up,a nuclear plant can no longer operate.Such uncertain., suitable shall continue to operate. ties in the nuclear`waste cycle make nuclear power an unto- (v) Regardless whether a contested case has begun,'the opera- nomical and uncertain source of energy.In addition, many .tor of any plant being reviewed shall cooperate with all persons Oregonians reasonably see the indefinite storage of spent conducting independent studies provided for in Section 2(aXii) nuclear fuel and high-level nuclear waste in Oregon in tempo. and the Energy Facility Siting Council,including the providing rary storage facilities as extremely hazardous,and that the haz. of all information asked for by the Council or persons'conduct and is,increased by continuing to add spent nuclear fuel and ing independent studies pursuant to Section 2(aXii), except high-level nuclear waste to temporary storage when,a perma• information established not to be relevant and not likely to lead nent storage facility is not available.Such legitimate concerns to the discovery of relevant information. Such information ,affect economic development and planning for the supply of includes,but is not limited to,all drawings, studies, specifics. 48 Offidal`1992 General Voters'Pam hlet _.. CONTINUED MeasureNo. 6 STATE OF.OREGON tions,'analyses, correspondence, memoranda, and all �ytr li scripts of testimony and other materials associated with EXPLANATORY STATEMENT igation regarding siting or construction of the plant.Upon its own motion'or upon application of any person conducting any independent study provided for in Section 2(axii),the Council is The effect of this measure is to'stop'the°operation of the empowered to and shall issue subpoenas to any person or entity Trojan Nuclear Power Plant on January 2,1993. for production of relevant information and P giving of testimony Before_Tro�an4cah-operate again:the federal goveznment` under,oath,iw deposition or,hearing. This provision supple- must be operating a'permanent.nuclear.waste.storage site or ments and does not limit ORS`183.440. on-site nuclear waste storage at Trojan must not exceed the (vi)The Council shall adopt all necessary regulations to enforce Plant's annual production ' x these provisions: In addition,'the,Oregon Energy Facility Siting Council miffs (b) REGULATION'OF THE STORAGE OF NUCLEAR determine by'September 29,1993,in a'contested case proceed= WASTE ing,that Trojan is able to withstand earthquakes to which the. (i). For purposes of this Act, "indefinite storage of high-level site may be.found to be susceptible;;without harm to health; nuclear waste and spent nuclear fuel at an operating nuclear- safety, property or natural resources.This proceeding must fueled thermal power plant".means storage of more than one include an independent geologic and'seismic'investigation and year's.accumulation of high-level,nuclear waste or spent an independent engineering analysis of Trojan.'These studies must be paid for by the operator of Trojan nuclear fuel at the,site of a nuclear fueled thermal power plant S"`It `y, . , while the,plant is in.operation at a time when a permanent The measure provides'tlat the'operator may not include in waste storage,site,developed and operated by the Federal its rates the costs.of closing or decommissioning the Trojan Government for such nuclear waste and spent fuel is not avail- Nuclear Power Plant due to passage of this measure. able. (ii) The indefinite storage of high-level nuclear waste and spent Committee Members Appointed by" nuclear fuel at an operating nuclear-fueled thermal power plant Richard Botteri Chief Petitioners , is prohibited, and any such plant in violation of this provision Kathy Schneider Chief Petitioners shall cease operation within 30 days of the effective date of this Roy Hemming'ay* Secretary of State A Steven Sautter* Secretary of State (iii)Nothing in,this Act shall affect any obligation of any opera- Laird Kirkpatrick Secretary of State [[ for of a nuclear-fueled thermal power plant,whether or not in s•,' " „ operation,from removing from its plant site high-level nuclear *member dissents(does'not concur with the explanatory waste and spent nuclear fuel,when a permanent waste storage statement) site developed and operated by the Federal Government for such nuclear waste and spent fuel becomes available. (iv)The Energy Facility Siting Council shall adopt all necessary (This Committee was appointed to provide an Impardai explanation of the regulations to enforce these provisions. ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251.215.) (c) COSTS OF DECOMMISSIONING. In the event any nuclear-fueled thermal power plant can not continue to operate because of any provision of this Act,no public agency regulating the rates charged by such operator or other utility having an interest in such L plant shall include in such rates the costs of decommissioning or closing such plant temporarily or perms-6 nently. (d) ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES:All actions required or authorized by this Act of any,state agency shall be carried out pursuant to the provisions of the Oregon law'of administra tive procedure,including ORS Chapter 183,as supplemented and modified by this Act.Any citizen of the State of Oregon may intervene as a party in any rule making or contested case proceeding conducted pursuant to the provisions of this Act: (e) SEVERANCE CLAUSE. If any section,portion, clause'or phrase of this Act is for any reason held to be invalid or uneon-� stitutional,the remaining sections,portions,'clauses and phras- es shall not be affected but shall remain in full force and effect, and to this end the provisions of this Act are severable. 49 -Official 1992 General' al Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED ti STATE OF Ax I MOREGON ARGUMENT: k FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR Don't Pay tgClean Up Their Radiontive Waste Dump .THE TROJAN NUCLEAR POWER PLANT IS EXPEN- SIVE, UNRELIABLE AND IS NOT NEEDED TO MEET The'accumulation'ofnuclear waste and the doubts about THE REGIONS ENERGY NEEDS. Trojan's ability to withstand earthquakes make power generat- ed by,Trojan undependable and I uneconomical.Here are the On April'14, 1992 the Board of Directors.of Emerald People's Utility District voted unanimous to support s three parts'of-Measure 6 and why we believe they are in the unanimously closing the Trojan best interest¢of all Oregonians Nuclear Power Plant. The truth-is,in 1991 Trojan had: Part I Measure six.requirea Trojan's owners to remove radioactive spent fuel from the site or close the 31 NRC violations industry average=12 ' �" plant 584 radiation exposure count industry average=436 307 outage days industry average=105 .r ?' 15.3%capacity factor industry This"effectively closes the plant since Trojan's owners p �' stry average=$33. have operated the plant for 16 years despite having no $169.96/MWH cost performance industry average=$33.72 pan or how to remove the radioactive waste which is Bonneville Power Administration assumed responsibility for 30 ' accumulating at the•plant percent of the costs and liability for Trojan.BPA did not give their customers,including Emerald PUD a choice in that deci- Part II Measure six requires independent studies of the plant sion.Our ratepayers, along with every PUD, CO-OP and and the likely earthquake that would occur at the site, Municipal utility ratepayer in the Northwest are going to pay i to determine what size earthquake Trojan can with- for this 30%interest,they should know how that happened stand If the plant can't withstand the size earth- The Federal Nuclear Regulatory Commission(1VRC)increased quake expected,Trojan would have to close. the estimated cost for decommissioning Trojan from$117 mil-' lion to$230 million(1989 dollars);recent estimates set the;cost Scientists have determined that a much larger earth- at $500 million. Every day the plant,operates the cost for quake can be expected in the area around the plant decommissioning will increase.Every day the plant.operates it than was anticipated when the plant was built in 1976. produces more highlevel radioactive waste that must be stored In addition,the accumulation of 440 tons of radioactive on site and ultimately transported to a permanent storage site. waste in what was designed as a temporary storage However,no permanent site exists and will not exist until some facility was not expected, time beyond 2012. This provision is just common sense,not even Trojan's Trojan did not operate for most of 1991 and has not operated for owners would argue that the plant should continue to most of 1992-This unreliable resource has forced EPA and PGE operate if it can't withstand an expected earthquake. , to purchase expensive short term power rather than contract " j for much less expensive long term power. { Part III Measure six prevents government regulators from Every day this plant stays open,taxpayers subsidize it through h requiring electrical consumers to pay the cost of clean- federal insurance. f ing up the radioactive waste that is left when Trojan is s closed Every day this plant stays open,ratepayers pay higher rates for expensive generation that can be replaced by cleaner,safer,less We believe that Trojan's owners should not be allowed expensive resources. to profit from their own mistakes. Every day this plant stays open, we produce more highlevel radioactive material for our children and grandchildren to fig- They operated the plant for 16 years with no idea how ure out what to do with and how to pay for. much it ultimately would cost to clean up the radioao- tive waste.They assumed that,whatever the cost,they Isn't trillions of dollars of national debt enough of a problem for would simply pass the problem on to the next,genera- the next generation?Let us stop dumping highlevel radioactive tion. waste on the doorstep of the 21st century., 'S We don't believe that,our children and our chit: IT NEVER TOO SOON TO CLOSE TROJAN dren's children should pay to clean up the radioactive waste they had no part in'creating Jeff Shields Richard(Dick)Eymaim Vote Yes on Measure 6 General Manager President EPUD EPUD (This information furnished by Ross Williams,campaign Manager,Do It (This information/umi Yourself Committee.) shad by Richard Eymann,President,Emerald to People's Utility District.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance,with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$30o in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The rink meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the p n8 of this argument does not constitute an endorse- accuracy ortruth of an statement meet by the State of Oregon, nor does the'state warrant the Y made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. c ;w 50 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ..._..CONTINUED p. STATE OF Measur eNO. 6 OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN�FAVOR Protect Public from Restoration Costs ITS CHEAPER AND SAFER TO'CLOSE TROJAN NOW. s; ,, , The Sierra Club national policy adopted November lb,1986 Here are some of the reasons it is cheaper and safer to`close'the says utility stockholders should be responsible under state law troubled plant now rather thanwait four ears as'reCenti' for decommissioning and dismantling costs not collected from posed: p Y " Y Pro • ratepayers during the operating life of the plant.. A Lot More Waste Will Be Created- Waiting would create more x Costs Will Exceed$488 Million dangerous,highly radioactive nuclear waste that would have to be stored at Trojan because no permanent storage site has These policies,like Measure 6,are designed to protect the pub- proven to be secure. lic from limitless liability for the mistaken decisions of privately owned utilities to build nuclear power plants. Qualified Employees Will Leave=The operators will struggle to retain top employees."As the best workers leave for more secure . According to Order 91-186 of the Oregon Public Utility jobs,safety may be jeopardized..If Trojan loses enough licensed Commission,February 4,1991"decommissioning costs are esti- control room operators; federal regulators would force an mated at$488 million"at Trojan.We believe this is the mini- unscheduled,highly.costly shut down,leaving the region ce n- .• mum amount.The ultimate costs are almost limitless. dent on emergency replacement power. Site Won't be Restored Before 2010 " Improvements Needed for Safety May Be Short-Changed-The operators will be increasingly reluctant to spend large sums of Decommissioning money on plant improvements and repairs.The plant cost$210 ning cannot be expected before the year 2010 and million to fix and operate last year.The operators will be tempt- even that is an optimistic time line. We believe that nuclear ed to reduce these costs for the next four years, possibly power plants;barring exceptional circumstances,should be dig- decreasing the margin of safety at the plant.Closing the plant mantled and the sites restored 30 to 50 years after the plant would avoid these costs and eliminate the hazards. has ceased operating. Replacement Power wer•is Avail4le'and Inexpensive-When Now that the owners of the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant have. Trojan was closed for a full year recently for maintenance prob- decided to close Trojan,this closure should be accomplished as lems replacement power was purchased at prices 30 percent soon as possible. This will prevent accumulation of more below the cost of running Trojan.But,the owners still had to radioactive waste,assure the safe closure of the plant and pro- pay all the expenses for a fully staffed plant even though it pro- tect ratepayers. duce no electricity.if the utility acts responsibly power could be purchased immediately from other utilities at reasonable costs. Vote Yes on Measure 6 Owners Need to Focus on New Sources-The owners say they want,to help customers.conserve more energy and build renew- (This Information furnished by Dave Mazza,Chairperson,Oregon Chapter able energy resources.But they will find it very difficult to run of Sierra Club.) a troubled nuclear plant and start their company on a new direction at the same time.If Trojan were closed,the company's management could devote themselves full-time to developing labor intensive,cleaner new energy sources including,conserva- tion,cogeneration,wind power and geothermal energy. Vote Yes on Measure 6 ' (This Information fugl/shed by Edward A.Sme(off.) (This space purchased for$'300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251-255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse. j ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant,the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.- III: 51 iI. Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED I w STATE OF . . O m"6 Measure% N_ OREGON ARGUMENT INFAVOR ARGUMENT'K FAVOR: TROJAN:A RISK'WE DON'T NEED TO TAKE Public Shouldn't Be Obliged to Keep Paying for Trojan The decision by:Portland General Corp:to close the Trojan Do Oregon's citizens have an"obligation"to keep a pri- nuclear power plant in 1996 clearly shows that it doesn't make vately owned utility financially healthy? sense to operate the plant any longer. Trojan's primary owner thinks we do.They stated in public tes The'Oregon,teague of Conservation Voters is concerned timony that the Oregon Public Utility Commission(PUC)has about thwenvironmental effects of operating Trojan for another "an obligation to'keep the utility financially healthy."(July 28, four years ;, 1992 hearing by the Secretary of State on Ballot Measure 6) The probability of an accident at Trojan rises as it gets older Last year, when Trojan Was shut down for repairs, Trojan's and wears out.In addition,the Northwest is vulnerable to an owner reported a loss of$90 million.Following this principal of earthquake 10 to 100 times more severe than Trojan can with- obligation to keep the utility financially healthy,the PUC stand,according to some geologists.Ballot Measure 6 requires passed on more than $50 million of those losses to electrical Trojan to shut down if an independent seismological study 'consumers,in the form of higher rates.Trojan's owners then shows it cannot handle this risk t paid dividends totalling more than$50 million to their share- holders,despite their reported losses. , P TROJAN CREATES NUCLEAR,WASTE - Should Oregon's citizens pay to clean up the radioactive Every day Trojan operates it creates more nuclear waste--w waste at Trojan? much as 120 tons over the next four year.It will have to be stored on-site next to the Columbia River,since there is still no No one denies Trojan's owners are entitled to a fair return on permanent Federal nuclear waste repository.' their investment.,But they have been producing radioactive waste at Trojan for 16 years without any plan for what will Managing this additional nuclear waste will add to the cost happen to it. of shutting the plant down.But too much time and money has already been spent trying to`k*p Trojan open,and there have Now they are planning to close the plant because it is no longer been consistent cost overruns.Studies by independent utility economically viable and they demand that the public give them experts show that, for the short run,Trojan's output can be a blank check for the cost of decommissioning.They want our replaced by surplus power without risking shortages or exces- children and our children's children to pay for this terrible,mis- sive cost. take.In fact they claim we have no choice.We don't think 1 that is fair. WE CAN DO MORE WITH CONSERVATION AND RENEWABLE ENERGY It will likely reduce their profits,but we think they should pay, these costs. The experience of the Sacramento Municipal Utility District, where voters recently closed the Rancho Seco nuclear plant,is By passing Measure 6 you will prevent the Public Utility' important.Sacramento now has a program to use.conservation, Commission from"obligating"future generations to pay renewable energy and cogeneration to help meet its future enerp these costs. gy needs,without the burden of having to rein a nuclear plant at the same time.We can do the same in Oregon. Vote Yes on Measure 6 2 By shutting Trojan down now,we can: • Eliminate the risk of a plant accident. (This information fumished by Ross Williams,Campaign Manager,Do it • Halt the creation of new radioactive waste. Yourself Committee.) Stop spending money to operate an oldqutmoded plant. Get a head start on achieving a new,efficient,renewable energy future for Oregon. Vote YES on Measure 6 (This Information furnished by Fred Heutte,,Board Member,Oregon League of Conservation Voters.) (This space purchased for$900 in accordance with ORS 25),255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not Limthe te an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does te warrant the men$by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement mad argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the a rgument. WNW • 52 sub r.3 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet.,, 'CONTINUED Me'asute STATE OF No.- 6 OREGON ` - RGUMENT IN FAVOR' ARGUMEN A T INFAVOR 4 4 , '- Recently, Portland.General Electric;decided to close down Statement of Ralph Nadear bn,Trojan Phase 0iit p]ah ° Trojan.l applaud the move.Now,,we need to make sure r ratepayers don't get stuck with the bill.It was management's h r' decision to build Trojan;it was management's decision to close Washington,D.C. `The'Trojan nuclear,power plant should, r Trojan.The ratepayers shouldn't pay for management's mis- be taken,out of service this year.Allowing this costly nuclear takes, lemon to run on for four more years will only generate more radioactive waste and pose a continued'safety hazard to Oregonians. —Gail R.Shibley - While Portland General Electric has finally recognizqd the s reality of a future without Trojan,its desperate effort toldelay f (This Information furnished by Gail Shibley,State Representative,District for four more years should be rejected.Oregon voters can still x12) use direct democracy under the ballot initiative to close Trojan down this year. The sooner this atomieVower plant is closed down,the soon er Oregon can move on to a sustainable energy future built on efficiency technologies and renewable resources. { ' The burden of Paying Trojan's heavy decommissioning costs should be borne by PGE's shareholders,not,by the"ratepayers " who have already paid too much for PGE's,reckless nuclear ven- ' tore." Ralph Nader' (This'inlormation fumished by Ralph Nader.) ' r a , II i ' Ali (This space purchased for$300 in accordance.with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) ' •I 1 The printing o this argument does not constitute an endorse- The rinti of this argument does not constitute an endorse p ng f r8u printing gu ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meat by the Slate of Oregon, nor does the state'warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 53 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED ",,; STATE OF Measure No, 6` OREGON i+" r f ARGUMENTIN�FAVOR' {' ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ' . THE'FO ORGANIZATIONS SAND COMMU• TIM FOLLOWING LANE COUNTY COMMUNITY LEAD- , NITY LEADERSHAVE ENDORSED BALLOT MEASURE ERS,INDIVIDUALS,AND BUSINESSES URGE:YOU'TO e.PLEASEVOIN WITH.US IN VOTING YES ON NOVEM- JOIN THEM IN SUPPORTING BALLOT MEASURE State Senator Grattan Kerans Southern Willamette Alliance' ' Stata,c eriator.Frank:Roberts Salem Electric Jerry Rust,Lane County Newspaper Commissioner* Star Gate Awareness State SenatorDick Springer Oregon Natural Resources Paul Nicholson,Eugene City Resources Council Councilor Surata Soyfoods Inc. . ,State Senator Bill McCoy Bruce Berg,Springfield City Sustainable Construction " '^ Ore on Lea a of Councilor* r , - g Su Andrew S.Bajer State Rep.Dave McTeague Conservation Voters Bill Kitterid e Springfield g , Steve Johnson' Utility Board Karen Keifer-Boyd Re 'Gail Shible y Ore °n Far Share Charles 0.Porter, Roger Knight Bruce , s "' State Rep.Beverly Stein ;Columbia-Willamette Greens Jayne Freese,Oregon Natural William C.Carpenter,Jr.. 'State Rep.Avel Gordly Eastside Democratic Club ' Florence s Council,. Thomas R.English. Norma Grier,Northwest Richard 0.Eyman,SPUD! `Ruth McFarland,Candidate `Marion County Democratic Coalition for Alternatives ` Laurie N.Fisher,'RN. State Senate Dist.11" ' Central Committee, to'Pesticides* Drue N.Fowler Marc Abr r•. ,'s Emerald People's Utility J.E.Laksar Geer erns,atty.(Portland) .'r.Ore gon Peaceworks District Kathy Ging,Realtor, Donald G.Allen(Sandy) Portland Gray Panthers Clergy and Laity Concerned Richard'Greene,Optician Antricari(a Store) Charles M.Gudger III,Atty. Lisa Maxfield,•atty.,Right To ,,,Ecumenical Ministries of. Astrografix Ruth Heyes;RN.; Privacy*(Portland) Oregon Legislative'. Coburg Hillview Farm Steve Johnson' Commission,' Circle of Hands' Barbara Keller Howard Glazer,(Portland) Down To Earth Home Farm Physicians for Social Janice May Marshall Dr.Tim Burto M.D:Ore n &Garden Nat.Resc Council(Hood River) Responsibility Ecoweb Graphics Gail Marshall Projecto:Independence Emerald Valley Kitchen Monte Marshall r Al Jubitz(Portland) Hispanic Chapter,David Stephen A.Messer,N.D Eugene Peaceworks t Loera " Marion Mlotok Dr.Mel Gurtov Friendly Foods*Deli ' (Portland) ;' `Chuck Miles Solar Design&Construction, Goldworks Jewelry Design Claudeen Naffziger } Eric Stachon(Portland) Corvallis Juice Bar' Ken Naffziger Za Tiendita,Oscar Hernandez * Robert,Reuschlein Peace ' These organizations listed for identifications purposes only Mother Kali's Books Economics 1 Northwest Integrated Pest John Saemann, Management Rodney Schaffer,M.D. d (This information furnished by Ross Williams,Campaign Manager,Do/t Paul's Bike Shops Yourself Committee.) Red Barn Grocery Gary Schneid*r.World Peace University SEA:School of Earthy Arts Jeff Shields,EPUD S.O.S.Save Our Ecosystems Inc Muriel(Mika)Singer,MA. Sandpiper Import Service Betty Soreng Second Nature Bicycles John Soreng Solar Information Center Peter Sorenson Tina Stupasky, Attorney-at- Law Nishan Van Atta *These organizations listed for identification purposes only. (This information furnished by Steve Myers,Field Coordinator,'Do It Yourself Committee.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse , ment by the.State of Ongori;'nor does the state warrant the meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state.warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the a t j ; 54 �.� ..v_ ' Official 1992 General Voters''Pam hiet m CONTINUED- Measure No 6 STATE OF • OREGON ? � •. '° . ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION,,''. , ; ARGUMENT.IN OPPOSITION 1,000 Neighbors of Trojan Opposed to Measure 6 Y h; } Measures 6&e would;immediately shut,down Oregon's single largest electric.generating plant—just when,the MEASURE .e 'WOULD SHUT.,DOWN OREGON'S Northwest"needs even.M=electric power,For over�l6, , LARGEST ELECTRICITY PLANT. The Trojan Electric Years,Trojan has provided electricity for Oregon homes&busi Plant has provided'safe and economic electricity to Oregonians nesses.Trojan has contributed to Oregon's economy by produo-' d for over 16 years.If Trojan is shut down now,power would have mgr on average,as much power each year as Bonneville Dam. to be purchased°from other sources immediately. Measures 5&6 would shut Trojan down just when,the power TROJAN IS'A GOOD NEIGHBOR We are the people.who surplus of the last decade is gone. In an August.l8,.,1992, live around Trojan,and we know it is a safe plant.The profes- Oregonian article, BPA announced it',will:cut,back;power to sionals,who operate Trojan are our friends and neighbors.The many industrial customers:This is;.a prime example'of our ; Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the Oregon Department of energy supply problem. Energy have full-time inspectors at Trojan. They have the authority to shut the plant down if they believe it is unsafe. As electricity consumers,we are concerned about higher utility bills that would result from the immediate shut- TROJAN"IS AN ENVIRONMENTALLY RESPONSIBLE down'.of Trojan. Shutting.down Trojan before replacement " PLANT.Environmental sdentists,monitor the plant regularly. resources are built would'damage,the state's eoonomy,in,many As Trojan's neighbors,we enjoy the plant's recreational park. Ways in addition to causing higher utility rates. Over 200.wildlife species thrive in the forests, ponds and marshes around the plant, including bald eagles,great"blue AA plant shutdown wo uld�imm dia ely_cause ahrn t Ob0 m n herons,and Canada geese.Trojan is featured in the"Oregon, and women to lose their Jobs.Small and large businesses would �v Department of Fish and Wildlife's Viewing Guide". pay more for electricity,making Oregon products and services cost more and endangering even more jobs,. A SHUTDOWN WOULD CAUSE OVER 1,000 LOST JOBS AND HUGE TAX COSTS.A Trojan shutdown would cause Oregon is already in a,recession. Shutting down our single over 1,000 men and women to lose their jobs.Ratepayers would largest electricity-plant before we have replacement'power foot.the bill for expensive new power plants to replace Trojan's sources in place,would hurt our efforts to maintain,and electricity.This would increase rates and create major new bud- strengthen our economy. et problems for local $ p governments at a time when Oregon ("• ", already faces serious budget deficits: We urge you to VOTE NO ON MEASURES 6&8 STOP DRASTIC HL WN OF TROJAN. One way,or.another,-utility customers,will,pay more with an immediate shutdown.A recent study by Oregon's Attorney James M.Wright Cheryl L.Wi1sAn General,concluded that plant'compensation costs to Trojan's Chairman,Oregon Vice President " owners,an amount in the hundreds of millions of dollars,could Economic Development.' evelopment Oregon Resources Corp. be paid by all Oregon taxpayers. Commission . Iry Fletcher` We live,with our friends and families,within a few miles of the Richard Butrick President. Trojan plant.We oppose a Trojan shutdown.We urge you to President Oregon AFL-CIO join us in voting No on 6. Associated Oregon Industries James E.Reinmuth 1000 NEIL r Ronald E.Fortune Dean,College of Business NEIGHBORS 0 TROJAN F TR AN UR GE YOU TO VOTE"NO ON MEASURE 6. Executive Secretary-Treasurer Administration` Northwest Oregon Labor University of Oregon• "' Council,AFL-CIO (This information funished by Betsy Johnson.) Ed Balsiger General Manager Pendleton Grain Growers The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations ` are included for identification only. (This information lumished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5 8 6 Comm,ittee.) (This space purchased wfth a petition containing the signatures of 1,000 voters eligible to vote on the measure in accordance with ORS This space purchased for$300 in accordance,with ORS 2 251.255.) � ( Pa P 251-255.)'.'. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute on endorse- runt the State o Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment the State- Oregon,nor does the'state warrant the by f �' f 8 • •i accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth,of any statement made in the argument. 55 P Official 1992 General Voters"Pamphlet P w. c fi CONTINUED � STATE,OF � OREGON fzr4 ARGUMENV,1 OPPOSITION ARGUMENT;IN OPPOSITION�� SCIENTISTS AND ENGINEERS URGE NQ VOTE ON 6"& Educators Oppose'The Drastic Shutdown'Of Trojan e.•We have'studied Measures 5&6 and urge Oregon voters to Caused By Measures 5&6. ` ' careu review the facts before voting: i �'• WEBSTER'S NINTH NEW COLLEGIATE DICTIONARY: TROJAN OPERATES-SAFELY. Trojan is operated by DRASTIC\'dras-tik\adj•radical in effect or action: licensed professionals who are trained and tested annually.The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) and the Oregon Measures 6 & 6.are drastic measures. Their radical effects `• 1 Department ofEnergy(ODOE)have full-time inspectors at the ;plant:;Trojanmust:also meet requirements of the Oregon would cause the immediate shutdown of Oregon!s single largest ,Department,.of.Environmental Quality and the Oregon, electricity plant. This unreasonable and'unnecessary action Department of Fiah and Wildlife : would cause an immediate power deficit equal in size to half the City of Portland's annual electric use.'' TROJAN'S POWER IS NEEDED FOR OREGON UNTIL WE EXAMINED THE EFFECTS OF THESE MEA NEW SOURCES CAN BE DEVELOPED.The electricity ears plus of the'last'decade is gone.Trojan pre SURES'AND SUPPORT THE PLAID,GRADUAL, duoes on average as AND RESPONSIBLE ALTERNATIVErTHE FOUR,-YEAR much power as Bonneville Dam.Developing the resources and facilities needed t6 replace Trojan will take time. PHASE-OUT PLAN. FROM A SCIENTIFIC STANDPOINT,INCREASED allow orderly phase-out te time for Trojan Qvlerlthhenlnnextt four years will RELIANCE ON FOSSIL FUELS POSES RISKS TO THE �P' planning and development ENVIRONMENT.Even with additional conservation,burning of responsible, low-cost energy resources needed to replace more ooal;to generate electricity would be necessary if Trojan is Trojan's electricity.This transition will provide time to make immediately shut down.Mining and burning;coal can have the right energy choices for Oregonians. adverse,environmental consequences..` A drastic shutdown will create higher power.costs for schools, Coal-fired electric plants add large amounts of carbon dioxide colleges, ady:atruggling,on tight and universities which are already, and`sulfur dioxide.into the air.'These by-products from electrici budgets. ty production contribute to"global warming"or the"greenhouse effect",which may',raise a major threat to our planet's ecosys. Please study the costs of Measure 5&'6 for all Oregonians,and tams. vote"NO"onMeasure 5&6. An immediate shutdown of the Trojan electric plant would be The,views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations bad nubhc•yolicv with adverse environmental cons guences are included for identification only. From a scientific nersnective. a planned phase-out makes j sense-a drastic shutdown does not. Gene Carlson Gerald E.Young I r Superintendent Dean of Arts&Sciences t JOIN US IN VOTING NQ ON MEASURES 5&6. Rainier School District Eastern Oregon State STOP THE DRASTIC HUTDOWN. College j Dr.Julian Battaile Lori D.Mayo The views expressed are our own and opr titles and affiliations Professor Emeritus of Chemistry. Teacher' z are included for identification only. Southern Ore.State College Bayith Academy j Thomas J.Nelson Dr.H.Chik M.Erzurumlu Judith A.Cochran Charles A.Clemans Dean,School of Engineering Dean of Engineering Director of Student Former Superintendent, } University of Portland Portland State University Development, Oregon City Schools M Columbia Gorge 1 Alan H.Robinson Cyrus W.Field Commuaity_College Head,.Dept.Nuclear Engineering Professor of Geology Corvallis Philomath (This information furnished by Paul w.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) (This information furnished by Paul W Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with DRS 251.255) i The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- went by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the does the state warrant the ment by the State of"Oregon,nor accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. -56 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet 5 CONTINUED Me asur STATE OF ND' ' 6 , e . OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN'OPPOSITION AN IIYIlVIEDIATE SHUTDOWN OF TROJAN CAUSED BY: WE ARE,CONCERNED ABOUT:THE ENVIRONMENT, , 1` MEASURES b&e WOULD CREATE HUGE COSTS AND' AND WE OPPOSE MEASURES DAMAGE OREGON'S ECONOMY: An immediate shutdown of Trojan by measures 5 &6 Measures 5 & 6 would be very expensive for Oregonians. would force poor energy replacement'chbices;that.could, `. Bonneville Power Administration has announced,that electrici- damage our environment. ty rates will increase as much as'20 percent over the next two -` years due to'drought conditions,endangered salmon species, "" and the need to build new generating resources. BPA recently announced that our'region is now facing power s deficits and that they must start buying new.energy resources t'. immediately to fill the gap(BPA Press Statement W22/92).' Trojan is a resource equal in size to the Bonneville Dam.The immediate'loss.of Trojan's power,would increase electricity rates.Local governments would,be,forced to increase taxes or Cutting off Trojan's electricity now`would no allow thQ`n—d a ' ee 'fees in order to finance the higher electricity costs of schools, time to bring on environmentally r a onaible new energy sewage'and water treatment facilities, streetlights,and othert'resources such as conservation Rmarams cogeneration lan basic services: and renewable resources like wins and"zeothermal' oD #e^: These drastic shutdown measures would cause about 1,000 MFMURF,S b&e WOLn D RFS'iTi T IN N »' Oregon men and women to immediately lose their jobs.This DEVIFDIA SHL IN HLmTOUR- would hurt our economy—when we face.a continuing recession. NORTHWEST>F`NVritONMENT_, 4 It'would cause a ripple:effect throughout,our state's.economy and'increase operating costs for thousands of small and large Closing Trojan immediately could force the purcha§"of more businesses. Higher electric rates would also discourage new hydropower,increasing the Rmssure on our hydroelectric dams businesses from locating here. at a time when our state may still be in a'drought conditioa. This would also further threaten our endangered salmon popu We are concerned about Oregon's job market and economy. lations. We urge you to study these issues carefully and Nothing can take the-place of good energy,planning We' VOTE NQ ON MEASURES 5&S. ;: care about the environment;and we'support'a responsi- ble four-year phase-out of Trojan to allow time to de4el- op enviro nmentally sound replacement resources The views expressed.are our own and our titles and affiliations are included for identification only. JOIN US.VOTE"NO"ON 5 8c 6. Elsie Stuhr Raymond Barnwell STOP THE DRASTIC SHUTDOWN Senior Advocate'_ President,Southern" Washington County Oregon Central Labor The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations Council are included for identification only'. Jose Alberto Nunez Thomas M.Zepp Gerald W.Herrmann John R.Donaldson President Energy Economist Naturalist&Environmental : 'Executive Director, Farmworker Housing Utility Resources,Inc. Educator,Oregon City,.: Columbia Basin F'tsli& Development Corp. Wildlife Authority Bob Montgomery Gerald R.Edwards! Vernon L.Rifer General Manager Mayor Past president Gail.Achtermam P Oregon Environmental Council Attorney Port of Cascade Locks City of Tigard Former Assistant to the Lt.Col.U.S.Army(Ret.)Sammy E.Radow Allen&Louisa Bateman Governor for Natural. , Environmental Activists Resources Board Member,Clackamas County Children's Commission Klamath Falls Former Chair,Clackamas County Community Action Agency (This information furnished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6"Committee.)• (This Information furnished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) ^ 'r (This apace purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.), (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.),. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute Ian endorse- ' ment by the State of Oregon,,nor does the state warrant the ment'by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 57 �. �4 0 ffldal 1992'General to Pam hlet CONTINUED, STATE Measure. v.,V OREGON ARGUMENT KOPPOSITION " ARGUMENT IN OPP0SIT10N 1 Ballot'Measures 6 & 8'Could Become Tax Increase Farmers Oppose Trojan's Immediate Shutdown''4r ` Measures. *c Oregon farmers face serious economic challenges:We can ill- afford the drastic, immediate shutdown of the Trojan electric If•'hojaa�is immediately shutdown by passage of Measures 5& plant.caused by measures 6 &8.We urge you to consider the 8;''do'you'know it could result in a tax liability to Oregon's tax- cost impacts these measures would have on farmers. Payers?We urge you to learn about these costly measures and { VOTE'NO" Oregon farms face serious drought conditions.Many of us have already lost the ability to irrigate our fields.An According to'a recent opinion by Oregon's Attorney immediate Trojan shutdown create the need to work the General (Letter 'of,.Advice, 8/8/92 to OPUC. hydroelectric generating system harder to make up for the loss +' Commiuioners),`if Trojan is forced to shut down, of Trojan's power.If additional water is released from the reser- Trojan's owners could seek compensation from the State voirs to generate electricity this winter,we-will be unable to In a court proceeding.That compensation would be borne by water our crops next summer. all Oregon taxpayers.Oregon taxpayer,do not need more taxes. E We depend'on,stable;low-cwt electricity rates.We can Phasing-out Trojan and replacing it with more economic not afford the large increases in power costs caused•by resources is the "least-cost option".for Oregonians. an immediate Trojan closure.Most of us have family farms Trojan's owner's will be conducting an orderly phase-out of the and need to watch our costs closely.Increased energy costs from plant by 1998.'Over the next four yearn, new,more economic a Trojan closure would threaten the survival of many,small generating resources will be acquired. But without adequate farms• time to plan for these new resources,our energy future is uncer• " tain.' The impacts of saving threatened salmon populations on the Columbia River Basin will make irrigating our crops We urge you to examine the potential costs for electricity con- and barging our products more difficult.An immediate sumers and Oregon taxpayers'of an immediate shutdown of closure of Trojan would place even more pressure on the Trojan.Join us in votingHQ on measures 6&8. already stressed hydro system and increase the costs of operat• ing our farms. The views expressed are our own and our titles and aMationa ars included for identification only. We support the responsible,orderly phase-outi plan for Trojan in order to ensure adequate power supplies over the next four I Stan W.Baumhofer Terry L.Cochran years while replacement resources are being planned and built. Oregon Tax Research President Former Executive Director.' Columbia River Bank Please Join us and Vote NQ on Measures 5&8 . Marvin Abeene Martin D.Alter L Past President, Partner, Salem Area Chamber Rookstool&Alter of Commerce Certified Public Accountants The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations are included for identification only. • s Bruce Hugo Vernon White Oregon State Representative Oregon Tax Research Stafford Hansell Doug Breese Columbia&Washington Former Research Director Award-Winning Conservationist President Counties. Boardman Oregon Farm Bureau ( ` Leli Robert G.Holdrid ge Bruce Hugo Shibahara Commissioner Executive Director. Shibahara Ranch Governor's Commission on Northwest Irrigation Utilities Hood River" Senior Services Hector Macpherson David Henzel Farmer . Director (This Information furnished by Paul W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) Linn County' Klamath Agricultural and Business Assistance Corp. 1 (This,nformation furnished by Paul W Vogel,NO on 5 a e Comm/rtea.) (This space purchased for$30o in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for'$300 In accordance w/th ORs251.265.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an'endorse ment by the State of Oregon,'nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor"does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.' MOW 58 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet Measure NOn STATE OF� OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION r r w: PHYSICIAN'S STATEMENT AGAINST MEASURES 6&6: RECOMMEND"NO"VOTE. + s•, As physicians and health care professionals, we want to con- tribute to the'public discussion of Measures 5,&6, since sup- porters of these measures often raise health and'safety issues. C We have concluded that the immediate shutdown of the Trojan electric plant makes no sense from a health and safety stand- point.Moreover, an immediate shutdown of Trojan would be environmentally damaging and very expensive: t Trojan has been safely producing electricity for Oregon for more than 16 years:If Trojan is immediately shut down,replacement power would be generated by increasing our reliance on fossil ' fuels.Fossil-fuel burning plants,such as coal-fired plants,pro- duce by-products that can have adverse health and environ- mental impacts. • �, rr�,r,X. From a health perspective,'an immediate Trojan shutdown is drastic and unnecessary.Trojan should continue to operate i until responsible replacement resources are`developed'under the current 4 year phase-out plan.We urge our fellow Oregon P• citizens to vote against the shutdown of this safe plant. PLEASE JOIN US IN VOTING"NO"ON 5&6. Gary F.Gates,M.D. Director,Nuclear Medicine Department St.Vincent Hospital&Medical Center Oliver N.Massengale,M.D. Pediatrician,Beaverton Stephen Weil,M.D. Surgeon,Lake Oswego David R.Arnold Chairman of the Board Merle West Medical Center Richard Allen,M.D. Past President,Oregon Medical Association James A Cross,M.D. West Hills Womens Clinic , The•views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations are included for identification only. This information furnished by Nut W.Vogel,NO on 5&6 Committee.) r (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251:255.) i The'printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 59 I Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet i CONTINUED.. r' STATE OF Measure NO.`I OREGON , Proposed by initiative petition to be voted on at the General MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE TAXES Elle/c�tiop,November 3,1992 For Each$1000.00 of Property�s Real Market.Value BALLOT ITL.E Fiscal Year School System Other than Schools c. ^' 1991-1992 $15.00 410 00 I < #AI M_ .:_JAX D 1TLTA I. 1 : ' 1992-1993 $12.50 ., $10.0w:, 1993-1994 $10.007 :%,= $lo 00 4jIS (ll Shall constitutional property tax'h YE$Q.; 1994-1995 : $ 7.50 . $10 00 tox tdperty other than d�vnar-00600ted res ttentfal 1995-1996 $ 5.00 $10 00 j and thereafter Ct+ti.tertyrbe increased,reffidential renters receive tax s NO. 0 �5YlMMARX Amends Oregon Constitution For Property tax revenues are deemed to be dedicated to funding p�` 9f#8 94 and hereafter, measure would increase the public school system if the revenues'are to be used:exclu- <proporty tail hmit for tho eclzool system to....to sively for educational services,`including support servicesf pro- 4 per$1004 of Teal market value on property vided by some unit of government,at any level from pre-kinder- 4tlier thazi proXtexty gvvtled aXid GGSttpied as a:pruioi garten through post graduate training. x 0. paI;residonce Current limits are$10 fn 1998 94, (2)The following definitions shall apply to this section: '? a� $?50in 199..95,$5:in 1995 96 R.....s Legislative : (a) "Real market value"is the minimum amount in cash} d; y to provide properly taX rolief residential which could reasonably be expected.by an informed seller'acting «k renters equivalent to that psvided:. homeowners without compulsion,from an informed buyer acting'without uixder Article XI;section 12b(1)r of the Oregon compulsion,in an"arms-length"transaction during.the period' Gdnstitutiou. for which the property is taxed. ES!kIMA '] OF FINANCIAL FACT Ell'ect. (b)A"tax"is any charge imposed by a governmental_unit . State Governmetxtn 19984,this a0ilo#sute would upon property or upon a property owner as a direct consequence 7ed11de State General Fund'eXpenditures by'$290 : of.ownership of that property except,incurred charges and 1 million and reduce>;revenues by$10 milhoi (Net : assessments for local improvements. Impact +�2$0 tnxlhouJ Ixt 1994 9 ,this measure (c)"Incurred charges"include and are specifically limited to 7vould reduce State General Fund expenditures by those charges by government which can be controlled or avoid $45 millioa and reduce revenues l y $16 Thill'on ed by the property owner. (Net Impact' +$440 milltdn In X995 96 and each year thereafter,the measure Would:reduce:State (i)because the charges are based on the quantity of the goods (iezieral Fund oXpenditureil by$657 tntllio>a and or services used and the owner has direct control over the quan- reduce revonuo..b .49 m1Won(Net Impact $634 ti ;or ty million) (ii)because the goods or services are"provided only on the Eflect 0>a.Ldcal Governments:In 1993.94,thYS mea specific request of the property owner;or sure would lncrease;property taX revenues ao local (�)because the goods or services are provided by the govern- PO.I districts and cgmtnunity oaUeges by$380 mil mental unit only after the individual property.owner has failed lion;In 1994 9b,this mascara twDUld increase:prep. to meet routine obligations of ownership and such action is arty,tax revenues to;"local school dlstr'ds aad cam deemed necessary to enforce regulations pertaining to health or ,. ma 14W.colleges by$ 92 million Iii 1995 96 and eaoh safety. thereafter,this measure:would crease prober Incurred charges shall not exceed the actual costs of provid- tY tax reyeiiies to]Deal schg4I d}stncts and coiimu ing the goods"or services. nitycolleges by$851 mullioA. (d)A"local improvement"is a capital construction project Administrative Costs In 1998 94, this measure undertaken by a governmental unit would inorease oxpen..... sTiy oouutaes by$2 2 ini] (i)which provides a special benefit only to specific properties lido;for implementation In 1994 95 and each ear � p y or rectifies a problem caused by specific properties,and thereafter,this measure would increase expend' tares by$25q,000 In,1999 94 and again in 1994 95, (ii)the costs of which are assessed againstthose properties in this:.measure would;iniaease eipenditures by;state a single assessment upon the completion of the project,,and 13oi!erniuellt by$0 6;iatilli4it for impleixtezttattoil It1 (iii)for which the payment of the assessment plus appropri 1995 96 and each year thereafter,,this measure ate interest maybe spread over a period of at least ten years. would loci ease expenditures by state government by The total of all assessments for a local improvement shall not $0 5milhon exceed the actual costs incurred by the governmental unit in designing,constructing and financing the project. ANACT (e)'Owneroccupied residential property"is property Be It Enacted by the People of the State of Oregon: that on the date of assessment is owned and occupied as PARAGRAPH.1.Section llb,Article XI of the Constitution of a principal residence. the State of Oregon,is amended to read: (3) The limitations of subsection(1) or (4) of this section Sec. llb.(1)During and after the fiscal year 1991-92,taxes apply to all taxes imposed on property or property ownership imposed upon any property'shall be separated into two sate except. goriest One which dedicates revenues raised specifically to fund (a)Taxes imposed to pay the principal and interest on bond- (a)public school system and one which dedicates revenues ed indebtedness authorized by a specific provision of this raised to•fund government operations other than the public Constitution. school system.'Except as provided in subsection(4)of this (b)Taxes imposed to pay the principal and interest bond- section,the taxes in each category shall be limited as set forth ed indebtedness incurred or to be incurred for capital construe in the table which follows and these limits shall apply whether tion or improvements,provided the bonds are offered as general 'the taxes imposed on property are calculated on the basis of the obligations of the issuing value of that property g g governmental unit and provided fur p perty or on some other basis: ther that either the bonds were issued not later than November Y 60 s T ,. Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet . CONTINUE Measure No. 7 ORE STATE OF 6,1990,or the question of the issuanoIa of the specific bonds has been approved by the electors of the issuing governmental unit. EXPLANATORY..STATE M ENT '(4)For 1993-1994 and`thereafter,.if property is other than owner-occupied residential property,the limitation Ballot Measure 7 amends,the o of subsection(1)of this section for the school system cat• property tax rate limits fa the' egory on taxes imposed upon property or the ownership Oregon Constitution,:creates two,categories of property'for.the of property is$20.00 for each$1000.00 of the property's purpose of setting different property tax rate,limits for schools' " �'• 'real market value. on each category and requires,the Legislative Assembly to pro- ': vide relief to residential renters equivalent to property tax relief RA(5)In the event that taxes authorized by any provision provided homeowners. a of this Constitution to be imposed upon any property should One category is property that is used as the owner's principal exceed the limitation imposed on either category of taxing units residence.For this category, which basically comprises,principal in subsection(1)of this section,then,notwithstanding family d residence.For the measure'makeh b changes in the t.singe.' any other provision of this Constitution,the taxes imposed upon such property by the taxing units in that category shall be limits imposed by section 11b,Article XI•of the'Oregon reduced evenly by the percentage necessary to meet the limita- Constitution(adopted by the people as Ballot Measure 5 in: tion for that category.The percentages used to reduce the taxes 1990). imposed shall be calculated separately for each category and The other category'established by the measure includes all 4 may vary from property to property,within the same taxing property that is not owner-ooupied residential property.This unit.The limitation imposed by this section shall not affect the category includes industrial and commercial property,farm and tax base of a taxing unit. forest lands,residential rental property,vacant lands,vacation [(5)] (6) The Legislative Assembly shall replace from the homes and other property not owned and occupied as a princi- �' State's general fund any revenue lost by the public school sys- pal residence. tem because of the limitations of this section. The Legislative For this category.of property, in 1993 and thereafter;the Assembly,is authorized,however,to adopt laws which would Property tax rate limit for schools shall be$20 per$1000 ofreal limit the total of such replacement revenue plus the taxes market value.Properties in this category will pay the school tax imposed within the limitations of this section in any year to the rate which would have been in effect had Measure 5 been corresponding total for the previous year plus 6 percent.This adopted(1990)or$20 per$1000, whichever is lower:The$20 subsection applies only during fiscal years 1991-92 through school'rate for-non-0wner'occupied residential property will go 1995-96,inclusive. exclusively to fund the public school system.This measure does. x not affect the non-school tax rate limit,which shall remain at (7) The Legislative Assembly shall provide property tax relief to residential renters estimated to be equiva- $10 per would be 30 per al tax rate limit for this category of prop- lent,to.the relief provided homeowners under the limita- tions erty would be$30 per$1000. of subsection(1)of this section. Through.1995-96 the Legislative Assembly]is required to r replace,from the state general fund,any revenues lost by the ; public school system because of the constitutional property tax •, rate,limitation adopted in 1990.Additional revenues.collected because of Ballot Measure,7 must be used only to fund the pub-' NOTE:Boldfaced type indicates new language;[brackets lic school system.The effect is to make more property tax rev- ry` and italic]type indicates deletions or comments, enue available for schools which reduces the demand on the f state general fund. This will make more general fund dollars I, available to help fund state services. The measure directs the Legislative Assembly to provide financial relief to residential renters estimated to he equivalent to the property tax provided to homeowners by the constitution al tax rate limitation: . = PPo Committee Members.' A inted b Phil Dreyer Chief Petitioners George Starr Chief Petitioners u: Gary Carlson Secretary of State Pat McCormick Secretary of State' 'i Jim Scherzinger Members of the Committee I� (This Committee was appointed m provide an impartial explanation of the ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251.215.) ' r , 1 . { 5 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet � ;����. •, ; , . CONTINUED 3 STATE OF 1 Measure NQ.•-7 OREGON •ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN�FAVOR Parentslor Quality Education urges you to STOP THE SALES TAX ' Vote-YES on Measure 71 VOTE"YES"ON MEASURE 7 \ Take the First Step Towards Stable Funding for Schoolsl A"YES"vote on Measure 7 is a vote to head off a general retail sales tax in Oregon. lldeasure 7;or the,Spht'Roll Tax,will raise 50-6096 of revenue Jost,from Measure b.Although this is NOT the final solution,it The sales tax has been promoted as a partial solution to the re v is anexcellent start on a serious problem that the Governor and enue replacement requirement brought on by Measure 5;the "'the'Legislature have not•been able to solve. We support property tax;limitation measure adopted by Oregonians in ',Measure 7:for the following reasons: 1990. 4 A YES Vote on Measure 7 assures money for schools.The Ballot Measure 5(1990)gave a massive property tax windfall to revenue generated from the Split.Roll tax will go directly to the owners of business,commercial and industrial property.In l local schools.Without this,Oregon,(because of Measure 5),Will first year,property taxes on homes went up over$24 million soon spend less on education than most states.We will spend statewide,while business property taxesdecreased.more than :.less at a time when the population in our state is growing and $68 million.Much of that relief went to owners of Oregon prop- ' an increasing proportion of children have special needs.There erty that reside in other states and in foreign countries.They 1, `is increasing parental'drug and alcohol abuse, increasing would not pay an Oregon sales tax as Oregonians would gang violence,increasing poverty,increasing child abuse, and a large number of non-English'speaking children.With all Measure 7,by recapturing most of that windfall,will substan- these problems,we cannot simply tighten our belts and educate Bally reduce the need for replacement revenues•from the state children with less money. general fund to provide support for the public school system and essential state services. AYES Vote on Measure 7 is an investment for the future. For every dollar spent on education,we will save many'dol Vote to restore-the balance between residential'and business lars in services such as:welfare,job retraining,prisons,police, and drug rehabilitation. property taxes without the need for a sales tax which has been voted down eight times since 1933,not ever receiving as much "Scrimping on education is a false economy....It's a simple 30010 voter approval. multiplication exercise:Spend a little more on a child's edu- VOTE"YES"ON MEASURE 7 "cation'or,'intoo many cases,spend more than four times as much on his or her imprisonment.",–The Oregonian,August 2,1992,' (This information furnished by George Starr,Treasurer,No Sales Tax 1 A YES Vote on Measure 7 is a vote for local control of League.) sehools!'Who knows best the needs,of our neighborhood schools?We do—not the state!Before Measure 5,the state pro- vided and controlled only 30%'of school funding.The bulk of school funding came from local property taxes,and we said how it was spent!With Measure b,the State increasingly provides and controls most school funding.Measure 7 restores local taxes to local schools and restores our local control. " Vote Yes on Measure 7, It's an Investment in our children and in Oregon's future! Parents for Quality Education is a grass roots parents orga- nization,dedicated to improving the quality of education for all j children. (This Information furnished by Susan Aiello,May Wallace,Parents/or, Quality Education:) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255. ) (This space purchased for$30o in accordance with ORS 251.255-) , The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute'an endorse- meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument, 62 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ` , CONTINUED STATE OF Measure No. 7 =- � OREGON ARGUMENT 1N.FAV,OR ARG UMENT,IN FAVOR SPLIT-ROLL.ENSURES A QUALITY EDUCATION SYS• SAVE OUR SCHOOLS TEM—Measure 7 wW etop,the massive business windfall and SUPPORT THE SPLIT ROLL PROPERTY TAX provide hundreds of millions of dollars to ensure quality.educe. Lion for Oregon's youth., RELIEF PLAN :. ,. • is 3 , � ,` .; BALLOT MEASURE 5 OF 1990 GAVE A HUGE WIND As the Legislature cuts more and more away from state sup• FALL TO BIG_BUSINESS—Between 1990 and 1991,proper port for schools,in order to pay for mandated Ballot Measure 5 ty taxes on homes went ug$24.1 million statewide(in spite of °� rohQf,who will be there to.protecb,our schools?The Measure 6).Property taxes on business and commercial proper- answer is we the people must act to save our schools,and Ballot ty went down$68.9 million.That's a$93 million shift from reef- .Measure 7 to the best available method dential to income-producing property in just the first year. The Legislature has already begun to cut state.support,for I SPLIT-ROLL PROPERTY TAX PLAN IS FAIR—Measure 7 schools right along with cuts in state budgets.State.funding'for ensures that homeowners continue to get the full benefits of the our schools could be reduced by more than 40,percent over,the next three school years, as the cost of mandated property tax Measure 6 limit of$16,per$1,000 of real market value.Tax relief goes up,and the legislature shifts resources. , rates on business,.industrial and other properties held to pro- duce income will not higher than they would have been had Measure a not been adopted or$30 per$1,000, whichever is Protecting our schools is up.to us—and Ballot Measure,7:1s f lower. the way to do it. SPLIT-ROLL PLAN HELP RENTERS,TOO—Measure ? Ballot Measure 7 directs the legislature to provide relief to residential renters equivalent to the relief provided homeowners. —Puts a new limit in the Oregon Constitution for school`prop. ' arty taxes on income-producing property(commercial,industri- MARK YOUR BALLOT"YES"ON 7 al,retail)at$20 per thousand of assessed value,or the school ^ FOR PROPERTY TAX FAIRNESS tax rate in effect before Ballot Measure 6,whichever is lower.,E, TO SAVE OUR SCHOOLS, =Sends all the revenue generated by this tax rate limit to our 1 schools,kindergarten through 12th grade,and community col- loges. (This Information furnished by James E.Smith,Board Director,Transit Rotlrsot Assodat/on,Amalgamated Tronslt Unlon,Divlson 757.) Maintains th — A property tax limit on owner-occupied homes set in the Constitution by Ballot Measure 6. ; —is the same mechanism 15 other states use to equalize the property tax burden between owner occupied homes,which pro- duce no income,and all other property, which does produce p income. (This,Information fumished by Eric Swenson, Treasurer,Citizens T°Save our Schools.). • !L �I (This space purd7ased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with'ORS 251.255.) tl The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not constitute an endbree ment by the State of Oregon,,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor does lhe,atate warrant the "i accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument 63 ;II • r ;i`r' IOfficial 1992 General Voters'Pam Net k , :CONTINUED ,L STATE OF . Measurr.1"Nb ".7,, '0REG0N I ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ,r . :1a. .,... HOMEOWNER PROPERTY TAX RELWF OUR ECONOMIC FUTURE DEPENDS ON ift i a _ << :'.PROTECTED i - EXCELLENCE IN EDUCAUON ` BY BALLOT MEASURE 7 Ballot Measure b, which the people passed in-November, t r 1990,will save business people a lot of money when it.is fully .Th splitm„.property tax roll created by Ballot Measure 7 pro- phased in. tech the property tax relief on our homes.that Oregonians ,kicrfor by'approving Ballot Measure 5,in 1990.Under Ballot But what is the price of this savings?Business people know A11leasure b,the total tax rate for all Property taxes will phase there has'to be a bottom line,and the Ballot Measure b balance down"to $18 per thousand in assessed value by 1995. This sheet shouldn't look good to them.The state government is .. phasedovm of property tax rates is retained for our required to pay more and more propert homes under)Ballot Measure 7. y tax relief for business es and homeowners,until the total reaches$1.4 billion a year. That money has to come from someplace,and it's coming from Homeowners like us can vote for Ballot Measure 7,to protect the state's commitment to our schools. our schools from the cuts being made in state support for educa- tion,and'still receive the full benefit of Ballot Measure 6 It makes no economic sense to take money needed to sustain tax relief on our homes. property quality education from kindergarten through community col- lege,and use it to pay the property tax relief bill mandated by The"growing burden of property.taxes on residential proper- Measure 6.The result is that we are cutting down the educa ty,`and the failure of government to do anything about it,was {Tonal opportunities of our children,in order to save'money on the reason'for passage of Ballot Measure 6. Property tax business,property taxes.. relief on our homes is still needed,and Ballot Measure 7 recognizes that fact:That's why this split roll measure is so The rice for this savings is too hi Our economic future important,to retain homeowner property tax relief,while treat- P gh' ing a new$20'rateaimit for school taxes on income producing depends upon skilled,trained and motivated workers.What property-manufacturing,utility;commercial,retail and the gad will the savings do business,if we are left in an education- like.If we want to guarantee homeowner property tax relief, al and economic backwater?Where does busines?get these while protecting our schools from deep cuts,Measure 7 is the employees,if our schools wren t able to produce them. ' way to accomplish both. ` VOTE TO SAVE OUR SCHOOLS Gerald J.Richardson Robert C.Nightingale ' VOTE FOR A STRONG OREGON ECONOMY Homeowner Homeowner Theodore W.McGrew Thomas D.Cunningham (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer,Citizens To Save Homeowner. Homeowner Our Schools.) VOTE TO SAVE OUR SCHOOLS VOTE FOR BALLOT MEASURE 7 (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer Citizens To Save Our.Schools.)` ru (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) t The printing this'argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment'by the State of Oregon,'nor does the"state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. :: j 64 F� l , Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ` CONTINUED' aw MCC�S U I'e No, 7 STATE OF OREGON ; 5�� , � `" 4 yk L ARGUMENT IN FAVOR. ARGUMENT'IN FAVOR �. . PARENTS SHOULD SUPPORT MEASURE 7 SAVE OUR COMMIJNITy,COLLEGES..-. OUR CHILDREN SHOULD HAVE GOOD SCHOOLS VOTE FOR THE SPLIT ROLL PROPERTY TAR .. . All parents'take pride in the accomplishments of their chil- The sixteen community,colleges in,Oregon,served 325,497 'dren.We want them to succeed,to do better and go farther than Oregonians last year:But the deep cuts.be' we did,and enjoy good lives. P, uig;made in state support for community colleges,in order to transfer money to the property tax relief process required by passage of Ballot And'all parents want\to protect their children from harm, Measure in 1990,hurts students from all the dangers they face today.Each one of us would do i f whateverit took to keep our child ren from being hurt.. : Here is what Dale Parnell, Oregon Comhussioner,of Community Colleges,said about these budget,cuts,in testimo- r Well, every child in an Oregon public school or community ny before the Special Budget`Subcommittee of the Joint } college faces a real threat today.Parents need to know about Legislative Committee on Oregon's Future this danger,and do somethingto•stop it. The harm our children face is the deep cuts instate support cation.Nursing is P hi�igh�t program,and how K for our.schools.State funds are being pulled out of our schools You deal with that when you come to cutting budgets?.,. 1, in order to finance the property tax relief program mandated by "d'i'e already have long waiting lists for most_technical t the passage of Ballot Measure 6 in 1990.How can our schools education programs.The li sts would get longer;[under accomplish the reforms needed'6 make excellence in education future budget cuts]and if they can't.take a clasi.-some- the standard in Oregon;-when state support for our children's times they have,to wait'until the next,semester or•they schools,is being'cut?How.do our children succeed,when over- would have to wait until the next year. crowding and discontinued classes are the standard,and the Dale Parnell is goal of excellence fades away? A August 3,1992 sa This doesn't have to happen to our children.Just because the Can the students in`our community colleges,afford'toywalt? governor and the legislature didn't get anything done on this crisis in the past.two years doesn't mean we can't.The people, The average Oregon community es that st r enofe every old: initiated Ballot Measure 7; and we can vote for it. It would The Department of Labor estimates that three of every four jobs >` in the year 2000 will require technical training and education r place anew property tax rate limit for schools of$20 per thou- above a high school level.How will we meet this demand,if we sand of assessed value on business and other income-producing cut the one institution which is designed to provide this train- ing—the community college? relief Ballot Measure 5 requires, and renters would also get z" relief. We can avoid this disaster by voting for Ballot Measure 7,the - All the money from this new limit on business property split roll property tax measure.All of the revenue of this new limit on business property tax is dedicated to the needs of our �4•�. would go to our schools and community colleges.That's how we `community colleges and our neighborhood schools.Don't let the keep our children's education from being hurt.That's how we keep our children from being hurt. doors close.on our community college students:Vote yes on Measure 7. Karen B.Farmer, - Rich Shidaker' Kieran Carney (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer,Citizens To Save Our Schools.) I, (This Information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer,Citizens To Save Our Schools.) : �I (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for,5300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) A• The,printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse= M ment by the State of Oregon,:nor does the state warrant the, ment by the Stale of Oregon,nor does the state,warrant,the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. r 65 u Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED' M 7 STATE OF OREGON u ARGUMENT IN'FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR,, RENTIIt$RECEIVE PROPERTY TAX RELIEF BALLOT MEASURE 7 NECESSARY y �UNDER BALLOT MEASURE 7 FOR HIGH-SKILLED,HIGH-WAGE JOBS' I x�wxi r' i.PeopleIlke'us who rent homes or apartments got no property No nation has produced a highly qualified technical work tax relief in$all ot Measure 5.All of the relief went to landlords, force without first providing its workers with a strong general' but;therae was nog requirement to share the:reduction in taxes education.The choice that Oregon faces is between high skills wits t nanta and low wages. Oregonians can chose high skills on November 3 by passing .Worse yet,the.1991 Legislature repealed the-law which Ballot Measure 7, which returns school property taxes on required'property tax relief for renters,and took away the only income-producing property to their pre-Ballot Measure 5 level, property tax relief low and moderate income renters ever got. or$20 per thousand,whichever is lower. To*correct this injustice done to renters,Ballot Measure 7 puts. The Department of Labor estimates that three of every four in the Oregon Constitution the requirement that;the jobs in the year 2000 will require technical training and educe- Legislature tion above the high school level The productivity of the workers in these jobs will make or break our economic future. "...shall provide property tax relief to residential Oregon will lose its place in the national and world market renters estimated to be equivalent to the relief provid- places unless it provides the education and skilled training its edhomeowners....". high school and community college graduates need for the 1' workplace. Ballot Measure 7 will support the education and, It is only air to training our young men and women they will need for these y give renters the same kind of property tax jobs. x relief for their residential rentals as is given to homeowners on their,residences.$ut`Ballot Measure 5 didn't recognize this Other industrialized nations have multi-year career-oriented need,and the'Legislature took away renters property tax relief. educational programs that prepare students to operate at a pro- And that wasn't fair. fessional level in the workplace. Passing Ballot Measure 7 will give working people the skills To et property,tax relief for renters and and education to meet the pro ductivity,requirements of g ,v guarantee it in the. Oregon's employers.We can only maintain our standard of liv- ing vote for Ballot Measure?. ing through these high-wage jobs if we give our young people the skills to do them,and those skills come from our'schools. Alice M.Pickard April Ann Perkins Renter Renter VOTE FOR A PRODUCTIVE WORK PLACE, i Jill N.Cameron. VOTE FOR BALLOT MEASURE 7 Renter RESTORE PROPERTY TAX RELIEF FOR RENTERS (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,'Treasurer,Citizens To Save ' VOTE YES ON MEASURE 7 Our Schools.) A. (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer,Citizens To Save Our Schools.) { 1 { II • J (This space Purchased for,$3oo In accordance with ORS 251.255.)" (This space purchased for$3o0 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) -' The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by the State of Oregon,nor floes the state warrant the meet by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument, accuracy or truth,of any statement made in the argument. 66 �.. , S F` Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No. T OREGON STATE OF ARGUMENT IN FAVOR . ARGUMENT IN"FAVOR: OREGON STUDENTS ASR FOR TAX EQUITY THE REASON FOR BALLOT MEASURE 7 SUPPORT OF SCHOOLS SPLIT ROLL PROVIDES BALANCE IN YES ON 7 IS YES FOR EDUCATION SCHOOL FUNDING As students in Oregon high schools,we know it costs to pro- Splitting the property tax roll between owner-oocupied homes vide our education,and we appreciate the sacrifices you have and all other property creates a fair division of the burden for made.Just.as-past generations made your education possible, school funding,based upon the,ability to pay.Property which is You paid the cost of ours,and we are grateful producing income and profits is better able to pay the school tax than residential property,a fact we all rt cognize. But the kids coming up behind us won't have the same kind ' of opportunities you were provided and We are now enjoying. That is why Ballot Measure 7 was put on the ballot by initia That's because all of the schools in our,state are getting less tive—to fairly distribute the school property tax load,and still money.from the state government.We can see what is happen- retain the homeowner property tax relief'created by Ballot ing, as Ballot Measure 5 is"phased in: State money for our' `Measure 5. Homeowners deserve to keep their property,tax schools is going to pay for mandated property tax relief. relief,and schools require adequate support to provide our,chit " dren with the education and skills they need to meet the chal- If this continues'the children Who will sit at our desks next lenges of their lives.Ballot Measure?,allows us to'have both: year,and the year after will not have anything like the opportu- Homeowner property tax relief and stable school funding , nities you gave•us.We will break the promise each generation has made to the next generation--quality schools with opportu The more than 119,000 Oregonians who signed petitions to nities for all We can't let this happen. place Ballot Measure 7 on the ballot want Oregonians to adopt the split roll system;,jo provide a logical balance for school taxes We believe it's fair to put the school property tax on money_ between income producing property and residential property making property back where it was before,by passing,Ballot With 15 states already using the split roll,'Oregon can join the Measure 7. movement to base school property taxes on the ability to pay. Business property will have a school property rate limit ' You promised us a good education, and you kept your of$20 per thousand;or the school tax rate in effect before Ballot , promise.We sincerely appreciate that.But now we have to keep our promise to the kids in kindergarten and middle school,and Measure 5 passed,whichever is lees.All of to moneyxaised. , he ones who follow them:To honor that obligation, by this new limitation will go to our neighbor ood schools and vote yes on community colleges.Homeowners will retain all of their Ballot I' Ballot Measure 7: t Measure 5 property,tax relief,and renters will receive equiva- lent property tax relief.,: Alicia Wolski'' Scott Edward Meeman '{ High School Student High School Student VOTE FOR FAIR SCHOOL TAXES BASED ON Travis E.F romwiller Kristina Elena Herrera THE ABILITY TO PAY ' High School Student High School Student " VOTE YES ON MEASURE 7`-T0 SAVE OUR SCHOOLS VOTE YES ON MEASURE 7 KEEP THE PROMISE TO THE NEXT GENERATION (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer,Citizens To Save Our Schools.) :` P (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer,Citizens To Save Our Schools.) t I q (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251-255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) , The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- Thje printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment.by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the rnent by the State.of Oregon, nor,does the state warrant the h accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any.statement made in the•argument: k 67 j 0 c al 1992'General Voters'Pamphlet 'CONTINUED ``' STATE OF Measure.X. 0 7 OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR. .1. ARGUMENT IN:FAVOR OLDER ORENIANS SUPPORT BALLOT MEASURE 7 SCHOOLS OF THE FUTURE NEED OUR HELP TODAY! For retnred'people living on fixed.incomes,voting for Ballot. Teachers can see what is happening to the children in our Measurer&*'1990 was a call to stop the,increasing pressure of schools.As the state government cuts funding,for schools and Ei property taxes on our homes:The voters expected state govern community colleges,the impact in classrooms is immediate and ment4o"fix the,'problem,and get on with providing needed ser- negative: Larger classes,fewer teachers,reductions in class ricea ' options,elimination of important technology courses for tumor- row's occupations.This and more will continue to occur,unless f•Few of us.expected our neighborhood schools and community we,act to stop it. colleges to suffer the kinds of cuts now being proposed,in order to%pay the property tax relief mandated by Measure b.But Our schools are being assaulted,at the very time we are try- unless we.take:action,these cuts will get bigger and the dam ing to implement-important educational reforms for our chil- - age to education in Oregon will be permanent. dren.This is happening because state government leaders_have failed to present a reorganization of taxes in Oregon Our ele-- This isn't the outcome people wanted, and we don't have to mentaryi•high school and community college programs face; ' wait for the governor or the legislature'to fix it.The people can deep cuts in the next budget cycle. Our children didn't cause, do something about it:'We can protect our schools and our this problem,but they are being made to pay the price,through { homes'atthe same time,bypassing Ballot Measure 7.It pro `reduced options and services.This is not going to make them { vides the balance needed for schools,by setting a new property better'prepared for the future, a future of complex technology i tax rate.limit of$20 per thousand of assessed value on income demanding high skills. ° producing property, and dedicating all of this revenue to our local schools:The reduction of property taxes on owner-occupied Ballot Measure 7 can prevent this disaster in our schools.All residences required by Measure b will be'maintained,'and prop-_ 'of the revenue generated by Ballot Measure 7 is dedicated in erty tax relief for renters will be instituted,something Measure the Oregon Constitution to finance schools from kindergarten b faded to do.,: through community college.By creating a new $20 school tax rate limit on income'producing property(commercial,industri The split roll,used in"15 other states to separate income-pro- ''al, retail,)business property will pay a maximum school tax ' ducing commercial.property from residential property on the .rate of$20,or the school tax rate,in effect before passage of ;` 1 'tax roll,will guarantee funding for our schools,and guarantee Ballot Measure 5,whichever is lower. property tax relief for our homes.That's the•kind of property ". tax reform we can live with. If we are serious.about giving our children the intellectual . tools necessary to compete in the sophisticated economy of the Richard C.Bartlett Shirley W.McGrew future,we must make our schools stronger,not weaker:Ballot Retired Retired Measure 7 will make our schools stronger, and protect' - owner and renter property tax relief,too. f William Gordon' George Starr Retired Retired 71 VOTE TO SAVE OUR SCHOOLS VOTE TO KEEP.HOMEOWNER PROPERTY VOTE FOR MEASURE 7 TAX RELIEF s, WHILE KEEPING GOOD SCHOOLS (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,'Treasurer Citizens T ' Our Schools.) o Save VOTE YES ON MEASURE 7 , (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,Treasurer,Citizens To Save Our Schools.). (This space pwtased for$300 in accordance with ORS 25 f.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) , • The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The Printing ment by the'State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the p °f his argument does not constitute an'endorse.state accurgcy or truth of any statement mode in the argument. oecuracy truth of an�s�atement made the argument.the �• 68' } law Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED ' Measure No. STATE OF , k ,ry, ; k OREGON '" ' V ARGUMENT IN FAVOR' ARGUMENT IN FAVOR RE-13ALANCE THE UNFAIR TAX SYSTEM 1990'S TAX CUT IS BAD LAW Measure 5, 1990, was drawn with'the intention of forcing Somewhere along the line the Oregon tax system got out of draconian cuts in all state services, forcing the adoption of a whack.Just look at the facts. :. sales tax„and thereby further moving the,tax load`to lower income.people.It gave income property the lion's share of the -The shale"of the total property tax bill paid by homeowners tax cut,half of.which went out of state, and'gave renters', went up more than 21 percent during the past eighteen years, absolutely nothing. and business property taxes went down indirect proportion. ' . —Repeal of the business.inventory tax caused property tax THE CASE OF CALIFORNIA ' rates to go up even higher on our homes. The current catastrophic crisis in California is'a fair measure Businesses paid 50%of total state and local taxes in the late of the results we can expect in Oregon if 1990's Measure 5 is not 'f 1970'8;L according to the Legislative Revenue Office.By 1989-91 amended.Several counties are bankrupt,education is deterio- businesses'share had declined'to 45%, and household's share rating,the state has resorted to 1930's style tax warrants,and had increased to 55%. the savage reductions in social.programs directly contributed to the Los Angeles insurrection. According to a 1990 study of business tax shares in seven Western states conducted by the Vtah State Tax Commission, MFASTTRF.77S A PA>3TLAT.SOL.LITTON Oregon's Business share before Measure 5 was lower than five - other Western states and 27%lower than Washington. Measure 7.will.recapture:b8% o f the revenues]ost�y Now.we have Measure 6' which will reduce businesses' Measure 5.It preserves the tax cuts given to,owner occupied ' residences and extends equal benefits to renters, who were share even further.At full implementation of Measure 5 busi- nesses'share will decline again to 4091 and household's share intentionally excluded in Measure 5 and'who:constitute<one will rise to 60% third of Oregonians,and it allows time for the,adoption of other measures to solve the problems caused by Measure 5 ! —This trend is compounded by the fact that residential { ' assessments are increasing at a much faster rate than commer- MEASURE 7 IS FAIR TO BUSINESS cial assessments.As a result,.even with Measure 5,property, taxes on homes went up by$42 million in 1991-92,while taxes The opponents of Measure 7 say it will drive industry out of on income-producing property went down by$50 million. Oregon.This is,totally false.Business will have a maximum of ' I /I $20 per$1000 of assessed value cap on property,taxes for " Something is clearly out of whack here and it's time to fix it! schools plus$10 per$1000 for everything else.,This is a reduc- tion from pre-Measure 5 levels for a majority of Oregon buss - The way to re balance the load is to pass Ballot Measure 7.It nesses.Why did they come to,Oregon and stay in Oregon before ; ' will institute a new school property tax limit on income-produc- Measure 5?The environment,infrastructure,educational facili- ing property of$20 per thousand of assessed value.Income ties and civic services.are far more important'than property property will pay the$20 per thousand,or the school tax rate in taxes in business decision making as to coming to or staying in effect at the time Ballot Measure 5 was passed, whichever is Oregon.All of these things are directly threatened if Measure 5 less.Measure 7 will restore businesses'share of state and local is not'amended.The opponents,argument stands the situation taxes to 45%,their pre-Measure level. on its head. With"all the money from Ballot Measure 7 dedicated to our TO AVOID UNDESERVED TAX BREAKS FOR BIG BUSINESS, local schools and community colleges,our schools won't be hurt by the cuts in state school,funding.And that's only fair.It's time .,TO PRESERVE HOME OWNERS TAX CUTS, for business property to pay a reasonable amount to keep good schools in our communities. TO`GIVE RENTERS A BREAK, VOTEVES ON MEASURE 7 TO GIVE US BREATHING SPACE TO REPAIR MEASURE 5 ' DAMAGE, >i VOTE FOR FAIR DISTRIBUTION OF THE TAR BURDEN TO MAINTAIN OREGON'S QUALITY OF LIFE, VOTE YES ON MEASURE 71 w (This information furnished by Eric Swenson,.Treasurer,Citizens To Save Our Schools.) j (This information fumished by Merton W.Saling.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$30o IH accordance with OAS 251.255.) I The printing of this argument aloes not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by.the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any.statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.' Ili � z 69 IIu I II' . .y 2 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OAF. x Measure 'No. .;7 OREGON - =ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR . '• EDUCATORS SUPPORT MEASURE 7 Help support the SPLIT-ROLL SCHOOLS OF THE FUTURE NEED OUR HELP TODAY Measure #7.Vote ygg. f , . w , rs CORRECTS, r educators we aee'what is happening too children in our INEQUITIES IN PROPERTY schools .When'.atate,government cuts funding schools and' community colleges,the impact in our classrooms is,immediate and negative:larger class sizes,fewer teachers,fewer choices of Are you a homeowner? class topics and the elimination of important technology courses for tomorrow's occupations.This will continue to,occur unless Oregonians act to stop it. Or ti Do you rent? Our schools are,being"assaulted at the very time we are trying ;THIS MEASURE RETAINS BENEFITS TO HOMEOWNERS OFF-SETTING RECENT,,BENEFITS - to: AND RENTERS BY implement important educational-reforms. Our elementary, GIVEN TO OUT-OF-STATE AND COMMERCIAL PROPER- high school and community college programs face deep cuts in the next budget'cycle. Our children didn't cause this problem, TIES BY MEASURE#b. but.they are paying the price through reduced services and larger'classea.;This is not going to prepare them for a future Help REDUCE further damaging CUTS TO EDUCATION complex technology demanding high skills. t Educated productive citizenry is ESSENTIAL.to our country's Ballot Measure 7 can prevent this education disaster.All of the future• revenue generated by Ballot Measure 7 is dedicated in the Oregon'Constitution,to'finance schools,from kindergarten ;'through community college—By B creating:a new school tax rate FOR OUR CHILDREN tY Be• Y g FOR OUR SENIORS r ' limit onincome producing property(commercial,industrial and `:��, • retail)business property will pay a maximum school tax rate of FOR YOURSELF $20 or the school tax rate in effect before passage of Ballot L Measure b(whichever is lower) (This information furnished by Patty Drew,President,NEA-R-0regon.) If we:are'serious about giving our"children the tools necessary to compete in the sophisticated economy of the future,we must make our schools stronger still;not weaker.Educators support Measure 7 for stronger public schools <VOTE TO SAVE OUR SCHOOLS VOTE YES ON MEASURE 7 (This information furnished by Karen Famous,President,Oregon,,. j Education Association.) { (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with.ORS 251.255.) The Printing Of this argument does not constitute an endorse. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the mint by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any,statement made in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. n f 70 Y Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED f; Measure No. 7 STATE OF ' OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN. FAVOR EASTSIDE DEMOCRATIC CLUB SCHOOLS WITHOUT SALES TAXES o In Support of Split Roll#7 A lot of old-timers were led to believe that Measure Five ti would help us,especially those of us on fixed incomes,by cut= , tin the tax rates on our homes.Imagine,We have come together as a group because we share these com- g our.surprise to.find i mon goals:peace,jobs and fair taxation.We believe that none of that nearly 60910 of the property;tax relief;went to thq,biggest, the above goals are achievable as long as some are able to pull most affluent�porations in.the link.A full $58 million in ; the wool over our eyes.We are satisfied that this has been done Multnomah County alone.We had no,idea that,many, much " by those who wrote Measure 5 two years ago. needed services would disappear along with jobs.Jobs by the thousands either gone or soon to be non-existent While it does give some relief to homeowners on fixed incomes, it does exactly nothing for young folks(renters starting out)and That's why we say,"Amend,change Measure Five by votin s , does grant huge windfalls for a considerable number of large, for alit-Roll Measure Seven which recovers that.Statewide income producing properties.Yes,we.believe that the wool has 6096 in all the years ahead The so-called lief already in Big ` a indeed,been pulled over our eyes. Corporations clutches is down the drain,gone forever...and 'they may well have used it to Tast track'our jobs to Mexico. Split-Roll language gives our-kids,today's.renters,the same We believe that the solution is to modify, amend, change tax break we receive.Also Split Roll takes away the Salestaxers ?: Measure 5 so that: 1)young folks(renters)get the same bre ak biggest argument for that phony'new source of revenue'so as Homeowners_on'fixed incomes;2)Large income producing unfair to workers and those of us with limited means. properties go back to paying taxes as they did before#5;3)Lost revenues-taken from our children's education be returned! Lastly,Split-Roll mandates all of these recovered taxes for SO WE SAY,"VOTE YES ON MEASURE#7"r YES—for fair- schools.Think about it.Our economy of tomorrow is determined by how well we prepare our children,our!students,.today ness for renters.YES—for those with income producing proper- Everyone knows our fiiture is our,children.Our children's.cre ties who have the'ability to.pay'to go back on the tax rolls as ativity, .job-adeptness, their. productivity,;starts;:in before Measure #5.YES'--for our children's future.(Their. school...To Education is our Future,too)YES—for our kids!Please! I^ VOTE-YES'ON#7 "YES"FOR SPLIT ROLL VOTE#7--SPLIT-ROLL . C.O.S.T.. . CONSUMERS'OPPOSING,THE SALES_TAX;' • 'a (This Information furnished by Marina Anttila,Chair,Eastside Democratic (This information lumished by Russ Farrell,Chair,Consumers Opposing Club.) the Sales Tax,C.O.S.T.) r (This space purchased with a petition containing the signatures of (This space purchased with a petition containing the signatures of 1,000 voters eligible to vote on the measure in accordance with ORS 1,000 voters eligible to Vote on the measure in accordance with ORS , 251.255.) 251.255.) i The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The painting of this argument floes not constitute ari endorse= %y ment by the,State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the to accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 71 j Offiaal1992 General Voters'Pamphlet' CONTINUED I. 1 Measu re No 7 OREGON ' of �I OREGON ;:' •:�'�»����.�::�.��� SARGUMENT�IN�FAVOR ARGUMENT IN{FAVOR` The Split'Roll Amendment to`Measure 5, as proposed by SAVE OUR SCHOOLS—VOTE YES ON MEASURE 7 ! 'Ballot Measure:7 on the November 3rd Ballot,is an effort to ,restore,equality to the.Oregon tax system a The following consumer/grassroots,education,`senior citizen,religious,labor,coalition and political organza- { ,h is the;only,practical alternative to a sales tax,It restores tions recommend a YES VOTE ON MEASURE 7 in order fiscal,responsibility-to income-producing property,a taxable to save our schools,maintain other essential services, <entity,which enjoyed a windfall at the expense of residential restore balance between individual and Business.Tax homeowners and renters following passage of Measure 5. burdens and keep Oregon the state we love.to live in: Consumer/Grassroots Senior The Oregon State Grange,a'leading opponent of the regres Oregon Fair Share Portland Gray Panthers , sive sales tax since the unfair tax concept was first proposed in Oregon State Gran 1933,believes that taxation should be imposed equitably on the g Grange 'Oregon'State Council of `ability to:pay.That is why the Grange became one of the three Oregon State Tenants; : Senior Citizens ;1 chief sponsors of the Split Roll Initiative and that's why we urge; Association United�Seniors of•Oregon the adoption of Ballot Measure 7. Oregon Consumers'League Portland/Multnomah Oregon Peaceworka Commission on Aging -The Split Roll Fprovides for equity in the'allocation of tax- 'Oregon Farmers Union Transit Retirees Association *responsibility,gives property tax'relief to those who need it .Citizens Utility Board Columbia River Pensioners ;most,and mitigates much of the,veryreal danger to our schools Rainbow Coalition/Portland Willamette Falls Pensioners and vital services posed by.the full implementation of Measure N 5, o Sales Tax League AFL-CIO Jane Jefferson Club � ` ,` �.The Split$oll measure does not mandate new or added taxes Education "Oregon Public'Employees on business.In the words of Oregon Legislative Revenue Office Parents_For Quality.Educatibn Union -(letter by Steven Bender;economist with said office,November Oregon School Employees Communication Workers of 15, 1991):"The initiative clearly will not relieve business prop- Association America#7901 erg taxes as.much as Measure 5 but it will not increase them.". ILWU(Columbia River,, Y. Retired Oregon School Employees District Council :In other'words,business will return to the tax responsibility Oregon Federation of Teachers Oregon Service Council ' it abided by prior to Measure 5,but will pay no more in taxes Portland Childcare Workers` Service Employees than it did then Organizing Committee International Union Local Graduate Teaching Fellows #140 The Split Roll measure will ease'the burden on Oregon'rural Federation United Food and Commercial communities,which'voted overwhelmingly against Measure 5. Workers#555 t i Only'the large urban centers,.where corporate business(a large' Inland Boatmen's Union bulk of it owned outside the state)benefits from Measure 5. Heart of Oregon Coalition American Postal Workers Portland alone,for example;has assessed'value greater than Jobs With Justice.Coalition Union(Portland Area Coos, Cprry,Jackson,Josephine, Douglas, Klamath,Lake, Oregon Alliance for Progressive Local) .I Harney and Malheur counties combined.:Here,.in the state's Policy most populous center, is located the bulk of corporate wealth Amalgamated Transit Union, ILI PrP Oregon Human Rights Division.757 which reaped the lion's share of Measure b's tax relief. Big Coalition income-producing property has enjoyed this benefit at the United Steelworkers#8378 expense of homeowners and renters,rural and urban. National Association of Social Political Workers Multnomah County Let's not,by falling to rectify the inequalities of Measure b Oregon Community Mental Democratic Central Permit desperation to become an excuse for the sales tax.Spike Health Providers Association Committee 1 the'sales tax for good by enacting the Split'Roll Fair Tax National Lawyers Guild, East Side Democratic Club System Portland Chapter Lane County Democratic 1 Central Committee VOTE FOR TAX FA T ITY VOTE FOR 1�^.i`AC TRr Relivious Ecumenical Ministries of Oregon Legislative, !;I (This Information furnished by Celia Luttrell,Oregon State Grange.) j Commission Eugene Church Women +r United, (This Information lumished by Phil Dreyer,President,Homeowners and Renters Fair Tax League.) (This space purchased for 5300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300!n accord d' ance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- T printing rgument does not constitute an endorse ! ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the by Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the a argument. argument.,:,, ny statement made in the + 72 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measul"e NO. STATE OF w ,t OREGON .1, ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ` ' ' CORRECT—' ARE WE REALLY BETTER.OFF THAN WE WERE'2 60% YEARS AGO? t REPAIR- of 1990 su Meare b PROBLEMS and DAMAGES TWO YEARS AGO MEASURk 5 backers made many claims in support of their property,tax relief scheme._They said it 7• i i i would-help,schools,not hurt essential services; would lower` t home owners taxes and force big business to pay it fair tax share.Has that really happened? Vote xMI XI SPLIT ROLL MEASURE 7 " THE LEGISLATURE HAS ALREADY BEGUN cutting state ` g a YES vote? school support along"with cuts in the state budget.And state Who will et the benefits of funding for schools could be reduced by more than 40%in the _ k r" ALL OF OUR CHILDREN and OUR SCHOOLS next three years, as the cost of mandated property,tax relief goes up and the legislature shifts tax resources- A TAX REDUCTION FOR Homeowners IN THE LAST LEGISLATIVE SESSION in-home services Residential Renters were cut and the Homeowner and Renter Relief Program a Senior Citizens the University of Oregon Gerontology Center were eliminated. All Families Senior programs,community based care,,senior mental.health and other human services face serious cuts by the next legisla- You ture. We BUSINESS and INDUSTRY will be provided with well IN SPITE OF MEASURE 5,taxes for homes actually went up trained,highly productive workers coming from Oregon $24 million in 1991,while business property taxes,much of it Schools keeping business and industry greatly cwmpeti- a: absentee owned,went down$68 million.Some relief! 9 tive in World Markets. Who finally pays for Damage Control Measure V MEASURE"7 WILL KEEP THE LIMIT on;owner-occupied homes;renters would also get relief.Measure,7 would re-set the school tax rate on income producing.property to$20 per thou- Out of State customers of Oregon Products;much as we sand of.assessed value,or the rate in effect before Measure 5, Oregonians pay hidden taxes on goods we purchase whichever is lower.Measure 7 would recover,some 70%of,the which were produced outside of Oregon: revenue lost by Measure 5 and prevent much of the damage in store for schools and essential services: KNOW THIS! A bird in the hand now on the November 3rd Election is worth whatever in the next AS HUBERT HUMPHREY PUT IT YEARS AGO:"The Legislative Session,this year or next year. moral test of government is how it treats those.who are in the dawn of life:the children—those who are in the twilight of life: MEASURE 7—VOTE YES! YES! NOW! NOW1 the aged—and those who are in the shadows of life:the'sick,the needy and the handicapped: (This In formation furnished by Richard Eymann,President,Oregon THE COLUMBIA RIVER PENSIONERS-ILWU believes Farmers Union.) that Measure 7 helps meet that test,and URGES A"YES" VOTE ON MEASURE 7. (This information furnished by Jesse K.Stranahan,Secretary-Treasurer, Columbia River Pensioners-ILWU.) WF , (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for.$300 In accordance with ORS 251:255.) II The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an"endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the = accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 73 i4 .ytl f Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED Measure N6. 7 STATEOF OREGON Ia ARGUMENT IN FAVOR. ARGUMENT IN FAVOR s VOTE";YES','ON MEASURE 7-SPLIT-ROLL TAX SAVE VITAL HUMAN SERVICES l AMENDMENT' ' END THE BIG BUSINESS WINDFALL . Measure 5,enacted by the voters in 1990,made no provision foeadequate"funding:for Oregon's education system without prior to the election in 1990, the Columbia River District redudng or eliminating other,essential State services Council of the International Longshoremen's' Warehousemen's Union(CRDC-ILWU)warned that Measure 5, ' Businesses and other income-producing properties received `the property tax limitation proposal was"a meat-axe approach about 60%of the relief—a property tax windfalll that would only make matters,worse"predicting that"more than half of the so-called relief will go to big businesses and And residential renters didn't get any relief at alli landlords, many of them from out-of-state" and`further that Measure 5 would"gut nearly all needed.services,'including ' those of direct benefit to seniors and low-income persons".• As"business property is used for.the production'of profit, property taxes ire a legitimate expense and are deductible for e CRDC•ILWU takes no pleasure m —"saying we told you income'tax purposes.Using property.for private gain is a privi- The Th But the facts are that Measure 5 gave some 68'10 of the"tax lgQ@:Residential property is a consumer use of property that : property,relief'to business billions of dollars of it absentee generates no monetary gain for the taxpayer. owned—no relief for renters—with deep and damaging cuts just " around the corner for most vital public services—like schools, MEASURE 7 IS THE SOLUTION TO THIS PROPERTY' universities,job training,police'and fire protection,senior and TAR INBALANCE human services. MEASURE.7 recaptures most of the windfall benefits now Measure 7 goes a long way toward undoing much of that dam going to`properties used for business,many of which have age.It would retain the property tax relief for owner-occupied absentee owners in other,states and even foreign countries. homes—provide equivalent relief to.renters--and stop the ` windfall given to commercial property owners,-including absen MEASURE 7 preserves the Measure 5 benefits for owner. Itee owners.Measure 7 would replace an estimated,7090 of the occupied residences and recognizes-that residential renters pay 'revenue lost because of Ballot Measure 5. property taxes indirectly through rent'payments"and are also,. I entitled to relief The CRDC-ILWU recommends a"YES":VOTE ON MEA ! SURE 7 to re-balance an unfair.tax system and to r MEASURE 7 substantially reduces the obligation thrust on harmful cuts in human'and other essential public-services.A j Oregonians to pay much higher taxes or go without needed "YES"ON MEASURE 7 would also allow time for careful con 1 State services. k sideration by Oregonians of any additional revenue needed to I maintain our schools and other needed`services based on"the ability to pay. And.best 1of all,Measure 7 will preserve the quality of educa- tion in Ore gon's public school system DO NOT BE MISLED BY CLAIMS THAT (This Information furnished by Don Liddle,Secretary-Treasurer,Columbia BUSINESS WILL BE ADVERSELY AFFECT- River District Council,International Longshoremen's and ED! OREGON IS Warehousemen's Union(CRDC-ILWU).) LAST AMONG SEVEN WESTERN STATES IN THE BUSINESS SHARP OF TOTAL TAXES!' ., VOTE"YES"ON MEASURE 7 (This information furnished by Ralph Frohwerk,Vice-president,"Oregon Consumer League) � 1 _ } I' t, (This.space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) f._ The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing o this a rent' the State o O P ng f rguntent does not constitute an.endorae by ,. f Oregon,nor does"the state warrant the ' ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement•made in the argument.' acc or truth y ur acy. of any made in the argumert.' . :M 74 �1 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED MeaSUt' STATE OF e N . T OREGO , N #; ARGUMENT IN FAVOR 'ARGUMENT IN FAVOR �� `� Make Property-owning Corporations Pay Their " The Portland Gray anthers urge `c Fair Share Y ge Your support of Measure Z Vote For A Split-Roll Tag As an inter nerationa ge l group of activists who work for:caus- es that promote peace and social justice, we.are concerned Federal Spending'and Measure 6, about the damaging effects of Measure 5 on both the young and Dunn the decade of the 1980s,ch the old,and the way it attacks Oregonians'quality of life,espe 8 anges in what the federal government spends its money on—=and tax cuts for the rich= wally for those who are poor. meant big losses for,just about every program that brings feder- al dollars into state and local government.Those losses,in turn, Many of us did not anticipate that so many vital services ' meant that Oregon's state.and.local taxes had to balloon to affecting seniors and children--•especiallythose'in greatest' make up the difference.Taxpayers saw their tax bills go up need—were to become the victims of Measure 5. Without while services remained the same or decreased.Many voters Measure 7,which will recover;60,percent.of,the revenues lost 'drew the conclusion that state and local governments were under Measure 5, we see,a difficult,compromised ,future-for, poorly managed and inefficient. So they voted for 1990's .children and seniors in Oregon, as major cutbacks are,expert-- Measure 5 to cap state and local taxes. enced in senior,and disabled services,children's,services,hous- The result was that out-of-state ro ing,transportation,health care and mental health care_.- t ; ;• p party-owning corpora- , • tions reaped a windfall in tax cuts while most of the rest of us saw little or no improvement.This happened because the reme- As parents•and grandparents, we are also deeply concerned dy,chosein(Measure 5)was based on a wrong diagnosis.(there is over the devastating effects proposed cutbacks will have on our a lot of fat instate and local government). educational system.The resulting elimination of vital jobs,ser- vices and programs in our schools will have tremendous long Federal Priorities Cost Oregonians term impact on the future of our young'people;a future p'redi-. In fact, Oregon has been plundered b the federal sated on how well they are educated. - go P Y, d govern Yfi ment.for money to pay for excessive military spending which Oregon got almost no benefit from.Too much military spending, I Do we want young Oregonians receiving a second rate educa ' cou led with tax cuts for the very rich means there isn't money tion in primary and second schools or lea ' 'the state for P rY y secondary leaving, in the federal treasury for housing, health,employment pro= .college because they have no viable alternative for higher'edu- `` grams,mass transit,FHA loans,child nutrition or education(to cation in Oregon?Can'we.afford to'fo6lishly short`change our • name a few).These are the programs that bring federal dollars .`education system and permit the"brain drain"that will surely: 'into state and local economies.Lacking that money,our state affect the future course of our state?, , to be higher to keep services available. Me t and local taxes have Measure Twill remedy this situation providing funds to j Yes On 7 Is,The First,Step help prevent devastating cuts in education from kindergarten i c' The first step to assure continuation of needed services is to to high school to higher education,as well as easing the massive vote yes for a split-roll tax to make corporations once again pay cutbacks in social service programs to both young and old. their fair share of state and local taxes. The Portland Gray Panthers urge your strong support of , " Voting Is Not Enough Measure 7. But voting is only the first step.While it is an important one, we must all realize that our election day votes'have to be { backed up with determined citizen action to,change federal (This information furnished by Bill Gordon Chat,Portland Gray spending priorities if we are to see any real changes. Panthers.) i Contact usl p (Signed)Oregon PeaceWorks'Peace Economics Committee :333 State Street + r Salem,.OR. 97301 585-2767 (, i (This information furnished by Susan R.Gordon,Oregon PeaceWorks' Peace Economics Committee.) { i (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251:255.) The rinti p n8 of this argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by the State of Oregon,'nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in'the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 75 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED OF me-'asure No.-7 STATE 'OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR The Oregon State'Council of Senior,Citizens,which has been The UNITED SENIORS OF'OREGON,the.'people who have advocating for the rights of Oregon's seniors since 1969,strong- lived through eras ly supports Measure 7. ', of child-raising,:, Measure 5 was not the answer to the state's tax ills;it is a of home-owning, nightmare—to the tune of about a$1 billion shortfall in 1993- of apartment-renting, 96.Under Measure 5,services for seniors will be devastated. of school-supporting, Homecare personal care, daycare,respite,case management, of property-owning,,, and adult foster care will be severely cut.Senior mental health of wage-earning," , projects around the state will come to screeching halt. Senior and,even,ofvoting-against sales taxes, centers will close.Transportation will not be as readily avail- able to seniors,particularly,those,living in rural areas. supports the SPLIT-ROLL Measure 7. And seniors are not alone:Services to children,the mentally We are in favor of Ballot Measure 7 because it... ill and the disabled.will also be devastated. Criminal justice Maintains the property tax limit on owner-occupied programs will be slashed.Community services such as libraries P and recreational programs will be shutdown.College campuses homes set in the Constitution by Ballot Measure 5. may be dismantled.The list goes on and on. Puts a new limit in the'Oregon Constitution for school ro taxes on inceme- roducin property. Measure 7 would provide about$800 million of the projected P P g P PeY• P P j Sends all the re venue generated by this tax rate limit $1 billion shortfall for'1993-95,retaining Measure 5 property to our schools'K through 12th grade and commutax,relief to homeowners with'equivalent"re liefto renters.It colleges. . Pity does not increase anyone's tax-it merely maintains the 1990 r Shall provide property tax relief to residential rentals tax level for commercial properties and asks business to finally as is given to homeowners on thee residences. �- pay their.fair share of the tax load in Oregon.Most importantly, j it keeps property tax.relief�where it.is needed most—with . Oregon homeowners. WE ASK YOU TO BE WITH US IN SUPPORTING THE Measure 7 corrects one of the SPLIT-ROLL PROPERTY TAX RELIEF' the'greatest inequities in the pas- sage of Measure 5: namely that commercial owned property VOTE YES ON MEASURE 7 ' 'gained 58%of the benefits compared to only 42%for homeown- ers.Hoof this enormous'windfall earned by business went to i foreign investors and absentee-owners of Oregon business prop- erty.As'Oregonians face massive cuts in schools and services (This information furnished by Alice M.Pickard,President,United Seniors :hundreds of millions of dollars-are going'out of the state`as a of Oregon.) windfall to big business.And the fact is,business was paying a very low tax rate before Measure 5 ever passed.. This is not the Measure 5 Oregonians thought was passed in 1990.Oregon homeowners need property tax benefits.But,thus far under Measure 5 this goal has not been achieved.Business property taxes went down$68 million in 1991'while homeown-' ers saw their property tax bill going uP by$24 million. - y,in stark contrast to th ' �� a omission of renter relief in Measure 5 Measure 7 provides relief to renters(who make up 'one-third of Oregonians).This recognizes and provides equiva- lent relief for the property taxes paid by renters(Legislative Revenue estimates 17 percent of.rent goes to pay property j taxes).' 'Something is clearly wrong with the supposed;panacea roffered by Measure 5. Business gets a huge windfall, .Oregonians watch their residential property taxes go up in 1991,no renter relief is offered, and,to top it off, services are being cut.It is time to correct this injustice to Oregoniansl Vote ° yes on Measure 7. (This Information furnished by Dr.James A.Davis,Vice President/ 1 Legislative Director,Oregon State Council of senior Citizens.) This s l; ( pace purchased for a3ot)in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for s3oo in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The rind meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meat the State of does not constitute an endorse- 'accuracy truth �' f Oregon,nor does the state warm the u�cy of any statement made in the argument aceuracy or,truth'of any statement made in the argument. 76 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED , STATE OFw Measure No. 7 } . . OREGON , ARGUMENT IN'FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR VOTE YES ONMFASTTRF 7m ' VOTE YES ONMEASURE 7 Y YESIII—Measure 7,the split-roll tax initiative,'will benefit The Oregon Alliance for Progressive Policy is a permanent; working men and women living in the state of Oregon,not busi- state-wide,multi-issue coalition of over thirty groups and hun- nesses,corporations and landlords,,, dreds of individual associates.We work together for ro ge Sressi p ve political change and social justice. The OAPP Statement of YES!!I—Renters who'meet requirements will benefit under Principles includes: I this measure as renter relief will be placed back into the tax ## laws' We believe tax equity is essential to maintain public I Al support for public services.We believe tax policy should `• YES!!!=Property taxes for businesses, corporations and be based on ability to pay �St landlords will nd be raised.They will just not drop as far as the property taxes of owner occupied residences. Homeowners in Oregon have been paying too much property t tax—because somebody else isn't paying their share j YES!!!—Absentee pro perty owners;both foreign and domes- li tic who are not.residents of the state of Oregon would see a • In 1971,homeowners paid just 33 perce nt of property windfall tax reduction if Measure 5 were to be fully implement taxes.in Oregon. "ed,Tax shifting to a possible sales tax would not affect them at In 1981,homeowners paid 42 percent. all' In 1995;homeowners will pay 60 per of all prop- erty taxes in Oregon. YES!!!—Large property intensive corporations in the state You are paying more because big business is paying less. received large tax cuts in the first year of the implementation of Measure 5.This can be expected to continue. Big business spend millions of dollars"on campaign contribu- tions and lobbyists to influence the Oregon Legislature to YES!!!'-Property taxes pay for many state and local services. reduce their taxes.It worked. A split-roll tax will limit to a lesser degree the amount of cut- backs that will have to be made in the-providing,of those ser- ? vices: - The legislature exempted business inventories,standing timber: and more from property taxes.Less property P PertY to tax means thaf� VOTE VFC ON MEASURE�m homeowners pay more.The average homeowner has lost.thou - sands of dollars because of this tax shift. Our local schools are suffering because business doesn't pay its share. " (This information furnished by Michael P.Parker,Legislative Director, Measure 7 will reclaim only part of the money that big business Portland,Oregon Area Local American Postal Workers Union and Oregon has avoided paying.For the first time,their tax break would be. Postal Workers Union.) smaller than yours!It's only fair. OAPP members urge you to join us in voting yes on Measure 7—Portland Oregon Area Local American.Postal Workers Union, Communications Workers of America•Local 7901, ." National Lawyers Guild/Portland Chapter,N:W.Farmers Union;Inlandboatmen's Union,Oregon Federation of Teachers,, 1. Education and Health Professionals,AFT, AFL-CIO, Oregon Human Rights Coalition, Oregon PeaceWorks,Oregon State., I„ Industrial Union Council,Rainbow Coalition Portland,United ` Food and Commercial Workers Local 555,and many more! (This Information lumishad by Margaret Olney,'Presldent,Oregon z Alliance for Progressive Policy.), iar .. I g (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) . l The printing of this_argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse= mart by the State of Oregon,nor does-the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state,warrant the accuracy or truth of anystatement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. I` 77 t 1, Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet A. CONTINUED STATE OF �x Mea'su' re: NO.` 7 OREGON w, AGRUMENT,IN FAVOR'' ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION 'Ballot Measure'7 can reverse what Ballot Measure b has Oregonians needs jobs not unemployment.VOTE NO on 7 and dane to Oregon schools. save your job. Measure 7 is designed to bring unfair taxation to business and • Our schools are closing stop homeowner jobs.Currently we all pay$15.00 per$1,000.00 • College and university seniors programs have disappeared. valuation.. • Faculty and staff,.our neighbors,'across Oregon are getting Renters—VOTE NO—as your rental unit is a"business".you pink slipS.:,r,�. . , , ., �" _ will be Paying$20.00 per$1,000.00 valuation,while we home- owners will only Pay$15.00., •'Homeowners,because of higher assessments,have seen enor Why should renters be forced to pay more besides losing their moue tax increases.Homeowners paid$24 million more last -year, m);­% ;; jobs.VOTE NO. • 'Cities,counties and the state have cut essential programs to We homeowners and renters must unite'on 7 to stop unfair taxation of renters.We are equal,under Measure'b, of$15.00 7 ,the bone. • Students, kids, law-abiding citizens, and other decent per$1,000.00 valuation. Oregonians have been penalized by the effects,of Ballot VOTE NO on 7 to save our home and stop your increase in ' rent,and save jobs. Measure b. VOTE NO on 7,as it is"fools gold".You will paythe extra$5 And businesses?,Business, unlike everyone else in dollar tax through cost of higher food,'meat,potatoes,shoes and clothing.Businesses are assessed on their ability to earn Oregon,benefited,from Ballot Measure 5.They now pay money.Measure 7 creates"Fools Gold"by raising the cost'of less of.Oregon s total tax than they did before Ballot doing business.Jobs will leave Oregon: Measure 6 was passed:They paid$84 million less last This system of overtaxing business is a left over from the a year.: ' "Wobblies"who want Government to own all business. As homeowners we know our mortgage payment comes 'from We can turn this around with.Ballot Measure 7.' Ballot our labor with jobs from small and large businesses. Measure:7 does not create new taxes.It just changes the Jobs will be lost to the State of California,Idaho,Nevada and assessment to businesses and restores the tax balance.It restores business tax levels to fund education in Oregon. Washington' Measure b,our:1 1/235 rate"limitation is based on"Market ' Value" of all property.Assessments for business property is When your kids are ready to go to college,there should be a based on what they earn,therefore,the$20.00 tax proposed in place for them.Let's stop the education disaster in Oregon.Let Measure 7 will further deplete the rate base by business failure business pay its fair`share to keep Oregon's schools"open and healthy. VOTE NO on 7. PROTECT THE SCHOOLS.;PROTECT THE STATE. PROTECT,t1m INDIVIDUAL TAXPAYER. (This information furnished by Clyde V.Brummell,President,Oregon„ YES ON BALLOT MEASURE 7. Homeowners Association.) r (This information furnished by Richard H.Schwarz,Executive Director, Oregon Federation of Teachers,;Education and Health Professionals, AFT,AFL CIO.), r , (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by,the State of Oregon,nor doges the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warmnt the accuracy Or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 78 ` Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED Measure No 7 STATE OF ■ OREGON i 4 ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION' � , ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION �. . YJ PROTECT OREGON JOBS FIVE GOOD REASONS TO VOTE"NO" "i VOTE NO ON MEASURE 7 ON BALLOT MEASURE 7 r Reason One: Doubles Property Tax Rate Limits Oregon's economy will suffer if Measure 7'is passed.Last year ; total;employment'in Oregon declined by 1400 and our unem- ployment rate is climbing.Increasing property taxes on busi- Measure 7 will double the property tax rate limits on all proper. nesses will cause'further job reductions. ty in Oregon,except that which is owner occupied,from a limit of$lb per thousand to$30 per thousand.Measure 7 affects a v' wide range of property:apartments and rental homes,farm Measure 7 Will double property taxes on all businesses in. land,forest land,grazing land,even vacant land.For all these Oregon.To pay the,extra property taxes,business will have properties,Measure 7 will double the tax rate,limits approved to cut back expenses—.and that means jobsl by the voters just two years in Ballot Measure 6. ; Passage of Measure 7 will guarantee that Oregon will have one Reason Two: Will Cause Higher Rants R of the highest business property taxes in the nation—the R' if we want to continue to have jobs for O ni regoans. wrong move By doubling the property tax rate limits on apartment complex- es and rental homes,Measure 7 will almost certainly mean rent Measure 7 will increase property taxes by$1.7 bf7lion and will increases.The measure promises rent relief;but that-"relief' not provide one additional dollar to local schools but depends on action by the Legislature,which has created—then instead will be used for state government programs. taken away—rent relief programs twice in the`past • Don't double property taxes on Oregon businesses! Reason Three: Damages Small Bnsmess j • Don't drive new jobs away from Oregon with high- Oregon is the nation's leading small business state.'higher ` or taxest property tax rates will hurt small business the most,`at a time when small businesses are accounting for nearly,all-of the Don't make Ore property state's job growth. 11 gon Number 1 in taxes on business! Reason Four: Doesn't Raise More Money for'Schools • Don't increase property taxes$1.7 billion for state programs! Measure 7 is not the answer to our school,funding challenge. fi Although it raises local property taxes,it doesn't generate addi- tional funds.for schools—it simply replaces funds currently ear- marked for schools by the Legislature.Taxes will go up under. VOTE NO ON BALLOT MEASURE 7 Measure 7;school funds won't. Reason Five: Pays for State Government Programs (This Information furnished by Rlchard M.Butrlck,President,Associated f Oregon Industries.) Measure 7 will generate an additional$850 million a year'that ; can be used to pay for state government programs.No wonder I� t` this measure is supported by state public employees,who see it \ as a way to protect their jobs. i • . Higher taxes Higher rents j • Hurts small business • No new money for schools • Pays for more state government .4 The choice is clear-VOTE NO ON MEASURE 7. (Th1s Information furnished by Gary Carlson,Oregonians For A Sound i� Economy.), (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.2s5.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance'with ORS 251.255.) is The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- Theprinting of this argument does not constitute an endorse-, ment.by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant.the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument."?.: Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OF Measure No,- 7 OREGON w 1 4 ARGUMENT LN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION MEASURE 7 DOES NOTPROVIDE FARMERS LOSE UNDER MEASURE 7. . s 1VIORE MONEY FOR SCHOO VOTE"NO"ON HIGHER TAXES.-. . r Backers of this measure say it means more money for schools. Supporters,of Measure 7 sometimes give the impression that That isn't,true.When voters approved property tax rate limits the doubling of property tax rates proposed by.the measure will two years ago'through Ballot Measure 5,the,.State Legislature only hurt big corporations with high-rise office boil y dings in the was obligated to cover.the losses incurred bylocafschools by cities. providing`replacement funds"from state revenues.Measure 7, which would double the property tax rate limits for business Take a closer look.The"split-roll"proposed by Measure`7 dou 'and:many,other:forms:.of property, raises more money for bles property tax rate limits for,all property•other,than schools.locally,thus reducingthe amount of replacement funds the state must'provide by about$850 million per year. "owneroccupied residential property" i That's.all Measure 7'does, It does not guarantee any ,That means: additional money for schools. - • farm land property tax rates would be,doubled. It frees up money at=the state level for the Legislature to spend forest land property tax rates would be doubled.' ' on any;$tats-programs,it.chooses:.That's the central problem' grazing land property tax rates would be doubled. with Measure 7—it gives more money to the Legislature with no obligation that the money go to education. Measure 6 would even double property tax rates on VACANT LANDI Look at all the vacant land in Oregon.Surely < MEASVM 7 IS NOT,THE,SOLUTION it doesn't make sense to double property tax Yates on land that's TO OREGON'S SCHOOL FINANCE CHALLENGE. ' not even used DONT PENALIZE FARMERS This isn't thefanswer to the'challenge we face.We need a solo tion'that'guarantees-our school children will have the kind of education they need to be successful in achieving their future Measure 7 would impose an unfair burden on Oregon's farming goals. community by doubling property tax rates on farm land.In a state so reliant upon agriculture, we need to encourage We must continue to work together in Oregon to find a compre f�?�to stay in business-not make it harder for them hensive solution to the school finance'challenge.Measure 7.is to survive.It's tough enough now for family farmersto make a not the solution..' living.Measure 7 would make it tougher. i j' Voters shouldsay"NO"to Measure 7.', Oregon's farmers pay their share in taxes to support schools and other government'programs.But there is'no'good reason tI , why they ought to pay property taxes at a rate double that of (This information furnished b Gary Carlson; homeowners.Measure 7 is not fair. I j Economy.) is info y ry Qregonians ForA Sound Oppose the split roll. t' Treat all'property fairly. Vote . to "NO" on Measure 7 (This information fumishad by Don A.Schellenberg;Director of Field { ° . Services,Oregon Farm Bureau Federation.) 41 ' I 1 r 1 (Thls space purchasad fcr.$sgo in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This spars purchased for S300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing.of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse rnent by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 80 Official 1992 Geheiral Voters'Pam filet f CONTINUED STATE OF asur } ilia - P, NO. �T GREG Y � •r , ,„ti,� , a ARGUMENT IN'OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ' 11IEASUR.E 7 HURTS SMALL BUSINESS, REN=RS$EWAREt THE'BACKBONE OF OREGON'S ECONOMY. MEASURE'7 DOUBLES TAXES ON APARTMENTS. ” ` Oregon is a.small business'state:In,fact,it's the leading small MEASURE 7.I8 BAD FOR RENTERS business state in the nation.Small businesses,those with fewer l ' than 20 employees, Measure 7 will double'the property tax"rate limits for"most , provided almost all of the net job growth in apartment buildings,•duplexes,and rental homes across the Oregon in the 1980x: r; state. Thai's why Measure 7 poses such a threat to Ore n's economy- ,. g° =ate That's a fact.And when property taxes go up for landlords,,who I; 'It hurts small businesses by doubling their property tax rate do you think will pay the cost?Renters,that's who.Landlords l '. limits.And what hurts small business this state hurts us all. get the bill and we make the payments with higherrent „ MEASURE 7 PUTS JOBS AT RISK. In our current economy,we can't afford to make life any harder for those who have to pay rent., By their very nature,small businesses are fragile.They are the businesses most likely to,fail.So when Measure 7 hits small MEASURE 7 SAYS WE'LL GET RELIEF businesses with a:doubling of property tax rate limits,many r; firms won't be able to absorb the increased burden.Doors could' , HEARD THIS PROMISE BEFORE! close,Jobs could be lost. Measure 7 promises'that renters will get"equivalent"relief to HIGHER TAXES that received b homeowners under B Measure . e ive y homed ers nd allot Me 6 But th � WILL DISCOURAGE NEW BUSINESSES._ measure doesn't define"equivalent.°And guess who gets to define it?The State,Legislature. ' Not only will Measure 7 hurt existing,small businesses,it will discourage those who want to start a new corn how much_they're worth.Lawmakers have created renter relief I' some of the highest business property taxes in the country,peo- programs twice in the past-and.both times the took them' # ple will think twice before risking their future on a new idea.' y away:With property taxes doubling for apartments and rental It's hard enough to get up the courage to invest one's life sav housing owners,rents would likely rise faster than any relief mgs in a new business-Measure 7 will' st make this situation � provided by lawmakers: worse.Now is'not the time—when we need every new job we can get—to deter creation of new businesses in Oregon.', Besides,where is the Legislature going to get the money for this DON'T SACRIFICE SMALL BUSINESS promised relief? By raising our income taxes?It won't help renters a bit if their income taxes go up in order to,pay for FOR STATE GOVERNMENT PROGRAMS `relief." Those behind Measure 7 say the'issue is school funding.That's Measure 7 will not helprenters M'Oregon.It doubles tax wrong. Measure 7 won't provide any new money for rate omits on rental property,forces higher rents,and schools.But it will double business taxes to pay for$s5o promises relief it can't guarantee! J million a year in state government programst No wonder %! this proposal has the strong backing of.Oregon's largest state f employees union. MEASURE 7 IS BAD FOR RENTERS. VOTE NO ON MEASURE 7. 'I No matter how much state employees want to protect their jobs, we can't put the health of Oregon's small business economy on I, the line just to pay for state government. (This information furnished by Dana Cooler,Executive Director,Southern Oregon Renters PAC.),. I VOTE TO PROTECT SMALL BUSINESS. VOTE NO ON MEASURE 7. c (This information furnished by E.Joe Gilliam,Jr.,State Director National f ii Federation of Independent Business.) i, • ',,}ill i (This space purchased for$300In,accordance with ORS 251.255.) ' (This space purchased for$900 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The'printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not eonditute.an endorse=: f meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 81 I :) Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTIN2-Ir STATE OF Measure, No. 7: OREGON ARGUMENT"IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT KOPPOSITION MEASURE 7 IS HARMFUL ' DONT1'MAKE THE TIMER SUPPLY PROBLEM TO COMMUNITY BUSINESSES WORSE! VOTE NO ON MEASURE 7 We are deeply,concerned about the negative impacts that Measure 7.will have on small community'businesse6.By Passage of Ballot Measure 7 could seriously impact owners of doubling the property.tax rates paid by business,Measure 7 small woodlands in Oregon and worsen the current crisis in will-harm the local merchants and service companies that are timber supply. so important to small communities; Small woodlands are important to Oregon's economy.More A.major••flaw in Measure 7 is that it treats all businesses alike. than 25,000 Oregonians own parcels of land dedicated to this "r It doesn't just target"big business"to pay a'larger share of use.All together we own over 40 percent of the private forest property taxes,it hits all businesses the same.-So no matter land in the state.Small woodlands play a significant role how-small a business is,Measure 7 will raise property taxes in meeting the state's timber supply needs. from$15 per thousand-of market value to $30 per thousand. That's true whether or not the business is making a profit! .. Right now—when we need all the timber supplies we can get to keep mills open and provide jobs for timber workers—is a tern- Obviously,that will hurt the`small businesses the most, ble time to discourage small woodland'owners. especially those that'are barely surviving already. The result ' could be that the local business could go under in favor of the But that would be the result if Measure 7 passes.Measure 7 big national chains.That's not good for Oregon's communi- y proposes to double,property taxes on small'woodlands. ; ' ties!. . That could cause two serious problems in Oregon. HELP LOCrAhBUS1NESSE$SURVIVE . First,imposing higher property taxes ion these owners could force them to convert valuable woodlands to We ought to be helping local businesses survive,not further other uses,thus reducing their long-term contribution to harming them through sky-high property taxes.Local business- the timber supply. es know their communities,they know what local people want, they provide jobs for local residents. It doesn't make sense to Second, if we impose higher costs on woodland owners, punish these crucial businesses with crippling property tax ,; i rates.Any proposal that makes it harder,for community busi. less money will be available to invest in sound for- nesses to survive should be defeated est management practices. y That's why we're against Measure 7. It will hurt small busi- nesses,particularly those.in small towns,like ours.At a time state's economy and a threat to Oregon jobs. When many of Oregon!s small-town retailers and service firms are fighting to hang on,let's not do anything to make the situa- tion worse. , DON'T MAKE THINGS WORSEI VOTE NO ON BALLOT MEASURE 7 W'A Stand up for your local businesses. Say"NO"to higher taxes. Jim Denison,President Say"NO"to MEASURE 71 , Oregon Small Woodlands Association' r (This Information furnished byHarold Brandon,Harold's Jewelers, (This information furnished by Jim Denison,President,Oregon.Small Stayton Jack Darley,Davis-Darley Insurance Company,Slayton;Dean Woodlands Association.) Odenthal,Stayton Pharmacy.) , s, (This space purchased for$300 in,accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space Purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) 6 The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment'by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument, accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. w 82 4 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet s STATE OF k. �easure Now. •7 ' OREGON < t`` ; ' , ` ''. ;,•# � t ARGUMENT�1N OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITIOk�'° MEASURED 7 WILL'MEAN. MEASURE 7MEANS HIGHER PRICES. HIGHER iITII,ITY 8ILL4. "NOTE NOII ' Let's examine one important impact upon-Oregonians if It's a basic fact of life than when costs go up for a busiaesst Measure 7 passes.It's this:Measure 7 will cause}nigher utili those costs have to be passed along to consumers in the form of wA` t'ybilla. higher prices.'This is true for,-the grocery business ias well'as any other company where you may do business eve day drug u every •� Measure 7 proposes to double the property tax rate limits on all stores,hardware stores,dry'cleaners,or video rental shops:,. Property except that which is owner occupied and a princi al residence;;Utilities are justone of the many types of businesses That's why Measure 7 will hurt Oregonians.The measure could that would be affected by Measure 7. double property tax rates`for,all businesses in the•state:from $15 to $30 per,thousand of market value.And when property. What would lugherproperty'taxes on utilities means to then taxes go uP.so will Prices.This isn t a scare tactic,its a:simple , telephone,electricity and natural gas customers?It would mean matter of economics.Oregon businesses,especially small;busi- t higher bills.That's because utility ates are nesses who,operate without much profit m y :government � P argIn,.Will lie forced regulated and the costs of doing business are factored into the to ask their customers to pay for.these higher property; taxes. rates allowed by the state.J k DON'T RISK;HIGHER.PRICES:., Highef property taxes-one of many costs included in rate deci- TO PAY FOR MORE GOVERNMENT.` lions—would be passed along to utility customers in the form of higher bills B Y doubling property P e rty tax rates on business—paid for in part by higher,prices on consumers—Measure 7 will generate$850 mil- Therefore,passage of;Measure.7 will mean higher monthly lion more each year to pay for state government programs. phone bills.Higher monthly electricity bills. Higher monthly Clearly this isn't what Oregon voters wanted when they passed ! gas bills. Ballot Measure 5,two years ago.Voters wanted less government spending and lower property,taxes,not higher prices and more The system works both ways.In 1990,when Ballot Measure bureaucracy. t 5 reduced property tax rates on utilities,the savings;Were f returned in the form of lower utility bills.-As those tax rate lira- DON'T BE TRICKED BY PROMISES;', J. its continue to lower:property taxes,;Oregon,customers will OF RENT'RELIEF. enjoy further reductions. � s Measure 7 also says it will help Oregomans by promising some There's a clear choice;in the'coming election.Stick with the can form of renter relief. Don't be misled. This rent relief isn't rent, ste sy m,which is lowering utility,wets and therefore cus- spelled out in the proposal and depends upon:action by the tomer bills.Or approve Measure 7,and plan on higher monthly State Legislature.Additionally,:since.apartments and.rental utility bills. homes fall under the proposed property tax increases, any rent relief forthcoming will most likely be offset by justifiable land- f lord rent increases. The choice is simple. VOTE NO ONMEASURE 7 Measure 7 is notgood for Oregon'consumers. '1 • (This information furnished by Gary SAY-NO-TO HIGHER PRICES!Carlson,Oregonians For Sound Economy.) SAY-NO"TO MEASURE 7. (This information furnished by Gene McIntosh,President,Mac's Markets- i. and Delis,Inc.) (This'space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance wRh ORS;251255) i The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- Tile printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.-.­ 83 i Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONT2'INU Measure :No 7 'STATE OF • OREGON ARGUMENT'•IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN'OPPOSITION ..'• ,• HOME CARE PROVIDERS DONT HARM ONE OF AGRICULTURE'S LEADERS. Ii1T HARD BY MEASURE 7. VOTE"NO"ON MEASURE 71' VOTE NO ON MEASURE 7. The Oregon nursery industry plays a major,role in our state's Adult foster care homes in Oregon provide an important service land-based agricultural economy.Between 85 and 90 percent of j • to.Oregon by caring for those who can no longer cars for them- our production is shipped out of the state,bringing new dollars selves.Many of,these homes operate on a shoe-string budget into Oregon's economy. and put quality of service above profits. The nursery industry is made up of nearly 1550 growers who' We're concerned that Measure 7 could double our property tax sell more than$400 million worth of plant material each year. rates and force many of us out of business.` That ranks Oregon third in the nation'behind California and Florida for size of its nursery business. In'Oregon there are more than 2,700 home-based providers who"annually care for thousands of Oregonians in need.If these SAY"NO"TO HIGHER TAXES - home-based providers are unfairly;taxed by Measure'7 and go under;who-will provide Wis.care?Where will the people and, �d is a critical resource for the nursery.industry,(as it is for families•who rely on our services turnto for help? all of agriculture)and property taxes'are,an'important'cost'of production.If Measure 7 passes it will,`ineffect,mean the loss ". MEASURE 7 IS UNFAIR of our farm use assessment.That limitation of our property TO ALL HOAMBASED BUSINESSES taxes was originally given in return for farmers'agreement to limit the options available to them when selling their property. M6st'farm land is located in farming zones'and is sold for a It's not just foster bare homes that will be hurt by this measure; lower value than commercial property.If Measure 7 passes it it's all businesses based in the'home.Think of who,could be will place a heavy burden of additional'taites,on agriculture. hurt:'"seamstresses,`child care providers,music teachers,-and many others.All would face the prospect of doubled property Agriculture has always been the backbone of Oregon's economy tax rates if Measure?passes. : 'It is an important producer of America's food crops and environ- mental crops.Measure'7 proposes to double''the property tax That's wrong.We should be encouraging,people to start busi- rate limits for all property other than that which is owner occu nesses, not penalizing them. Home-based businesses allow pied.Measure 7 tax increases will apply to agricultural lands. •many Oregonians who can't'work out of the home to earn need- food crops,dairy,beef,nursery lands,and even vacant lands ed income.Why single them out for increased taxes?It doesn't make sense.Unemployment is high enough without making the Higher es are not what we.ne problem worse ti tax ed•to solve our economic prob- lens in Oregon."A better approach would be to allow Oregon's 1 `' `SAVE OUR FOSTER CARE HOMES. agricultural industries to-grow and continue to bring more dol. Lars into the state through exports. SAVE OUR HOME-BASED BUSINESSES. SAY"YES"TO A STRONG ECONOMY. I VOTE"NO"ON MEASURE 7. VOTE "NO"ON MEASURE 7 (This information fumished by Kathleen Femrite,Executive Committee (This information furnished by Roberta Ronning,Oregon Registered Care Oregon Association of Nurserymen.) Providers Association.) s I ' (This space purchased for,f 3001n.accordance with ORS 251.255,) (This space purchased for a30o in accordance with ORS 251.255.) r The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument ' meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment the State go does not constitute an ront the or truth of any'statement made in the a of Oregon nor does the state umrrant the rgument, accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument., 24. 84 • n rte: - ......_.._._.._.�-._�. 01 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet 7 k , STATE OF Measure No 7 OREGON ARGUMENT`IN OPPOSITION k J THIS MEASURE IS MAINLY SUPPORTED BY GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES. d The petition signature sheets for this measure'were delivered to the Salem address of The Oregon PubhcEmployees'.Union. THEY SAY IT WAS CREATED BECAUSE MEASURE S IS NOT WORKING WRONGI' THEY SUPPORT IT BECAUSE MEASURE 5 IS WORKING! Measure 5 is slowing the growth of government spending and 4. government people-don't like that...because the growth of spending is directly connected to the growth of public employ- ees'wages and.benefits,.which have far outstripped those of the privately employed worker,to the point of scandal..and.they .want to keep it that way. i I cannot think of any other,Measure in Oregon's history " it Evhich would have caused as much damage"to the state's econo `my as this one surely will.Property taxes on businesses will'go to a level higher than before Measure 51 The proponents say that business can afford it,.-that business received a."Windfall" from Measure 5.The fact is,Measure 5 was intended to protect every element of our society,and economic system,"private citi- zens and private business alike,from.a greedy and irresponsi-' ble government. Remember,all businesses in Oregon are not"Big,Multi- . National, Corporations", as the proponents imply.In fact, Oregon has very few big businesses.Ninety percent of our non- government employees work for small businesses. There are over 83,000 separate companies in Oregon,the vast"majority of, them have less than`15 employees...and these businesses are no different than individuals when it comes to taxes:When the , government takes large payments which are unrelated to income,then economic vitality is crippled or destroyed.Jobs Lost! The proponents say,that higher taxes on private businesses ! are necessary to keep up the level of"government services". r ! Just remember that when they say services,8035 of the money ' is for ever increasing, Pay,Perks and Pensions for Public People! . Think of this Measure as'simply a crude and thoughtless way to guarantee a good life for,those who benefit from taxes.Come to,think of it, this measure probably will create more jobs...more government jobs. Let Measure 5 Work!VOTE NO on MEASURE 7. !, (This information furnished by Don McIntire.) M iv! I' (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) !' The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. i 'Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ' CONTINUED j .. STATE OF R Measure .No.,:,,8 OREGON , Proposed by initiative petition to be,voted on at the General most selective methods while causing the least interference Election;November 3,1992. with upstream utilization and the spawning and rearing offish BALLOT TITLE , ` •' 3) All individuals who represent this state on any inter- state or international board,commission or council that regu- :•;:•:>: >; t of the fish resource are directed to perform lates management pe kS '> i: ^ ' > :<'<' those representational duties in a manner consistent with this, >;;? '.'1'C MOST ?<>>::::'<;;::: ; section,but not inconsistent with federal laws or court orders, ° 4) Upon determination that sigaif`icant numbers of QJES`I'TiJNh8118Elkit!xttitlttiv8r ilttmisi0. $ salmon would exceed established escapement goals,the State xele e>iaeshB Department of Fish and Wildlife may,cause to be operated P selective salmon harvesting facilities:'Salmon so harvested ':..�,'vEy:>:C�:::: m shall .[ktilir�AtilYs :lh �kpr.;::;.;;:;::: ::;:: shall be by the highest bidder and the pnoceeda therefio o# 1alaavex hx.....most selective meang ava114ier' . ?;: be paid into the State Wildlife Fund.Notwithstanding ORS 496.300,all monies received pursuant to'this P�BroPh aTe } gE:kiiytit:seleefa�te,utetltasls,to allow appropriated centrnuouslyto carry out the provrswns of this 'tool! >fits tli `>"`:':p i9ifatiiag0itlo t lslan�fox apeol SECTION 6.1)Any person may commence a civil action + 'by rveat,oppq against the.commission or the State Department of M and {iillAet€ing Plan goals illB plS1t #&i? z $Sr Wildlife to compel the performance of any duty prescribed in, c div�xsi of#llaso s ea:ee gon t ;,.. ;:.•:,; :;.,^:•> 1 >:%;:<:::» section 4 of this Act that is not discretionary. tisara€iflknu►17eejicgr?!}IiU `1? z plaintiff prevails sction•referredtointhis' Csr1�! M A A;ct enfaxoasble�b lawsuits G::::'.€ <:'.::; 2) If.the P P Y ngtdns section;the court shall award reasonable-attorney fees incurred ::::.;::::::.::::.. ..... .... ..:;;;>.•<:<;::;::::<:::. ::;;:;;;:::;<:: ,m bringing the action on anyappeal of the judgement. , 4", `F'f ' 0 ! � >>" SECTION 6. 1)Paragraph b)Subsection 1)of section 4 of Spa M. dlt t 1T'bae l,d»>llhonfox3nl lomezt JanuaryI,1M. ;pn� State' this Act Srst becomes operative alld eachleleaier' 2) The first investigation'and research by the State `` ' sold x5tevenuns ::: De rtment'of Fish and Wildlife b ar h a)'of' c leted b • of 'Act must be om .:::..:::::.:::::::::.;;::.:.;:.:::.:.:::.>:::.;:;;;;;;;:;:• subsection 1)of section 4 this'Act, Y .. , 'RELATING TO FM' December 31,1993. t SECTION i: This article shall be known as the Fish Conservation A t % SECTION 2. The people of Oregon find and declare that the'fish of the State of Oregon should be managed and con- served for the benefit of all people and for genetic diversity and abundance To prevent Columbia River salmon,steelhead and sturgeon from being threatened and endangered demands that the State of Oregon move strongly and effectively and take every means Possible to protect them from non-selective harvest and restore our historic resources. I I SECTION 3. 'Sections 4 and 6 of this Act are added to and made a part of ORS chapter 606. +' SECTION 4. >Notwithstanding any other provision of the wildlife laws or the commercial fishing laws: 1)" It is the policy of the State of Oregon that the harvest offish in the main stem of the Columbia River from the mouth to Bonneville Dam be conducted by the most selective means available and in a manner that allows all nontarget fish to be ; returned to the water unharmed.In carrying out this policy: a) ' the State Department of Fish and Wildlife shall con dud investigations and research-to determine the most selec- tive methods for harvest offish that will allow all nontarget fish I to be returned to the water unharmed.The determinations made shall be reevaluated not later than December 31 of each Odd-numbered year: b) The commission shall oppose to the extent of its authority and influence, the taking of fish by gillnet in the mainstem of the'Columbia River from the mouth upriver to Bonneville Dam during the period beginning January.1 and ending August 31 of each calendar year. 2) In carrying out its duties,the commission shall devel- op and implement management plans for the protection of those + species most likely to be affected by harvest.To protect the native species and genetic diversity of those species shall be the Principal goals in the management and harvest of all fish stocks in waters of the main stem Columbia River from the mouth to Bonneville Dam and all harvest shall be conducted by the 86 N IN "Iwo low Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED, Measure' NoA STATE OF OREGON K f_ EXPLANATORY STATEMENT ARGUMENT IN FAVOR This, proposes to'further define public policy (This measure does not effect Native American Treaty Rights), F toward anaging and conserving the fish of this state,and reef- firm present laws on genetic diversity and abundance.This measure includes the protection of Columbia River salmon `cco�r*to the American fisheries society, an organization of steelhead and sturgeon from harvest methods that do not per- National Fisheries Biologists and fisheries experts)there are 76 mit the commercial or recreational fisher to release all non tar stocks of Salmon threatened,with extinction in,the Columbia get fish unharmed, River. It is common knowledge thatdozens of other stocks from To carry out the fish harvest" h the State De the Columbia are already extinct. Oregon must act now to stop Po cy,, Department this trend by requiring selective harvest methods that allow ; of Fish and Wildlife is to study and determine the most eelee_ members of the 76 threatened stocks and other non-target fish tive methods,of fish harvest available that allow all non-target to be released unharmed. fish to be returned to the water unharmed.This determination must be made not later than December 31, 1993,and must be t'' reconsidered not later than December 31 of each odd-numbered In many years surplus,Salmon return to hatcheries in large year. numbers intermingled with these sensitive stocks:. Selective. The State Fish and Wildlife Commission is directed to methods of harvest must be devised to allow continued supply ' develop and implement of surplus Salmon for consumer consumption. .additional management plans having °t ' protection and diversity of.native species as the principal goals in the management and harvest of all fish stocks in that part of High seas drill:gill nets sweep the ocean clean'of fish,lees mam the mainstem of the Columbia River from the mouth upriver to orals,and birds.and.yet"we allow the same type non-selective Bonneville Dam.Commercial and recreational harvest of fish•in fishery within our own Columbia River. Even if fish escape the that portion of the river is to be by the' selective methods nets,their gills and protective scales are torn away and a high available while causing the least interference with upstream percentage of them will die. utilization and the spawning and rearing of fish runs.' Beginning January 1, 1994,the State Fish and Wildlife Some opponents to'this measure will say thaf,this measure Commission is directed to oppose to the extent of its power the could cut back on sport and commercial,fishing opportunities; harvest of fish by gillnet in that part of the mainstem of the 'but in reality,target fish will be harvested in greater numbers Columbia.River from the mouth upriver to Bonneville Dam' and sportsSshing will be enhanced. _Sportfishers will not lose ; from January 1 to August 31 of each year. their rights to fish in their usual and accustomed places: Sport The State Department of Fish and Wildlife will continue to anglers alone have gladly accepted recent proposals to use determine the numbers of salmon which will exceed escape- selective harvest methods(barbless hooks)and release sensitive j went goals,then may allow for selective salmon harvest at loca- stocks unharmed only keeping hatchery bound surplus fish. +. dons provided to the highest bidder.Money received from the This measure will requiro commercial fishermen to use similar sale shall be paid into the State Wildlife Pund and used to regulations. implement this measure. Individuals who represent this state on interstate or inter- The causes of the Salmon decline are complex but include,fish- national fish resource management groups are directed to per ing,river flow management(dams), agricultural practices, 'form their duties in with this measure and federal forestry practices and pollution. The Northwest Power laws and court orders:This measure would not affect Native Planning Council in their updated fish and wildlife recovery American treaty rights to fish any part of the Columbia River. plan,•are addressing'many of these issues. Harvest manage Any person may bring a lawsuit against the Statement and limitations.on fishing arc difficult for them. This Department of Fish and Wildlife or against the State Fish and measure sets Oregon's policy on harvest and fishing. When the II Wildlife Commission to force the performance of any duty in the plan is finalized and this measure becomes law,they will com s measure.A person who brings such a lawsuit and wins is enti- pliment each other. •tied to reasonable attorney fees. s With four species of Salmon in the Columbia River System i Committee Members: Appointed by: declared threatened or endangered and a fifth species being Representative Larry Sowa Chief Petitioners reviewed,how can we allow gill nets to continue this discrimi- nate slaughter of fish and wildlife? Bob Eaton Secretary of State j Tom Robinson Secretary of State r Harry Wagner Members of the Committee (This Information furnished by Guy Schoenbom,Executive Director, , ,.. Fisheries Improvement Now.) {; • I� (This Committee was appointed to provide an Impartial expianation of the ballot measure pursuant to ORS 251215.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with,ORS 251.255.) i The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- 4 ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state uxu7 'it the ` accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. I ;: 87 _ i I ••! Official 1892 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No STATE OF :' r • OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR We all know that salmon runs are declining,at nn alarming The Northwest Sportfishing Industry Associates are in support , rate.There are many causes of this decline,and it is obvious of Measure Eight which ells for the termination of gill nets as that state and federal management policies are not working. a means of commercially harvesting sahnon in the Columbia , The prime 4,'5 and 6_year old fish have been the target of the River. gulnet harvest.These are the larger,stronger fish,and should be used.as brood stock.We should first obtain the best Block at Today the Columbia River remains the only River in the United. 'the hatcheries to.maintain the run.Then all surplus fish should States that s commercial gill net fishery still occurs,•other than be taken as a terminal no waste.The jj taking those used by Native American tribes.In today's climate of of sturgeon would be stopped as their,numbers are declining. depleted runs ofColumbie River salmon and steelhead we feel The economic value of the spring Columbia salmon run is mil- lions for the people of this state.The most pressing problem we the time has come to join the others and ban the use of gill nets, in have is a duty to preserve some of our natural heritage for the Columbia. future generations. Our children and grandchildren have a right,and we are duty,bound to preserve this resource for their Today gill nets simply represent an inappropriate means of use.The Columbia spring chinook;is the most biteable fishery, 'catching"surplus"stocks of Columbia River salmon,If in fact a• and provides more recreation to the citizens of Oregon than any 'surplus of a particular run of Columbia River salmon exists.,a other segment of the'salmon fishery.The close location of this more selective means of catching just•those`surplus'salmon' . fishery to the major population centers provides easy access for should be used. the fishing public.Recreation is vital to the area,and"provides heavy economic income to moorages, motels, hotels,boat Unfortunately,it is the fact that depleted stocks of fish'swim, buildera,'motor,sales,'restaurants and numerous other bus'- the Columbia the same time as the few remaining'strong. nesses:The'Oregon.Department of Fish and Wildlife obtains a stock,.Tl ubled native stocks of steelhead and'salnon am in large share of its revenue from license and salmon tag sales. the river the same time as the surplus hatchery stocks. Gill The gdlnet'fishery is a wasteful fishery and should be stopped. nets cannot distinguish between the two.Gill nets are capable. There is no quick fix for our salmon problems,but you have SSluty your try to protect declining nma. of etching and killing almost any fish ore run irate swims to ur children to the Columbia including endangered native m•im Winter,steel-, , head,endangered salmon atocks,sturgeon,walleye;etc' VOTE YES ON MEASURE 8 We believe a more selective means,other than gill nets,of tak , ing only that"surplus"of salmon out of the Columbia should be (This Information Is fumished by Oscar Thomsen,President,Oregon rule.Flrrthermore,that more selective means'should only Division,Mask Walton League ofAmerks.) be permitted after it has been proven that a surplus offish does in fact exist.It is unbelievably poor management`that exists ciurently that allows a commercial harvest to take place before escapement goals are in fact reached. We believe times must change.Things that were done and ways of doing them that may have been appropriate fifty years ago simply are wrong today.Let's wise up.,VOTE YES ON MEA- SURE EIGHT. (This Information fumished by Ron HOW,Associate,Northwest Spoffthing IndustiyAssodatlon.) i. t X ' MUS space Pumhaased for$300 in accordance With ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with OR3 251.255.) { The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse. sent by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the sent by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant.the Y accuracy or truth of any statement made"' the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument , I Official 1992 Generaf Voters'Pamphlet } CONTINUED Measure No■ 8 STATE OF . OREGON ARGUMENT IN:'FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR The Association of Northwest Steelheaders McLoughlin For the past twenty years,O Chapter Supports Ballot Measure 8. regon's loggers and forest landown- an have been subject to ever increasing regulatory actions with The7worthwest Steelheaders are a conservation organization the objective of providing for.protection of freshwater habitat dedicated to the preservation and enhancement of Salmon, .for the fisheries of this state on forest lands.These regulations, ? Treut,and Steelhead and have taken a statewide position on the A8 applied to private forest lands,impose significant costs in the catch and release of wild steelhead. form of specialized and restrictive logging techniques.The for nets are the most indiscriminate of all of fis est'landowner also loses the value of timber which is required types hing.Just for retention along fish bearing stream,"Loggers and.landown as the High Seas;drift nets are devastating the ocean and era have not o s depleting all types of marine life a mo greed n these regulations,they have assist- are depleting gill nets in the Columbia River. ed in their development and implementation This is fnrecogni• p mg marine life here at home.It only makes good tion of the public values embodied in these fisheries as well as sense to eliminate these curtains of death especially as more the other uses of water.,. and more species of salmon get closer to the endangered es list.Ballot Measure 8 contrary to what others would have, ou believe,does not eliminate sport fishing and in fact will contin- While recognizing that comnieicial fishing is'a'valuable and ue to allow commercial fishing as long as it is done by the most important part of the economy of Oregon,;it seems that the selective means.Non-targeted fish such as Steelhead need to requirements set forth in this measure could play a significant have the opportunity to be released unharmed in an effort to role in helping to assure that non-target fish'are able to return rebuild these dwindling runs;Genetic diversity is crucial to the to the flesh water habitat for which so much has been,done to rebuilding of all fish runs and unless we begin now to rebuild by preserve and restore.Fresh water habitat,pristine or other- eliminating the devastation of gill nets we will lose precious wise,is of little value to anadromous fish if theycannot'return' species forever. to it for that necessary portion of their`life cycle spent there:, z The Columbia River is the only river in the continental U.S.to still allow gill netting.It is time to stop this indiscriminate corn Feral recent studies have shown that lack of escapement of mercial exploitation of one of Oregon's most precious resources, these fish,through the many hazards they encounter as they, migrate upstream plays a very,critical role in their continued. ` ; The"McLoughlin Chapter of the Association of Northwest viability,While gill netting is already regulated,we believe Steelheaders urges you to vote yes on Ballot Measure'8 and there is more that could be hone to assist in the recovery of help restore our fisheries for all future generations to enjoy. these stocks.The regulations envisioned in this measure would be a finther step in dealing with all phases of the critical objet- " tive in retaining and restoring Oregon's fantastic fishery:High (This information furnished by Ginny Van Loo,Association of Northwest quality habitat and adequate numbers offish to use it are the i Steelheaders Md bughiln chapter.) critical components. (This Information furnished by H.Mike Miller,Executive Vice President, f Associated Oregon Loggers,Inc.) . • i (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251:255.) (this space purchased for$300 In aacorrianca with ORS 251.255.) The priming of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorme- ment by the State of Oregon,'nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does`the state warrant the p accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument " Oftidal 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED I M OREGON F ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION Save our Sabmonl In a professional capacity as Director of the Northwest Resource Information Center,President of Chinook Northwest The Oregon'Wildlife Federation,,one of Oregon's oldest comer. Inc.;and as a delegate to the Salmon Summit representing a vatioS organizations,'asks the state's voters to endorse ballot broad coalition"of Idaho conservation and.environmental meaeure'8 and vote''yee to call for an end to gillnettiag and groups,I have spent 25 years"fighting to protect Columbia non-selective salmon harvest River salmon and steelhead.Ballot Measure fib'is a`politically divisive,anti-commercial fishing measure cloaked In fish con. nervation clothing. f as thing. passed,it.will not restore`salmon listed. Don't be confused by commercial'salmon interests who suggest under the Endangered Species Act,It will only compound the that'Measure 8 will eliminate valuable jobs and negatively damage to people and communities already vicimized by.:the impact the salmon sportsfishery.,.itwen't real fish killers, the Army Corps of Engineers and"the Bonneville Power Administration. In fact, it will enhance both while protecting fragile native salmon and steelhead stocks as-well as a diversity of marine animals and game fish. (This Information furnished by Ed Chaney,Director,Northwest Resource Information Center,Eagle,Idaho.) The measure does not eliminate'commercial salmon harvest,it simply appeals-for more selective means. capable determining the difference.between a s ; The 1000 feet or more of fine web net that is run into the river " is not ca ]e of date salmon or.sturgeon,native or hatchery fish or an endangered species. 'Whether bird,mammal or fish--all are susceptible to the com mercial curtain that'spans the.Columbia through the spring " and early summer.,a By allowing the state to better manage these salmon stocks and selectiv harvest the hi prized spring will enable sly highly P Pig the lower Columbia'commercial interests to harvest a higher quality fish and process larger.numbers offish with no negative impact to either sportfishing or commercial processing,inter- eats. This measure is designed to insure the future of indigenous- at-aim of Oregon salmon and steelhead and protect the fragile balance of our state's'natural resources. Protect the future ofboth sportfishing and commercial interests } and vote"yes"on ballot measure 81 fi (m a Information fumished by Stu Sugarman,President,Oregon Wad its Federation.) #7 i� (Thin apace Purchased for$309 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This apace purchased for$300 accordance with ORS 251.255j, The.printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse.: ' mart by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the mart by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant,ihe. accuracy ortrudl+of any statement made in the F . argument.' accuracy or truth of any statement made in the .argument, : Official 1992 Gen eral Voters'-Pamphlet r ,Y CONTINUED Measure Nog STATE OF �# OREGON 5, ARGUMENT:IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT N OPPOSITION-,` ' Ballot Measure No:8 does not deserve our support: 4 Y pport I have been a recreational"salmon fisherman and charter .' boat Operator over the Past twenty years•:During the last four 'MeasureNo.8 is not needed to preserve the Cohunbia River yew, I have served as an appointed member of the pacific fish populations.Current fishing regulations already do that. Fishery Management Council.I have also served as President . of the Oregon Coast Charterboat Assn.,and the Columbia River •. Measure No.8 will.probably close both.Oregon commercial Sportfishing Assn.I oppose Measure#8. b fishing on the Columbia and Oregon sportfishing on the The drafters of this measure have shown duck of under- , Columbia mainstem for spring Chinook and steelhead as well standing of fisheries management and harvest dynamics.This € " as the popular Buoy 10 season. is clearly demonstrated by their assumption that recreational hook and line fishermen can distinguish between critical natur- al salmon stocks and"hatchery stocks at the moment of catch • Washington residents,will be able to catch the River's fish, They cannot.Further,the measure is written in a way that will thus increasing their economy at the'expense of Oregon have a profound negative effect on all Oregon,sportfishermen, ' workers and residents. likely eliminating the mainstem Columbia;River salmon fish- eves,as well as Buoy 10.Proponents say they will have the leg- The economies of Astoria,Warrenton,Knappa,Swensen and islature"adjust" the measure if it passes (Monroe,The more of Clatsop County depend on commercial and sports fish- Oregonian,8/23/92).While an adjustment is pending,'Oregon eries:Many hard working people in our communities—charter sport anglers will travel to Washington to fish the Columbia. boat operators, fishing guides,commercial fishermen,fish This translates to a serious loss to Oregon charter boat opera- 'processors,-motel and restaurant workers and others—are at tors,sorely needed revenue for,the Oregon Department of Fish . risk of losing their livelihoods ff Measure No.8 is approved . and Wildlife,and the Oregon economy. Current measures used to'protect critical salmon stocka''du, The goal of protecting salmon from endangered status is mg harvest are extremely,stringent,,Present harvest by all' important:Responsible efforts throughout the Northwest are ocean and Columbia River fisheries account for less than 10�of underway to solve this problem.Passing Measure No:8 will not total f salmon e mortality.The Columbia River gfllnet fishery`is help that process,and one of the most closely regulated of all fisheries harvesting making sahnon.recovery a political issue Columbia River salmon.Any references that high seas'drift through the initiative process is wrong, nets are the same as Columbia River gillnets is either a blatant y misrepresentation or further"indication that proponents of this Vote"N(r on Measure No.8 and allow the experts to develop measure lack knowledge about these two unrelated fisheries an effective plan that will recover fish md save Oregon jobs. Measure#8,'if passed by uninformed voters,will eliminate;a I tightly,controlled gillnet fishery, disrupt or eliminate recre- ational fisheries, and do little or nothing to protect critical t ms Information furnished by Willis Van Du'sen Mayor,City of Astoria; salmon runs'The economic losses will be devastating to those Clatsop County Board of Commissioners;City of Astoria City Council, who depend on the intelligent use of our salmon resource I urge r CRY of Warrenton City Council,•Port ofAstoda Board of Commissioners; your NO VOTE on Ballot Measure#8., r Greater Astoria Area Chamber of Commerce.) } Frank warrens Portland,Oregon i (This Information fumished by Frank Warrens.) - ,�1. ' i (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) ` (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse= ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.- ' 97 �•'�; ,i Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet STATE OF = Meas' u re NO.- 8 OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION We'are organizations committed to the restoration of VOTE NO BALLOT.MEASURE#8-1T IS BAD PUBLIC Northwest wild salmon.In our view,Measure 8 raises too many POLICY M questions to be considered a good,workable fish conservation This poorly written measure will abolish sport and wmmer measuue:`° cial fishing on the Oregon side of the lower Columbia River by, establishing impossible and unnecessary standards for fishing Because.fish uld stop the measure oes not release all methods. 'non-target could eliminate lower AND it will be done at taxpayer expense—an estimated S2.1- s Columbia River commercial fisheries,spring chmook and sum million the first two years,and$500,000 each year thereafter. mer steelhead sport fisheries,,and the popular Buoy 10.These AND it will cost Oregon jobs and shift the economic benefits; fisheries are'already selective in their methods and catch,and of catching Columbia River fish to Washington residents and we do not consider them to be a:major cause of the decline of workers. Columbia and Snake'River salmon,Most significant,because AND it will mean that Oregon consumers and restaurants, Measure 8 would only apply in Oregon,we expect that the fish- will buy Oregon-raised Columbia River salmon,from: eries'dosed in Oregon would simply shift to the Washington Washington,Alaska or even British Columbia where they will ` side of the river. be taken in commercial fisheries. AND the provisions of Measure#8 call for excess fish to be We are also concerned that Measure 8 will encourage divisive sold to the highest bidder.We anticipate this will increase the lawsuits between various fishing groups—with the"haves° retail price if the excess fish are taken from the Willamette near fighting the"have-nots ,and the State footing the bill.This Willamette Falls near Oregon City.Fish sold to highest.bidder would certainly be counter-productive.In order to restore our in the upper Willamette would be diminished in quality.80%of region's once abundant salmon runs,conservation groups,corn- Oregonians do not catch their own salmon,relying instead on' mercial and sport fishers, and concerned citizens all need to the commercial market to supply their fish, and the message work together in a common effort to prevent further destruction would be that low grade quality salmon created by passage of Of salmon habitat and to improve;passage on rivers blocked by Measure#8 is all right for the Oregon consumer. hydroelectric projects. Measure#8 adds nothing to existing fisheries conservation' laws or policies.It makes a mockery of scientific fisheries man We urge all Oregonians to join'us in our broad-based wall- agement policies and will do nothing to recover or restore tion of Northwest salmon advocates to help restore the region's depressed salmon runs in the Columbia River Basin,and will salmon runs.There are many;better ways to.help this effort disadvantage the salmon consumer. than Measure 8:. VOTE NO ON MEASURE#8. b. j (This Information furnished by Steve Flak,President Salmon for All,Inc.; (Tlys In formation furnished by Bob Eaton,Treasurer,Oregon Consumers Oregon Rivers Council;Amedcan.fNvers;Natural Resources Defense for Seafood No on Measure#8 CommiKee.) Council;Long Live The Kings.) :- 1 'I I (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (rhls space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse• The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the,State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.'. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument I 92 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED., Measure No.' g STATE OF OREGON "• Proposed by initiative petition to be voted on at the General Election,November 3,1992. EXPLANATORY STATEMENT This measure would'? BALLOT TITLE end Oregon Constitution by adding a new section relating to homosexuality,pedophilia, �(lrlb 'I'1'>U `Jtd1V31G4VL)t1V sadism and masochism I'I< ANNUT�+�A�CIT1 ,i41<US�I ><,9 AC1:80M+ASFXUAI,>( The amendment would prohibit government promotion, "$E$AUIOR5" r8 encouragement or facilitation of homosexuality,sadism and masochism. Pedophilia, UESxN Sha)1 eonatltutigit lie arn�ntted to The amendment would prohibit the.state from recognizing te+ptue that all governments discourage hanuosexu ality,tither listed�`beehavlors,"seed not facilaca# or aloprovision, such as "sexual orientation; "sexual ` r Ogiuze t emp preference," similar phrase,that includes homosexualit sadism $' S ? AlZAmends 0 pedophilia, m or masochism: The amendment•prohibit regt>n Cotiaiatution All v the application of quotas, minority status,'affirmative action »' �rniYit$ n Oxegal? tfta)t ilbt usa tZefr monies Or and similar concepts to homosexuals prdpeifies promotes,encourage or facilitate h°mv masochism homosexuality,pedophilia,sadism and tY,pedoPn;sadism;or naaspchisna,All Iev The amendment would 8 df lI1iY8riizri£ztt.3zludut pabli4 education s prohibit the use of state,regional ass>gt sY� and local governments and their properties and moneys for the : u setting s standard for Oregon s .� promotion, encouragement ot facilitation of homosexual whxoh r000 n�tzas that these"liehavloxs hre �, . abtormal,wrong,unnatural and perverse"anrT that pedophiles,sadism and masochism they are i:o be discbiiraged seed avoided Statn may The.amendment would require state,regional and local v- �riotrdrpgl xEth- :egjdq.gnaer'�seXilaldxletitatloi�" a m'ntps and'their subdivisions, including specifically the rn e or"sexual preference"labels,or through"quotas State De artment of Higher Education and the public schools, ' miz€4rity s atus�a iriiiative BtCii4#,tir sixtnla e41i# assist m setting a standard for Oregon youth that repo to se gaizes " homosexuality, pedophilia, sadism and.masochism as abnor- ES tMATI;:OF...... IA).IMPACT Iv.... i ,wrong,unnatural and perverse.In addition;the standard Fitt&xtcial itil}�BGt,The I)epirtinent bf laduoatioii would recognize that homosexuality,'pedophilia, sadism and expects tli mttk0 some curriculum Clt masochism are to be discouraged and avoided. sages valued at The effect of this measure:is to establish the right of citizens $2O,OtlO 7!ederalpds if t}ns measure passes to challenge nge governmental promotion,encouragement.or facili- tation it Enacted by the Petiole b h Gfef s tation of homosexuality,pedophilia, sadism'and masochism. y��• Examples include but are not limited to:. PARAGRAPH I. The Constitution of the State of Oregon is The establishment of homosexuali ' L amended by creating a new section to.be added to and made a io for purposes sadism• ; I part of Article I and to read: and masochism as a minority classification for purposes of gov- ernment affirmative action programs,quotas,or benefits;or for r SECTION 41(1) This state shall not recognize any categori purposes of anti-discrimination statutes or ordinances. - cal provision such as"sexual orientation,""sexual preference," • The expenditure of publicfunds either directly or through and similar phrases that includes homosexuality,pedophiles, the free use of government go property'for purposes of sensitivity sadism or masochism. Quotas, minority status, affirmative' training relating to homosexuality, pedophilia, sadism and t +; action,or any similar concepts,shall not apply to these forms of masochism, r oonduct,nor shall government promote these behaviors. • The expenditure of public funds either directly or through' (2) State,regional and local,governments and their.properties .the free use of government property for promotions,rallies,or and monies shall not be used to promote,encourage,of;facili- 'parades supporting homosexuality,pedophilia, sadism and ' ,'• tote homosexuality,'pedophilia,sadism or masochism. ' masochism by public or private entities or individuals (3)State,regional and local governments and thew depart- . The employment in government,including public schools,of ments, agencies and other entities,including specifically the an individual whose primary job duties lace the Y State Department of Higher Education and the public schools, P person ands- , shall assist in setting a standard for.Ore Oregon's sand regular contact with children or youth,if that individ- shall homosexuality,in g° youth that recog- ual publicly promotes,encourages or facilitates homosexuality, pedophilia, sadism and masochism as pedophilia,sadism and masochism- abnormal, wrong,unnatural,•and perverse and that these behaviors are to be discouraged and avoided. (4) It shall be considered that it is the intent of the people in Committee Me�bem- Appointed by: , enacting this section that if any part thereof is held unconstitu- by- Scott Live , Chief Petitioners tional,the remaining parts shall be held in force. Al Mobley Chief Petitioners - Charlie Hinkle Secretary of State Ellen Lowe Secretary of State i Representative Kelly Clark Members of the Committee ?!I (This Committee was appointed to provide an Impartial explanation of the ballot measure pursuant to OILS 251.215.) , V : 93 I Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED STATE OF Measure-No.1 OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR V.O.I.C.E.Against Hate (given in Rome),October 1,1986 by Pope John Paul II&' Joseph Cardinal Ratizinger Hate and apathy go hand-in-hand.The U.S.Supreme Court,in The issue"of homosexuality and'the moral evaluation of deciding a case regarding obscenity,declared'that each commu- homosexual acts have become a matter'of public debate.;Since nity is ,gvs2 Bible for s, in¢their own com==ity standards, this debate often advances arguments and makes assertions Oregonians can fulfill this obligation by voting on Measure#9. inconsistent with the teachin&g�,of the Catholic Church,�it is a cause for concern to all....speddl concern and pastoral'attention should be directed toward those who have this,condition lest, , Measure#9 on homosexuality CANNOT be ignored by people of they be led to believe that the living out of this orientation is conscience.By ignoring the issue,we refuse to understand that homosexual activity is a morally acceptable option.lT IS'NOT- democracy,runs'the risk of allowing our traditional rights and •••ministers'must ensure that homosexuals will not be misled liberties to degenerate into harmful,self-indulgent perversions by this point of view so profoundly opposed to the teaching,of of freedom regardless of the cost to our society. the Church... There are.many who seek to create confusion regarding the Real love compels legislation against behaviors that,from the Church's position....ministers will reject theological OPINIONS perspective of wisdom, are individually and socially harmful. WHICH DISSENT FROM c=RCH TEACHING and..cannot Love-in-action is not universal permissiveness.It is because of '.be used as guidelines for pastoral,'care..:.numbers of love that the Bible prohibits murder,incest,theft,'human sacri- people...are'bringing enormous pressure u bear'on the Church face,homosexuality,bestiality,lying,and the like.It prohibits to accept the homosexual condition as though itwere not'disor- these practices even though some people have found them wn- dared and to condone homosexual activity-One tactic used is to venient,expedient and adtr ye. protest that any and all criticism of,or reservations about, homosexuals,their activity and lifestyle, are simply diverse ' just discrimination. +, Society has condemned drinking and driving while en wuragmg forms of unjust by law and treatment centers a way out.for victims of.the Christians who are,homosexual are called,as all of us are,to behaviors.Society has condemned drug use/abuso spousal' a chaste life,As they dedicate their lives to understanding the abuse,violence against children,etc.while.setting up programs nature of God's personal call to them,they will be able to' for the victims of the behaviors to escape such a,destructive, receive the Lord's grace so.freely offered in order to convert lifestyle:Society is NOW BEING CALLED upon to stop acxom their lives more fully to His.way.The Lord Jesus promised, modating victims of homosexuality while saying,"it's ok,it's ,"You shall know the truth and the truth shall set you&ee.' alright,go ahead and play on the freeway,we'll make no effort (Jn.8:32).Scripture bids us speak the truth in love'(Eph 4:16). to help you". The God who is at once truth and love calls the Church to min- ister to(all)....with pastoral solicitude'of our compassionate A test of human experience rs,found in the parent-child.rela- Lord:It is in this`spirit that we have addressed this tionahi .There is no nor, there be,any presumption that letter...with the hope that it wi)l be of some help as they,care P for those whose suffering can only BE INTENSIFIED BY parents who truly love their children may not or should not ERROR AND LIGHTENED BY TRUTH. establish and enforce behavior guidelines for them.Most authorities on family life insist that the absence of protective guidelines indicates absence of love because it does not secure the best interests of the child.A YES vote on#9 will secure the (This Information furnished by Marta DeMers,Treasurer,Cathold best interests of all of our children,our communities and our OregoNans for Truth.) State,It will even help those who have chosen the practice of homosexuality. This vote on community standards WILL BE TAKENI Will YOU be one of the'decision-makers?Vote YES on#9: (This information furnished by Robert R.Mlles,V.0.I.C.E.) • 9 (This space pur teased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251255.) (This space purchased for$300In accordance with ORS 251.255.) «_ The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state uw7unt the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 94 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED STATE OF MeasUre No. 9 OREGON ARGUMENT IN.FAVOR ARGUMENTIN,FAVOR > . According to the book of Leviticus is the Bible o a ing, crossbreeding cattle, shaving a beard, te"a m OF r R Awn,•INTENT T clothing made of mixed fibs wearing .It is the adultery just as immoral as homosexuality.Bone's parents and P ►ary intent of the Chief petitioners of the initiative ty.If the OCA s to distinguish between private behavior and public policy,and No Special Rights"Committee wants to take one of the 8,000. prevent the establishment of special rights,taxpayer fiend. Yemwld laws of ritual holiness from Leviticus and put it into 'or authorized access to public schools for individuals who the Bill of Rights in the state constitution,they should be sin. Promote, encourage or facilitate homosexuality,sadism, care enough to put all the rest of Leviticus into the constitution maeochiam;°r Pedophiha: as well It's a simple matter of respect for these biatoi c laws to The initiative is not intended to interfere with the aoast(tut on-' r treat them consistently. al rights of anyone,including but not limited to opponents of we at the Special Righteousness Committee are just the,.measure... offended by oyster-eating,shaving and mixed fibers as the OCA the initiative would not amend;reduce or interfeie'witli any. is offended-by homosexuality,and we have just.as much right .one's rights under the U.S.Constitution and federal law as ihe.00A dose to change the state constitution to The initiative would not amend or repeal a>y exiatiiig provision ernment discrimination a gov. of the Ore �• against people whose behavior we don't Oregon Constitution.Subject to state and federal crime- nal and civil law,the measure does not prohibit persons from MY friends;do you want the public schools teaching your chil- 00 to participate in the conduct identified in'the initia dren that shaven >$a 1 Live... �b g' legitimate and equal alter ad a style to � hire and healthy beard?Would you want to be forced to with respect to government employment:As long assn individ- ; oyster-eater to direct your church choir?Adam and Eve. ual is performing his.job, and is not using his position to;pro- wore fig leaves--100 percent fig leaves—and this is divine Moto,encourage,or facilitate:the behaviors listed in the initia= proof that those disgustingly unnatural cottw41polyeater blends five,his private practice of such behaviors will not be-consid- are sinful.And when the.00A was analyzing the threat to trs- eyed a matter of.public policy and will be considered anon job i ditional family values, we don't know how they managed to factor.However,if a person is using his job to promote;enooun overlook adultery!Why,there's a lot more adultery than homo- age or facilitate one or more of the behaviors listed in the initia- sexualitygoing on out there;and extrapolations fiom OCA sta- five,inquiry by s superior is required,and subsequent disdplin- tistics show that 90 pereent'of the people who have engaged in ing action,reassignment,or dismissal is appropriate;Remedial sexual perversions are heterosexual("straight'. actions should be proportional to the degree that the individual The state condones adultery by not punishing it with death has made his private sexual behavior a job4olated factor.With'. as required by Leviticus.It promotes oystereating by licensing to government employment:':;.if an individual's position seafood restaurants;and it allows people to.take mixed fibers Puts him in direct contact'with children or youths, and;rt out of the closet and to flaunt them right out in ' becomes known that(he)is promoting,encouraging g public without gn►g or,facilitat• ,, ' • being fired or evictedl.The state is encouraging sink ing any of the behaviors listed....,then inquiry,by a superior;is required.If the charge is substantiated,subsequent_r a-as If the-OCA'can have the special right to make their personal went to a'ob of moral agenda into public policy,then anyone else also should be equal status and pay not directly affecting chit able to amend the state Bill of Rights to eliminate basic human dren 'The primary factor in jobs relating to children rights for people who they don't like. . is the Protection of the innocence:pf'the children,and not the comfort of the individual•practicing,promoting...behaviors list- Let's put ALL of Leviticus into the constitutionl Ayes"vote The above statement is su is the first step in facilitating our militant moral agenda' bmitted by the Chief } Petitioners as the true intent of the NSM:.initiative.All , AGREE WITH US OR BURN IN HELLI other representation of the motivation or purpose of the a '! petitioners should be examined in relation to this docu- 4 pe I^,# Special Righteousness Committee meat. P.O.Box 1851 I Portland,Oregon 97207 (Thls lnformaton fumished by Lon Mabon,NSR Chsihnsn,No Special Rights Committee PAC.) (This Information funlished by M.Dennis Moore,Chair,Special Righteousness Committee.) fr _ i5. (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.)o,,- v The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- meet by the State of Oregon,:nor does the state warrant the mennt by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. . . ; { 95 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No. 9 STATE OF OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT KFAVOR' Homosexuality is an abnormal and unhealthy behavior that OREGON TAX_4 HOMOSEXUAL AGENDA should be discouraged,not encouraged by our government. Studies b.V leading researchers show.that the following prac- How are Oregon tax dollars now supporting the homosexual ; tices are regularly engaged in by many homosexuals: fellatio agenda in our state?Here are a few examples; 10096,fisting 41%(inserting fist and,forearm into rectum),rim- .; The"Diversity*section of Portland's"Future Focus"futuris- ming 92%(licking rectum),water sports•29%(urinating on tic plan includes homosexual agenda goals. partners, drinking urine),mud wallowing 17%(defecating on , P sado-masochism 37%(beating,piercing,another per- ' The Multnomah County Social Services Division mandated son for sexual pleasure),public sex 66%(public resta o the bath- all-day sensitivity training for staff in June 1992 on the subject houses;parks),,pedophilia 46%(sex with minors).(Nebraska of"Heterosexiam/Homophobia." Medical Journal,,1985 and Lancet,June 9,1984). Oregon State Health Division an&Oregon Department of , Sodomy and other routine homosexual practices tear and rup- Education have included homosexual propaganda in'the 1992 ture the.tissue of the lower bowel and-allow for easy transmis- 1?dam"of"AIDS:The Preventable Epidemic"school curricu Sion"of viral,and bacterial infections'.'IVs no wonder that lum for grades K-12,sent to every Oregon school in May,1992. Portland's.'homosexual'newspaper JUST OUT(July, 1992), Homosexual bias pervades the curriculum but articulated {- .reports that homosexuals account'for 92%of all AIDS cases in specifically on pp.284-5,386.Pages 377-8 list 20 resources for Oregon to date:Similar figures were reported in The Oregonian teachers,ten of which are homosexual organizations. (March 18, 1991).A 1982 Center for Disease Control study •` Lesbian propaganda dominates Women's Studies courses at showed that homosexual men'infected with the AIDS virus had Portland State University., averaged 1160 partners. • 'Homosexual student group's operate on State University i Rimming brings the participant into oral contact with fecal campuses throughout Oregon. ' material.Thus,the rate for infectious hepatitis B is 20-50 times ,Oregon State employees and school employees planned and greater for homosexual males than for heterosexual males attended the"Gay,Lesbian&Bisexual'Youth,Conference"on (American Spectator,'1984).Homosexuals account for over half 'taxfnnded time,April 23-24, 1992.Present at this conference the U.S.cases of syphillis,gonorrhea of the throat,and intesti were verbal language and reading recommendations offensive nal infections (Plenum Medical Books,'1982 and Atlantic to most citizens. Monthly,1/1988),, • In April,'1989, South Eugene High School held"Gay, Homosexuals are at least 8-12 times more likely to,molest.chil- ,'Awareness Week." , dren than heterosexuals(Psychological Reports volumes 57, . Cascade AIDS project, known for its "man to man 1986;58,1986;64,1989). playshops"for learning so-called safe sex,used Lakeridge High i Despite the glaring truth'about the homosexual lifestyle;some School facility in April 1992 to teach students,and give them' Oregon public schools are teaching children that homosexuality' flavored condoms. is a good and normal choice.No one gave public officials this . The Portland public school district has developed an out- authority.They'took it upon themselves under pressure from reach program for lesbian and gay youth,including,classroom. homosexual special *interest' COUPS (Project 10 Educators Conference Aprfl;1992). "I''Fr curriculum and counseling, • Valuable time is used during legislative sessions to debate The only way to reclaim our authority as parents and citizens is homosexual rights bills such as HB 2325 in 1987 and SB 708 in to put our will and,beliefs into law. Protect your children. 1991. !• Protectyour community. The Oregon heir�"men's groups for men 'e University of Or "who are beginning to explore motional and sexual inter. VOTE YES ON 9 est in other men." r '' Vote"YES ON MEASURE 9"to keep your tax money from sup- porting the special-interest agenda of homosexuals in Oregon. (This information furnished by Phillip Ramsdell,,Political Director,Oregon Citizens Alffance PAC.) (This Information furnished by Beth Auges,Communications Director, Concerned Women for America.) *E (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 iR accordance with ORS 251.255.)' The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The nti ri this O P ng o f argument does not constitute an endorse= meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth'of any statement made in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.' 96 r: a Official 1992 General Votets'Pam hlet r CONTINUED O aS u re STATE OF , IN . .9 OREGON • ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ARGUMENT IN FAVOR Dear Eagle Forum Members; ' AN FE+iMtr Y A-'�SO TArMmm t c rm a former teacher and mother of school-aged childrenH4MOSEXattended the Lesbian,Gay,Bisexual Youth Conference for ov160 teachers and counselors this Apri123&24 in Beaverton. l rights laws ate unnecessary Theyate protected turned out to be not al and verbal abuse by the same laws that protect htng mote than a training session on how .The le implement"Project 10"in grades K through 12,utilizing ! sYstem'should not suggest that the Proven strategy designed to avoid g Pin of one person is somehow more'intense than the pain of ? insult to any Parental control.To add another.As for discriminatioti m employment,' injury,this conference was paid for with taxpayer indicates that the income of the"avemgd msexual household; money! J is$55,480,as compared to$32,144 for the general population that's more than$23,000 higher. "Project'10"is a California school-based program started in 1984 by a lesbian teacher.Its goals are:schools adopting homo- 2.There is no nerx„asive emd -„o - rs e,sner k. sexual"affirmative"curriculum—hiring homosexual teachers. aenetrc or nhvsrolo¢iCal m mn *� 4 � and counselors—placing"gay-positive"books and magazines in by the press,recent studies do ill-informed.reports school libraries for&U ages--.tea s nd prove.,the case fora:genetic. is Ching p@cifics about homosex- predisposition.to homosexuality Even,the authors of these uality in,all its forms and that children are born sexually neu- studies have rejected such a thesis:A�lthorities fiercely disagree tral,needing to discover their real sexual orientation by experi- on the causes homosexuality, r mentation, Students ' d 3,« ,,and there is no prospect that, a Ju ged.bY teachers to be sexually con- the question will be resolved in the foreseeable future.,7'hus,, fused"would be sent to homosexual counselors without civil rights legislation should not be passed on the'false parental consent All at taxpayer's expense! tion`that homosexuality is undeniably an inherited trait like According to Project 10's founder these program race or sex. P grams need no"om stuff approval*to get started.Attendees were told"to get your, 3.Almost ha f the=We in the Tint a Ste going before you ask permission...give`gay-positive' aous_grouua that condemn homos +.+lit• and ' books,MW Daddy's:Roommate and Heather Has Two Mommies isolation of the+r const,t++t±onal riQhto(T, m of rsRginn.±:as„ t to Your school library..:cause once they're in place,you can cry dom of assoiation) insist that such censorship if anyone wants them removed" maple h; homosaxuaia admit them to their social organizations. and tal�,e tit+••m intyr ' their homes as room ra. a' Voting yea on Measure 9 will stop the government from spend- in +' r g our tax dollars on this kind of promotion of homosexuality 4.The nassaae of aws iney'fab y'lea�a f btzarr;s'et►d in Oregon so every parent will not have'to maintain a constant extreme m preretations by the m+,re x is In Wisconsin two women vigil against the insidious strategy of Project 10's pro ponents. who chose not to room with a lesbian were hauled before the ;I; To have any hope of saving our public schools,we must pre- Human Rights Commission,fined,ordered to write letters of t ? serve parental support and stop this obnoxious social engineer. apology,forced to attend"sensitivity training" mg. " tY g"conducted by a ; gay rights group,and compelled to submit.to official monitorirtg ` of their living arrangements. ChristineNickelson i 9; ' i .• (This Information furnished by Aden Wildmon,Amedcan Family r (rhls Information furnished by ChrlsUne Nickelson,Eagle Forum.) Association Foundation.) it"1 (This space purchased for$300in accordance wdh ORS 251.255.) (This space pwn)ased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.265.)•, J 1 f g of this argument does not constitute an endorse•' tiu *2 :The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The ruitrn ment the State o O fOr by f r egon,nor does the state warrant the inert by the State.of Oregon,nor,does the State,warrant accurney or truth of any statement made in the argument., accuracy or truth of any statement made in the ;• n. Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OF x, a `, 4 M easure No. 9 OREGON ARGUMENT IN FAVOR ` ARGUMENT IN FAVOR Gay Rights activists have attempted to pass special rights laws AS A HOMOSEXUAL...I Wpg�No Special Rights granted through the Oregon legislature for years,'but the voters have upon behavior. I feel this is an unusual,but needful,endorse, consistently thwarted their efforts.,Now,the tactic seems to be meat of Ballot Measure 9. to force special •gay rights laws and policies through govern- moat entities such as city councils,;commissions and education- An objective review of this measure assures me that its passage al facilities-thereby avoiding a vote of the people.Measure 9 would in no way criminalize homosexuality is Oregon. will insure that special rights based on private behavior,includ- Although some gays wish government to promote and affirm was been content to keep sexual their lifestyle, I have always P mY homosexuals will tY � Y ing affirmative action and quotas for declared . not be forced on Oregonians.,Homosexual activists have made preferences private. their behavior central to their self-identification.and they insist ` f' that society give it immunity fi om moral judgment.Further, a resident of San Francisco,I have eye-witnessed aecelerat- . " they seek to propose legislation which forbids other citizens to ed degeneration of this city since"sexual orientation"clauses disapprove of their lifestyle,which has the effect of compelling were implemented. I applaud the Boy Scouts,a private organi- social acceptance.Portland's Future Focus program to promote zation,for standing firm against gay-rights corporate giants "cultural diversity"'includes phrases such as"embracing and such as Levi Strauss,Wells Fargo Bank'and Bank of America. ;.: celebrating,"which could be used to force acceptance of homo- I believe I speak for many in my community who are appalled sexual lifestyles. In addition,'the National Education by the fascist tactics of ACT.UP and Queer Nation. It'is a Association's position paper',"Affording Equal Opportunity to Gay=and Lesbian Students through Teaching and Counseling' shame that they allow themselves to be exploited by the far lib- tells teachers to censor books fiom school libraries that do not oral left. Attacks against police are becoming more frequent give positive treatment to the subject of homosexuality. and violent in nature. With these,facts in mind,there is evidence that homosexual However,my main concern is that energy and money which propaganda can sway some young people into homosexuality �d be used to research a cure for AIDS is being channeled to and,perhaps,Permanent orientation in that direction Because promote a liberal agenda. I agree with early,gay-rights activist, some persons enter adolescence with sexual orientation unre- Wham Dale Jennings,who said,"The heirs of our long and, solved,.the state should defend the rights of children not to be' hard,and literally dangerous pioneering...demand special priv- subject to such influences in school.This is not homophobia,but ileges on no discernible basis...It is literally true that all homo- rather the assertion of parents'rights,over those of civil rights sexual organizations that thrive on private'-and public grants act speak only for the extreme few who have the compulsion to flaunt their sexual preference."(Los Angeles,7Ymes,October 11, Homosexuals,as humans, have the same rights as all. 1991) However,homosexual orientation is an objective disorder and the acting out its lifestyle threatens the rights of the family. PLEASE VOTE YES ON BALLOT MEASURE 9. ,I (TMs information furnished by Caro/A:Petrone,Phlillp Ramada#,Oregon (This Information furnished by Aftan Abe.) Ca"Ca forLY0 1 1 i (Th)s space purchased for$300 in accordance wlth'ORS 251.255.), (This space purchased for$300 In accordance wllh ORS 251.255.)' The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the, meet by the State 0'Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth'of any statement made in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement mode in the argument. t ' Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlei r CONTINUED t Measure STATE OF Non 9� OREGON . ARGUMENT IN.OPPOSITION ARGUMENT k. IN OPPOSITION °5 °I'd also purge he queere.I despise them worst of all. Why do the They're.one of the ugliest problems of our society, and the must be removed—I don't]mow if with y Christian Qoalitiou of Oregon,the don't poison society..,.- 8�or what so they Traditional F ty.:. arils•Values Coalition,and the American Heritage Party PACs American Nazi Party leader George Lincoln op��the OCA/No Special Rights initiative? Rockwell 1966(Unnatural Quotations,1988,Rutledge) '. Because we"support what our founding fathers RF,Aidy"said about the separvAion of church and state,:and oppose the ". the initiative attempts by any narrow,right-wing,:fundamentalist splinter and...will only serpve to exacerbate ttheaharassment,fear and organization rge Washino `�'L,Oregonians to follow their creed. violence toward gay and lesbian " EtOn,our country's gist,president said,'�'he People'- United States is in no sense founded upon the Christian reli- gion" (Conway,H01y Terror, 1984)''Even more direct was ecumenical Ministries of Oregon Thomad Jefferson who,at his inauguration in 1801 said;`Let October 8;1991 letter to pastors us,then,fellow citizens,unite with one heart'and one mind Let us restore to social intercourse that harmony and affection without which liberty and even life itself are but dreary things.. And let us reflect that having banished from our.land that reli- The choice really is that simple...encourage hate and discrimi- gious intolerance under which so long bled ands h nation,or support the dignity of ALL Oregonians, f eyed,we have yet gained little if we countenance apolitical .intolerance as des otic Please vote NO on Ballot Measure Nine,for all'of urns,'for p ,,as wicked,''as capable of bitter and bloody,persecutions." _ Yourself, s Vote against discrimination and divisiveness,VOTE NO ON NINE. (Triis lnlom►a60n furnished by Scott Seberf,Treasurer,Oregonians . United Together,OUTPAC.) (This Information furnished by Scott Sebert,Treasurer,CArisBan rCoa1ltlon Of Oregon PAC,Traddlonal Family,Values Coalition PAC,the Amerban Hertt$ge Party PAC.) "t I ` i sl (Thls'space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purdmased for$300 lh accordance with ORS 2511.255.). ; t! The printing of this argument aloes not constitute an endorse. endorse: The p}lnting of this argument does not constitute,an rent by the State of Oregon,"nor does the state warrant the meet by the State of Oregon,nor-does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument t; 99 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet { CONTINUED STATE OF Measure` No.:' 9 OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION � , ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION Human rights are indivisible. The Oregon Psychiatric Association and the American Psychiatric Association,strongly oppose Measure 9 and con- Measure 9 singles out one group,homosexuals,who have tradi. demn discrimination based on ignorance and distortion of scion tionally been hated and feared.'`Measure 9 would make that tific information., irrational fear and hatred into law. It would embed two-level l citizenship into Oregon's constitution. Based on scientific evidence,the American Psychiatric Association has determined that homosexuality,is not a mental illness. Measure 9 intentionally and erroneously,links homo- As much"of Oregon appreciates our increasing diversity,the sexuality with various mental illnesses such as pedophilia. voids of intolerance grow louder in reaction.'A climate which Scientific evidence does not support this stereotype. encourages fear and hatred toward any group is never limited to just that group. All of us am at risk' H We oppose the censorship of scientific and medical information We, members of the Eugene Human Rights Commission, which Measure 9.would require. strongly urge you to VOTE NOON 9. We urge all Oregonians to oppose Measure 9 as a destructive LeRoy Dickens Carol Fernlund law which would foster bigotry and discrimination against the Bobby Green Alicia Hays citizens of our state. Myron Kinberg . Jeff Lewis Gretchen Miller-er Marion Malcolm G Rico PBrez an Oliver (nds Information fumished by Fred Filed,M.D.,President,Oregon - George Russell Rya Phillips Psychiatric Association;American Psychiatdc Assodatbn.) Marshall Sauceda Signed and paid for as individuals. No city funds used. 'This is what you shall do: Love the earth and the sun and the animals..Amd up for the stupid and crazy,devote your income and labors to others,hate'tyrants,argue not''concerning,God, have patience and indulgence toward the people,take off your hat to nothing known or unknown or to any man or number of men,go freely with powerful,unedueated persons and with the young and with the mothers of families,re-examine all you have been told at school or church or in any book,dismiss-hat- ever insults your own soul..... ..". -Walt'Whitman,quoted in Gay and Lesbian Poetry in Our Time:'an anthology(1988) (rots Information fumished by Gretchen Miller,members of the Eugene Human Rights Commission.) M rl I' I. (rhls space purchased for$300 In accordance fth ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) ` t The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- m1, ent by the State of Oregon,nor does the state wanwt the meat by the State of Oregon,-nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of anystatement made in,the argument, accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 100 ., $ Official 1992 General Voters'Pain hlet CONTINUED 4• M STATE OF easur % No, ,9 1 OREGON ry :: , ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION : ARGUMENT UMENT K OPPOSITION - ;. "We don't like your kind around here." .To the People of Oregon: `hiYtey're dAngereus,They want to take over." In Measure 9 we as a State are faced with a monumental.rope sition which,if as `If we don't stop them now,the h+ passed,will directly determine:the troatment hold sac d, everyt�ng we �� �°e at least ten Percent of our population and involve the ` Process The issue is:How ate we going to treat one another?We have a choice.Treat others as we ourselves wish to k `They're not really like us,you know." be treated with decency and respect or se perceive as dlfFetent and,consequently, pmt out a group we not as good,and blame Theseu the woes of society-and our own special problems on them. gly Phrases have re-appeared throughout history Often Equal rights for ALL'our citizens lies been the 4" they have been the prec usors of Official discrimination,reptes. our society since its inception.Equal �ng goal of sion and violence.And they have,at one time or another,been constitute special rights for anyone or rights for�of us does not applied to every group imaginable., { Jews, Blacks,,Native Americans, Catholics, Irish,'Italian; We cannot afford as a'society to exclude a o Armenian G evangelical S from full Participation.Labelm n3'of.our members Gypsies,even ev lical Christians the list p pa g any group as not worthy to be on forever, a part of the greater community invites blame,hostility, rejection.A vote in favor.of Measure 9_is a vote to set m tion 1t you lived in the wrong place`at the wrong time,;t destructive forces that will tear Oregon apart and damage would include you. countless lives with no conceivable gain.We must-not let this happen.We have a unique,though not'entirely welcomed Now,in Oregon;it is the turn of Gays and Lesbians.Thai is opportunity to rise,above prejudice,Petty politics,and mean- what Measure Nine is about:singling out a group as being less spirited thinking to block discrimination before it gets a legal than the rest of us, foothold in Oregon.You and I must mee t this shall sage to our It is not about"s g ,•;r y 8s $OOdJudgment,our aeries of justice,and lability.Our diversity keeping penal ri hts unless you think thin like .is our strength.Let us all continue to contribute to the richness P g yourlob and having a place to live are,°special rights;• of our land through the variety of our talents and backgrounds. Measure Nine is about making olficialgovernment-sent- j b tioned discrimination a part of our state Constitution. '� a psychologist and an active community member,I have seen first hand in my office and on the street how destructive Our nation was founded b rejection,hatred, and discrimination are.I will do whatever I Y People searching for a place where can to eliminate these problems from our society and ask Your . they could live their lives o freedomr Where neither the govern- help to do the same.Think hard about the issues involved and meat,nor,the church, nor an angry mob-could deny them "Life,Liberty and the Pursuit of Ha No implications of a move to legalize discrimination and VOTE what they were. - .illness"based who or NO ON NMI Measure Nine destroys that principle.And if it is Leonard Lindas Jr.,Ph.D:' ' destroyed for Gays and Lesbians it will be so much easi- er to destroy it for the neat group.Perhaps for you. Oregon City,Oregon Perhaps for your children. To pass Measure Nine is wrong.It would bring enduring shame (This Inlon"atlon fumbhed by Leonard Undas Jr.,Ph.D.,Oregon Co, fi upon us as a state and as people. Oregon.) k Vote NO on Measure Nine, SAM ADAM *�A nTr MARK c�M TRACI SPILLMAN , IY (This Infonnatlon furnished by Mark Wiener,Sam Adams,Tract Spillman.) �I! (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.)., (Th/s space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The rmttn o thu a does 't ment by the State o/`Oregon,nor does the state warrant the �gby the State of argument nt does the state..aw runt the ' accuracy or truth of any statement made.in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.. _ 101 ;i Of ial 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONT21NU STATE OF M Prt�S�II�Ei No.' � OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION '; For over$00 years the Religious Society of Friends has strug- MEASURE 9 IS ENTIRELYjCHRISTIAN gle$to understand and testify,to our belief in basic human Jesus Christ's message and ministry speak'compellingly of rights.We affirm again that there is that of God in every per Love-pure,`unconditional Love which is made visible in corn-, . son.We are reminded that"God is love,and those that abide in passion for�,even those we do not understand. love abide in God and God abides in them"Q John 4:16):.We MEASURE 9 WOULD LEGISLATE DISCRIMINATION,CEN- find that the Spirit,of God is present in all loving relationships, SORSIiIP,SUSPICION,SURVEILLANCE,AND,IiII GHENT regardless of the genders of those involved.We abhor all forms WITHOUT FACTS OR TRIAL.These are not the tools of Love of sexual violence or coercion and recognize that these forms of or Compassion.These are the tools of hate. abuse have nothing to do with sexual orientation. TO LIFT THE CROSS ONLY TO STRIKE OTHERS IS A Therefore,North Pacific Yearly Meeting of the Religious WOEFUL MISUSE OF CHILIS'I°S MESSAGE.To preach intol- Society of Friends endorses efforts to protect the civil rights of erance in the name of virtue is selfish and cruel,and a ruthless all persons regardless of their sexual orientation.Our love and use of political power to destroy those who are perceived as dif- support is for all persons and is not based upon the gender of ferent.People of faith must act honorably toward all others and the person they love.== cast out fear. We oppose all legislation or policy which disparages lesbians, MEASURE 9 IS BLATANTLY PREYING UPON THE FEARS gay men,bisexuals or transsexuals or abridges their constitu- OF OUR SOCIETY.This measure attem to te'e' u tional or civil rights. Pte, 'egos group of people with crimes for which there are current laws Societ}�s fears and lack of knowledge often put'discussion of the gqy com- munity in a highly emotional arena,rarely objective (this information furnished by Henry Van Dyke,Clark North Pac flc dialogue or understanding.This leads to more irrational fears. Yearly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends and Multnomah, Measure 9 utilizes our society's unsettledness in attempt to Eugene,Corvallis,Rogue Valley Mono*Meetings of the Rellglous '� make this group of people scapegoats.This,is yet another tool of Society of Friends.) , r• ]rate;and should be rejected WE MUST REJECT PERSECUTION OF OTHERS BECAUSE CHRIST'S MESSAGE IS SELFLESS LOVE OF ALL OTHERS; IT DOES NOT MATTER WHO THE TARGET OF RATE IS. We must embrace the guidance found in the fullness of the Gospels.Throughout the Gospels'we find that Christ Himself broke through society's prejudices to accept and lift up people who were rejected and discriminated-against by others. CHRIST HIMSELF SAID:"Be compassionate as your Father is compassionate.Do"not judge,and you will not be judged your- selves;do not condemn, and you will not be condemned your- selves;grant pardon;and you will be pardoned.Give,and there Will be gifts for you: a full measure,..because the amount you measure out is the amount you will be given back.* Luke 6:36-38 VOTE M ON MEASURE 9 " (This Information furnished by Rend Sandd,Representative,A Gathering 1 of Faithful.) S able space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) P The printing of thi&argument does not constitute an endorse. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- went by the State of Oregon,'nor does the state warrant the, meet by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument., accuracy truth of anystatement made in the argument. 102 . Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED Meal U re N 9 STATE OF OREGON . ,ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION. ' ARGUMENT IN:OPP OSITION AVERAGE Cl!k=NS'OF OREGON:"NO ON 91" A LL'1"1'ER TO Average Citizens of O FELLOW OREGO1vIANS regon(ACO)supports the OCA s belief We am a group of concerned citizens`froni the community of , in'conformity-our own campaign �, p gn song t "You've.Gotta Be Estacada who urge you to join,us in voting NO ON AWASURE - • Me'—but,we so strongly disagree with this measure's 9. We believe it is unconstitutional and approach-that we urge voters to vote NO. immoral:• The OCA claims tc promote`normality,"but their definition This is not gay issue;it is a human rights issue of"normal"is biasek based on their particular fundamentalist In our country it is illegal to discriminate against others on religious beliefs.'Certainly,,it's the job of state government to the basis of their race,national origin,religion,gender,political define normality and force everyone into it.(Our own slogan is affiliation,marital status,age,or physical disability.-The laws "You're.One of Us:It's the Law.")But we believe Oregonians that ensure freedom from discrimination apply to An want and deserve an objective definition,a statistical profile .Americans;they are not"special"rights., However,Measure a, of the truly average citizen to live up(or down)to.This official discrmunation by passing judgement on gay people Norm would regulate every aspect of life,since there's more to and diminishing their worth as human beings. life than sex.(The OCA seems not to be aware of this fact.) The Oregon Citizens Alliance says Measure 9 would not lead Or course,to become average some people will have to give net*, of gay People and their support6 rs,.but unfortu- up money,or a child or spouse.Untypically healthy folks will �',this has already started in Our,coaununity, ,OCA sup- have to be injured in some way.,The OCA will have to stop their porters here are challenging the integrity of school.;employees clearly abnormal attempts to,investigate and'control other who oppose Measure 9. :w adults'private,consensual,non criminal behavior.And every- Additionally,Measure 9 would g schools to teach only,a one will have to eat,dress;.and worshi exactly alike,But is fundamentalist interpretation of sexuali P et1Y ty. This selective the sacrifice of our values,beliefs,habits,tastes, and manipulation of public school curriculum is no different than personalities too much to ask in trade for the comforts of book-burning;,it undermines the ability of teachers.to develop conformity?Face it,this whole"democracy'thing,this"let's quality,balanced curriculum that honors and reflects the rich respect and learn from each other"idea,has gone too far.Let's diversity in our lives.' just say no to individuality! The OCA's suggestion that Measure 9"pro tects"children is u=, Perhaps you don't take us seriously.l hat's okay.-The OCA's an insult to voters'intelligence and a shameful attempt to On- Persevered even thdugh many people can't believe they're for erate irrational fears., Without question, we passionately real.Remember our state's future depends on whether people believe in the safety and well-being of all children,and iwe. like you(though not as much like you as we'd like)really want believe the best way to do this is to guarantee their.humen to make Oregon more ordinary, rights while working to stop the REAL causes of child abuse. For these reasons and more WO feel Measure.9 is unoonstitu- a Warning.You,yourself,may be dangerously deviants tional and momll offensive.,Most of us have never before been average citizens don't read the Voters Pamphlet.Please Y � consider the example you're Betting for our,youth! Politically active,but we've never been so insulted by it ballot measure. Please join us in voting NO onlVleasure 9 so we can, all get on with our lives in a traly democratic society.. (This INormaMon fumished by Laura Phll Treasurer Ips, rage Citizens of Oregon.) Concerned Citizens of Estacada., - Spokesperson: Mauragrace Healey P.O.Boa 1172 Estacada,OR 97023 fThls Information furnished by Mauragracs Healey,Concerned Cluzens of ' Estacada.) 1 (This space purchased for$300.1n accordance wllh ORS 251.255.) (fhb space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.),,: e The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse• Theprinting of this'argument does not constitute an'endorse- went by the State.of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument accuracy or truth of any statement made in the drgument.,s I 103 s :j , 1� `Offidal 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ' { , . CONTINUED STATE'OF M 9 OREGONr ARGUMENTIN,OPPOSITION ARGUMENTIN OPPOSITION 7 ti SAFEGUARD OREGON LIBRARIES EDUCATORS OPPOSE MEASURE 9 >~ VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9 C On the surface Ballot Measure'9 a PPS to impact only a small Oregonians who value the integrity and intellectual fieedom of segment of Oregon's population.In,reality,its tentacles reach their libraries should vote no on Measure;9. out for all Oregonians—beginning in the classroom. The threat of censorship posed by Measure 9 is real,'and it Under Ballot Measure 9 teachers would be forced to present must be taken seriously by Orego nians. controversial social issues in only one context,thus eliminating critical thinking.Purges of school libraries and teaching materi Here's the evidence:Last May,when a'similar OCA-sponsored als would not be far behind. measure was passed by Springfield voters,an OCA spokesman said school and public libraries,would be checked for objection- In a world that is becoming smaller and more compl�,"expo- able material. sure to diverse cultures,societies,lifestyles and individuals is { "If we find that a book about:homosexual lifestyle..is in a open�for It cloossean economic survival.Ballot Measure 8 doesn't library;we mill do everything we can to get it out of there,"the „br Germany,they first'a=for the Communists, spokesman said,according to a May 26, 1992,report in the Eugene Register-Guard. and I didn't speak up because:I wasn't a Communist Who knows what books or authors the OCA may have in mind Then they came for the Jews, for removal from library shelves?. and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew., , . The Oregon Library As wants voters to know about ,Then they came for the trade unionists, i some of the likely candidates for an OCA purge.The following is and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist a partial list of some acknowledged or recognized'gay end lea- , .: ' bias writers. Then they came for the Catholics, ` Edward"Albee,Horatio Alger,Hans Christian Andersen,James and I didn't speak up because I was Protestant. Baldwin,Brendan Behan,William Blake,Thomas Carlyle, Then they came for me, Willa Cather,John Cheever,Stephen Crane,Emily Dickinson, and by that time no one was left to speak up.!",:. Ralph Waldo Emerson,E.M:Forstsr,'Lorraine Hansberry,A. E.Houseman,William'Inge,Henry,James,Jack Kerouac, Edward Lear,Vachel Lindsay,Jack London,Amy Lowell, –attributed to Martin Niemoeller ♦ `` Somerset Maugham,Rod McKuen,Herman Melville,Edna St. Vincent Millay,Plato,James Whitcomb Riley,Percy Bysshe ITS TIME $PEAR UP Shelley,Alfred Lord Tennyson,Henry David Thoreau,Jules Verne,Gore Vidal,Evelyn Waugh,Walt Whitman,Oscar Wilde, VOTE NO on 9 Thornton Wilder,Tennessee Williams,Virgins Woolf, Sensible Oregonians may find it difficult to believe that any author on this list could be seriously challenged for removal (This Information fumished by Karen Famous,President Oregon , from a library just because of that writer's sexual orientation or Education Association.) point of view. But•other,less well-known writers are challenged every year in Oregon,for exactly those reasons.-%ere would the line be drawn?Who would be qualified to make such decisions?Would OCA members have to approve library acquisitions?. i - The Oregon Library Association urges thinking Oregonians to • safeguard the intellectual fivedom of their libraries and to vote no on Measure 9. (this Information furnished by Deborah Jacobs,President,Oregon L@�rery Association.) % ii • I � . (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse= ment by�the State of Oregon,nor the state w arrant the' ment b the Stain of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.' accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 104 ift now Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED STATE OF M 9 :�, OREGON- ARGUMENT,IKOPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION Meast>re e'would strip the civil rights oP 1000's of law abiding citizens.There is nothing"special"about civil rights. DON?BE MISLED BY THE OCA! ' Civil rights are rights to fair treatment in housing, employ- VOTE NO ON 9 went,education,health.cai-e,credit(loans),etc.9 prohibits laws ' Protecting the civil rights of certain citizens. Measure 9,promoted by the .Prohibiting civil rights protection is the same se Oregon Gigue Acid mend and their"No Special Rights"Committee,.would-amend removing dvil,rights:History has proven over and over that Oregon's Constitution to people who are not Is group of against one Sally Protected become victims of discrimi- Oregon citizens.'Under the guise of preventing"special nation and oppression.If certain citizens are denied legal rights",the OCA actually wants to take rirrhta that_ve Protection of their rights,they are,for all practical pur- Dvina�citLe*±e.±io�e away from t+.±�m:,.. d_s__ poses,denied rights. gam. , One of every,10 people,(women and men)is homosexual: 280,000 Oregonians._Despite hate-group Propaganda,there is What would happen if measure 9 passes? no evidence that homosexuality is related,to social problems or crime.. r" •Access to public services,Programs,and facilities could be denied' Measure a is un-American:America was founded on prin- � • ciples of liberty and equality.We have fought and died to pro- •Meeting rooms in public buildings or '` a tact our inalienable rights to life,liberty;and the pursuit ofhap= arks could be denied to groups—labor permits to use public Y. piuess.America stands for justice.But Measure 9 says these P ny gro unions,i perceived o principles no longer apply:liberty and' groups,civic organizations-any grou�•that is perceived to all.The Bill of Rights says all justice are no longer for "promote,encourage or facilitate"gays and lesbians Measure 9 says they were not.Our founding fathers t ugh the State and noun fun wisdom of separating church and state.Nine ty ding for AIDS prevention could be ; to enforce one interpretation of Christian doctrine the state eliminated. Measure a is dangerous to •A climate where hats dimes and violenceagamet anyone gero you and to every American,, ' perceived to be gay or lesbian would be tolerated., 1f9 passes,it will set a precedent that could change America.If 9 can declare some citizens unworthy of rights today,another •Employees fired because are percelved'to be gay or -measure could remove the rights of other citizens tomorrow. bias - Any group(racial,,religious,'political,or?)could become the tar get of similar laws. Businesses could lose their business licenses If the,owner If liberty and justice are not for everyone,who will decide is perceived to be gay or lesbian. which citizens are worthy?In Germany,the Nazis decided. i Early in his career,Hitler spread anti-homosexual propaganda, •Professionals such as doctors,lawyers,acmuntents,nurs- similar to some in circulation today.Then,in 1933,years before es—anyone who is required to be licensed by the state— Jews were imprisoned,homosexuals were sent to the first con- could have their licenses revoked or denied if they are per- ; eentration camps.Homosexuals were first,but one-by-one other ce ived to be gay or lesbian x. groups became the targets of Nazi propaganda and attack .Restaurants could.refuse to serve anyone who was per - DO" to be gay or lesbian. DONT LET IT HAPPEN HERE:VOTE NO ON 9. •Public libraries could be`required'to remove any book, magazine,or work of art that makes any positive reference (This Informadon furnished by R.Cogbum and M.Fiery) to gays or lesbians. ' Are these"special rights"? NO1 Is it a"special right"to hold a job? N01 Is it a"special right"to eat in a restaurant? NO! , Is it a"special right"to have access to public buildings and services? NOl r, Say No to the OCA Say"NO"to 9 (This information furnished tiyPeggy Norman,Canpaigh Manager,No on 9 Campal9n.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased,for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.). ., r. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 105 ' Oinclal 1992 General Voters Pamphlet CONTINUED MeasurSAE NF ae N o 9 o Go ARGUMENT IN OP F ;POSITION : ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION , PEOPLE OF FAITH OPPOSE MEASURE a The National Lawyers Guild,Portland Chapter;urges i you to VOTE NO ON MEASURE e. People of Faith Against Bigotry is'an interfaith coalition of Christians,Jews, and other people of faith working against 1) Measure 9 requires state and local governments to Ballot Measure 8.As people of faith,'we feel an urgent need to discriminate against lesbians and gay men.It isolates one denounce Ballot Measure 9 as being against the religious teach- group of people and mandates discrimination against them. ings by which we seek to live.Our religious,spiritual,and This measure radically departs from our basic traditions of fair. faith.traditions teach us to work for justice for all peo• ness and equality.We also must ask:Which of us will the OCA I p� age next Ballot Measure 9 would destroy religious freedom.The 2) Measure 9 is unconedtutionaL It denies to one particu= q OCA wants to mike their particular religious views the law for lar group the flmdamental rights that all Oregonians now have all people in Oregon.They.want control over how tax money is (free speech,flee assembly and equal treatment by the'govern- `A spent, who is allowed to gather in public places, what can be meat),:Measure 9 will force the state to spend enormous viewed on television and in movies,what books can be kept in resources because it will be litigated and ultimatelyinvalidated public libraries,'who can work,"-who can getservices.Religious by the courts. f tolerance and diversity must be respected. . . 8) Measure 9 will drain critically needed money from ` Ballot Measure 9 denies human rights to Oregon citi- schools and government.Each agency will be required to zees.Human rights:should be guaranteed to everyone in a free spend time and money trying to understand and comply with it, l' and democratic society. Ballot Measure 9 would amend the not to mention litigating lawsuits.. =i Oregon'Bill of Rights to require discrimination against ; Oregonians who are gay,lesbian,or perceived as such. 4) Measure 9 requires the government to intrude,Into the private lives of most Oregonians.'Undar Measure 9, No one will be sate.if Ballot Measure 9 becomes law.The state and local governments cannot"promote,encourage, or OCA is counting on people not speaking out to protect`this facilitate homosexuality."Because these terms are so broad, minority,just as people were afraid to speak out to protest the everyone who uses a public building or.park,or obtains'a'per- persecution of minorities under the Nazi regime.The OCA is mik business license,or professional,license,or has'my bud. targeting one group at s time.Their next target could be Jews, new with the government,will L be subject to questioning by'the Catholics,immigrants,'people of color,or women.All of these government about their sexual practices.Government workers people have been the target.of Oregon hate groups. could ask you to prove that your.sexual behavior is not"abnor-- " mal EVERYONE DESERVES HUMAN RIGHTS VOTE NO ON BALLOT MEASURE e. 5) Measure 9 requires every state and local government ' r entity and public schools at all grade levels to teach the People of Faith Against Bigotry OCA's version of mandatory se:education.DMV employ- ees will have to provide sex education to teenagers when they 2249 E.Burnside take a driver's test.Teachers will be required to describe the Portlea d,OR 9721¢, specific"behaviors"the OCA deems"abnormal."Never before k (608)280-9427 Oregon w required such bizarre intrusion into our has an 0 law children's lives. (rh/a Infonnatlon furnished by Dan 3tuteaman,Program Director,People pause the state constitution orders the affairs of all of us,we of Falth Agalnat 8lyotry.) should amend it only for sound reason and with a sound text. Measure 9 is unsound,intrusive,discriminatory,and unconsti- tutional.It will harm every citizen in Oregon, + VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9 k ' (rhls Information fumishad by Elise Gautier,Treasurer,National Lawysre Guild,Portland Chapter.) (Ma apace purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) , The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment,by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the. ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the.state uarrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. _.. ...._.•, , 106. I M11— Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet 7. CONTINUED Measure No STATE OF . � �OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ' ARGUMENT,IN OPPOSITION GOD CALLS US TO LOVE OUR NEIGHBORS NEVER AGAIIN! AS OURSELVES AS JEWS,WE DENOUNCE BALLOT MiE�ASURE As Christians we must oppose the attempt of the Oregon a FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS: . Citizen's Alliance to promote hatred and discrimination against people of homosexual orientation.Jesus told us that we should love our neighbors:He showed us that all humans are our L Ballot Measure 9 would destroy religious freedom., neighbors,our brothers and our sisters.He did not discriminate The OCA wants to make their particular religious view the law against anyone.He did not attack sinners because he knew' for all people m Oregon.They want public schools to teach their that we are all sinners.He condemned those who judged the religious values.The OCA has called for the elimination of the moral worth of others.Those were the hypocrites,whom he separation of church and state:Our history teaches us the dan- denounced. . ger of this path: Who are our neighbors?As in the story of the Good 2. .Ballot Measure 9 would subject our neighbor to Samaritan,our neighbors are the despised and rejected by soci- injustice.Gay men and lesbians are our neighbors, family ety.Today the despised and rejected include people who are members, fellow Jews. Our tradition teaches:.We must:not homosexual.Jesus calls us to love and to accept all people.We stand idly by while our neighbor is subjected to injustice. . . cannot love others and at the same time promote discrimina (Leviticus 19:16) tion. S. Ballot Measure 9 would take away civil rights;truly The Presbyterian Church in Oregon and in the nation warns us making gay-men and lesbians,resident aliens without citizen N against the sin of homophobia,the fear of homosexuals.The rights. eange Our tradition teaches: We must not oppress the church says that all people are equally valuable in the sight of strange for we were strangers in Egypt.(Exodus 22:20;23*9; , God. Deut.11:19) We believe that heterosexuals and homosexuals alike 4. -'This[measure]is one more example of the intolerance that ) is all'too rampant in our society Which does not tolerate norms are beloved children of God.We,as Christians,cannot deny and views,that are different from the position of the self 3 to any child of God the basic rights of employment,housing,and appointed guardians of morals in our society."(Rabbi Joshua i participation as an equal member of our society.We,'as Stampfer,Congregation Neveh Shalom Chronicle,11/20/91) Christians,.cannot set ourselves up as better than the rest of humanity. "As for myself,I have seen too much in my life to stand by and watch."(Elie Wiesel,Los Angeles Times,9/19/80)., Ash stn ,we call on other Christians to remember the love 5! We say"NEVER AGAINI".Remember,Hitler started nto VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9 with small steps,denying civil rights to those the Nazis deemed i unacceptable in an Aryan world:Jews,homosexuals, Gypsies, and defeat its attempt to divide us from each other. people with disabilities...'NEVER AGAIN"must mean never again.We will not"allow persecution or systematic denial of Church and Society.Committee, . human rights.VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9. Peacemaking Unit, u Racial-Ethnic Unit,and Jewish Committee of People of Faith Against Bigotry Justice for Women Unit 2249 E.Burnside of the Presbytery of the Cascades. Portland,OR 97214 (503)230-9427 (rhls information furnished by DeEtte Wald Beghtol,Church and Society Committee,Peacemaking Unit,Racial-Ethnic Unit,and Justice for (This information furnished by Shulamit Levine,Board Member,Jewish Women Unit of the Presbytery of the Cascades.) Committee of People of Fafth Against Bigotry.) E ' k G !T his space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255. (This space ace purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255. i' P 1 P p ) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- f ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument., accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. ' 107 / 'i Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet ` CONTINUED' m6a' sure No. 9 0REG OF'OREGON , ; + .. A►RGUMENT'IN OPPOSITION ` ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION' TO ALL OREGON MPUBUCANS VOTE NO ON 9 J am/a'Republican for traditional reasons.I am a fiscal con- The people of Oregon should vote NO on Measure 9 because it servative and a believer in a market based economy.I believe in is completely contrary to the values of h'berty and freedom this limited government.I volunteered for and served in Vietnam in country was founded upon.This measure clearly asks us`to ` large part because of my opposition to totalitarianism in any decide whether rights,anyone's rights,are inalienable or not,` form.Because of these beliefs,I am opposed to Measure 9.The and would require us to legislate discrimination against gay state should not intrude into the intimate,private relationships and lesbian people. ` of its citizens.Measure 9 is simply another attempt by one group.of citizens to impose its values on the private lives of oth- Voting NO doesn't mean you agree with,or for that matter even ers.Such state•action is completely unacceptable. . understand homosexuality.It simply affirms that you believe in ti justice and in the freedom that.built this nation. I also oppose Measure 9•for personal reasons.I have gay and lesbian co-workers.They are productive and hard working citi- The individuals who proposed this measure want you to believe zens.I have gay and lesbian friends.I know them to be good this is about"special rights".Yet,when you read the actual text and decent people.I cannot in good conscience allow MY friends of the initiative it is obvious that much more is at stake here. and colleagues to be insulted by'a state label of"abnormal"..:. This measure will repeal segments of Oregon law that deal with crimes of violence,it will also restrict political dialogue,force I urge all Oregon Republicans who share my views not just to segregation,and deny citizens equal access to government.' quietly vote against Measure 9,but to list their voices in opposi= tion.It would be tragic for the;silence of good people to allow Finally,this measure will-mandate that the department of this measure to pass. Higher Education teach about such subjects as pedophilia, sadism and masochism in our state classrooms,subjects that do '7 not belong in our Junior.Highs and High Schools.And who is (This Informaton fumished by Kenneth Upton.) going to pay for these classes?You and I are!A conservative estimate for the cost of curriculum changes to the Department of Higher Education for Measure 9 is a minimum of$210,000 just at the state level.This comes at a`time when Oregon's ' schools are already struggling for survival due to state budget cuts.Is it worth the quality of your child's education to pay for classes about pedophil*sadism and masochism?Is that how t: 9 you want your tax dollars spent?Of course notl', 1 As you prepare to vote on Measure 9 remember one thing IF YOU VOTE"NO"NOTHING CHANGES111 Oregon remains a place where freedom is valued, and human dignity is affirmed. r VOTE NO ON 9 ` (This Information fumished byAlan Brown,Chair,NQ ON 9-Lane County P.A.C.) (TNs space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The panting of this argument does not constitute an endorse. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment,by.the State,of Oregon,nor does the state'warrant the went by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant'the t ' accuracy or truth of any statement made in the • argument.:' accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.' 108 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet t CONTINUED Mea, ure` NO 9 - STATE O ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT.IN OPPOSITION. Because we believe that the purpose of Measure 9 is ethical- We are lesbians helping each other sustain'faith in ourselves lY,morally,economically, and socially wrong,and because we while voters are deciding whether we deserve respect believe that its intent is inconsistent with the Christian gospel, heir and as citizens.Nearly everyone, 1�as human we,as individual members of the staff and con Y eryone,not only lesbians and congregation at First gay Yuen,is fiustrated`and fearful about the future:Like you, United Methodist Church,Portland's first church,intend to we worry about physical and emotional security for ourselves d. N vote`No"and urge other Oregonians to join us in defeating this and our children:safe streets,safe homes;work that gives us divisive measure, dignity.We need clean air and water,healthy food,decent ical care; and the certainty that there is a place for us,our fiends,and families,in our communities.We need to be free of T, (This Information furnished by Rev.H.Laron Hall and!ndlvlduals fro m f�' First United Methodist Church:Grant and Elaine Jones,Rev.Paul and Measure 9 doesn't answer any of these needs.Instead;it cre- Rev.Deanna Sel/-Price,Dlckand Olive Pomeroy,Mark and Ruth Ann ates a scapegoat,lesbians and gay men,to;bear.the brunt of bodson,Joyce Buckley,Howard and Cheryl Luce,Judy Kuhlman,Wllpam society's fear,anger,and frustratron.If it passes,here is:what Haden,Carol Kimball,Drs.Leff and Marforfe Terdal,Troy Nash,Chuck will ha and Kathy Dimond,Jay and Carol Kent,13111 and Sonia Connor,Gene plan as lesbians: ,: a Ediger,Rosemary Dodds,Paul Nickell,Janet Harbold,Rev.Terry Voss, '`children,;including our own,,would be tsughti the" f Max Mehlhalf,Robert and Virginia Anderson,Lindsey and Tony McGpl, schools that we are`abnormal, wrong,unnatural, and per- Scott and Janice Grafton,Jonas and Nancy Nordwall,Blair Stlgglns,Tom verse." custody of our children and of verbal and l Balmer and Mary Louise McClintock,Bill and Thelma MacDonald, • we would live in'greater fear of losing our homes;our jobs, Norman and OIINa White,Rev.Eat and fptty Riddle,Maroey Balcomb, Iola Haulgan.) Y physical assault. •'.we would be turned into outcasts,"beyond the.pate"of decent society,though we,like you,pay our taxes,risk our lives in war,fight child abuse and other injustices,and contribute daily to our communities at our jobs;at home,in the schools,in I our neighborhoods. If Measure 9 succeeds,it will be the first amendment written 1' into any American constitution, state or federal,,that takes away rights that already exist.If the amendment.passes-and turns us into targets for society's frustration,.wiU the problems we face—unemployment and minimum-wage jobs,:expensive and inadequate health care, homelessness and violence,,and. soaring rates of child abuse—disappear?When they don't disap- it ar,ewill other groups become the next scapegoats?Where will To get through these di$icult:times,we need to pull together' a our diverse resources—not to scapegoat and divide.We need to work together so that all of us can have decent lives.Qu of us g deserve this. (This lnfonnatlon tumished by Janora Y.Stombock,ELAN(Eugene Lesbians Against Nine).) . _ . (This"space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 25 f.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.), The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument,does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meht,by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the' accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.` v 109 _ k p { Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE Of �O. OREGON Me'asure f ARGUMENTLN OPPOSITION' ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION PSYCHOLOGICAL ABsOCIATION OPPOSES MEASURE 9 "On that point hold firm, as with a chain of steel The Board of Directors of the Oregon Psychological Those who deny freedom to others, Association has unanimously voted to oppose the Oregon deserve it not for themselves; Citizen's Alliance sponsored Ballot Measure 9 that would call and under a just god, s ' q homosexuality abnormal,unnatural and perverse:conduct,and cannot long retain it" urges you to vote NO ON NINE. J E' Abraham Lincoln,Lincoln Speeches&•Writings 1859- Policy established by the American Psychological Association 1865, 1989.From a letter to Henry. I fifteen'years ago declares,"homosexuality Der se implies no L.Pierce and others,April 6,`1869;' impairment in judgment,stability,reliability,or general social 7 and from the'"Lost" Speech at or vocational capabilities."As behavioral scientists,responsible Bloomington,May 29,1866. professionals,and concerned citizens,the'Board of the Oregon Psychological Association believes that the public has a right to know that homosexuality has not beengonsidered to be a men- tal disorder for the last 18 years.It is not currently listed as a (This Information furnished by Dave Beckett&Mlke Dana A Cindy Banks, mental.illness in the,Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Lynn F.Anderson,Angela Stein:Susan S.Thompson,Marlin Darrel,. Mental Disorders,'the universally.adopted psychiatric manual Katrina Greene,Don Maley,Julie Darrah,and Pam Holley.) that defines mental disorders. The OPA Board believes that the Ethical Princi In es of ' PsvcholoQL requires psychologists to"respect the dignity and worth of the individual"and to speak,out against the.misuse and distortion:of psychological findings or language. Measure 9 distorts,s scientific facts:To use language like "abnormal,unnatural and perverse"to apply to homosexuality is a serious misrepresentation of decades of scientific research on homosexuality. { The OPA respect and defends each system.right to have his or her own moral and religious value However, we believe that to impose by law these particular moral or religious positions on others in order to discriminate harmfully against them is antithetical to respect for human.dignity and worth. �! As an organization whose founding principles require us as professionals and citizens,`°ro fiLrther the development of nsv- ' chology as a science:as an eBALied practice.and as a means of promoting human welfare"we urge you to reject the misdirec- tion and misinterpretation of scientific and human data in Measure 9 and vote NO: (This Information furnished by Elliot Weiner,Ph.D.,ExecLlive Director, Oregon Psychologkal Association,Inc.) (rhls space purchased for$300In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 110 Offidal 1992 General Voters'Pam let CONTINUED w Measure N9 0 EG NF ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENTIN OPPOSITION',r • ,��� � t Measure 9's authors are leaders of the Oregon Citizens Alliance,a nationally recognized hate Don't put Discrimination into attempt- ing to fool group.They are attempt- = Oregonians by padding their anti-gay Platform with the Oregon State Constitution) a. inflammatory language.Lumping homosexualittyy together with -Vote NO on 91 pedophilia has no bulb in fact or logic,but the language ie designed to produce an emotional reaction at the ballot box Measure 9 will amend the•Oregon State Constitution require^ Ballot measure 9,if ratified into the Oregon Constitution,, state and local to governments to discriminate against gay and ' would be a dangerous precedent for not only Oregon,but for the lesbian Oregonians, entire nation.Never before in America's history has a specific group of people been targeted for ode-citizenatiol If passed, This would include dental'of professional licensee, as well as A resulting inability,of Oregon governmental bodies to even access to public facilities their tax dollars helped build.:,It recognize the existence of variance in sexual orientations would o requires censorship of libraries,public broadcasting and educa- pen the door for,unchecked discrimination and hostility tional institutions. It will curtail AIDS prevention efffirts and against Oregon gays and lesbians, eliminate state or local for ma Measure 9's authors have taken an invalid and incorrect provide direct care services to people organizations that approach in labs People living ling homosexuality a behavior.Homosexuality ,, �g with AIDS z: , occurs naturally;it is extant in at least 1096 of humans,and it It requires the state to teach our that honioeexusli apps throughout the animal kingdom,,as well.Recent bio- t1'is 1 medical research indicates that one's sexual orientation is bio- abnormal and perverse:.The effect will be devastating accord- logically predetermined,not a behavioral choice.So convincing �to the Dept.of Health and Human Services,leabian'and gay I$,the scientific evidence indicating homosexuality is a normal, youth suffer 4 to 6 times higher teenage suicide rates than het- ` natural occurrenoe,that the American Psychiatric Association SOS D' Being repetitively told that they are abnormal and dramatically reversed its position on it in the early TO's.The perverse will drive even more young people to a tragic end.; Association has since adopted a strong stand in opposition to ' discrimination „ against homosexuals. It would overturn state hate crimes laws. Physical violence The ramifications of this amendment would be devastating against homosexuals(and those perceived to be homosexual) for all Oregonians.This ballot measure requires censorship, has dramatically increased just'since this initiative was requires the denial of rights, and requires conetitutionalized brought before the public. This trend will accelerate;,and very. discriminstion.Measure 9 authors are attempting to dupe and likely spread to other minorities and to anyone perceived as coerce Oregonians into suidecting a minority to second class cit• different. P ,• '. `.-The Bill of Rights states that we all have certain 9nalienable Measure 9 would overturn the civil rights ordlnanoes banning rights, and among these are the right to life,liberty, and the discrimination in employment,housing and public accommods pursuit of happiness".It does not stipulate that these rights 'tions in many cities,including Portland. Everyone will be , should be denied to any segment of the American population, Potential victims of discrimination: The majority of homosexu- ' The passage of measure 9 would set d repugnant and evil prece- als do not appear any different than you or your coworker— ?, dent which le•contrary to Americas ideals of justice.and lreo- most of us have been invisible for years. Oregon will become a r. corn. place where accusation and innuendo are used to destroy lives,- In this state, in this nation,there is onty one choice that' much like the McCarthy era. reflects our nation's values:NO to 9. �., This measure will require the State of Oregon to spend undeten j mined amounts of your tax dollars spreading hate and fear to (MIS formation furnished by Carla(K.C.)Hanson,Noon Hats Your children and into every'corner'of government: Wouldn't PortlandMetro.) this money be better spent on police,fire and other'essential services which are in danger of being cut already? Don't let the OCA ruin your quality of life with their political agenda. Vote NO on discrimination! Vote NO on 91 (This Information furnished by Alan Bath,SteerInp Committee Msn�sr'` No On Hate PDkMetro PAC.) r I (Ma space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) ; The printing of this'argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment bythe State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant.the j accuracy or truth of any statement trade in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. lr. 111 �i I r Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hiet K ; { CONTINUED #. STATE OF , measurPr No.. 9 OREGON 4 ARGUMENT IN`OPPOSITION ` ARGUMENT]N OPPOSITION Don't be Tricked! The vague wording of Measure 9 makes it extremely danger- ous.Words like"facilitate"and"condone"are open to pardously Have you heard the terms"Militant Homosexual Activists", wide interpretation. r "Pedophilia","Special Rights"or"Child Molesters"lately? If.so, .H pfd.right-wing extremists could grab hold of Meastu`e you've probably,seen some of the irrational,'emotional and mis- 9,interpreting it to mean what they want.They could force the leading arguments the Oregon Citizen's Alliance is using to try state government to follow their'narrow agenda,f om unfairly and turn Oregonian against Orego nian. discriminating against gays and lesbians to withholding fund ing from,AIDS organizations. .' The OCA,nationally,identified as a hate group,is trying to de- Oregonians should vote no on Measure 9 because vaguely' I worded tripe is not worthy of and does not belong in our humanize homosexuals so that it becomes acceptable to attack Constitution. us. We would urge all Oregonians not to scapegoat any group Furthermore,Oregonians should oppose Measure 9 because with hateful,untrue labels. ,We'must judge everyone as a full person,.with the human need.for.acceptance and the same it will literally'put people's lives at stake. capacity.to love. This country was founded with the idea of a There is one new H1V infection every 15 seconds-HIV is the wider.acceptance of all people,based on the equality and five- virus that causes AIDS. dom of all individuals.'„Measure 9 is the first step towards It is estimated that there are approximately 10,000 infected restricting that fivedom. Oregonians As the AIDS epidemic expands among all Oregonians—het-• The OCA would have you believe that"Traditional Family erosexual,women and men,gay men and lesbians, gay and Vahies"excludes homosexuals-,This is absurd;all lesbians.and straight teenagers—Measure 9 would,have a devastating gay men have families.,And,as family members,our basic val- ,impact ues are the same as those in all families: loving one another, Mere are some of the effect's Measure 9 could have because of trusting one another,helping each other in times of need. The its vague wording: OCA's"family'values"seem to say,"love those you agree with. Publicly funded AIDS prevention programs would be elimi and to fours the others to conform or leave".�` nated,Ui'e.saving information that-prevents'the transmission of HIV would be kept from Oregonians. n Their emotional,hate-filled arguments work to erase the'sepa Measure 9 would promote a climate of fear and intolerance ration between Church and State. The founding fathers under towards people with AIDS.While:people'with AIDS.already stood the'danger inherent in this,and considered it to be so face enormous discrimination from a corrupt health care Indus- great as to prohibit it in the very first Article of the Bill of fry and in their day-today lives,Measure 9 would exacerbate Rights. discrimination against people with AIDS. Organizations which serve people with AIDS could lose state ;{ The rest of the country is watching Oregon,wondering if they funding. ' {{{ are next to be attacked. 1rpady a group similar to the OCA 'Anonymous or confidential HIV tosting programs could be- has formed in Washington.. eliminated, The Oregon AIDS Hotline could be prohibited from answer Don't let Oregon be the first state in the country to put discrimi- ing questions about safer sexual practices that prevent HIV nation into the Constitution: transmission. In short,all the positive steps that we have taken as a state Vote NO on 91 towards ending the epidemic would be reversed by Measure 9. Measure 9 would jeopardize the quality of health care for all Alan Batie Oregonians. Bill Chin People who want to stop AIDS should vote no on Measure 9 '' Oregonians who respect the sanctity of human;life and who . Scott Guthridge. , Gerrit Huizenga recognize the basic dignity of all people-gay men and lesbians, nongay people,people with AIDS—should vote no on Measure Mark Morrissey 9. (This Information furnished by Alan Batie,Biff Chin,Scott Guthd ilge, (This Information furnished by Thomas Strong,ACT UP/Columbia,AIDS Gerrit Huizenga and Mark Morrissey.) Coalition to Unleash Power.) P. (This space purchased with a petition containing the signatures of 1,000 voters eligible to vote on the measure In accordance with ORS (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.), 251.255.) The rWin of this argument does not constitute an endorse The p 8 8r� printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- k I ment by the State of Oregon,nor,does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant,the, accuracy or truth`of any statement made in the argument.: accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument 112 official 1992 General Voters,Pamphlet r, CONTINUED OF EGON STATE Measure :No. 9 OR w ` ARGUMENT,IN OPPOSITION . ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION WE CONCERNED FRIENDS MEASURE a IS VIOLENT A principle that brings particular strength to American " For over 300 years the Religious Society of Friends hes strug- Friends Service Committee's (AFSC)75 years of work for jus- gled with the actions required by our conviction that there is rice and peace is seeing each human being as of infinite worth. Nthat of God in every person.Early in our history this conviction This belief has led AFSC to ways of work which support the led to respect for leadership provided by women.Subsequently, uniqueness of communities°and cultures and to respect the rich- " ,F• it required us to.eradicate slavery from among our Society;to 'diversityof the human family act against slavery in our communities; and to support civil What kind of society are we creating if we'allow'any group of ', f +' rights for all people regardless of their color.We are.now persons to be discriminated against in state services, employ- i required to speak out in defense of civil liberties of all people in meat, and housing? It is clear that the:supporters"of Ballot the State of Oregon. Measure 9 are waging n attack u f grog poi the gay and lesbian com- Thereare those in".state,who have proposed an,amend. munity of Oregon. ment to the Oregon Constitution which would abridge,the civil: Discrimination and bigotry are forms of violence which deny rights of homosexuals.It would deny homosexuals equal prgtec- the sanctity, equal worth,'and dignity of the individual: n tioof the law when they face discrimination in employment,or .Protection from discrimination is a basic'human right deserved ' `in housing,or from harassment based on their sexual orienta- by all Oregonians,including its,gay:and lesbian citizens,whose tion.We find this is wrong,that it denies.God's love for each lives are no less sacred and whose rights"are no less inalienable and everyone of us, regardless of sexual orientation.We are than those of any other human beings.Vote NO on Ballot convinced that civil rights flow from our common humanity,as Measure 9. , we are all children of the one God."God is love,and those who r„ ; abide in love abide in God, and God abides in them."(1 John 4:16) M,pROYECTO DE LEY 9 ES VIOLENTO El rnncn no fundamental del.Comit6 de Servicios de los, Therefore:We as individuals of faith'call upon all people in , p p Oregon who care about the civil rights of anyone in this State to egos Americans(CSAA)qua le ha dado mgs fuerza al traba- ; vote NO on Ballot Measure 9. jo por la paz y justicia es la convicci6n sobre el-valor iniimto que , tiene cede ser human.Este fe se refleja en la profunda partncn- { ` paci6n del CSAA en trabajos que'apoyan to que es peculiar de las comunidades,de las culturas yen el respeto a la nca dnversn- (This information furnished by John Allcott,Teri/Allen,Merrill Bamebey, dad de la familia humans. f Lois Barton,Janet Bauer,Greg&Janet Berleman,Tonic Blum,Kathleen " 'ndo.,per Bourque,Bonnie Brune,Annette Caner,Darlene Co/born,Mark Connell, LQue clase de sociedad estamos construyendo cua mitimos qua hays discriminaci6n en los servicios estatales,en el Aimee Conner,Rosemary&Vern Cooperrider,Chris Cradler,Fran Curtis, em leo en la vivienda? Es obvio•que los ue a o an el i Crystalle&Paul Davis,Ardelle Dennis,Doyne Deos,Ken Deveney,Gary Pro ecto de Le 9 estQn lanzando un eta e a q p Y &Susan Einhorn,Andrew Elliott Kyle Engen,Leif Erickson,Dave Fabik,; Y Y qu la comunidad gay, Estelle Field,Kyrstin Faulkner,Bill Fender,Lawrence Ferguson,Jr.,Peter Y lesbiana. Ford Jane Franklin,"Myit/e Fricke,Bob Gans-Morse,Carol Geantonio, La disrriminaci6n y el fanatismo son expresiones de violehcia p Frank Granshaw,Michael Groshong,Dalcus Hankins,Dennis-Harris, que niegan Is santidad,la igualdad y la dignidad de la persona. Rosana Hart,Joseph Havens,Tom Head,Beth Heller,Jocsyln,' La proteoci6n contra la discriminati6n es un derecho`huanano Henderson-Conrad,BillHof/hines,Kate Holleran,Nicholas Horton,Lewis fundamental que se merecen todos los habitantes de Oregon, &Lois Hoskins,Pam Johnson,Bob&Mary Ann Jones,Ma)orie Kellogg,;. ; Virgin King,June Kirk,Olivia Masson,Barry A Lesley Laing,Dick& incluyendo a los ciudadanos gay y'Tesbianas cuyas villas no sons Rose Lewis,Emily Lewis,Sue Little,Dale Loonen,Tina Louis,Vance menos sagradas ni sus derechos menos inalienables que los de MacDowell,Cathy&Merlin McDaniel,Lucy McIver,Joseph Miller,Jr., otro ser human: Madeline Moore,Olga Morrison,Margaret Morton,Barbara&Eugene, Vote 1No!En el Proyecto de Ley 9 Norcross-Renner,Paul Orr,Edythe Pearson,Back Pshan,David Papen, Helen Poucher,Jay&Teys Penniman,Clarence Parisho,John Prideaux, Elizabeth Rademaker,Kris Rebce,Unde'Renfer,Norm&Toni Ranoos, j Julia Riseman,Mari Ruthkowskl,Victoria Salinas,Mary Beth Sarhatt, (This information fumished by Martin Gonzalez,Associate Executive• John SM Smith,June Smith,,Sheila Smith,Ua/a Snow,Joe Softich, Secretary,American Friends Service Committee.), Donald Stand,Jeffrey Standy,Jeraldine Standy,Candace&Chuck 'Steele,pan Tangible,Barbara Thygesen,'Bonnie Tinker,David Travis, Lynn Vincent,Carolyn Wilhelm,Suzanne Willow,Allen Wineland,Nancy Woods,Mary Zimmerman.) � 1 5 is (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) r The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- w ment by the State,of,Oregon,nor does the state warrant the merit by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ; accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument:. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.: qu, .jp 113 �� Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet 4 � 1 CONTINUED Measure No.1 STATE of �. OREGON � `'�`• ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION VOTE NO ON e" NO,NO,NO ON 9. OREGONIANS HAVE ARIGHT TO PRIVACY NO ON 9 MEANS OREGON w WOMEN OPPOSE MEASURE 9` • Oregonians have long cherished their independence and right to privacy from government intrusion into their .Why should the women and men of Oregon'umte in opposition lives.Ballot Measure 9 would reverse this right and require to Measure 9?. the state of Oregon to scrutinize the activities and speech of individuals and associations. • '.Measure 9 would discriminate. •,'City,county and state agencies would have to verify that Women understand all too well the effects of discrimination. groups and individuals using,public facilities are are not pro- Working women, single,11 too well he older women m Social moting,encouraging,or facilitating homosexuality. Se 'cirri t -a11 women unde stand the devastating ffects of unequall.treatment under the•law."'We strongly oppose any VOTE NO ON 9—Preserve freedom of Meech measure that would deprive some of a job or home due to nreiu- •, Free speech would have to be monitored by the state of Oregon to determine if public employees are "promoting or Measure 9 would take rights away from a group of encouraging"homosexuality Oregonians. • Free speech will be censored in our colleges and universities. Government could deny services to individuals or groups Textbooks,novels used in literature classes,videotapes, and thought to"encourage or facilitate"homosexuality. And-our'x` works of art would be censored'or banned if they do not"dis- school system will be'forced to teach propaganda to students courage",homosexuality, from kindergarten to college. If we stand by while one grouRis j;arizeted.who will be next? VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9—Preserve the rieyht to Drivacv • `Measure 9 is written and promoted by the same peo- °I« ple who tried to ban abortions in'Oregon two years ago.' • In 1990, Oregonians voted to"uphold a"woman's right to reproductive privacy.When the Oregon Citizens Alliance(OCA) They oppose women's rights—from the Equal Rights f put an initiative on the ballot to limit a woman's right to choice Amendment to reproductive choice to parental leave. $g ` and ban abortions,OREGONIANS VOTED NO. believe Orezon must move foihyard together.'not retreat tothe ideas of the past. ! Measure 9 is a continuation of the OCA's attempt to intrude into the private lives of Oregonians. This time the OCA has WE STRONGLY URGE ALL OREGONIANS TO JOIN US' gone toe by trying to insert their religious beliefs into IN VOTING NO ON 9: . Oregon's Constitution.We urge you to vote no again. American Association of University Women . Oregon Women's Political Caucus • Oregon Coalition Against Domestic and Sexual Violence (This information furnished by Kim M.8auske,Treasurer Right To • Privacy PAC.) Planned Parenthood ofColumbia/Willamette Oregon Federation of Business and Professional Women (This information lumished by Tia Plympton,State Coordinator,National Organization for Women.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.)- g` ` - .e The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The rinti " P ng o f this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the-state warrant the accuracy or truth:of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. , 114 li h 992 General Voters'Pam*hlet CONTINUED ' Me as u re, STATE-OF OREGON ARGUMENTIN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT51 N OPPOSITION•Y ': NOON#9. VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9, Measnre 9-is a giant step backwards for civil rights.. The sheer'outrageou`sness oi'the O" , re on Cit`` ize Alli g' ns ance s • Measure 9 would! Proposed.anti-homosexuality measure should speech of teachers and 'be enough to set every rational Oregonian's teeth on officials of public government.We must not allow',censor ;age» ship in Oregon,but need to stand by the First Amendment to "the.Constitution., ,+ °. :Grants Pass DailyCourier,May 23 1991 The NO ON 9 Campaign is a statewide,grassroots coalition of thousands of Oregonians. •' Measure 9 would remove equal rights on the basis Of sexual orientation from all laws through-out Ore n w must not be the first state to turn-back civil rights;b�rrent American' Service Committees w local laws prohibit discrimination in housing, to American Jewish'Committee f g,employment and American a public accommodation on the basis of sexual orientation. Massage Therapy A sociation i x Cascade AIDS Project •. Measure 9 uses a big lie tactic.There are no current'nor Columbia-Willamette Green's ' proposed,laws to protect,"pedophilia, sadism or,mesochism." Equity Foundation; AND there already are strict laws against teachers being Gray Panthers g s involved olved se xually with students.' Human Services Coalition of Oregon E Measure 9 tears apart the,school,communit Jewish Federation of Portland ' ' :Teachers need our su y' Lesbian Community Project ; pport;in dealing with,thedifliculties of; today's youth. Students—especially ga'ty and lesbian youth—= Metanoia Peace Conununity United Methodist Church need our support,not the message that they are illegal. National Council of Jewish Women National Lawyers Guild,Portland Chapter • Measure 9 helps to build a climate where hate cximes ! No on Hate Metro Portland PAC, will flourish.The connection of hate crimes to the OCA's mea. Northwest Coalition Against Malicious Harassment sure was clearly,demonstrated when the NO On 9:Campaign, Northwest Gender Alliance offices were vandalized.Other break-ins included the offices of a gay newspaper,and an AIDS treatment center."These bur. Oregon Chapter,National Association of Social Workers ,glaries are more fallout from the climate of fear,hatred and Oregon Education Association + d divisiveness that the OCA campaign against homosexual rights Oregon Federation of Teachers, Education and Health f has produced.And they are further rebuttal of the OCA's hol- Professionals,AFT,AFL-CIO low argument that its initiatives are nothing more than Oregon Fellowship of Reconciliation j ,attempts,to prevent special rights'for homosexuals.They, are OregonNARAL unnecessarily dividing Oregon communities to good r ' Purpose."(The Oregonian,June 24,1992) The Other Side Parents and Friends'of Lesbians and Gays Measure 9 must he defeated.,Oregonians need to work to Phoenix Rising overcome their differences,and not fall prey to this divide and Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/Willamette conquer strategy. Portland NOW' ' Portland Parents and Friends of Lesbians and Gay Men, • Measure 9 is a blatant attempt to control important; 'Inc. civil liberties guaranteed by the Bill of Rights.Differences Right to Privacy PAC and diversity are what have made our nation strong.Measure Urban of Portland k 9 is a giant step backwards for civil rights. (PARTIAL LIST) Join us in voting NO ON 9! PO Box 3343,Portland,OR 97208,. phone 232.4501. (This info rmation furnished by Betsy Hayford,Director,Kent J.Spring Treasurer,Kenton Neighbors for Quality Public Education.) (This Information furnished by Fred Neal,Treasurer,NO ON 9 , Campaign.) ( P9 P n'accordance with ORS 251.255.) . (This space purchased for x300 in accordance with ORS 25!.255.) This space purchased for$3001 The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- men!by the State of.Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the Slate of,Oregon,nor does the state'warrant the 4' accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument 115 !. Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet i CONTINUED STATE OF r n E Measu reft. 9 OREGON I ARGUMENT K01 PPOSITI;ON ARGUMENT.IN OPPOSITION .VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9 ' VOTE NO ON 91 "The issue here is not homosexuality,but whether this bizarre;demeaning,stuff should be inserted in the con- We are Oregonians from a variety of backgrounds committed to stitution...We hope!Oregonians'will refuse to endorse a progressive and flourishing Ore gon. Our diverse traditions thi's poisonous attempt to pervert the, Oregon and experiences inspire us with a common dedication to'dignity' Constitution:' and equality for all.. East Oregonian(Pendleton), May 22,1991 We are committed'to a system of laws and justice which ensures basic civil rights and equal treatment for all. "...We cannot support the alliance's efforts to turn homo- sexuals into second-class citizens+'subject to job'and We oppose discrimination based on sexual orientation, housing discrimination and to;acts of potential hatred raoe,gender,age,income,religion,marital status,icoun and violence." try of origin or being differently abled ; -Salem Statesman.Journal, May 14,'1992 ' Lesbians and gay men are our neighbors and family members and co-workers."Measure 9 would encourage discrimination The NOON 9 Campaign is a statewide,grassroots coalition ofr againstanyone'who is perceived to be different,disrupt families thousands of Oregonians. and neighborhoods and.workplaces,and encourage an atmos Academic Communities Together Opposing Dine(ACT ON Phere of hatred and bigotry. NINE) Anti-Defamation League of B'nai B'rith Your vote against Measure 9 is a vote for real'family values Bradley Angle House ` . love,understanding,acceptance. Your vote against Measure 9 Peace Church of the Brethren is a?vote for democracy—protection of differences is the core of American freedom. Your vote against Measure 9 is a vote for a Educators for Equity- democratic society where everyone is valued,and encouraged to Feminist Broadcast Quarterly of Oregon participate. Frar miscan Friars with PFAB Hemophilia Northwest Don't fall prey to misinformation. Don't allow Oregon to be the Inland Boatmen's Union of the Pacific' first state to mandate discrimination in our constitution. Join with us in OPPOSING.MEASURE 9! ` ,Metropolitan Community Church• ,. , - ' New Jewish Agenda/Portland Northeast Community Development Corporation, Postal Workers Union • NW Farmes Union, Lesbian Community Project, Oregon Alliance for Progressive Policy _ National Lawyers Guild/Portland Chapter Oregon Coalition Against Domestic and Sexual Violence New Jewish Agenda,Portland 0 regon Fair Share: .•- _ NW Farmers Union Oregon Gay and Lesbian Law Association Oregon Federation of Teachers, Education and Health Oregon Human Rights Coalition Professionals,AFT,AFL CIO Oregon PeaceWorks Oregon NARAL Outside-]n Oregon NOW s;, .,:., People of Faith Against Bigot ry(PFAB) Oregon PeaceWorks Physicians for Social Responsibility "" Rainbow Coalition Portland/Multnomah Commission on Aging United Food and Commercial Workers,#555. ,Portland, Oregon Area Local American Postal Workers Union Portland Reproductive Rights Committee (This information furnished by Cheyenne Chapman,Executive Director Rainbow Coalition/Portland, Oregon Alliance for Progressive Policy.) South Asian Lesbian and Gay Association y (PARTIAL LIST) Join us in voting NO ON 91 PO Box 3343,Portland,OR 97208, phone 232-4501. ;r (This information furnished by Fred Neal,Treasurer,NO ON 9 .Campaign.) (This space purchased,for mo in accordance with ORS 251.255.) ` (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251:255.) The printing,of this argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not-constitute an endorse meet by the State of Oregon,:nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any'statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in'the argument.•-'' 116 -x Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED ' Measure NQ 9 STATE OF ■ OREGON { ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION .' ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION DONT BUY THE OCAS 'SPECIAL RIG DON'T UNDERMINE THE OREGON BILL OF RIGHTS!! } RIGHTS'CLAIM MEASURE 9 WOULD RROUTHR DISCRIIVIINATION!! Measure 9 spells D-I-S-C-R-I-M•I-N A-T-I-0-N,plain and sim- VOTE NQ ON MEASURE 9!! ple. On the surface, the phrase "No Special Rights"doesn't Don't be fooled by the doubletalk of Measure 9's supporters, sound too bad.But the Oregon Citizen's Alliance wants to take Section 3 of the measure requires.all basic civil rights away from one particular segment of society. government ize ho — state,regional and local—to take actions that"recognize"home- tion,andawe work to fight ht it every dally aware of discrimiha- sexuality as abnormal,wrong,unnatural and perverse..." g y " That means government agencies would be fQ=d to discrim. "In the U.S,today, it is estimated there are nearly 25,neon inate against homosexuals. lesbians and gay men—about 10 percent of our population. Lesbians and gay men come from every part of society and from MEASURE 9 WOULD UNDERM1E EQUAL every stripe of the Rainbow, and are an integral part of the PROTECTION! quilt that is America.They are Black,Latino,Catholic,Jewish, farmers,unemployed, homeless, disabled, students and par- Oregon's current Bill of Rights-which was written in 1857- eats:As citizens of this great country, lesbians and gay men RMIlibit"discrimination by the government against any group must be afforded all the rights the Constitution provides." of citizens. `Where are those who isolate differences,desecrate our humani- Article I,Section 20,of the Oregon Constitution says: j ty,and then justify their inhumanity,just as the Nazis did with "No law shall be passed granting to any citizen or class of Yellow stars or pink triangles. It was not right in Nazi citizens privileges, or immunities, which,upon the same Germany,and it's not right in America." terms,shall not equally belong to all citizens." –Rev.Jesse Jackson Keen Ho Alive 1989 This provision prevent,the government from granting sp.- j cial rights to gy group or individual: PLEASE VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9 MEASURE, 9 WOULD OVERRIDE'THIS'PROTECTION!! Because the proponents of Measure 9 chose to draft it as an (This information furnished by Jan Hhara,co-chair,Portland Rainbow' amendment to the Oregon Bill of Rights,it would override this Coalition.) equal protection guarantee whenever there was a conflict between the two provisions. ; FREE SPEECH&ASSEMBLY WOULD BE UNDERMINED! Again,because Measure 9 is written as an addition to the Oregon Bill of Rights,our state constitution's protection's of freedom of speech and freedom of assembly would be weakened., For example,Measure 9 would require public libraries to cen- sor any books that mention homosexuality but don't condemn it as"abnormal;wrong,unnatural and perverse.", - While the current Oregon Bill of Rights free speech protec- tion would prevent that type of censorship,Measure 9 would almost certainly override that fundamental right. I ,.1 DON'1<UNLEASH THE THOUGHT POLICE IN OREGON! VOTE NQ ON MEASURE 99 r� ,1 (This Information furnished by Stevie Remington,Executive Director, d American Civil Liberties Union of Oregon.) y' I i 3 (This space purchased for$3004n accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) q The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- Tjie printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- o, meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument.: UN 117 I Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED MeasuNO. 9 STATE OF ' re OREGON, ? Y r ARGUMENT.IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION . MEASURE 9 IS AN ASSAULT ON OUR SCHOOLS, MEASURE No.9 IS FOUNDED IN FEAR,HATRED,AND OUR CHILDREN,AND OUR DEMOCRATIC WAY OF LIFE DECEIT. ' Measure No.9 is disguised as an initiative banning a selec- CENSORSHIP.Measure 9 would dictate what teachers could of"perverse behaviors."In truth,its aim is to legitimate teach and what students could learn thus restricting the discrimination against those born with a homosexual orienta- opportunity,for freedom of thought,expression,and access Don. to information.Schools would be reouired to review all The backers of Measure 9 claim that the initiative is neces- sary because men and women who are homosexual'seek to win censor them if they refer homosexuality. "special rights"for themselves.This is the same argument once or Measure 8 strem at the heart. t the public schools used against African-Americans, women, people with disabili- mission to help students learn how to make their, ties, and other non-dominant groups to deny them their basic own informed decisions. civil rights.'People of homosexual orientation do not seek spe- cial rights;they simply seek the same freedom others have to -DISCRIMINATION. Measure 9 legalizes discrimination work and live where they want;without'fear,and to maintain g their lives in peace. against gay and lesbian teachers and any teacher per- ceived to be homosexual.Lon Mabon,Executive Director of the OCA,has said that teachers suspected of being homo- THE TRUTH ABOUT HOMOSEXUALITY.REFUTES sexual would be subject to an inquiry. (Ch. 2 News, MYTHS AND STEREOTYPES Portland, 718/92).Most Oregonians believe that everyone • Evidence indicates that people are born heterosexual or has the right to work in his or her chosen career or profes- homosexual.Sexual orientation is not choice. sion. • Heterosexuals cannot.influence people to.be heterosexu- al;homosexuals cannot influence people to be homosexu- •SUICIDE. According to The Report of the Secretary's Task m Force on Youth Suicide(U.S.Dept.of Health and Human • Heterosexual and homosexual persons alike condemn Services, 1989),lesbian and gay youth are 2.6 times more crimes against children.Statistics confirm that the vast likely to attempt suicide than other youth.Without posi- majority of child abusers are heterosexual,not homosex tive intervention,these numbers are certain to escalate. ual. Under Measure 9,,students who are coming.to terms with • With people of homosexual'orientation numbering at the difficult issues of sexuality could be denied services least one in ten in the population,they are among your and counselors could be forced to advise students to see friends,neighbors,co-workers,and family members. themselves as"abnormal,immoral,and perverse." THE BIBLE HAS BEEN MISUSED.BY BACKERS.OF 1 Do we want our schools to be a place where children learn MEASURE 9. hatred,bigotry,and intolerance of others?Voting NO ON 9 ja a proponents of Measure 9 claim that homosexuality deserves vote. a democracy where everyone is valued and allowed to participate.Don't let Oregon be the first state in the history of condemnation because they interpret the Bible as condemning I the United.States to take away the ri¢hts of others. it.However,in similar ways,the Bible has been twisted in the past to wring interpretations condemning minorities and women to secondary status.In the Bible,God'commands us to Passage of Measure 9 would create a climate of fear and susoi- love,not hate.We cannot imagine Jesus condemning people on d=among educators,students;and the community at large. the basis of who God created them to be. WE CANNOT ALLOW HATRED AND BIGOTRY TO Measure 9 targets for discrimination those guilty of nothing DETERMINE THE FUTURE OF EDUCATION IN OREGON. more than being born a certain way. ! VOTE NO ON 91 Discrimination is wrong.:' 7 Hatred is wrong. This initiative is wrong. (This Information furnished by Barbara Tillman,Educators for Equity; We must stand up for one another. Portland Association of Teachers.) We must speak out against injustice. That's why we urge a"W vote on Measure 9. (This information furnished by Rev.Gary L.Davis,Mission and Outreach n , Committee,Central Pacific Conference,United Church of Christ.)" (This space purchased for s30o in accordance with DRS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 25f.255.), The printing of this argument,does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument, . i 118 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No, 9 STATE OF OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ` ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION . RURAL OREGONLANS PARENTS AND FRIENDS OPPOSE MEASURE 9 OF LESBIANS AND GAYS, INC.(Parents-FLAG)AGAINST MEASURE e, "Who the heck do these OCA nuts think We�an international federation of parents,family members, , they are?And in what particular century and friends of lesbians and gay people.While we are diverse s, do they think we live,the 14th?" our ethnic, racial, religious,educational,-and economic back--. grounds,we cherish the family unit as a fundamental building Cottage Grove Sentinel' block of society.We support the gay and lesbian person's August 7,1991 full human and civil rights. Submitted by: We are outraged by the Measure 9'initiative to label homosexuality as an abnormal perversion— Central Oregon Battering and Rape Alliance Vote NO on e Bend,Oregon Homosexuality has nothing to'do with sickness nor sin. Children are not influenced nor taught to be gay,or lesbian by • Citizens for Equal Rights Parents nor any other persons. Coos County,Oregon We adamantly defend the rights of our gay and lesbian children • Citizens for Human Dignity-Blue Mount ' to live in a society that accords them the same di tY am Region, leges, and protections accorded all of our citizenstJusti e Pendleton,Oregon demands that all lesbian and gay children grow up in a world • Citizens for Human Dignity that accepts them as equal citizens: x Columbia County,Oregon Measure 9 Promotes discrimination and intolerance. • Central Oregon AIDS Support Team(COAST) We are appalled that Measure 9 would permit religious-based Bend,Oregon dogma to promote discrimination and intolerance against a group of citizens.It is a purposeful insult by the promoters of • Gay'and Lesbian Alliance of Roseburg(GALA) this proposed measure to equate homosexuality with already Roseburg,Oregon unlawful acts such as pedophilia in order to promote religious based intolerance and discrimination against healthy and pro- • Gorge Alliance for Human Dignity ductive citizens, Hood River,Oregon Vote NO on 9, • Josephine County Human Rights Alliance Parents-FLAG is Pro-Family ;; Josephine County,Oregon Each g Y a or lesbian person comes from a family Unit.One out of • Lincoln County Homan Rights Coalition every four families has a gay member.Our gay and lesbian chil- a4 Lincoln County,Oregon dren have parents, grandparents, sisters, brothers;cousins, aunts,uncles,nieces,and nephews whom they love,Rejection of • Mid Willamette No on 9 Campaign a lesbian or gay person by her/his family is a tragedy for each person in the family.Parents-FLAG is pro-family because we Linn-Benton,Oregon seek to keep families in loving and respectful relationships. � • Planned Parenthood of Lane County Please join us in VOTING NO on Measure 9., a Lane County,Oregon The views expressed are our own and our titles and affiliations • Sherman County No on 9 Committee are included for identification only: Sherman County,Oregon Candace Steele Kathleen Cooper,President • Tillamook County Citizens for Human Dignity Pacific NW Regional Director Family FLAG of Tillamook County,Oregon Federation of Parents-FLAG,Inc.' Eugene-Springfield' Kathryn Meyrovich,President Deanie Barker,President Parents-FLAG,South Coast Parent-FLAG,LaGrande r (This Information furnished by Ellen Lowe,Kathleen Saadat,Catarina Cherie Garland,President Jim&Elise Self,Founders-- Soto,Marge Work,Coalition Council Liaisons,No on 9 Campaign.) parents-FLAG,Rogue Vall ey Parents-FLAG,Grants Pass (This information lumishad by Kathryn Warrior,President Portland Parents and Friends of Lesbians and Gay Men,Inc.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In,accordance with ORS 251:255.) The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse ment by the State of Oregon;nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. I 119 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED STATE OF mea's, ure No. 9. OREGON, ARGUMENT KOPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION,. DONT BE FOOLED VOTE NO ON 9 - BY THE OCA The Oregon Citizens Alliance wants you to believe that MEAS&E 9 IS FLAWED,COSTLY TO TAXPAYERS AND Measure 9 is'about"special rights"and affirmative action and BAD PUBLIC POLICY ' quotas and protecting kids from some"evil." DON'T BE FOOLED 'Measure 9 will open a'Pandora's box of legal problems,lawsuits BY THE OCA and constitutional challenges which could only be resolved at 9 is really about government intrusion. Its about great coat.and loss to all Oregonians.We,as lawyers,urge you Measure y g ut to vote No on Measure 9. requiring discrimination and it's about taking away human " rights. Some of the questions which will be'raised and challenged in We are a diverse group of individuals,`businesses,and organize- court if Measure 9 passes are: tions:Vote No on Measure 9.Respect our differences,preserve our freedoms. IS MEASURE 9 UNCONSTITUTIONAL?Does.it conflict with the U.S.Constitution's guarantees of free speech,freedom Please join us in voting No on Measure 9. of association,privacy,y,�N al protection,and due process?, VOTE NO ON e WHAT ACTS,MEMBERSHIPS,OR OTHER CONSIDER- Corvallis Human Rights Coalition ATIONS CONSTITUTE PROMOTING,ENCOURAGING No 9 Mid-Valley OR FACILITATING HOMOSEXUALrM Corvallis NOW. . Circle of Hands WILL GOVERNMENT AGENCIES BE REQUIRED.TO: Ecoweb Graphics School of Earthy Arts Dismiss any employees who'are or are perceived to be Theda Antrican homosexual or who are perceived to be promoting homosexuali= La Tiendita("The Little Store") ty?Where employees are protected by union contracts,'can' Bill Conde', these employees be dismissed or must they be reassigned to other government jobs? Mother Kali's Books People for Human Dignity Union County •'Deny admission to public hospitals and clinics of patients War Resisters League who are or are perceived to be homosexual? Southern Willamette Alliance Newspaper Eugene Peace Works Deny or revoke licenses to physicians, lawyers,teachers, Kathy Ging,Realtor accountants,chiropractors,nurses,hairdressers,realtors,:and World Peace University others who are or are perceived to be homosexual,-or are per Friendly Foods&Deli ceived to be promoting,encouraging,or facilitating homosexual. • 'Red Barn G rove , i O' Emerald Valley Kitchen . Remove from public libraries all or portions of books,mag- Light aJiImport Service azines, cassettes or videotapes authored by homosexuals or, Light Majic Productions which contain positive or neutral references to homosexuality? 'Peace Economics Save Our eooSystems,inc.(SOS) :There are no easy answers to these questions.What in 11 Second Nature Bicycles certain is that they will strain the State's limited William C.Carpenter,Jr.,Attorney 2E.our 9a create divisiveness and eke years to resolve.. Charles 0.1 Porter: VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9. .aa Anatolia Bill Morrisec American Alliance (This Information fumished by Tom Balmer,Erne Bonyhadl,Rich Botterl, Bill Joan ette,Mayor of Springfield John Paul Graff,Mark Johnson,Chlo Lazenby,Doreen Margolln,Phil Rev.Joanne C.Sizoo Margolin,Don Marmaduke,Susan Mandiberg,Katherine McDowell,Ben Msrrill,Lynn Nekamoto,Carl Nell,Paul Non•,Ken Novack,Margaret Olney,Katherine O'Neil,Bonnie Serldn,Cory Stralsinger and Cathy (This information furnished by Sherry Osser,Chair No on 9 Campaign, Travis.) Peggy Norman,Manager,No on 9 Campaign.) �I (This s pace Purchased for�?oo in accordance with i. ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) The rust �r p ing of this argument does not constitute an endorse The printing of this argument does not constitute an m&r.- meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy.or truth'of any statement made in the argument.. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument i r 120, F l Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet STATE CONTINUED Me'asul e No. 9 OREGONF f 'ARGUMENT,IN OPPOSITION' ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION A CHRISTIAN CALL NO ON MEASURE E e VOTE REJECT OPPRESSION,SUPPORT THE CONSTITUTION Faithful Christians may disci No one has any legal right to crush the constitutional rights and its application to social h But on Biblical interpretation of any American citizen to fairness and equal protection under Christians should u Point,at least,all the law.Ballot measure 9 does just that to citizens who ate,as agree-There is no room in the Christian a matter of biology rather than choice,either gay or lesbian. gospel for bigotry and prejudice. Affirmative government oppression,discrimination, and perse- cution would be the end result of measure 9• However, through the years many groups claiming to be Attempts in earlier times to use the'law to deny women,.or Christian have defended their bigotry and prejudice by saying it blacks, or Jews, or Asians, or Hispanics their rights to fair is God's will.Racial prejudice,the subjugation of women,even treatment and equal Protection,based on biological differences, slave have been defended at times on the ground that the equally ills In America, were gal• ca.a person's constitutional right Bile condones or even requires them.; to fair and equal treatment is determined,only by the fact that he or she is a citizen: Today,proponents of Measure 9 are waging a similar war The champions of measure'9 try to deceive the public into against homosexual people,claiming that gays are like child believing that a persons gender orientation should determine molesters and that God supports this view. Measure#9 whether he or she is to be treated fairly under our Constitution requires an amendment to the Oregon constitution which and laws:However, gender orientation,or race,or any other would males reli gious viewpoint the law of the state; orientation,are irrelevant.. and it would require the state to discriminate against gay peo- Moreover,fair_and equal treatment is all that ple. gays and les- biana seek.Fair and equal treatment means not being singled out for special wrongs.Fair and equal treatment does not mean It is wrong to use the Bible or the-Christian faith as'a quotas or special rights. cloak for intolerance and discrimination._The issue of Measure 9 seeks oppressive treatment of citizens on grounds homosexuality is not mentioned in The Ten Commandments or that are both wrong and unconstitutional.We ask Oregonians ; in the teachings of Christ.Instead,Christ calls us to love our to VOTE NO on measure 9. neighbor neighbor-is as ourselves ,even when our differ- ent from'us.For this reason,First Congregational Church of LOG CABIN OREGON,Republicans Portland welcomes and accepts for membership all people who concerned for Individual Rights, believe in Christ,regardless of sexual orientation. ; an Oregon nonprofit Corporation. Eric D.Brown,Chair Lee Coleman,Vice Chairj" During a dark peri od in its history, Germany had laws that stigmatized homosexuals and made them,targets for hatred and intolerance.Measure 9 would be a tragic step in the,same direo- f lion.Measure 9 is contrary to the teachings This Information furnished by trkb.'Brown,Chalr,Lee Coleman,V1ce ' gs of Christ and Chair,Log Cabin Oregon.) r to the principle of separation of church and state. It should be defeated. VOTE NO ON MEASURE a`. Open and Affirming Task Force First Congregational Church of Portland United Church of Christ (This information furnished by Albert Horn,Member,Open and Afflrming Task Face,First Congregational Church of Portland,United Church of Christ.) ^s `1 r M (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255. ' (This space purchased for 5300!n accordance with ORS 251.255.) F 5. The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- meat by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrnnt the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. r 121 �?I Official 1992 General V oters'Pamphlet ' CONTINUED , Measure !NO 9 STATE OF . OREGON ARGUMENT IR OPPOSITION,.' ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION THE DEMOCRATIC,PARTY URGES As Catholic Christians,we ask all Oregonians to heal a deepen VOTE NO ON 9 ing wound in our state.We call upon people of good will to say NO to Measure 9, which"bears false witness" against our homosexual neighbors by spreading half-truths in a spirit of This ballot measure would place language in the Oregon division and intolerance, and demands active government dis- Constitution that would unfairly discriminate against crimination against homosexual citizens Oregonians with an alternative lifestyle by lumping them with persons who participate in criminal sexual behavior. AS CATHOLICS,WE OPPOSE MEASURE 9: The Oregon Democratic Platform Convention adopted the fol- lowing statements in the 1992 Oregon Democratiq Platform, you do to the least of my brothers and sisters,you do,to me."He (March 1,1992) cautioned that only those people who are without sin should be prepared to cast the first stone of condemnation.' "AS DEMOCRATS,WE BELIEVE that our nation can IN THE SPIRIT OF ST FRANCIS OF ASSISI, our founder, only be as strong as our commitment to liberty'j�ce' " -4 el�tY• whose deepest desire was to be an instrument of God's peace." He challenged his followers to be brother to gu people and.to. bring pardon,understanding and hope to the world. The Democratic Party of Oregon is committed to indi- IN THE SPIRIT OF OUR FATHERS AND MOTHERS, who vidual liberty, dignity, and opportunity. Individual experienced discrimination and violence in Oregon at the hands rights,including the right to privacy,must not be limit- of the Ku Klux Klan,a few short decades ago.They'called us ed because of race,national origin,sex,sexual orienta- "foreigners" and"papists."They said that we would corrupt tion,age,religion,disability,medical history,reproduc. children and destroy families.`Catholiachurches were burned tive choice,marital or financial status,or political affili- down and convents of sisters were attacked.We Oregon ation. Catholics will not do to others what was once done to us. IN THE SPIRIT OF THE U.S. CATHOLIC'BISHOPS;who The Democratic Party of Oregon believes that among said:"Homosexuals,like everyone else,should not suffer-from the"inalienable rights"referred to in the Declaration of prejudice against their basic human rights.They have a right to Independence and the rights reserved to the people in respect,friendship and justice.They should have an active role the Ninth Amendment to the United States Constitution, in the Christian community,"(To Due In Christ Jesus,1976) our forefathers intended the right to be left alone,or,in IN THE SPIRIT OF OUR OWN OREGON BISHOPS,who have contemporary language,the right of privacy.Nowhere is opposed this OCA initiative,saying: "The Oregon Catholic this more necessary to human dignity and self-determi- Conference,then,finds itself in a position of opposing the pro. nation than in the right to bodily integrity and the right posed constitutional amendment..."as"overbroad,ambiguous, to associate,with and love whomever one will.Thus,we and potentially harmful and discriminatory to homosexual.citi- believe that all attempts...to discriminate on the basis of zens"(Oregon Catholic Conference Statement,9/3/91) sexual orientation...are unacceptable,illegal, and unAmerican. IN THIS SPIRIT,we call upon Catholics and all people of good will to bring understanding,mutual respect and healing to,our Therefore, we;condemn the Oregon Citizens ate,Do not write hatred and discrimination into the Oregon Alliance...ballot measures regarding homosexuality as Constitution., bigoted attempts to legitimize and protect discrimina- tion and create fear and divisiveness among Oregon's citizens." x (This Information furnished by Br.Douglas Hamill,OFM,MD,Frandscan THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY OF OREGON Friar,Frandscan Friars with People of Faith Against Bigotry.) URGES YOU TO VOTE AGAINST DISCRIMINATION VOTE NOON 91 (This information furnished by Wayne Anderson,Chair,Democratic Party Of Oregon.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$3oo in accordance with ORS 251.255.)• , �I The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse, The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of.Oregon,nor hoes the state warrant the menu by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the' accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the:argument, 122 Official 1992 Gene'ral Voters'Pam hlet + Measure STATE OF N0. 9 OREGON f ' ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION", Your NO vote'on Ballot Measure 9 is a vote FOR YOUR RIGHT to continue to have access to information. ��NO ON DI .. "NATION VOTp No ,9 "Congress shall make no law R" • merit of reli o respecting an establish- 9°7O or abridging� n'or prolvbiting the free exercise thereof; the freedom of speech, or of the the right of the people peaceably to assemble and to Petition the Gov' ' M Dednle to be fired from their�obs erriment for redress of grievances." —The First Amendment • cost taY.;a..e... litate Ve hundreds of thousands of dollars to defend America,the great'melt' go rnments against lawsuits 1°g Pot,was founded and has prospered by accepting.the talents and efforts of diverse people.The as- . sage of Ballot Measure 9 would be dis P • some community groups from using publicly owned estrous for Oregon s quell- meeting ropms,parks,and other facilities ty of life,fi ee expression,and exchange of ideas. WHAT WOULD HAPPEly]F 1SURE 9 PAS refusal of service in coffee shops,banks,stores,etc.to Pe orientation ► E SES?� Persons based on Perceived sexual Classic and bestselling works will be taken from our public library schools and libraries, such as Alice Walker's The Color men,including Walt Whitman Gertrude Ste materials by or about lesbians or gay Purple, Stephen Crane's,The Red B in,Willa Cather, edge of Courage, Leonardo Da Vinci,James Baldwin,and Socrates Hans Christian Anderson's Fairy Tales, as well as works by Rita Mae Brown, Thoreau,May Sarton,Flaubert,E.M. 1. Forster,and Gore Vidal These and other fine works,which S�SIIY state services, including'health care for people with are read by many not only for enjoyment,but also because h AIDS,based on presumed sexual orientation their insights into our common humanity;will be banned in our state ' thrafilm,accreditation of Oregon's medical and mental p health training Pro ems b " ' Oregon will experience isolation and financial losses'as y��g"the teaching of,myths that contradict medical and professional standards and ethics artists, tourists, and events bypass our state, since only Oregon will have discriminatory anti-minori policies. • teot and IeQrali�e a. typo ties. entation based on sexual ori- _ • Information on AIDS and other health issues will not be, found in your library.Teenagers may become terminally ill with AIDS because they are denied preventive information •�ri h disrr;�,,,anent from ever about the disease, pun'si"r'� no matter.how blatant and unjust. Oregon MUST NOT be the first state ever to take away rights Ballot Measure 9 would not lust"allow discrimination', from its citizens and to promote di mandate di it would P fors and ethnic Who will be am- scriminave in Oregon.Measure 9 is`� Bled out next as"abnormal'.'?Religious and a 81 thmC groups? Shat it a,i.,raa pnyernmwn+to f� Oregon's Constitution gives EVERYONE the right to ex w VOTE.NO ON VO R Nn nr`* ideas and opinions.Don't allow others to force the state to take away YOUR access to information and YOUR right to express yourideas! , (This Information furnished by Merry A.Demarest Manager,NO on 9 VOTE NO ON Mid-Valley.) NZASURE 91 It is'a bad piece of special_ interest legislation which would be only the first step in restricting the freedoms of those who do not agree with its sponsors. Oregon Coalition for Free Expression Pacific Northwest Booksellers Association $y (This information furnished by Deborah Garman,Free Speech Committee Co-Chair,Pacific Northwest BookseflersAssoclation;Founding Board Member,Oregon Coalition for Free Expression.) (This space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251:255. y 3 i . (This space purchased for$300 fn accordance with ORS 251,255 The rinti P ng of this argument does not constitute an.eiuforse_ The rind merit by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the P ng of this argument does not eoi atttr aQ. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the a meat by the State of Oregon.,itor;doed}ihe stare, rgument. accuracy or truth of any'statemut made Yn 123 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CONTINUED STATE OF M r9 OREGON " "o i.; ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT iIN OPPOSITION VOTE NO MEASURE a MEASURE a DOES NOT REPRESENT' OREGONVALUES RESPECT DIFFERENCES Having grown up in Oregon and having traveled through this, The Directors, including the Bishops and Executives of state for decades,we think we know Oregonians and their vat- Ecumenical Ministries of Oregon,(EMO)recognize the diversity ues. among their 17 denominations and over 2,000 Oregon congrega- tions as to their teachings about sexual orientation and expres- We Oregonians cherish our independence. We are honest sion.They are unanimous in believing thqt such diversity does and seek the truth. We are tolerant of one another and respect not negate their Christian conviction that every person's our differences. From Burns to Eugene, from Medford to human,dignity ought to be respected.They believe a vote Beaverton,from Bend to Lincoln City,we are fair-minded by against Measure'9 is not a vote of approval or disapproval of compassionate.. We value the contributions made by all homosexual expression;it is a vote for human rights. Oregonians.' BUILD COMMUNITY Measure'9 represents none of those values. It is not repre- sentative of the Oregon we know and care about."We're con- The Mission Statement of EMO states that"we believe that the cerned about the legacy we leave for our grandchildren. mission is to discern and respond to the Divine call for the unity Measure 9 is bad for business. It's bad for our schools and our of all peoples'under God and to build a just and loving human It's bad for Oregon. community in Oregon and in the world."Measure 9 draws a line between us rather than a circle around us.' Join us as we are joining with thousands of fair-minded Ore gonians from all across this state to say: UPHOLD THE BELL OF RIGHTS DISCRIMINATION DOES NOT BELONG The Social Principles of EMO further states that"we uphold for IN OREGON'S CONSTETUTION. all persons and groups the Bill of Rights...We believe everyone should be protected from discrimination.'Measure 9 amends VOTE NO ON MEASURE 9. . 1 the Oregon Bill of Rights to take away rights rather than pro- tect them.It codifies fear and bigotry.EMO asks you to discard i these destructive and hurtful emotions and join the quest for an Norma and Bill Paulus Oregon where all persons might live without fear,expect justice Dave and Lynn Frohnmayer and be able to contribute their talents. Neil Goldschmidt Bob and Pat Straub Ecumenical Ministries of Oregon Clay and Elizabeth Myers and member denominations: Barbara and Frank Roberts •African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church•Christian Church(Disciples of Christ) •Church of the Brethren• This Information furnished by Sherry Oaser,Campaign Chair,No on 9 Episcopal Church•Evangelical Lutheran Church in Campaign.) America•Presbyterian Church USA•Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints•Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Portland•Society of Friends (Quakers) *,United Church of Christ• United Methodist Church (This information furnished by Ellen C.Lowe,Associate Director, Ecumenical Ministries of Oregon.) r (This space purchased for$300 in accordance w/th ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) r The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ' ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the; accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 124 .i Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED Measure No., 9 oREGO F N ARGU MENT IN:OPPOSITION ARGUMENT N`OP POSITION '; � l As an equal opportuaity employer,US West'Communications u does not support measures which have the potential to create Vote NO on Discrimination an environment of discrimination groups.against individuals or Vote NO on 9! I 'i We believe'our co po cY, We are a corporate li which recd gip of People who are linked b human diversity, gauss the value of interest computers,our sexual orientations and ou�stro g % IF ty, makes good sense for business,government desire not to be the subject.of legislated bigotry. and education: , go ry-.We.normally j •r do not get involved in'Politics,but what the Oregon Citizen's {If Unlawful disparate and discriminatory. Alliance trying to do is not normal We are average people ' �P criminatory treatment of an I St ' gin,age,handicap,martial status or force deserve.or individual because of their race,sex, d into a battle we don't want by an attack we don't d on national on J sexual orientation is prohibited. This includes harass. The OCA is attempting to force their beliefs on all Oregonians. ' ment and intimidation,the use of derogatory or Their current t I demeaning remarks,and ethnic or sexist jokes directed Passes, it can be used to'deny and gay men. If Measure 9' at or offensive to another employee or individual• equal legal protection for,ho y fobs, deny housing.a basic deny + ' � mosexuals. Denying basic civil Submitted by: US WEST CO rights and human dignity to anyone is discrimination. You MMC1rTICATIONS—OREGON can prevent this blatant discrimination by voting NO on 9. M.B.Congdon,.Vfce President and „w Chief Executive Officer We be that traditional family values are based on trust 421 S.W.Oak St. honesty,stability and love,not hatred and bigotry. hep P Portland,Oregon 97204 g°riy as a disregard for these values undermines its own position as a Christian organization. There are few, if any, discernible !`' Christian qualities embodied within this measure: We encour- 1 age the OCA to look past eir hatre(Th/sYn/ormation furnished by M.B.Congdon,Vlce Pra iden(and Chle/ People based on wh they are not whatted try and fudge `E Executive Officer,US West Communications—Oregon.) they are We believe that the members' an' nd supporters of the OCA have the right to hate anyone they choose. -However; the Constitution of the State'of Oregon is no place for hatred and ' bigotry. The State of Oregon should not be forced to become a tool of the OCA agenda. Vote NO.' Discrimination criminatfon Vote NO on 91 (Thls information fumished byA.Batle,B.Chin,Joe Farrenkopf,D.S. h Guthridge,Kyle Grieser,Dorsle Hathaway,G.Hulzenga,Douglas Macfver,Nelson Wier,M.Morrissey,Ben)ucker,.Bill Cesti.) 1. • rJ i (This space purchased for$900 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) , (Thls space purchased for$3001n accordance with ORS 251.255.) ` The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The�rinti p ng of this argument does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon, nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument• accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. t 125 ` a. Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED STATE OF Measure No 9 OREGON ; ARGUMENTIN OPPOSITION ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION MEASURE a TAKES AWAY PROTECTIONS WORKERS EMPLOYEES SHOULD BE JUDGED BY HOW WELL HAVE AGAINST DISCRIMINATION AND FIRING. THEY DO THEIR JOBS Unions have long supported the idea of equal and fair,treat- Fair and equal treatment on the job is important to all ment of all employees.:We believe that what is important in Oregonians. We believe people should be judged by their ability employment is an individual's ability to do the job, and do it and skills,and by how hard they work. But the supporters of well:', What law-abiding citizens,do in their private life is nd Measure 9 believe that the mul important thing m judging a their employers'business. person's job performance is their sexual orientation. 1 ANY WORKER CAN BE ACCUSED OF BEING DISCRIMINATION AGAINST EMPLOYEES ON THE HOMOSEXUAL' BASIS OF SEXUAL ORIENTATION IS UNFAIR` Measure 9 will allow a neighbor,employer or co-worker to point Union contracts we have negotiated,covering over 19,000 state a finger at ya.'You could be demoted or fired. Measure 9 pro- and local government employees,currently prohibit discrimina hibits government agencies from using their resources to pro- tion on the basis of sexual orientation. Under these contracts, tect you from such conduct. employees are judged by their abilities,not by their private lives. Measure 9 eliminates these,protections. . EXISTING CONTRACT PROTECTIONS WOULD BE IMPAIRED , MEASURE 9 COULD REQUIRE GOVERNMENT TO DISCIPLINE EMPLOYEES REGARDLESS OF JOB Because many workers have already suffered just such unfair PERFORMANCE discrimination,union contracts covering thousands of public employees currently prohibit discrimination by an employer This measure requires government employers to discourage based solely upon sexual orientation. Measure 9 could rewire homosexuality, and allows discrimination against public that Government discriminate in this,way. employees solely on the basis of sexual orientation. MEASURE 9 PROVIDE$A LOOPHOLE FOR EQUAL TREATMENT SHOULD APPLY TO ALL UNSCRUPULOUS EMPLOYERS Employers should not discriminate against employees on the Workers who call for improved safety in their workplace, who basis of religious beliefs and marital status. Nor should they support a-union or who"blow the whistle"on illegal or unethi. discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation. cal practices by their employer could be silenced with the threat of Measure 9. Identifying an employee as a homosexual, whether or not it is.true,will be a convenient excuse to get rid VOTE NO ON MEASURE e of any worker who"rocks the boat". Submitted by: Oregon Public Employees Union MEASURE a I8 UNFAIRAND.UNAMERICAN;, Alice Dale,Executive Director P.O.Box 12159 Individual's should be judged by their own worth and work, Salem,OR 97309 that's the American way. Measure 9 judges people by their real or suspected sexual orientation. That just isn't fair. Access to jobs and services should be based on ability and performance. (This information furnished by Alice Dale,Executive Director,Oregon Public Employees Union.) DISCRIMINATION HAS NO PLACE IN OREGON. VOTE NO ON MEASURE e Submitted by:No on 9 Labor Coalition JoAnn Bowker 1900 Hines Street S.E. Salem,OR 97302 (This information furnished by JaAnn Bowker,NO on 9 Labor Coalition.) i' (This space purchased for$300 In accordance with ORS 251.255.) (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) I, The printing of this argument does not constitute an endorse- The printing of this argument does not constitute an indorse- ment by the.State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state wanunt'the accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. accuracy or truth of any statement made in the argument. 126 M 0 ffida1.1992 General Voters'Pam hlet r j` measure STATE OF . 9 OREGON ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION LABOR UNIONS AGREE:"NO ON 9" The state's largest labor federation,the Oregon AFL-CIO,and Y largest labor council, the Northwest Oregon Central Labor Council,AFL-0IO,urge you to vote on Measure 9. ; MEASURE 9 EXPANDS GOVERNMENT POWER OVER PRIVATE BUSINESS AND WORKING PEOPLE } r i Measure 9 has large and far-reachin g implications for Oregon's businesses;our economic health and our workforce. If passed, 4 it would Place government in the position of deciding whether a r business"promotes, encourages or facilitates"homosexuality? Business licenses,could be revoked or denied., Professionals licensed by1he state, such as medical professionals,attorneys I and accountants,could be denied licenses. Any.business could suffer because employees are or am o ro iv d t 7 T4 • homosexual. ...:. MEASURE 9 WEAKENS JOB SECURITY'FOR WORKERS v ' Any worker could be called a homosexual and be harassed or fired,throwing that person's life into chaos. Oregon has a good C workforce, with skilled,hardworking People upon whom.thou 1 k sands of businesses depend. We all work hard to make Oregon ' prosperous, and any one of us could suffer discrimination. Public employees are especially at risk.. v OREGON'S REPUTATION AND COMMERCE WOULD BE HURT Passage of Measure 9 would create a climate of intolerance,and could result in chilling business trade with other states,redua i ing the number of outof-state visitors and tourists. Jobs could 'be lost. Oregon doesn't need such negative publicity and �' can't fiord i we Submitted by: Oregon AFL-CIO,Iry Fletcher,President. i . Northwest Oregon Labor Council/C.O.P.E., AFL-CIO, Ron Fortune,Executive Secretary-Tre asurer. jl 1125 S.E.Madison St. Portland,OR 97214 4 I, (This Information furnished by lMn Fletcher,President,Oregon AFL-CIO; Ron Fortune,Executive Secretary-Treasurer,Northwest Oregon Labor , 3<. Counc/DC.O.P.E.,AFL-CIO.) ' III (This space purchased for$300 in accordance with ORS 251.255.) printing P ng of this does not constitute an endorse- ment by the State of Oregon,nor does the state warrant the accuracy or truth,of any statement made in the argument. 127 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet VOTING ACCESSIBILITY FOR ELDERLY AND INDIVIDUALS WITH PHYSICAL DISABILITIES Pursuant to the federal. "Voting Accessibility for the Elderlyand Handicapped Act," Public Law 98-435, the State of Oregon has made the following provisions for voters'who are elderly or who have physical disabilities: 1. A cassette edition of the Voters' Pamphlet is available for Oregonians who cannot read standard print due to a visual or physical 'disability.. For information regarding eligibility, please contact the Oregon State Library, Talking Book and Braille Services, State.Library Building,Salem, Oregon, 97310-0645, or call Portland:, 224-0610; Salem: 378-3849; or,toll free 1-800 7452-0292. Please use these'hiumbers only if you are ordering a cassette edition of the Voters';Pamphlet. If you need information. regarding where you vote, please .call your county elections official. All other Voters' Pamphlet questions should be directed to the Office,of the Secretary of State at 378-4144 or 378-5812 (hearing impaired). 2.; : Large=type voting instructions or hand-held magnifying glasses for.the visually impaired will be.provided at each polling place. 3: Telecommunications devices for the hearing impaired will be available in each county elections office. The special telephone number for your county f. appears at the top`of the polling place list in the back of this pamphlet,or you may contact,the Office of the Secretary of State by dialing 378-5812. 4. If an elderly or physically disabled voter's polling place is inaccessible the voter may request, in advance,to have a ballot brought from the polling place to the voter's car, or to be assigned`to`an alternative polling place. 5. Any voter who is unable to mark or punch the ballot because of a physical disability or an inability to read or write shall receive, upon request, the assistance of two election board clerks of different parties or of some other person'chosen by the voter. Under no circumstances.may'assistance be given by the voter's employer or an agent of the employer or by an,officer or agent of the voter's union. 6. A special absentee ballot may be requested by any elderly or physically, disabled voter.' This request, once made, remains in effect for each F election held in the same calendar year. Details -concerning the nature of barriers present at polling places designated as inaccessible may be obtained by contacting your county elec- tions official. 128 Ill- w Official IO2 General Voters'Pamphlet RTI ' OF'FICEIt"' CA' ' x C III i {v - 41 I . 1�0 DATES PA SAN The State of Oregon has attempted to correct spelling errors, but is not responsible for rammar syntax or inaccuracies of candidates' statements. I Official 1992 General Votets'Pamphlet DEMOCRATIC Political . Part Statement PARTY OF OREGON AS DEMOCRATS,WE BELIEVE that a just workplace with well-trained and highly motivated workers is one'of the keys to the revitalization of economic competitiveness in the United States. AS DEMOCRATS,WE BELIEVE that protection and wise use of the environment and its resources is essential to our economy and our lives.Economic vigor and responsible environmental protection are interdependent,rather than contradictory.We acknowledge that the ultimate solution to the problems of diminishing resources,environmental degradation,and obtaining an accessible quality of life for all lies with responsible resource management practices that balance ecological considerations with human,social,and economic.factors. ASMEMOCRATS WE BELIEVE that the strength of our nation lies in the well-being of its people,sustained by strong invest- ment in our human and physical infrastructure.Government at all levels must be empowered to provide for our people's needs in, health,education,public works(highways,water,and sewer systems, parks),housing,and law enforcement;funding priorities must be changed to,greatly increase our investments in our human resources and physical infrastructure,especially at the local; government level. AS DEMOCRATS,WE BELIEVE that'our nation can only be as strong as our commitment to liberty,justice,and equality.We believe that'the nation's resources can provide adequately for all our people and that it is a matter of right to adequate nutrition, good shelter,comprehensive health and mental health care,necessary social services,and a healthy,unpolluted,and safe work place..Individual liberty;dignity,and opportunity depend on an individual's needs being met. We hold that welfare reform must assist the needy to receive help.and give those who are able the opportunity to return to or. achieve gainful employment.As a Party,we are committed to the broadest possible concept of justice for all persons as guaranteed by our Constitution and Bill of Rights. AS DEMOCRATS,WE BELIEVE that Native Americans comprise unique cultures and sovereign governments deserving spe- cial recognition.We also support Oregon's recognition and relationships with American Indian Tribal governments located within the State of Oregon.We recognize,that each of the "sovereign"Tribal governments within Oregon is unique in its history and responsibilities and that the government-to-government relationships established between such groups and the state need to reo- ognize these concepts., AS DEMOCRATS,WE BELIEVE that the problems of economics and national security which face people throughout the world cannot be solved by-unilateral action.Building a safer world requires elimination of war,respect for human rights,protection of our global environment and resources,and promotion of economic justice. The Democratic Party,in supporting these objectives,calls for a new definition of security that balances economic,environmental, social,and military resources,and recognizes the need for international cooperation.Excessive and misguided military spending' weakens security by undermining economic strength and reducing living standards throughout the world. AS DEMOCRATS,WE BEIJEVE-that the process of governance must be a compact between citizens and public officials.To achieve this,we must have honest,caring,responsive officeholders,a citizenry willing to actively participate in public affairs,and laws which guarantee the widest,most informed participation in the political process. The Democratic Party of Oregon supports the great Oregon tradition of the free and open exchange of ideas inherent in political campaigns.We reject negative,personal attack campaigns which degrade the political process and obscure the productive discus- sion of ideas. y Our Party understands that government services are not without cost.We support a tax system to finance needed services which' provides the greatest degree of fairness and equity and which is based on the ability to pay. WE,THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY OF OREGON,the party of hope,change,and fairness for all,hereby challenges the people of, Oregon to do your patriotic best to meet your community responsibilities,encouraging you to protect and preserve your families,' our most precious asset;and invites you to join us in leading the state we love to a brighter and still greater future of opportunity and justice for all: t, VOTE DEMOCRATICI I. (7h1s Informatiav furnished by the Democratic Parry of Oregon.) I . 130 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet P diti LIBE caI Part St a t e m RTARIAN ent PARTY OF OREGON Liberty! Arguably one of the most important sacrificed lifetimes and fortunes to it tWithouconceived by the human end Millions have died for it,others have sion of liberty,great peoples build riY.life is debased,demoralized and less than human,In ' great nations of abundance,hope and��}�possibility, posses- Libertarianism celebrates liberty• Libertarianism is the philosophy.the vision and the passion of because we believe that all freedom loving Americans Your Libertarian Party.We sa law,have the right to live their lives as they see fit,as long a they our. espect the rights of ot}jers to }}1e Libertarian party is a live and let live philosophy.We beli eve it is the path to lasting People,being equal before the . g Peace and prosperity. same.Simply,it. A Universal Message,A Global Movement• The Zibertarian Party is the poli tical arm of a worldwide freedom movement Libertarians universally'advocate government,truly free markets and tolerance of peaceful diversi hnuted tion,inefficiency and special interest politics ty.In the glaring light of never-ending re and bureaucracies who run it.In spite of the�y of us are rightfully disillusioned with`goverriment nd th Politicians o c of us to seek alternatives and new wa soft state of the state there is cause for ho e! Y hinking about the nature of governance.People all over the world are gredis-' covering the wisdom of this nation's founders.Our country's long history has taught that liberty is more than:mere luxe- ry but a precondition to the success of the American experiment. •The Lessons of the Fall of Communism• Centralizing the control of resources results in shortages,inefficiency,pollution and corruption.Despite seven tinkering,the overlords of the socialist a !; responsibly control pro experiment could not change the natural desire of seventy Years of q P Perty and to make their own decisions.Far from its promise of boil people to be free,to own and munism'only brought old fashioned tyranny in a new package.IF SOCIALISM DIDN'T WORK FOR paradise'co ; NOT WORK FOR US. THEM IT WILL . t •Building On Our Strengths• 3 Libertarians have d plan for Lan even better America!We are dedicated to stren make us great—tolerance, respect g hening those parts of our system that actively work for: Pact and self-reliance.As part of the continuing struggle for"freedom in our time".we The decriminalization of work. Hundreds of jobs now re c measures,these laws actually harm the consumer b raising genre state licenses.Introduced as consumer protection vices.Worst of all,such regulations keep the costs and lowering the quality and availability of ser- ' right of free association.Laws that prohibit but unlicensed poor people from working.,People should be have the' P peaceful,honest behavior should be eliminated. Ending the"War on Drugs".Drug abuse is not a crime problem:it is a nomic problems;problems not solved by force.Re-legalize drugs and the violence n to. much deeper personal and eco ha A cleaner environment.Pollution is an insidious form of aggression.Polluters should pay for the cleanup of their mess.Liability cap laws discourage the development of renewable energy sources and send the message that our right to" a clean environment is up for sale. Putting justice back in the justice system.Nearl without victims, YY percent of our prison population have committed"crimes"' i Prisons should only house those who are most dangerous to our communities—the'violent offender.,' Restore victims rights upkeep, g through effective restitution.Put more responsibility on the bffender to carry the costs of their �i •The Libertarian Alternative• j Only the libertarian Pa rty consistently calls for an end to government intervention in people's personal lives,in the econ- omy,and in the affairs of other nations.Liberals are learning that taxes and regulations stifle freedom as much as viola- tions of civil liberties.Conservatives are learning that policing the world stifles freedom as much as economic regulation. Religious believers are learning that legislating morality Political spectrum are learning that the libertarian app a hn personal and economic liberty for all—traPncesoends the tics of the past.Libertarian values represent the best of the American tradition.Vote Libertarian for o pros- perity and peace. opportunity, THE CAUSE OF LIBERTY NEEDS MORE GOOD PEOPLEf PLEASE YOUR LIBERTARIAN PARTY. CONSIDER JOINING AND SUPPORTING Pl! For more information about the Libertarian party please write to P.O.Box 40471,Portland,OR 97240 or call 1-800-829-1992 f `' PLEASE NOTE:The Libertarian Party is not associated in any way with Lyndon LaRouche. 9 � 1 (This Informallon fumished by the Libertarian P ) arty of Oregon.J , 131 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CANDIDATE FOR CONTINUED United' States President f, 9. GEORGE BUSH ' Republican OCCUPATION: President of the United States,1989 to present. it OCCUPATIONAL t�'�4"I I Mi'I��Il��li Ill BACKGROUND: Dresser Industries— Supply Salesman, 1948-1951;Bush- Overby Oil ;. Development g Company—Co- Founder,1951-1953; ; 6 Zapata Petroleum j Corporation—Co- Sa'.1 Founder,1953-1959• Zapata Off Shore Co-Founder and President,1959-1966;Republican National Committee--Chairman,1973-1974. EDUCATIONAL o BACKGROUND: Yale University, Graduated Phi Beta Kappa in 1948 with a degree in Economics. PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:United States Navy, 1942-1945; Member of Congress for the 7th Congressional,District of Texas, 1967-1971;United States ' Ambassador to the United Nations, 1971-1973; Chief of the Liaison Office to the People's Republic of China, 1974-1975; Central Intelligence Agency—Director, 1976-1977;Vice President of the United States,1981-1989., In 1980 I came to Washington as part of a team committed to revolutionizing government,banishing malaise and restoring American pride.I seek re-election because I want to complete that mission. I want to restore the pond between people and government.I want to get government off people's backs, and into their hands.I want a government that trusts the people to propel America to new heights—rather than one that taxes them to new depths. I want to change our schools.Parents, not bureaucrats, should make the important choices about our children's futures. I want to get our economy moving at full speed, so every American has a fair chance to live the American dream I want'safe streets.Our justice system should punish crimi nals and care for victims of crime • _x And I want Americans to push themselves to new levels of greatness:As someone who served with pride in the Second ' World War and led this country through Desert Storm,I know we can meet any challenge when we work together. ; We won the Cold War and ushered in anew,exciting world. Today Americans need a President they can trust to make the hard decisions,the.right decisions.We need someone whose 'k experience and values can guide us steadily through the squalls of change: I know the limits of government,and I know,its appetites.I know the pressures and responsibilities of leading this country. And I know that I will devote all my energy to completing our r Freedom Revolution,to building a future where people control their own destinies—and through their struggle and toil,make this country brighter,better,more optimistic and prosperous than ever before: ; (This information furnished by George Bush.) i 132 vow CANDIDATE FOR o 1ss2 General Voters'Pam hlet ,;• #" United Sta CONTINUED tes Vice President r + DAN F' QUAYLE 5 Republican z OCCUPATION Vice President of the United States,1989 to present. OCCUPATIONAL x BACKGROUND: The Huntington Herald Press— Associate Publisher, 1966-1976;Private . Practice of Law, .1974-1976. EDUCATIONAL BACKGRO (F UND� r _ DePauw University, 1I Graduated in 1969 ft with a BA Political Science;Indiana University Law School,Gr dua d in 1974 with a J.D. �^ PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: Indiana National.Guard, 1969-1975; Indiana Attorney General's Office—Chief Investigator for the Consumer Protection Division, 1970-1971;, Governor Edgar Whitcomb- h, Administrative Assistant, 1971-1972; Indiana Department of Revenue--Director of the Inheritance Tax Division,1973-1974; Member of Congress for the 4th Congressional Indiana,1976-1980;Member of the U.S. enate from the State of Indiana,198o-1988. 9 h America has thrived because Americans dream bigger dreams than anyone else.We look ahead,think ahead, move ahead.Today,:as we race toward the twenty-first Century,we must look to the values that have kept this great nation on a steady course,from the opening of our frontiers to the victory of American ideals in the end of the Cold War. The America of the cede Century,like the America of the our forefathers,will grow stronger through the hard work,integrity ' and responsibility of its people. The people make this land '; great, and we should do everything,in our power to make our people even more free. We must give families greater authority to make the impor- tant decisions—about schools,health care,child care.We must; free entrepreneurs from the bureaucratic chains of regulation. We must reward success, rather than punishing it.And we must restore the virtue and vitality of our political system. Divided government has become divisive government.While i;. politicians in Washington squabble,Americans wonder:Who will address our real ambitions and needs?We must restore a sense of purpose to government—and honor the sacrifices of so � many who have died to keep our system alive.We must restore M coherence to government by electing a Republican Congress.; As Vice President,I have tried to fulfill my vow to restore the jh ' traditional values of family, home, community, religion and country;the virtues of hard work,tolerance,decency and hon- esty.We cannot ignore the battle for what literally is our .national heart and soul.So over the next four years,"I along ' with President Bush, will continue my efforts to restore what the Republican President,Abraham Lincoln,called"the better ' Angels of our Nature.' d (This information famished by Dan Quayle.) .;a 133 �jl Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED CANDIDATE FOR United States President BILL And we'll give all Americans the chance to borrow for college-- ' and ask them to serve their communities in return. CLINTON for victim$and gets Putting people first means standing up . 3u ' tin g tough with criminals.Our plan will put 100,000 new•police g $ Democrat officers on our streets,and put beat cops.back in our n ghbo hoods.We'll keep handguns out of the hands of criinals."And OCCUPATION: we'll reduce demand for drugs by increasing treatmentand edu- Governor of cation. Arkansas. ' OCCUPATIONAL Putting people first means putting everyday Americans back BACKGROUND: in control of government:fighting the special interests,cutting Attorney General of bureaucracy, and achieving real campaign reform.We will Arkansas make the tough choices and do what's right. ' 1976-1978;Governor And putting people first means uniting Americans behind of Arkansas, the hope we share—that we can build a better future for our '! 1978-1980, nation.:We won't serve the special interests.We will create " F 1982-present. tut EDUCATIONAL °pp° m y and demand responsibility.We won't;blame others when we do not succeed. We will work'tirelessly for the BACKGROUND: American people. ' Georgetown University,Bachelor We offer real change and new hope We will put people fir st h of Arts,1968;Rhodes for a change. Scholar,University College,Oxford;Yale University,Juris Doctoris,1973. PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL-EXPERIENCE: Attorney General of Arkansas, 1976-1978; Governor of Arkansas, 1978-1980,1982-present. It's time for a change.It's time to get our economy moving again. Our government has failed our people.For twelve years now, the Republicans have cut taxes for the rich and raised taxes on the rest of us. Good jobs have disappeared. Health care is beyond the reach of millions.Schools'have declined.Our streets and neighborhoods are more dangerous.And the Republicans have done nothing. a' We can't,afford four more years of a President without a vision. Al Gore and I have a bold new plan,to fight for what �+ Americans deserve:good jobs, quality health care,world-class education and safe neighborhoods.Middle-class Americans will finally have leaders who are on their side.-We will put people first for a change. That means reviving our economy. Our plan to rebuild America will create'a high-wage,high-skill economy for the post-Cold War era,and give defense workers the transition help they deserve..Well stop the tax breaks for corporations that _ ship jobs overseas—but.we'll give incentives to those that invest at home.'The;wealthiest 2 percent will have to pay their fair share—but the middle class will get ta relief.And those on welfare will get the training they need—but after two years they7l have to go to work. Putting people first means rejecting the false choice between protecting jobs and preserving the environment.American can only achieve a strong economy if we have a clean,safe environ- ment.We will work for both.. Putting people first'means making health care a right,not a privilege.We will guarantee affordable, quality care for every American—and take on the health care industry to bring costs down. Putting people first means educating our people—from the nursery school playground to the factory shop floor.Well estab- lish tough national I standards for K-12 education and reduce class size.We'll make sure high school graduates get the skills they need,and require companies to invest in worker training. "(This information furnished by Clinton-Gore i92 Committee.) 134 CANDIDATE FOR let 1992 General Voters'Pam ph UnitVCONTINUED ed States- ice Pre sident ' 'N'M 0 u GORE sn r emocrat r OCCUPATION: United to d States Senator(D. Tennessee). OCCUPATIONAL, Journalist;Home Builder. ' EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND: ' Harvard University, �I AB.;Vanderbilt School of Religion; Vanderbilt Law School. }. PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL ERL'ERIENCE:U.S. House of Representatives 1977-8b;U.S.Senate 1985—present., i" rm running for Vice-President for one simple reason:I love my country, and I believe in,my heart that the Clinton/Gore ( hi ticket gives our country the best chance,for the chan desperately need. - ge we so rmproud to serve as Bill Clinton's running mate:to fight on behalf of the hard-working people of the United States. The time has come for all Americans to get off the sidelines;to get involved in the process,to be a part of the healing this country desperately needs,to get to work on the changes for the average working people of this country. I believe very deeply that this nation simply cannot afford another four years of the kind of leadership that we have now. They've run out of ideas,they've run out of . energy,they've run of abili t to inspire our people. One of my greatest hopes for this campaign is to lift the public dialogue,to make this cam- w paign a national conversation about America's future, so that we can present to the people ideas,choices,a sensible plan for getting our country moving in the right direction. . a We're going to lay out the plan that Bill Clinton has put for- G ward. We're going to present choices to the American people. We're going to ask all Americans, regardless of what political party they're.in,to join,our team. We want all Americans to join this common effort to bring our country together,to get our r economy moving,to create jobs,change course,and get America back on the right track. (This information furnished by ClintonlGore Committee:) 135 Official 1992 General Voters,Pamphlet CONTINUED CANDIDATE FOR nt United S side In survey after survey,the vast majority of people have said " LENORA B. that they want more choices,that neither of the major parties FULANI represents them,that a fundamental restructuring of the politi I cal system is called for. New Alliance Clearly, independent politics is on the agenda in America. Party The issue is:what shape will it take?I am running as an inde- pendent candidate for president of the United States as part of OCCUPATION: a long4erm effort to open up our political process—to`make it Psychotherapist in more fair,more inclusive and more democratic private practice, i " Harlem,New York; 'Faculty and trainer, I am an ardent advocate of civil rights for people of color,for lesbians and gay men,for the elderly and the disabled.I fully East Side Institute support the right of women to choose'an abortion and the right t T Short orerm - I think that corporate of all workers to organize and to strike. a " Psychotherapy,New elves—and foot the bill.I polluters should clean up after thems York. oppose war. ' OCCUPATIONAL BACKGROUND: I believe that the profound crisis of the American economy sy Former director of cannot be resolved without radically transforming the political Community Clinics of environment:until the American people are included in the eco- the Institute for nomic decision-making,the professional politicians of the PAC- Social Therapy and owned major parties will continue to enact public policy that Research;has taught at Bank Street College of Education, puts,trillions into the pockets of the military industri alists'and Empire State College,State University of New York and - the Wall Streeters while leaving us without solutions to the College of New Rochelle;Founder of All Stars Talent Show array of social problems that confront us:homelessness,AIDS, Network;Editor of The Psychology of Everyday Racism and? police brutality, drug-induced violence, and the scandalous Sexism. absence of a national health care system. EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND:Hofstra University,B.S.; Columbia University Teachers College;City University of New The Perot phenomenon revealed that millions of white York,Ph.D. Americans—bit hard over the last five years by the economic PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: Chairperson,' crisis—would waste no time in breaking with the two governing parties if the opportunity arose. The Black community,the New.Alliance Party,1985 until present.. Latino community,the lesbian and gay community, women, Native Americans, workers—who have suffered bitterly for LENORA B.FULANI became the first African American°and decades,even centuries—must make that break as well. first woman presidential candidate to be on the ballot in every, state in 1988;that same year she became the first Black woman If two to three million Black,Latino,Native American,labor to qualify for federal primary matching funds. She garnere d a quarter of a million votes as an independent and forged the and gay voters from the liberal wing of the Democratic Party vote for me in November,and if they are joined by two to three New Alliance Party,Americas fourth largest electoral party, million Perot supporters and other independents,we would establishing independent;politics as a viable'option for the have the beginnings.of a new,broad-based electoral majority 1990s.She initiated a lawsuit which could restructure presides that could win the White House(and a lot else besides)in 1996. •tial debates and inspired the "Democracy in Presidential Debates Act,"H.R.791. I urge you to vote independent in 1992 because political:inde- INTERNATIONALLY she popularized the struggle to over- pendence is America's future.I urge you to vote for me so that throw the fascist dictator of Zaire-Mobutu Sese Seko-and together the ordinary people can shape our futurer in the light of d hu a social vision. helped to fund several hundred candidates seeking local office a progressive!lre ssive an man in Haiti on the ticket of the first democratically elected presi- dent,Jean-Bertrand Aristides now exiled.She has led countless protests against POLICE-BRUTALITY from Los Angeles to Plainfield,NJ to the Bronx,and led the Youth and Democracy Voter Registration Drive in New York City.• ,{ Dr.Fulani hosts a weekly cable TV show,"Mani!"syndicat- ed in 10 cities and authors"This Way for Black Empowerment" a weekly syndicated column in 140 newspapers. Sheds the mother of a son,Amani, 15 and a daughter,Ainka, 19.Born and raised in Chester,PA,Dr.Lenora B.Fulani is 43 years old A MESSAGE TO THE PEOPLE OF OREGON FROM LENORA B.FULANI Since the first primaries were held in New Hampshire last February,the American people have been expressing their pro- found dissatisfaction with our political process, with the two k major parties that maintain a stranglehold on that process,and with the lackluster candidates the two-party system produces. (This Information furnished by Lenora B.Fulani for President.) 136 1 mail CANDIDATE FOR Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet -r United President- CONTINUEStates , 1 ANDRt over$200 Billion each year.It would save the lives'of countless x MARROU men and women in uniform.It would reduce the risk of war. `F This hands-off,'non-interventionist foreig gn Policy his in the Libertarian best interests of America and Planet Earor Commercial Re Slash Taxes Estate Broker. Hack back government;Balance the federal budget by cut ' �g federal spending and borrowing..We want to put OCCUPATIONAL ment on a crash diet before it eats•taxpayers out of house and 3 BACKGROUND: home. Chemical Engineer, Engineering I Manager,Wholesale Shut down the Federal Morality Police I Supply Distributor; f We would introduce a Constitutional Amendment forbidding Real Estate Broker., federal, state and local , governments from outlawing restrict, 'EDUCATIONAL mg, or regulating voluntary relationships betweenconsenting a, BACKGROUND: adults.Personal,social,and business dealings would all be mg , H B.S.,Massachusetts tected by this Amendment. Institute of Technology,1962. ' Make Government Employees Personally Liable .I PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:Alaska State for their actions Representative,1985-1987. If an IRS agent causes damage to an innocent taxpayer,the taxpayer should have full legal recourse:If a DEA agent kicks` The key issue in politics today is individual liberty versus in the door of innocent people,he should do time and pay dam government power. Personal choice versus government control ages. We will apply the Nuremberg principle of personal accountability to all government employees. Pro-Choice I Libertarian'a are the only people who are consistently Pro- Vote Libertarian �LI� Choice on economic,civil;and personal matters.The only prop Almost every politician running for office teens.people to voter l er role for government is to protect each individual's right to They say,"It doesn't matter who @I ' you vote for;just vote. I dis-; choose.America's large,powerful, intrusive government has agree, If you don't vote Libertarian;your vote won't matter. i grown by shrinking our individual freedom.Government power Nothing important will change.It will be politics as usual. and individual choice are opposites.When government power grows,individual choice dies...slowly or quickly. There is only one basic issue in America today:Individual Freedom.Libertarians support it.The other two political par- Libertarian candidates are trying to reclaim America's true• ties don't. birthright: individual liberty and self-responsibility.Emerson called it Self-Reliance. For more information,please write to the Libertarian Party of Oregon,PO Box 40471,Portland, OR 97240; or call 1-800- Revolving Doors 829-1992.. If you want to make a difference,if you want to make history', When Republicans have the White House,we see revolving vote Libertarian. Vote Andr6 Man for President and Dr. x doors for Big Business and Big Banking,claiming that govern- Nancy Lord for Vice-President. meat protection and subsidies for their interests are essential. They represent corporate welfare, welfare for the grey flannel suits. When Democrats have the White House, we see revolving doors for Big Unions and the Educational Establishment,claim- ing that what's good for them is good for America.They repre- sent assembly line thinking,turning out mass-produced prod-' ucts and cookie-cutter minds: Who pays for these government privileges?You do.Whether t• yo u be n efit or not. you want to or not.You are taxed. and regulated.You are not free to choose. Bring the Troops Home No more American soldiers stationed on foreign soil.No American soldiers patrolling and protecting foreign seas.No American aviators defending foreign skies.No more foreign wars. Withdrawing American military personnel from Europe,the Mideast,Japan and elsewhere would save American taxpayers (This in/ormatton furnished by Llbertadan Parry of Oregon.) , 137 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CANDIDATE FOR Y United,States Vice, President If drugs were sold in a liquor store just like liquor,we could ,NANCY keep cgs out of the hands of children,and we could take the 3 y LORD profit and the crime out of drugs.. Libertarian Health Care OCCUPATION: Health care is another government-induced problem:If the government would just getout of the way,the price of health G Attorney. care would go down.The amount of regulation and paperwork OCCUPATIONAL imposed on the medical profession is staggering. BACKGROUND: Looking to the-Canadian system as a solution is a mistake. Attorney;Physician. People wait five months in Canada for routine procedures such EDUCATIONAL , as pap smears. BACKGROUND: JD.,Georgetown Vote Libertarian Law Center,1990; i M.D.,University of There are other Libertarians running for office this year in Maryland,1978;B.S.,. the State of'Oregon: for Attorney ,General,State Treasurer, University of Secretary of State,U.S.Representative,State Representative, Maryland,1973. and State Senator.Please read their statements closely,'and PRIOR GOVERN- please vote for them,for they too offer a change from politics as MENTAL EXPERI- usual. ENCE:None. For more information, write.to.the'Libertarian Party of Oregon,PO Box 40471,Portland,•OR 97240;or call 1-800-829- More Government is not the Answer 1992. Whenever the federal government gets involved in doing nice Vote Libertarian for a change.Vote Marrou/Lord for United things for the people, it inevitably leads to aself-serving States President and Vice-President. bureaucracy., When government gets involved in people's lives, it always gets Involved on the side of the rich.; The federal government should leave most things to individu- als or"private enterprise or local governments. The federal gov- ernment shouldn't be involved in daycare, education,art, or telling farmers what to plant Subsidized Destruction of the Environment Our tax dollars are currently spent supporting economically inefficient and environmentally harmful practices,such as over grazing on public lands and the subsidized destruction of the national forests.Why should taxpayers pay for the building of roads into the national forests in order that trees may then be clearcut?We must end the subsidy to clearcut,and instead the s national forests should may money for the;country without being destroyed '^ Welfare Bureaucracy The current welfare systems creates a permanent underclass with no hope of escaping.Most of the money spent never reach- es the intended recipient,but instead goes to pay the bureau- cracy. Paid to Not Produce The Department of Agriculture wastes billions of dollars pay- ing farmers not to make food.Supply and demand would do the same job,but would cost the taxP nothing. a ers Y �8• t5 End the Drug War The current drug laws are not working.We are spending a large amount of money on violating civil rights, and drug use ? has risen during this so-called drug war.The laws are making sellers very rich: The jails of this country are'mostly full of persons convicted of drug crimes. This is why there is no room for real, violent criminals. . (This information furnished by Libertarian Party of Oregon.) 138 Offiaal 1992 General Voters'o---Lt xl; ' Con, grMap STATE OF eSS�Ona� OREGON 1 tr 1 Z fr • Y I i --�-------------- ----- --- I. f ? i z •� I1 Z I. Y I w LL 0.c —, I WIM U W III W,..� <, IZ CD O 'tea 'I _ •Y "'`_� , V o a !! r J o I a. o O W s" y co E22 p cn,(n co w. �0: W um UO u' official 1992 General voters'Pamphlet CONTINUED CANDIDATE FOR United States Senator, r THE CHOICE FOR THE FUTURE:. o �! LES afthesame Incumbent SeimtarBob Packwood gffersmore AuC01N Challenger Les AuC m:an economic change of direction Democrat. THERE ARE REAL DIFFERENCES: A MIDDLE CLASS TAX CUT OCCUPATION: Packwood opposes a tax cut for the middle class; only Oregon - AuCoin supports cutting taxes for the middle class and pay- Representative. ing for it by raising taxes on the richest one percent of the OCCUPATIONAL population. BACKGROUND: SAVING OUR FACTORY JOBS Reporter;editor; Packwood voted for a Fast Track trade agreement with �- administrator. Mexico; only AuCoin opposes the Mexican agreement .,. EDUCATIONAL because it is not"free trade,"but unfair trade—the'agree- ` BACKGROUND: went will cost us over 400,000 factory jobs,lost to cheap Graduate:Pacific labor abroad.And the agreement will allow big corpora- - University,Forest tions to move to Mexico to exploit lax pollution laws. Grove;Redmond SAVING OUR FOREST JOBS High School. sting today—without Packwood wants to allow over-harve PRIOR GOVERN- regard for the future jobs that will be destroyed.AuCoin r!' ERI- AL EXP MENTAL today. e jobs to that have :U.S. supports sustainable forestry, so tha 1 y ENCE AYE and tomorrow. Oregon Legislature. HEALTH CARE FAMILY:Married to Susan Swearingen AuCoin; father of Packwood supports minor changes in health care,with no Stacy,26;Kelly,25.' real cost containment;only AuCoin favors national health ARE YOU BETTER OFF7 insurance that includes home health'care,nursing bome If you're undecided in the U.S.Senate race, ask yourself this care,prescription drugs and tough cost controls. question:are you better off after 12 years of Reagan-Bush/Bob AND MORE.... Packwood economics? There are other critical differences as well-such as on If your answer is"no,"consider Les AuCoin. defending a woman's right to choose. WHAT IRS AuCO1N IS ALL ABOUT Bob Packwood voted for seven justices on the Reagan-Bush AuCoin grew up in Redmond,Oregon.His mother,Alice, sup, Supreme Court poised to overturn Roe v.Wade. Les. ported the family on her own working as a waitress earning$35 AuCoin will never vote for a Supreme Court justice a week.Those roots define what AuCoin is all about:a fighter who opposes a woman's right to choose. for equal rights for women, an advocate for working families, someone who believes government has,a role in making the` "Abortion rights leadership falls to Les AuCoin" economy work for working people again. -The Regisfer-Guard.Eugene,Dec.9,1989 ON THE ISSUES,THERE IS A DIFFERENCE. PACKWOOD'S ATTACKS FORGET ONE THING:FACTS. The AuCoin commitment to jobs and a strong economy is the you won't learn about these real issue differences from Bob core'difference between Les AuCoin and Bob Packwood. Packwood—instead his campaign is spending millions of dollars Packwood has supported Reagan-Bush,trickle down attacking Les AuCoin.For the record,here are the facts on just economics. some of Packwood's distortions: Bob Packwood:led the fight in the U.S.Senate to cut taxes for. Checks:AuCoin admitted his mistake and apologized; the rich;voted time'after time to.take money from education, every one of his checks cleared, on average within four Social Security and Medicare and spend it on military hard days;his and Sue's account was balance d.every month;and ware such as Star Wars;and it was Bob Packwood who wrote most importantly, not a dime of taxpayer money was the 1986 tax bill. . involved. 11he largest tax giveaway in the,75-year history of "We're not accustomed to defending Members of the Federal income tax." Congress in this space.But in this case,the failings of -Philadelphia Inquirer referring to Bob Packwood's the House Bank were its own,not those of all the indi i 986 tax bill.Agri 10.1988. vidual members who now are getting unfairly tarred." AuCoin has fought Reagan/Bush economics. Albwy Democrat-Herald.March 19,1992 Les AuCoin has fought, time after time, to stop trickle down Pay raise:Bob Packwood has taken every single con- eeonomics.He voted for tax'relief for wociag families;to pro- gressional pay raise-13 in all.Just last year he promised test Social Security and Medicare;'he has been a leader in cut- the people of Oregon he wouldn't take it,but then he broke F ting wasteful military spending-,'and he voted over 10 times to his proms and took it anywayl require the wealthy to pay their fair share. • Attendance:The difference between Packwood's`life- WAS REAGANOMICS A CHRISTMAS PRESENT FOR time record and AuCoin',s record is only 6%. YOU? • Honoraria:Bob Packwood collected over$710,000 in "Packwood:`Reagan is Santa;I'm one of his elves'." speaking fees from special interests,an Oregon record and -The Oregonian.June 2,1984: almost three times more than Les AuCoin. During the Reagan-Bush years,the rich those with incomes Balanced Midget amendment:Bob Packwood voted over$250,000—got more than $164 billion in tax cuts. If five times against requiring the President to submit a bal- Reagan was Santa Claus,it was the rich who got all the gifts. arced budget. THE BOTTOM LINE: CHANGE V. THE SAME OLD "Bush said he might accept a higher tax on the wealthy,but he later seemed"to back away after lob- Two DOWN. bying by Packwood.».Packwood said he believed the THAT'S THE DIFFERENCE IN THE RACE FOR U.S.SEN basic tenet of Rehganomics..-remained alive r ATE:THE ECONOMY.AND THE STAKES?OUR JOBS. The Oregonian.October 12.1990. (This Information furnished by Les AuCoin for Senate Committee.) 140 . .: s, Wow _�� { CANDIDATE FOR Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet United, ............ States Senator, ' .,,.. , BOB THE n IFFERENCES BETWEEN, h PACKWOOD Sena for Con �'BOB PACKWOOD •AND Rep ubllcan LES Aucom OCCUPATION: United States 1989$30,000 CONGRESSIONAL PAY RAISE a Senator from Oregon. PACKWOOD.NO AuCOIN:YES E OCCUPATIONAL, dM u BACKGROUND: 0 Practiced law in Portland,1958-1968. BOUNCED CHECKS IDUCATIONAL PACKWOOD:NONE Co (! BACKGROUND checks fr !' ` B .t1 Willamette o r University,1954; $61,000 � LL.B .,New York University School of Is CONSPITUTIONAL AMENDMENT !' Law,1957. REQUIIZiNG BALANCED BUDGET PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL E ME ' !I' RIENCE:1962,elected to Oregon House of Representatives;Re-elected 1964 and 1966; PACKWOOD:YES AuCOIN:'NO !' 1968, elected to United States Senate; Re-elected 1974, 1980, 1986. • LINE-ITEM VETO I�I In order to properly represent the people of Oregon in TO CONTROL SPENDING the United States Senate,one must be fiercely indepen- dent and strong in their resolve to•fight for the interests PACKWOOD.YES AuCOIN NO` of the people of Oregon and do whatever it takes-to deliver for our state-At times;I've.rocked the boat and roiled the waters to get results for the people of Oregon. . u And,at times I've stood alone on issues of conscience— USE OF FORCE IN but I hope I've always stood strong for the people of PERSIANGULF a' Oregon.I ask for your support. PACKWOOD-NES AuCOIN.NO —Bob Packwood ATTENDANCE G PACKWOOD.MGlIESr AuCOIN:LOWEST ATTENDANCE ATTENDANCE RECORD in the OREGON RECORD in the SENATORIAL DELEGATION OREGON h ` CONGRESSIONAL DELEGATION PROTECTIONIST LEGISLATION' WHICH COSTS'OREGON JOBS AND INCREASES COSTS'ON OREGON , 1 CONSUMERS PACKWOOD:NO ' AuCOIN.YES fi (This informadon furnished by Re-Elect Packwood Committee) 141 �!1 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CANDIDATE FOR CONTINUED Representative In Congress DISTRICT DENZEL Senior citizens and Social Security benefits-must be protected from people like Bob Smith who wants to balance " FERGUSON the budget using Social Security funds.We need a national health care plan that controls costs and offers health:care to @t11�Cfi1t every senior citizen. Women should control decisions regarding their bodies and reproductive rights. Government must be kept out of the rper-- q OCCUPATION:, sonal decisions of families and individuals. Bob Smith has Scientist and writer; � , voted for the gag order and supported Bush's,efforts to former university outlaw safe and legal abortions., professor. ; OCCUPATIONAL REDUCE MILITARY SPENDING,RE-THINS OUR PRI- BACKGROUND: ORITIES AND BALANCE THE NATION'S BUDGET: Farm worker; Growth of the national debt, which is increasing by t lumbermill worker; more than a billion dollars a day,must be controlled by set- university teacher, ting spending priorities. researcher and . The Strategic,Defense Initiative and the NASA space sta- program coordinator; tion should be cancelled.No more$30 billion boondoggles. advisor to several �°hThe United States sould'not bee exporting 40%of the arms � state and federal g agencies;Malheur and weaponry sold on the world market. Field Station America should reduce its armed forces,bring more Director;newspaper, troops home,and require our allies to pay a greater share columnist. of their own defense.Bob Smith voted against just such a measure in August,1992. EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND:Wallowa, Oregon public We should pay our over-due debt owned to the United schools;Eastern Oregon State'College; University of Kansas; Oregon State University–B.S.,(1951),M.S. (1952), Ph.D. Nations and basis place greater emp on international peace- (Zoology and botany,1956). keeping forces. 1 PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:None. (And • The 60%share of federal research and development funds j darn proud of itl). designated for the Pentagon should be slashed and diverted to increasing our competitiveness in world markets through value- WHY WE MUST CHANGE CONGRESS: added production. j . 'Denzel Ferguson says"We can only have responsible STOP STEALING FROM FUTURE GENERATIONS. . government if elected officials act responsibly:' Denzel Ferguson believes this nation is on the wrong track • We must start managing our natural resources on a D We'need change,leadership believes his hard work if we are to put sustainable basis.We can preserve our timber industry and matters right.We can no longer afford politics as usual in our environment so that our children and grandchildren can i Congress• enjoy both in the decades to come, •'. Elected officials should'be held accoundible-when the To preserve jobs In our forest products industry,we nation's affairs go awry—government is not a no-fault open- must ban log exports NOW!We cannot have a secure econo- ation.Since Bob Smith has been in Washington,our national my based on the export of raw materials.The growth of the see. debt has increased to over$4 trillion.: ondary wood products industry is critical to our economic ' The cosh of running Congress has gone up 705%since future. 1970.The coat of a loaf of bread has gone,up 28090. Congress The United States must begin cooperating with other must stop granting itself pay raises and perks that amount to nations in solving world-wide environmental problems. more than most of us make in a year.Bob Smith spent • We must invest in alternative forms of energy and energy $643,376.16 on staff and expenses in 1991.Denzel will do conservation.Fuels derived from grain will help our agri- the same;job with half that. cultural base. • Bob Smith spends over$200,000 a year on franked • Chlorofluorocarbons,which destroy the ozone layer and are mail paid for by taxpayers like you and me.I support ban- scheduled to be banned in the civilian economy,must also be ning all taxpayer-paid mailings unless it's in direct response to banned by the military which accounts for 60%of its use. a constituent request. The 1872 Mining Law must be revised to'reflect modern A vote in Congress should be based on facts,thoughts and realities. the effects on all citizens.Votes should not be surrendered To preserve our dwindling water supply,streams on public to support party politics or special interest groups. land should be protected from livestock grazing and logging operations. LET'S TAKE CARE OF OUR PEOPLE FIRST: . We must seek new growth industries as a means of sup- • ' Health Care must be available to every American.If nee, porting our local communities.New national parks at Steens essary,health costs must be regulated as are utility'companies: Mountains and Hells Canyon would be a good start to entice Bob Smith refuses to support a national healthcare plan. more travelers to Eastern Oregon,providing new jobs and new • 'Jobs and the environment are not separate choices,but opportunities. equal necessities for a quality life. ENDORSEMENTS: • ' Quality education is vital to our future—and we must Oregon NARAI4 Oregon Education Association,Brotherhood of begin giving it the attention it deserves.Since Bob Smith went Locomotive Engineers Local 362, Service Employees to Washington,federal education funding has declined 45% International Union Local 49. while defense spending has increased over 200%.I'll put smart If you believe Oregon and America have bright futures in the kids before smart bombs: new millennium,but must make major changes in the way of • Corporations and wealthy individuals must bear a greater doing business then vote for Denzel Ferguson. tax burden the poor and middle classes deserve greater tax fau ness• (This Information is furnished by Ferguson for Cwgress.) MOM low- 142 CANDIDATE FOR Offidal 1992 General voters'Pamphlet Re p In C D r esentative on , DISTRICT ROBERT F. serve the American people.I have an agenda for real,change in 9BOB) . , the next Congress that will take influence from the congression- al elite and give it to the people, MITH , I am the Principal Re blican sponsor of the Balanced ,. Repubilean Budget Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.,Congress has spent our children and future debt.It's time the Congress lived bathe same princip es otrillion iscal er OCCUPATION responsibility that average Oregonians and Americans live by. Cattle Rancher; Businessman; •. I support proposals to limit congressional terms. Member of Congress Scandals involving Congressmen who bounced checks,at the k OCCUPATIONAL House bank,abused privileges at the post of ice,,and refused to >" BACKGROUND: Pay their tab at the House restaurant show how imperial the Oregon State . , Democrat-controlled Congress has become.I had no role in any '' " Legislator;various of those scandals,and was an early and ardent supporter of full 4' private business disclosure in the House bank scandal, enterprises.. EDUCATIONAL I am unalterably opposed to new taxes on the Ameri can BACKGROUND: people..We have a$4 trillion debt and$400,billion deficit not Burns public schools; because American's are under-taxed, but because'Congress Vpillamette overspends.New taxes do not reduce the deficit;they only seise University BA, Congress'unquenchable thirst for pork-barrel spending.,I sut` Economics and Business Administration), port a capital gains tax cut and expanded Investment Tax PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXP Credit to jump-start the,Cre my and create jobs EXPERIENCE:. House ' of Representatives, 12 years(two,terms as Speaker);,Oregon • State Senate, 10 years(two terms as Republican Leader);U S. Act,the National o Envurongm ntal,Policy Act, and articularly House of,Representatives,.elected 1982, re-elected in 1984, the Endangered 1986,1988 and 1990. ge Species Act to put the interest of Oregon's peo- ple on at least an equal level with owls,fish,and other animals: As a legislator,rancher,businessman,husband,and father,'I p e wand they should behtrreeated as kindly embodied it our.peo bring over thirty years'experience in Oregon's public service to laws as any othercreature.h- y in our envu»nmental the U.S.House of Representatives:No member of Oregon's.del- acquisitions egation to he U.S.House of Representatives has more expel . ence representing Oregonians than I do. I°PPOce new federal land and will fight to preserve the multiple use.of our federal lands, particularly at Steens Mountain and Hells Canyon.With 75%of the Second I have fought for the interests of Oregon's people—not the Congressional District owned by the federal government, interests'of owls, politicians, or easterners. I have fought for enough is enough.,Only the-privileged and elitists want more Oregonians and their jobs.That dedication has earned me the federal land lockups and new national parks;Oregonians want , respect of Oregon's press,as well as our people. . jobs.,. The Oregonian said"Smith is becoming an effective la er in I support repealing the earninga limit on,Social Security P y recipients to encourage senior citizens;who choose to work to do a number of areas important to his district'and to Oregon..after so.Senior citizens have a wealth of knowledge and experience several terms on Agriculture, where he has built close ties to that can benefit Oregon'and America,and they should be both ranking Republicans and to the majority Democrats, encouraged to'ahare their talents. h Smith is emerging as a figure of some influence on the commit- tee.".(4119/90) I support America's'parents hawing a greater choice in where their children can attend public schools. Competition in The Medford Mail Tribune concluded that Bob Smith"gives the Public schools will foster more efficient use of scarce public the state's congressional delegation a needed conservative voice, resources and a more serious academic environment:If there is one that can be counted on to speak out strongly for Oregonians ally way to improve our schools,it is,to give parents a greater who make their living by working the land and harvesting tim- voice,, bel("/90) This year, retirements and the American people's disgust And the Central Oregonwn said"there probably aren't man with Congress has created the opportunity to make real people in the U:S.Con y changes in the Congress.No American institution needs reform gress who have a better sense of who they are, where they are from, and who they represent,than more than the Congress.It is broken and must be fixed. II Congressman Bob Smith..in the past 20 years,I've never meta As one who has fou ht for that change person better suited to represent.Eastern Oregon than.Bob I see a e unique opportunity g ange throughout my career, Smith.He's a good person and we would be fools to replace him interests deliver Congress from the grips e in Congress with anyone else."(10/4190) liberal special interests and back into the hands of the American people.With your support on November 3 I'll go back . to work on that agenda. BOB'SMITH'S PLAN FORA NEW CONGRESSi, CONGRESSMAN BOB SMITH. I'm fed up with the liberal Democrat leadership's tax-and- HF VOTES IN WASHINGTON LIKE HE TALKS IN spend philosophy and disregard for the average.Oregonian and American in the application of America's environmental laws.I OREGON' believe,above all else,that,the.United States Congress should (This informatlon furnished by Bob Smlth for Congress Comm/ttee) i; 143 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CANDIDATE FOR CONTINUED Secretary �of State ' PHIL ` 'SECRETARY OF STATE KEISLING:`,,` i I A RECORD OF INTEGErrY KEISLING Phil Keisling believes in strict enforcement of our election laws.He initiated criminal indictments s a B ainst'two,elected II . Democrat officials—both Democrats.—for alleged violations of Oregon eleo- tion law.. ; OCCUPA TION: When the Oregon legislature failed to re-draw legislative 'f Secretary of State. boundary lines in six months,Keisling had dust 45 days to do OCCUPATIONAL the job. He refused to accept campaign contributions during BACKGROUND: those 45 days or make any back-room deals,and held 20 public Senior legislative hearings., ' assistant to Speaker Keislin$s�fmal plan was applauded for its integrity,and upheld of the Oregon House, Bo by,Oregon's Supreme Court j $ 1985-88;investiga �•..Keislings impressive experience in little over a year in tive reporter and edi- office make him a clear[primary]choice...Most impressive tor,writer,Tom speech- was his achievement in drawing up a legislative'reappor- venter,Tom McCall tionment plan fair to both parties and accepted in its entire- EDUCATIONAL ty by the Oregon Supreme Court."(The Oregonian,4/30/92) BACKGROUND: SECRETARY OF STATE KEISLING: Yale College,BA.,; AN ADVOCATE FOR COMPREHENSWE CAMPAIGN 1977;Sunset High. FINANCE REFORM School,1973." Keisling's plan includes: PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:Oregon House • Legal limits on the size of contributions from individuals, { of Representatives,1989-91;Chair,Legislative subcommittee corporations,and PACs.Today,Oregon has no limits. on Toxic Use Reduction;Co-Chair,Joint Interim Education •Voluntary spending limits:The Voters Pamphlet should s Committee,1990: list whether or not candidates pledge to abide by the limits,so Oregonians know who is keeping a lid on spending: SECRETARY OF STATE KEISLING:A NEW ' . Stricter disclosure and enforcement,including bans on GENERATION OF LEADERSHIP "pass through"contributions;post-election fundraising, and In just over 3 years as a state official,Phil Keisling's leadership conversion of campaign accounts for personal use. has meant results for Oregon.As a state representative,his "Keisling,too,has been a public advocate for campaign efforts included enactment of"true' life"sentences for murder- finance reforms and for improving the campaign finance ers;a nationally-recognized law to reduce toxic chemical use; reporting procedures within the secretary of state's office to initiatives to promote community service among young make it more effective and responsive to the media'and.the Oregonians;and reform of K-12 education citizens of Oregon."(East Oregonian,5/12/92) Since becoming Secretary of State in January, 1991,,Phil SECRETARY OF STATE KEISLING:INNOVATIVE Keisling has been widely recognized by leaders in both parties LEADERSHIP FOR OREGON'S FUTURE for his integrity,independence Land leadership. As a member of the State Land Board,Phil Keisling has been a "Keisling is bright,articulate,imaginative,and honest'° leader on behalf of better'management of close to 1 million (Salem Statesman Journal,4125/92) acres of state owned land.He is working for all Oregonians to SECRETARY OF'STATE KEISLING:WORKING TO protect valuable resources while creating new job opportunities. GET THE MOST VALUE FOR OUR TAX DOLLARS Phil Keisling's programs include: Phil Keisling believes that every dollar government wastes is . Development of a"Forest Resource Trust Fund"to reha- an unacceptable breach of the public trust.He has proven that bilitate and reforest over 250,000 acres of under-productive tim state government can be more efficient with your tax dollars. ber land.Modeled on the Tillamook Burn,this overdue initia While others merely talk about"auditing,""Phil Keisling is actu- tive will create jobs today,and billions,of dollars in future ally cutting waste by: revenues. • Identifying potential tax savings of over$10 million— • Continued acquisition and development of potential income through increasing child support payments.owed by delinquent producing land. One project in Clatsop County is projected to parents;reducing improper welfare payments; selling surplus produce Boo new family-wage jobs. property; and cutting building construction and furnishing .•Forging a balanced,long-term solution for'state-owned costs forests that will ensure'sustainable timber harvests for • Eliminating managers by"auditing" his own Audits Oregon's communities and families.. Division to expand its capability to uncover wasteful spending "He's[Keisling]also been a balanced,thoughtful voice on the and improve government effectiveness. Keisling's initiatives Land Board."(The Register-Guard,Eugene,5/7192) include,for"the first time in 20 years,contracting with the pri- vate sector to perform audit work. PHIL KEISLING:COMMITTED TO OREGON • Ordering the elimination of an entire section of his own Phil Keisling was born in Oregon and attended public schools in agency b `redistnbutin and consolidating its war cutting Washington County. He and his wife Pam have a son Y Y B m8 .. Benjamin,born.in March 1991. management and overhead. "Keisling has not been around the statehouse so long that he • Investigating the state bidding process,revealing the flaws is resigned to its limitations.With Measure 5 upon us, we that produced such excesses as$1271yard carpet in the State especially need a new outlook in Salem...He also could be a Archives Building. beacon in our state government."(Daily Astorian, 12/7/90) "He[Keisling]has streamlined his own agency and made PHII.KELSLING strides toward streamlining others by being aggressive in' �INDEPENDENCE TO DO THE JOB. his role as the state official in charge of performance and financial audits of other state agencies." - THE INTEGRITY TO DO IT RIGHT. (Baker City Herald 4/3N92) (Mls7nformation furnished by Friends of Phil Keisling.) 144 CANDIDATE FOR Offidal 1992'GeneralVoters'Pam Dhiet CONTINUED S,ecrets ry of State r, •4' SARAH D. crack at public offices;I'm not interested in givin' LYONS Republicans their share of the political boot I su g term limitations because with the y PP°rt tics nation �'0�h°f independent poli- ; New Alliance ally,term limitations would.be a;ivay to make it possible for increased participation by independents who now " Part make up more than one third of the electo but"are:hardly - Y rate represented.I am committed to giving the people t this state and country the opportunity to be fairly represented " OCCUPATION- ,poet CUT---IN— H&LE Oregon'"allOt access requirements for'initia- OCCUPATIONAL tives,independent candidates and independent parties:;._ ' BACKGROUND: Establish criteria' Clerical worker;can- for FULL P TI .ipeMONIN r+y, �,m.c ' vasser;publishers for all candidates at every level Its not enough to have the right to run. The voters need to know who running and ` assistant;petitioner. what the candidates stand for! EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND: ' Happy Valley Grade - .. OTHER Y SUES Dale ale Ickes Jr. N AIDS is a full-blown health care crisis. The Democrats;who a High School;LaSalle hold the purse a; High, p strings on'social service funding in,this.coun= University, State try, are more committed to their relationships and funding ty, with the AMA and the health•care;insurance and pharma- Linkoping University ceutical PACs than to people'who are suffering allover the i (Sweden);BA.,University of Oregon. globe because of this fundamentally unchallenged disease.I PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL ERPERIENCE: National JOIN WITH MILLIONS OF OREGONIANS'AND AMEe.I f Committee member,New Alliance Party. CANS'.IN DEMANDING THE mmEDIATE.ESTABLISH- ' Pm tannin for Secret MENT OF A NATIONAL HEALTH CARE SYSTEM AND 8 Secretary of State on the New Alliance Party AN IMMEDIATE CURE FOR AIDS ticket led by the independent presidential candidate Dr.Lenora Fulani because the two-party system has failed the vast majori- I Personally challenge each and every candidaie'and electhd ty of people in this country and state.Polls show.that the Official to take a public position in opposition to the ballot American People.want more and better choices in our'elections. measures of the Oregon Citizens Alliance, 849b of the American people are saying they want fundamental restructuring of our political process.The outpouring of support for Ross Perot speaks volumes'about the deep and broad based desire of the American people to build something radically dif- ferent in this country. What does radical mean?Well in " America today,'after 215 years'of government dominated by a two-party system,radical means independent: ' Let's face it.Most people living in the'.`cradle of democracy" dont even vote because they already know elections are good for the professional politicians,not for people.In order for me to ±; get on the ballot as an independent,candidate for Oregon Secretary of State, my party,the New Alliance Party, was required to submit 39,966 signatures of registered voters:That meant gathering nearly 60,000 signatures to account for invalid ones and in addition,the final and official number of required I�! signatures needed to'qualify for the ballot is not'even deter- mined by the State until the day the signatures are submitted! N f Restrictive and complicated ballot access Taws,which vary greatly from state to state,are a major barrier which keep peo- �Ple out of the decision-m aking process known.as politics.And the State of Oregon has some of the most restrictive ballot access laws there area i I My:campaign is part of a`new democracy alliance in this country which is working to empower the majority,of people who have been left out of that decision-making process-people �! of color,-women;lesbians and gays, progressive white folks, working people.I am running with.Lenora B:Fulani to provide people with a progressive independent option,an alternative to " the good-old boys club candidates that the Democrats and : Republicans consistently offer us. , In order to open up the election process we must: • SUPPORT TERM IDMA71ONS,While term limitations is a reform that Republicans have supported because they saw and give themselves a • it as a way to get rid of Democrats gl (This Information furnished by Sarah D.Lyons for Secretary of State.) ; ,r 145 ll Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CANDIDATE FOR CONTINUED Secret a o �Y f State 1 g3&.Asa third generation member of an Oregon timber family, f RANDY Randy Miller knows the importance of a healthy timber indus- MILLER try. . Unlike the Phil Keisling/Andy Kerr,preservationist lock-up Republican approach that has been so cruel to Oregon's timber towns and families,Randy Miller has called for rewriting the endangered species laws to allow consideration of the human factor when OCCUPATION: endangered species designations an made. ' Vice President, Secretary,and AN INDEPENDIi'NT VOICE" Treasurer,Moore' Rand Mer is no i i AU"debt-free." Mill and Lumber Co.; Unlike his opponent, Phil Keisling,Randy Miller owes no Lawyer;and State favors to anyone.Keisling,owes his current political fortune to Representative Governor Barbara Roberts.Keisling was a little known state 1983-present. representative when Roberts appointed him to the state's seo- s OCCUPATIONAL and highest office.Roberts has contributed thousands of dollars BACKGROUND: in cashl equipment and services to Keisling's campaign. �?{ ? Elementary and come Not surprisingly, Kgi,l_i11Q supported Roberts ill-fated g munity college "Conversation with Oregon,"her billion-dollar tax increase,and teacher,director of found her bl m.less in the sycnding ce surrounding the new management firm; State Archives Building. Army Reserve. EDUCATIONAL As Secretary of State,Randy Miller will be a counter- ilk nt to .•` BACKGROUND: Barbara Roberts. No longer will Roberts be assured the r�, " Secretary of State will fall-in behind her every whim,Program, t.- Doctor'of Jurisprudence,.Lewis and Clark Law School;Master or proposal of Education,B.S. Political Science, University of Oregon; Randy Miller will be an •nd nandent voice instate govern- Beaverton High School. pgii.He will speak up for us,he will fight for us,regardless of PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: State the political cost. Representative 1983-Present;Republican Leader, 1987-88; That's why on April 25,1992,The Statesman Journal wrote: Chair,House Judiciary Committee'1991-Present;Co-chair, Legislative Counsel Committee;Chair,House Subcommittee on "...He i .v that he could help restore iMblic trust in gov- Crime and Corrections; Special Assistant to Speaker of the ernment nartlyr by serving as the IgW oopnosition and nartly House Vice Chair Reforestation and Hardwoods Utilization by promoting stronger audits programs and other waste- Committee. Other Legislative committees: Rules, Operations ,;reduction plans.And he is honest and earnest" and Reform;Agriculture and Natural Resources; State and And on May 5,1992,The Bend Bulletin said: Federal Affairs; Transportation; Legislative Counsel; Law "No one will have any trouble knowing where Miller stands Improvement;Rules and Reapportionment; Subcommittees on on=issue before him A Civil Law and Judicial Administration,Family Justice,Natural And gn May,7,1992,The Flillsboro,Argus wrote: 'Resources and Game Violations. RANDY MILLER—A LEADER WITH A NEW DIREC- "Must's un-front style is one the state needs in what cotid TION FOR OREGON prove some tough years ahead." Randy Miller is not your typical leade he brings abusiness-r. Nothing points out the'reasons we need an independent voice man's"real world'-approach to government.; Secretary of State more than: While the Roberts/Keisling team has declared the state in '1'FiF, D TORY OF R HIVES p T.ACF crisis and demanded a billion dollar tax increase,Randy Miller When the true story of the State Archives Building began to offers innovative solutions to reduce state sggn in¢and keep come ou 10 light taxes down fixtures.and$4200 desks—Phil Keisling was pressured to oon- Randy Miller proposes a Five-Point Program to duct'an audit " ElimuLte Mang in Statue Government: Unbelievably. the audit found no one to blame for the L"Use private auditors to review projects and programs on Archives fiasco,neither Keisling nor Governor Barbara Roberts an ongoing basis was held accountable.Keisling's in-house audit ignored the fact 2. Establish a Budget Review Team to focus on specific to- both'Roberts and Keisling served as Secretary of State and p were responsible for the Archives during approval and constrao- jects"and make recommendations on saving taxpayers' {ion. " dollars; 3. Establish atoll-free"Waste"Hotline so Oregonians may Isn't it time we Meld govewxtment officials accountable for their actions?'� report government waste and make suggestions for' With Randy y Miller as our Secretary of State there will be 4. Examine all major construction contracts to assure that more"cover-up"audits.Randy Miller will hire private,outside work is performed b the firm bid auditors who will be told to¢et.and tell.the whole story. pe y ding the lowest cost;and As a small businessman,Randy Miller has auditing expert b. Require,under law,that all major construction Rroje. ence and recognizes the waste and excesses of state govern- ment.If Randy Miller's Five-Point Plan to End Waste in State Randy Miller proposes turning many state functions over to Government had been in .effect during. Archives private contractors to increase efficiency and reduce costs. construction...There wouldn't have been Randy Miller favors extending vote-by-mail to ll elections. co in the first place. Vote-by-mail increases voter participation and reduces costs. There is a clear choice for Secretary of State this year.More Randy Miller is aleade_ r n the fght for term limits and cam- of the same old Keisling/Roberts approach...or new directions paign finance reform.He believes people with"real world'expo- with Randy Miller. rience,not career politicians,belong in government. Randy Miller says Wo le and Job re more'mportAnt thin (This information furnished by Cidzens for Randy M/ler for Secretary of State.) 146 --�.. •cos - - - CANDIDATE FOR Official 1992 Genaral voters'Pam hlet Secretary of -SHAUN can use,thus demonstrating to their children the im' SAVAGE education. Po. ce of SHAUN SAVAGE also believes parents should receive tax credits or vouchers to be applied to their choice of schools This Libertarian will create competition between schools, thus increasing the educational standards of all schools. OCCUPATION: Graduate student, Personal statement by SHAUN SAVAGE'�:� Oregon State, University,computer , engineering, "I am an engineer by trade,father by choice sand a pohticiau OCCUPATIONAL because I fear for my children's future.I have both a large and BACKGROUND: small business background Pve been trained to think logically, ' Ten WOULDN'T LOGICAL years in the oom- Z'HINHING BE A,NOVEL,BUT:WEI,- puter industry: COME IDEA, FOR GOVERNMENT,ADMINISTRATION?I ,' Owned computer con- "'ant to make this world a better'place for my,children and sultingbusiness-2 their friends and my-neighbors statewide.-Help,me do this by Years;Taught com- voting for me November 3rd.", C puter technicians at ' ITT Technical ENOUGH IS ENO Tr'H! Institute,Salt Lake r " City,Utah-1 year; VOTE.LIEMIRRTAUrAivr Engineering manag er of SPIRICON, For as long as most of us can remember, Republican and Logan,Utah–2 ;Sys;Test engineer for GTE,Phoenix, For politicians have talked about solving the problems f Arizona-2 ears• stems en ' eer for S Y �' gin perry Corp.,Salt Lake that face Americans;but their solutions have onl worsened City,Utah 3 years. the situation—higher and higher taxes only :worsened BACKGROUND: Presently workin on'' our g ;Suter intrusions into graduate degree in computer engineering at Oregon State our personal lives;more rapes,murders;and muggings;and;a ' University;B.S.from University of Utah in computer science, people who can read school system graduating fewer and fewer minor degree in electrical engineering;Attended West Point ,^ f Prep School,Fort Monmouth,New Jersey. For voters who want an alternative to the establishment can- PRIOR_GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: Candidate for didates,the Libertarians offer a true and viable alternative. State Representative in Utah-1990; Chairman of the The Libertanan Party is the third largest party.in he nation It Libertarian Party of Cache County, Utah for three years; is running over 600 candidates for public`office across the coun- Y try,More than 200 Libertarians have held public office Treasurer of Scottish Rite Fraternal Organization; Former member of National Abortion Rights Action League,National By winning seats in the state legislature and city councils, Organization for Women,and the National Rifle Association. Libertarians are in,a position to do more than talk about liber- ty--they are actively winning it back for their constituents! ENOUGH I ENO =HI T�Year,show the establishment'politicians that Oregonians LVGAl JZP.RRSPONSIRTr rmv have had enough of tax and spend policies and broken promis= es.Vote Libertarian. SHAUN SAVAGE believes that the government is making o e g VOTE,FOR CNAiTNoAt7An�+ 1t many rules and regulations that individual responsibility has been limited and reduced.If this trend continues,Shaun fears FOR FT Y OF STATE' our citizenry will lose the American spirit of self-reliance: I' As the government does more for some individuals,the bur- f den increases on all individuals,thus stagnating the economy. I I if elected,SHAUN SAVAGE will exercise the necessary lead- ership to"promote responsibility by opposing unnecessary gov- ernment interference in private decision-making. This will transfer state regulatory jobs into the private sector,allowing the private sector to be productive again. IMPROVE, .D TnATION ' There are three ways for a person to gain success—the use of. ,force,the use of money and the use of knowledge.Of these three options,only knowledge is available to everyone.With knowl- edge,a person will be able to make better choices in his/her life. I i�I As a Libertarian,SHAUN SAVAGE wants more support education—education of kinds and by all appropriate hods. Parents.should be more responsible for their children's educa- tion.This can best be achieved b r tion. Y requiring parental participa- tion. Ross Perot told,his volunteers he wanted them to"put some skin in the game,"by contributing part of the costs of his cam- paign.SHAUN SAVAGE believes parents can put some"skin in the game"by donating time,money or products which schools (This IN mat on furnished by Friends of Shaun Savage.) j 147 �J Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CANDIDATE FOR CONTINUED . State Treasurer ROSE MARIE . the highly regulated condition of both the economy and our elect tions,the only ones who=win are those who already control F BORCH ERS the game.And they are the Very same people who destroyed the economy and crippled our democracy: Fr; NeW Alliance The job of State Treasurer is to determine how the wealth of Party ; our state will be invested.I say Oregon's resources need to be invested on behalf of all the people of our state,not just the 1% OCCUPATION: that now controls most of the wealth.I'm running with Lenora PoaCUPATIO B.Fula as p�of a new democracy movement which is tak- Post-raity Student: ing steps to deregulate the economy and deregulate democracy. OCCUPATIONAL As a voter you need to take a step also. BACKGROUND: VOTE INDEPENDENT for myself, for Sarah Lyons for y Postsecondary Secretary of State and Lenora B.Fulani for President. Vocational School, founder and Chief Executive Officer; Homemaker-Mother; Community Activist. EDUCATIONAL ' BACKGROUND: Candidate,Master of Science in Guidance and Counseling; Bachelor of Arts, Elementary Education,University of Portland, 1992;Attended Laurelwood Academy, Gaston, Oregon,1953. PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:Appointed to and served on Washington State Governor's Advisory Council for Employment and Training Partnership Act,9183 to,9/85 I,Rose Marie Borchers,am a candidate for State Treasurer, ' running on the New Alliance Party slate headed by indepen- dent'presidential candidate Dr.Lenora.B.Fulani,because I believe that it is the people of Oregon who must decide how to invest Oregon's financial resources, '. Oregon's job losses are getting worse. Our com ipities are a dependent on natural resources for jobs and income:Oregon faces a future of painful increases in joblessness based on the erosion of our natural resource base.As a state we are not alone.The basic economic and political fact in America today is that the current distribution of wealth is inconsistent with a growth economy.The vast numbers of Americana who are unemployed,underemployed and living in poverty make recov- ery impossible because they'are increasingly unable.to buy even the necessities of life. Unlike the beautiful mountains,forests and coastline of our state,the economy of Oregon is not a natural phenomenon.It is the result of human beings making choices about how and what to produce.And the decisions made by the Republicans WId Democrats of the past 40 years here and all over America have resulted in the collapse of the economy.Both political parties t have sold out our future and that of our children.The proles- sional politicians and the big money interests got theirs and left the ordinary people holding the bag: Clearly the people being' hurt by Oregon's economic collapse need to be the ones who fig- ure out how to reorganize what we produce and how we produce it. r While"business'as usual"politicians argue about who has the"right"family values, the people of Oregon are at risk.. Joblessness creates the conditions that tkput our society at risk— not lifestyles,sexual preference or cultural differences. If we are going to have a shot at winning health care for all of us,jobs, a decent education for our children,houses to live in and the restoration of our natural resource base,then we, Oregon people,American people,have to break'some bad voting habits.We've been convinced.by,those already in office,of course,that we,should vote for winners.But at this point,given (This information furnished by Borchers for State Treasurer.) 148 C ` ,. .:. , N a , DIDATE_FOR ° d�1992 General voters Pam hlet .. State,°:'1 r CONTINUED ensurer DAVID Director, where he helped-hold the line on property y ness taxes.He consistently earned national re gniiti'on for his CFI�iV'.. excellence in financial reporting from the Municipal:Finance Officers Association of the United States and Canada. Republican In 1986, he was named Oregon.. a Director`.o8°tlie U.S. OCCUPATION: Farmers Home Administration(FmZW,the,State's largest Financial Mana r. agricultural lender. Ini;1990,'David-was.recruited to ge Washington,where he served as:Associate �dmiiiistrator'of the r'.. OCCUPATIONAL, , BACKGROUND: FmHA,,the federal governments.chief,agriculture"'and?rural Associate development agency.At the ,, mans ]!mLiA,David played'a,key role m Administrator, grog a.loan portfolio exceeding$50 billion and successfully { "Farmers Home worked to,bring new management efficiencies to the,agency: :Administration,U.S.' ` Oregon's leadmg'farm organization,may have gamed it up Department of ti Agriculture, best: "We believe David Chen's-experience in,public finance Washington,D.C., administration over the last 20 years makes him uniquely ly goal- ' n ified for he of(1990-91);Oregon, ice.He's got the experience and ideology to.truly State Director serve the people Oregon.We feellthere's no;canilidate more Farmers Home qualified." AC, Administration,U.S. -•Oregon Farm Bureau (• Department of March 2,1992, �5 Agriculture, " ` (1986 '90); Portland,Oregon DAVID CI�N i� ,. Finance Director, City o Beaverton,.Oregon A PLANFOR SOUND FINANCIAL MpNAC1IIVVIENN,r (1977-.8b);Finance Director/'14•easuret for 3 city/county govern - ments(1971-77);Adrninistrative.Assistant for 2 city meats(1969-71);Credit Negotiator/Assistant Trader,National Ilan to Orel n s StategTre evidenced by lus six point Bank of Commerce of Seattle Washin p go ash' gtdn(1966-69).. EDUCATIONAL-BACKGROUND:MA in political Science "We need to improve the financial management practicei" (Internatio ays.And nal;Laws and Relations), University of Oregon-. accountability in the State Treasurer's office,"David s Eugene; B.A.-in Mathematics, University of Washington- that's what the"Chen Plan"offers: Seattle;B.A.in Public Administration, National Chung Hsin University,Taipei,.Taiwan.. David has proposed a system of new internal controls to review PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:Associate the state,'s investment transactions:,He will institute regular i Administrator, Farmers 'Home Administration, U.S. 'performance analyses and reform.current cash management Department of Agriculture,Washington,D.C. (1990-91); City 'practices to ensure Oregon,is maximizing investment returns. "Councilor, City of Beaverton, (1986-89); Council President (1989); Oregon State Director,:Farmers Home Administration To help get the State's economy moving.'David's plan includes s U.S..Department of Agriculture;,Portland,.Oregon(1986-90); expanding the use of"Private Activity Bonds"to help finance Finance Director;City of Beaverton,Oregon(1977-85) Finance business,expansion and create new jobs.'He will,require fiscal Directortrreasurer for 3 city/county governments (1971-77); impact:statements---�similar to.environmental.impact state Administrative Assistant for 2 city governments(1969-71). ments—on any changes to policies affecting state.lands. Community Service:Long active as a community olunteer, f, ty - g David served on the Boards of Directors of the Beaverton Sister David is also committed to take aJ 'a'rs}up role in other areas Cities:Foundation,Inc.; the Oregon Chapter of the American that will help create jobs in Oregon—like"using his special Red Cross;.the,Tualatin Mental Health Center• and the knowledge of the Pacific Rim to promote exports of State prod ' ' American Heritage Association. ucts• i" Personal Background:David Chen,57,was born in Nanking,' � , ' China.His family fled China during the Communist takeover in. DAVID CIIEN. 1949.Seeking freedom and opportunity,David emigrated to the MMGRIM EXPERIENCE AND LEADERSHIP-.1 United States in 1963.David and his wife, Debbie currently f reside in Beaverton with their three children:Winston,Wylie Throughout his career,David has been known for his honesty; and Winnie. integrity and competence.As a recognized expert in public finance,he has the knowledge to manage State funds more DAVID CHEN: effectively—to maximize investment returns and help strength- A PROFESSIONAL MONEY MANAGER en Oregon's economy. NOT A CAREER POLITICIAN ;' The bottom line is this:In these times,we can't afford to elect a David Chen is not a career'politician. He is a professional State Treasurer who requires on-the-job training.And that's money manager,and he is running for State Treasurer for one why we need David Chen basic reason:To improve the way,State funds are managed "I seek the office of State Treasurer with great enthusiasm," David says."I believe that my experience as a professional' 4 'These are tough times;'David says;"and we need to invest j more State resources to create jobs and opportunity right,here money manager has prepared me to meet a standard of service in Oregon.,As State Treasurer,that will be my number one pri- that Oregonians expect and deserve." �' ority." DAVID CHEN. i! DAVID CHEN: A STA'T'E TREASURER WE CAN BANK ON i ! UNIQUELY QUALIFIED FOR THE JOB For eight years;David Chen served as Beaverton City Finance. (This lnformaflon furnlshed by Friends of Devfd Chen Comrnittee'j 149 it Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CANDIDATE FOR State"Treasurer JIM "Jim.combines attributes of vision and sound judgment that �a� r make him an effective leader Tom Bruggere bPreside t, H I I.�. Mentor'Graphics Corp : "I am confident that Jim HA as a member`.of the'State �d ' R Democrat Board,has the skills to get-the highest rate.of.return4froxgi , e = =' Common School Fund to help pay for:the education of qulchil- OCCUPATION. dren" -Karen Famous;',,President, Oregon Education Corporate Accounts. Association. ��Aty h , Y x� F'Manager Mentor Graphics Jim Hill fits the job �I Corporation;State "Hill's legal,business and legislative background-plus his Senator. sound ideas for protecting Oregon's bond rating;promo. cap- ,: OCCUPATIONAL ital formation in the state and mn:rL+?ing the return on state UPI BACKGROUND: investments-combine to make him clearijr•,the`stronger,of the PEN-NOR Inc.; two contenders'E.igene Register-Guard in its Mai 11 199 `General Contractors ; „�,6 Primary editorial endorsement ' Director of 'Marketing;State The real job facing Oregon's State'Treasurer 3s bl ger,than " Farm Insurance, being a clerk/money manager. Personnel Specialist As The Register-Guardf reposted`on May 11, "' e,office* and Consultant; requires more than money-management,skills:It requires poYit R Ore gon Department, ical judgment,an understanding of broad policy—as opposed`to' k = of Revenue;Hearings just•fmancial-issues, and:a.'sensitivityto'the en Referee;Oregon and economic balances that must bey achieved invitpnmehtal.'issues'that Department ofJustice,Assistant Attorney General. come before the state Land Board." EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND: Master of Business The'Ore onion stated on May 6, 1992 "Chen(Bill's o t ' Administration-Indiana''• University; Doctor of g y ppo- Jurisprudence-Indiana University; Bachelor'of Arts in nent)shocked the editors at how little'grasp he had of the sub.- Economics-Michigan State University. tleties of land use issues: And as The Register-Guard'added on PRIOR;:GOVERNMENTAL W.ERIENCE:.Oregon State May 11,"He(Chen)has woefully little grasp of the implications Senate--1984''to:Present: Chair,''Committee on Business, of service on the Land Board and his political judgment'is Housing and Finance;Vice-Chair,'-Committee on the Judiciary; untested on the large policy issues that might mvolve,the tree- Member, Committee'on Trade &,Economic Development; surer Member,Interim Transportation Committee.,Oregon House of Jim Hill's priorities for Treasurer ' Representatives-1983-4987:Co-Chair,Committee on Trade& ' Economic Development;Member,Committee on the Judiciary; '!I'will be a;State:Treasurer who puts Ore gonians`And our Member,,Committee on 10 Member, Committee on economy first. Agriculture,Forestry&Natural Resources.Assistant Attorney everything possible to preserve the quality of.life in k General,'DepartmentofJustice . ' Oregon that.we all are so proud of.To do that we-must create . more'decent paying jobs:As your State Treasurer,1 will invest Jim Hill has earned our trust. in Oregon as much as is prudently possible to create these jobs:' 'Jim Hill,like no•other candidate for State.Treasurer,has „My parities for State Treasurer are - May of Oregonians..Hereceived more votes in the May Primary Election than any other candidate on the ballot To be a leader in creating new jobs. , dent U S:Senate and Congress.including those forPresi ngre Prudently invest in Oregon jobs which are as"good,as "Jim Hill's reputation in private business,'.public service and sound and return just as much money to`the"state y for personal integrity is unmatched: ' treasury as'investments in jobs in New';York, • It was Hills initiative`that protected Oregon businesses London or,Tokyo.We need those jobs ­' ;'y' • moratorium on public'Works and other from hostile takeovers .•, ;., `Lift the bond `Ast ,,:., needed projects. Chair'of..the Business, Housing and Finance p j Committee in the State Senate,Hill drafted legislation and led Oppose any raids on our senior citizens'.retirement the fight-to pass the'package`of bills that saved our Veterans' funds Home Loan ond mina from foimulatin an Expand our baccalaureate bond program to help families played g economic finance their children's education. growth,strategy using proceeds from the state lottery; • Demand that State Treasury employees be held to the Jim Hill has earned our respect. highest ethical standards:`The`Stste Treasurer r should,be barred from:moving'from this position'of "Hill has enmeshed-himself in business,economic develop- public trust to the sales offices or boardrooms of big ment and finance activities.He is acutely,aware of the need to Wall Street or foreign investment firms.!, ; prevent any lowering of the state's bond rating and has good ideas about,how the treasurer can help.counteract Oregon's Jim Hill,trusted for his judgment.-respected for his:1 capital-poor.status A-The:Oregonian in,its May 5,1992 editori- l�dership•••and committed to Oregon's economic futum al endorsing Jim Hill "Jim is honest;straightforward and above all prudent." -John Kitzhaber,M.D.,P•resident,,Oregon State Senate. "Jim'Hill comes from.a background of strong values.Hard work,integrity and a clear sense of public service are part of the measure of a person and their value to the community." Matthew Prophet,former Superintendent, Portland Public' (This information furnished by the Jim Hill for State Treasurer • , , Schools Committee.) ..,?. . ... .. .,.. .... 150.'... . CANDIDATE FAR Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet f CONTINUE CO .fi h Attome General Eo . N M , TED TED KULONGOSKIe TOUGH'ON BUREAUCRACY KULONGOSKI Ted returned approximately$ll million to ore' n" consumers through beefed up enforcement"efforts, t he Democrat Department of Insurance and Finance 9 Ted helped save millions of dollars for businesst and govern_ .- ment through long overdue reform of the state worke OCCUPATION: Pensation syste r's com- m. Attorney. ,., Y• Ted demanded on the,fob safety requirements in:the work= OCCUPATIONAL place;worker illness and injury rates plunged DeputtyDistn Attorney, Neil Goldschmidi;`former Oregou Governor,,'* M, g Multnomah County; "red Kulongoski took apart a state agency dominated Executive Director,•. by insurance and banking interests and put it back Metropolitan Family together in the public interest,Ted will:brin to the Service;Director,; attorney general's office the cam g e energy and commit Oregon Department went to solvin g tough Of Insurance and problems:' ;, f k Finance;Attorney in private practice with TED KULONGOSKi. the Oregon law firm, "' 'TOUGH ON POVERTY.THAT HURTS FA1VIIIdES t Kulongoski,Durham, Ted believes that'strong,healthy families and children depend " Drummonds and on a decent family income: Child support'Payments, .> Colombo,(1974- the difference,between,dependence and o can mean 1987),specializing in labor law;Bricklayer;Steelworker pportunitn between e driver. ,Truck families destroyed and families strengthened.Ted pledges that EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND:B.A.`1967,University,of ;families will get the child support they deserve. , Missouri;J.D.1970,University of Missouri-Columbia School of c ' Law. TED KULONGOSKIi PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: Director, TESTED BY EM ;I Oregon Department of Insurance and Finance, 1987-1991; Ted is the ONLY candidate for Attorney General who: ? Oregon State Senator,1977-1983(Lane County);Oregon State • has tried felony cases,. Representative,1974-1977(Lane County);Member,Governor's Juvenile Corrections Task Force, 1977;Member, Governor's has worked in a district attorney's office Adult Corrections Task Force,1975. •,is admitted to practice in both the U.S:District Court for , Oregon and Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Born November 5,1940 has sueoessfully tried criminal and civil cases in both state Married;three children.Wife Mary Oberst is an attorney with and federal courts and argued appeals in both state and federal ' the Oregon State Bar. appellate courts. ' Veteran!U.S.Marine Corps • has run a large agency TED KULONGOSKI:DUTY,HONOR,COUNTRY "Based on his experience' and abihties,Rulongoski has From serving in the;Marines to directing non-profit social ser- the Potential to be an unusually.effective attorney gen. d g P oral,a fitting successor to Dave Frohnmayer." r vice-agency to,working as'a deputy district attorney, Ted Kulongoski believes in giving something back to his country ( Oregonian;April 23, and community.In fact,public service is a Tamil tradition— son,Ted E. is a Peace Corps volunteer in Africa, daughter TED KULONGOSKi: `I Kristen is a Vista Volunteer in Wyoming, and son Justin is a TRUSTED TO DO WHAT'S RIGHT campaign volunteer. Ted is endorsed by the Oregon State Police Officers'Association ' and the Oregon Council of Police Associations..:. TED KULONGOSKI:TOUGH ON CRIME Mike Schrunk,Multnomah County District Attorney,says:"I Ted believes in the bedrock principles upon which safe and believe we need Ted Rulongoski on our side in thear strong communities are built: .w t against gangs and drug-related crime—he understands s Taking responsibility for your own actions what it takes to protect the lives and property of • Respecting the civil rights of others Oregonians." �1 Breaking the law means paying the consequences i ,TED KULONGOSKI:... . Ted will uphold the laws as Attorney General,guided by these OREGON'S ATTORNEY GENERAL G ' fundamental beliefs. Tough on crime Tested by expe I� ' Te rienoe Ii "(Kulongoski) would take an out Trusted to do what's right iY 4 in important areas such as city gangs,leadership role FINALLY-SOMEONE TO VOTE EM y gangs, the war on ,. drugs,and maintaining prison space." (The Observer,La Grande,May 6,1992) Er (This/nformatlon furnished by Ted Kulongoski for Oregon Attomey General Committee.) 1, Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CANDIDATE FOR CONTINUED Attorne .General '.y t FRED CIVIL RIGHTS OF cITIZENs - OERTHER Most of the budget for the A.G.office comes from'contracts providing-counsel to various state agencies;I milll instructsmy �.• Libertarian staff to consider above all else the constitutional,civil±rights of d the'citizens when such counsel is drawn up.It must be'possible; F OCCUPATION: for instance,to do a better job of collecting child;suppoi't%�paY; d - Organic Farmer. ments and supporting the victims of crime without using 1301 e. `OCCUPATIONAL state tactics. #_ BACKGROUND: , Retired Physician. PRIORITIES OF THIS OFFICE '` ` -EDUCATIONAL EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND: ,s `University of Have,you noticed that crimes of violence and crimes against ,r Michigan 1955-59,` property have risen steadily over the past 12 years,that you are ` B.A.degree 1958; less well protected and defended while the street price ofheroin . Wayne State ' and cocaine is one-fourth?Have you noticed the war;on:drugs is ' University College of a fraudulent scam mostly at the'insistence of the federals who ; x Medicine 1959-63, think too many Oregonians are disobedient and should be " M.D.degree 1963; locked up'and otherwise jerked around by the criminal system } If ti• Intern&Resident,, as punishment? lo Internal Medicine, ID, %Detroit'Receiving Hospital I will bring new priorities to the policies and programs of this Fellowship"University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, office.The time and energy now spent on'this fraudulent"war Parkland'Ho'spita11966-68;Oregon State University Extension �be changed to truly protective functions such as catching Service Master Gardener,Q978 on Sta a Uni Master Small Farmer and punishing murderers,robbers,rapists,thieves,those who . 1981;Otherwise'auto-didact. abuse women,children,minorities,those who cause environ- PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: U.S. Army ,mental pollution of soil,air,and water,those who defraud the Medical Service 1969-70;Vietnam 1M-1969;Discharged-with consumer in the marketplace rank of Major,1970 W ' PRINCIPLES QUALIFICATIONS` I do not believe in nor do I advocate the initiation of force or I am qualified for this office because I understand Latin and I violence for the achievement of social or political goals.`As:a know how to hire and fire lawyers and managers. . ` Libertarian, I seek a non-violent society,a free'market econo- my,a tolerant self-governing society,disestablishment of privi- lege,and decentralization. There is no constitutional or statutory requirement that I be a lawyer:`I am running for this office because I think"the Sys- - tem°isn't working,and neither do most of the'people in it.I am If you are dissatisfied with the current`available choices to tired of supporting it and them and want to see new priorities, express your social and political goals through the partisan policies,,and, brought;into,the government. electoral political process, please consider the Libertarian x Government was,instituted to protect and defend us in the Party.All we ask in our pledge of non-violence is that!you and s' exercise of our natural:;rights,'yet we.see-government and its we have this extreme care for the morality of our means of agents acting like a blundering bully,engaged in central and achieving our social and political goals.We can be rid of govern.4 intimidation,we see the repeated establishment(using the tax- 'ment of do as I say,not as I do.Please join us.I am in the phone ing and police power)of privilege'(wherein some are made more book.Thanks for your attention. equal than others)bylegislation driven by vested special inter- ests(big bucks.),. CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM ' Look`at the°so-called criminal`justice system. The justice F: seems'to'be°on`.vacation,"leaving only the criminal system behind,'in the care'of the officers of the court and the officers of the law,neither of whom seem to be under civilian control.I will advocate we stop using taxpayer money for any two of the state's law schools as a step to get lawyers under control.I am sure there are.,honest police,just as I am sure there are some ^ good,useful lawyers.Having said that,I will push for legisla- tion to put every armed officer in this"state under,immediate civilian oversight and review,collective bargaining agreements x. and union contracts notwithstanding.And I will push to replace the system of secret grand juries with a system of open coroners inquests:Using the priorities,'policies and programs of this ; office,I will resist legislation which would make.Oregon more of a police state. (This lnformadon furnished by Frederick J.Oerther,M.O.) ,.k 152 CANDIDATE FOR offciW 1992 Genera I voters'Pam hint n Attorney,:,Genelal 4 RICH . RICH RODEMAN-COMPARED TO HIS OPPONENT RODEMAN Rich is . only Y to . who,supports DEATH PENALTY, Republican, Rich is a first time candidate and'career public attorney Opponent is a professional•Po$timan and has run for 5 differ OCCUPATION eat offices in last 15 years! w ° RAttorne y. ich is only candidat e o to mabage'a pub; law ofTce OCCUPATIONAL Rich supports term limits;limiting his job to 2 terms.(cvr ' BACKGROUND: rently there's-no limit on Attorney General terms) Corvallis City, • Rich supports timber jobs,his opponent wanted environmen Attorney,1981.1992;` tal protection for BIGFOOT!'.. Corvallis Deputy City Rich wants an elected Attorney General his o 4. 'Attorney,1978-1981. believes the Governor should appoint Y PPonent Rich brings 14 years' the AG a experience as a pub ; r lic attorney with RICH RODEMAN-A STRONG CAREER PROSECUTOR # F background in prose cation,enforcing , . Over a decade experi ence as criminal pro secutor ' y N ' Oregon's open,meet- Member Oregon District Atty's Association since 1980 ! s j ings and records Successful advocate'before Oregon'Supreme and pppeas '.' laws,a recognized expert in labor and courts thorough knowled of land use law,and a ge government law. Rich worked through RICH RODEMAN'S ACTION PLAN FOR OREGON school as a teaching assistant at Willamette University,meat cutter,tax preparer,and retail clerk.. ' EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND:Law degree, Willamette Make Attorney General NONPARTISAN and remove politics University, 1977;Bachelor's,Humboldt State University rom the job, (grad- uated with high honors,Magna Cum Laude)1975. (grad Enforce strict term limit fo`r Attorney General PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: League of •'Stronger enforcement of Oregon's consumer protection laws. Oregon Cities,Legislative and Legal Advisory Committee(s); • Crack down on telephone marketers and make them pay Portland.Community,College,Program Advisory Committee; 'their share of enforcement costs. _ Legislative Aide,State Senator Wallace Carson;,Administrative• •'Improve coordination and upgrade ort' ro am Aide,Humboldt County;U.S.Congressional Intern. e c su PP P gr FAMILY:Married to Kathy,Field Rodeman,,Fiscal Manager Establish efficient standards for legal services for the Corvallis School District 509J:Father of 4 boys;two of Demand"full compliance with Ethics laws whom were adopted from Cambodia.Rich is a third generation Fight for citizen rights as Ore gon,implements 1Lleasure`5 . law enforcement officer: COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT:Rich and Kathy are active ` in community programs, schools, soccer, scouts and adoption OREGON NEEI)S A PROPECS161Y support groups:Rich has worked over 20 years in community 4 projects/activities; and promoted programs for community NOTAPOLITICIAN mediation,libraries,job training,and children. RODEMAN'S PHILOSOPHY: Rich, like James Madison AS ATTORNEY GENERAL ; believes, "Justice is the end of government"Let's elect an r Attorney General who will ensure Justice for Oregonians.Rich wants to be your Attorney General to provide effective legal ser- RICH RODEMAN, vices to make government work better. A PROFESSIONAL-NOT A POLITICLAN! ) FOR OREGON'S ATTORNEY GENERAL RICH RODEMAN k' RICH RODEMAN—RECOGNIZED PROFESSIONAL AT'T'ORNEY Nationally ecd ii Y gnized expert in government law • Chaired,Oregon Bar Government Law Section • Chaired,'Oregon Bar Administrative Law Committee t Who's Who in American Law,listed since 1990 • 14 years representing ers/citizens g taxp Y I, Advised hundreds of elected-a • ppointed officials • 700 Laws written...none overturned (This Information furnished by Oregonians for Rodeman.J 163 II Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CANDIDATE FOR St6te"SenatO 27THr> DISTRICT NEIL R. BOB BRYANT ,.PICKARD ' . Republican ' Democrat OCCUPATION: OCCUPATION • Attorney:" sv Rancher/legislator' OCCUPATIONAL OCCUPATIONAL' BACKGROUND: BACKGROUND: General practice Teacher,school ,attorney since 1973, administrator;U.S. !" partner with the firm Forest Service;con of Holmes,Hurley, sultant. Bryant,Lovlein& EDUCATIONAL. 'Lynch. " BACKGROUND: ! EDUCATIONAL Chapman College," BACKGROUND: z B A Law Degree, PRIOR Willamette GOVERNMENTAL University(1973); EXPERIENCE: Bachelor of Arts in Deschutes'County History from Pacific .': Board of Lutheran University Equalization; (1970);McNary High School,Salem(1966):; Deschutes Extension Advisory Board;Redmond School Board; PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: Chair, Legislative committees: Special Committee:on''Children's Deschutes County Children&Youth Services Commission; Issues, chairman;Water Policy; Environment& Energy, Steering Committee,Your,Community 2000; Chair, Bend Education;Forest Products Task Force. Development Board." COMMUNITY SERVICE: Rocky Mountain Elk"Foundation; WHILE OTHERS;TALK...NEIL GETS THINGS DONE.` Bend Chamber of Commerce; Central Oregon Arts Society; Oregon Hunters Association;Central Oregon.Flyfishers. FOR EDUCATION AND KIDS.:. BOB PICKARD:PEOPLE FIRST - While the politicians talk about education,Neil Bryant is busy Bob co-sponsored the Oregon Education 2000 Act to prepare our, taking action.When Central Oregon schools were in crisis,Neil schools and youth to meet the.challenges of the future. Bob Bryant;rolled up his sleeves and went to'work.Together with sponsored legislation to improve rural healthcare opportunities parents,teachers,,community.leaders and students,Neil helped and transportation services for elderly and disabled lead the successful campaign'to stabilize funding for Bend/LaPine'schools. The result;better funding, four new BALANCING JOBS AND ENVIRONMENT schools,with less crowded classrooms and a brighter future for Bob has earned a solid reputation of balancing jobs'with pro- our children.,, tecti the environment. He opposed the'dams on the Upper NEIL GETS THINGS DONE. Desch tes and passed legislation to protect-90 miles of the Deschutes River.He has sponsored legislation to update water TO PROTECT QUALITY OF LIFE... records and assure wise use of our scarce resources.Bob has been a strong advocate for small businesses and co-authored a Our region is changing.Neil Bryant understands that to protect workers'compensation reform package that.The Oregonian i the quality of life that makes Central Oregon special,we must called`well-balanced'(2/21/90).Bob's common sense approach plan for the future.Neil was selected to help lead the,citizens' has earned him high vote ratings from both Associated group that developed a plan to manage growth—Your Oregon Industries and the League of Conservation Voters. Community 2000.It outlines how we can balance the need for RESPONSIVE GOVERNMENT jobs with the desire for less traffic,cleaner air and water, and Bob has"worked hard for the le of Central Oregon:tougher more green space:While others may talk about quality of life, PceP go Neil Bryanfs already there, looking ahead...and doing some- pbnalties on drugdealers and abusers;improved college oppor- thing about it tunities in rural areas;stabilized veterans'home and farm loan program;local highway improvements and safety programs.- NEIL GETS THINGS DONE. Bob has sponsored legislation to strengthen Oregon govern- ment ethics laws and to clean up campaign financing loopholes. FOR RESULTS,NOT POLITICS... PEOPLE BEFORE POLITICS ' From kids to Rotary Club,Neil Bryant is involved.He was one. Oregon's greatest challenge is managing change:Bob listens to of the people that brought together The Community of 10,000 to people and works for thoughtful solutions.Bob gives straight assure support and.stability for our schools.He chaired the answers and has the courage to cast tough'votes.He has earned Children and Youth Services Commission'and helped establish our trust. the Rosie Bareis Campus that gives young people a helping "We must put people first.That means investing our limited hand and,a place to belong.,Neil led the effort to revitalize downtown Bend making,it a place people want to go again. resources wisely to avoid costly problems is the future.,' ' That's leadership! BOB PICKARD.FOR OREGON'S FUTURE NEIL BRYANT FOR OREGON SENATE. This lformadon furnished b B ant for Oregon Senate Committee. ( n Y. 4' 9 ) (This Information furnished by Pickard for State Senate.) �. 154 CANDIDATE FOR Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet State'.R e resentativ` 54TH e, DISTRICT x4 Dui MARGE GARROW `DENNIS R. Democrat r w , u c a n OCCUPATION: Lawyer. `'OCCUPATION OCCUPATIONAL Small Businessman' * Buildin emodeling s BACKGROUND: g� Claims Examiner; Contractor. Foster Care OCCUPATIONAL' Caseworker, "BACKGROUND:A „ $ Personnel specialist• d generation car. EDUCATIONAL repenter,Deems is. BACKGROUND:, =proud to have been`^ J D.,University s-:able to start-a con- ty'of tractinjbusiness spew, Oregon;1983;B.A., �}yr University of re n, in medium- `priced homes in ` 1966;Ashland High Deschutes Coun 'School,1962. President,+"Central, r PRIOR Oregon Builders; GOVERNMENTALi Association;Oregon EXPERIENCE:Vice-chair, Deschutes Central Committee; Builder iotheYear; Precinct Committee-person. 1991. :` EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND:North Salem high School ; COMMUIVITY'SERVICEc Campfire Leader;J Bar J Youth graduate; Oregon State University,.,mathematics:ani political Services;League of Women Voters science major,continuing education classes. ' MARGE GARROW—THE RIGHT CHOICE PRIOR.GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:aOr"ego''n Marge"Garrow knows our community, epartment of"Education Committee on Trades Cunciilum MarieM nity its problems and potergny' Oregon State Treasurer's Business AdvisoryICommittee; listens,then takes action.We must put her energy, city/county urban development committee integrity and common,sense approach to work forpg in Salem. +. , As our representative,Marge will work to make our state v. IACRGROUND/FAMILY:-Married Central Oregon native go Joanne Copley in 1968. Two sons:Matthew is the fourth gener. r ernment better and more efficient.She'll seek ways of balancin g ation in the carpentry/construction business,and Brian is in' our state budget without,imposing new burdens on families, seniors and businesses. She will fight for a legislature that Navy flight training: r serves the people,not the politicians. COMMUNITY:Active in the community for 19 years: Member THE RIGHT CHOICE FOR JOBS:It's time to get Oregon mov- of , Bend': and - LaPine, Chambers ,-of Commerce: ing forward a Volunteer-Habitat;for Humanity's:"Home in a Week"and gain,As our new representative Marge Garrow Redmond Teen Mother House.;Scoutmaster/10 year Scouting, will fight to r. award. Dennis has represented himself, business, and others ' Protect the economic interests of Central Oregon families, before county and state government. Denms`was.1991 Oregon seniors and businesses; Builder of the Year for outstanding community service. stop raw log exports to`save our timber industry;and`cre- ate new jobs'with high pay and long-term o CENTRAL OREGON IS SPECIAL g pportumty. Central Oregon is very special plao�+to live and make a living: THE RIGHT CHOICE'FOR'EDUCATION:Education is the N' key to our,future;.Marge Garrow will work to We enjoy the unique environment and beauty bestowed upon us restore educational excellence and ensure adequate local by nature: We must respect and enhance this wonderful gift. I. funding under Measure 5, EDUCATION provide families expanded education options,and employ- Oregon needs to invest in its future,not its ast: Ad ers awell-educate hi cation for our children must be•a to priority 1a i; d,highly skilled workforce. top, use of our'tax , THE RIGHT CHOICE FOR HEALTH CARE:We must.save' money: We need to prepare our children for tomorrow's chal- health care reform.Marge Garrow will be a strong voice to lenges. -' guarantee access to quality medical care;for all COMMON SENSE&FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY l s Oregonians,'including rural residents,seniors and work- We must use a common sense business approach to solve the ing families; problems of State E government,' We can't'afford government by '. control exploding health care costs that hurt families and gridlock. seniors,,and harm the ability of local businesses to LAW ENFORCEMENT• in the global economy. Hard crime deserves hard time Administration should be cut THE RIGHT CHOICE FOR GROWTH MANAGEMENT:We before police and prisons, need sensible I' fight to growth,not urban sprawl,Marge Garrow will 'SIIVIORB curb overdevelopment in Bend and channel sensible Our senior citizens have worked hard for their retirement:We' growth to timber-dependent communities; need to protect the quality of life with cost effective government. preserve open space and our dwindling water supply. DENNIS will LISTEN,LEARN,and LEAD DENNIS LURE:UNIQUE LEADERSHIP FOR A UNIQUE AREA (This lnformatlon fumishsd by The Committee to Elect W a Garrow. Elect DENNIS LUKE . • r9 ) (Th/s in/omrat/on fum/shed by Commmee to,E190 Dennis Luke.) Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet CANDIDATE FOR 55TH State Representativ*e DISTRICT 'A BEVERLY CLARNO Republican OCCUPATION: Rancher;Legislator. 5 ' °OCCUPATIONAL BACKGROUND:' - �Cor�tsultant- _ Securities Examiner, Corporation Division, °',State of Oregon; Wheat and Hog Farmer;Real Estate Instructor, Appraiser-Oregon, Broker-Oregon& Washington;Circuit' Court Reporter. ' 'EDUCATIONAL,\ BACKGROUND: Graduate of Redmond'High`School; B.S. Communications/ Management,Marylhurst College;attended Lewis&Clark Law School. . �. PRIOR''GOVERNMENTAL EXPERI ENCE:Mid-Columbia Economic Development Commission; State Representative since 1989; Appointed'Majority Whip 1991; Legislative Committees:Chair,:Agency Reorganization&Reform,Revenue & School'Finance,Legislative Rules,&Reapportionment, Human Resources;Agriculture Forestry&Natural Resources, Joint Legislative`Audit,•Emergency-Board;Joint Bench/Bar Committee on New Judgeships., BACKGROUND:`Fourth-generation Oregonian, graduate of Redmond High School, married,'mother of four,private pilot. Community:.Boys & Girls Aid Society; School Scholarship Chairman;Foster Parent;'High Desert Museum; Citizens for a Drug-Free Oregon;'League of - Women-Voters;Oregon Cattlemen's Assoc.;Agri- Business'�Council;President Women's Society of Christian Service; Outstanding Young Woman Award 1975;United Methodist Church;Chamber of Commerce in Bend, Redmond, Sisters and ` `Jefferson Co. "A STRONG VOICE HERE,FOR OVER THERE" RESPONSIBLE, EVERIENCED,LEADERSHIP FOR DIS- TRICT 55• CRIME: Bev supports alcohol and drug education and treat- r ment,increased victims'rights,and reducing the high cost of indigent defense. SCHOOLS:Bev feels quality and equitable education must be'a top legislative priority. SENIOR CITIZENS:Bev knows seniors have laid the founda- �Aion for our community and should not be denied the dignity,of sufficient health care. GOVERNMENT:Bev pledges continued monitoring of govern- ment waste and mismanagement of taxpayer rh money..During the 1991 Legislative Session Bed introduced Legislation to save taxpayers 30 Million dollars: (This infonnatlon furnished by The Committee to Reelect Beverly Clarno.) r 166 , Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CANDIDATE FOR DESCHUTES COUNTY C , :POSITION NO:2 Y . PETE BARRY PEDONE SLAUGHTER Democrat Republican , OCCUPATION: " OCCUPATION Self-employed Manager;Arnold Worker Safety and Irrigation Distract. !> Environmental , ' consultant. : OCCUPATIONAL BACKGROUND: OCCUPATIONAL BACKGROUND: Supervisor& U.S.Military, Systems Analyst, Ford Motor Vietnam Veteran, Company;Warranty 1953-1980;Director, 'andipany;,Control Community ' Development.• Manager,', Planning,Puget �9�V,���i�.�y'�q��� ;Volkswagen PacMc National Service s, SofllndCouncilof I1' Government Development ' Manager,Nissan >• 1980-1983; •Motor Corp.in± '\ Washington State U.S.A.;owner of a , Hazardous Materials custom furniture Advisory Committee to the Governor,1981-1983;Adjunct company. Faculty,Columbia College,Seattle,1979=1989;Chair,Pierce EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND..B.S::in ,Business; County(Washington)Solid Waste Advisory Committee, Administration,Wittenberg University: I. ' 1986-1989;Self-employed Worker Safety and Environmental PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EgpERIETTCEc Nme years asV ' Consultant,1983-present;Part-time instructor,Central member Bend Urban Area Plarining.Commission,:Member Oregon Community College Business Department,Bend, Deschutes County Corrections Advisory Committee;Manager,; 1992 present. Arnold Irrigation District;�Presidentt Deschutes County EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND:19731VI.B.A.,Golden Gate Historical Society,President,Regional Arts Council of Central University, San Francisco; 1962 B.S.,,l:ndustrial Relations & Oregon;Member,Your Community 2000 Subcommittees Personnel Management,San Jose State University. PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE: 1985-198 9 .During my 18 years as a resident of Deschutes County;Pve Vol_Elected Councilman,Town of Steilacoom,Washington. unteered hundreds of hours of my time to help make our com munity a.better place.Now many believe we are in danger of "Pedone has expressed a concern about preventing`sprawl losing our quality of life.I share those concerns.I am convinced growth'.It's an issue most Deschutes County residents are con that we can harness change in a way that will preserve our way cerned about.Unlike some people who have moved here only to of life,and improve it. tout the need for the kinds of growth they left behind Pedone realizes that unrestricted growth would destroy those qualities THE CHALLENGE. that make Deschutes County special.He is intelligent, a good In'order to preserve our quality of b''f'e we must preserve our listener and a caring individual.And he is a candidate who is rural environment.We must also create good jobs affordable it not afraid to take a stand" housing,quality schools,and efficient systems:,Those improve- Ted Kramer,Editor,The Redmond Spokesman.,5/13/92 ments will only be funded by a healthy ecbnomy.If the county !i "Deschutes County is a precious commodity.We can keep it adopts"no-growth"policies,our environment,our economy,and that way by following Oregon's statewide land use planning our future will suffer. goals.Working together we can control growth so that we...n9t growth;dictate the final outcome."—Pete Pedone. DEMAND EFFICIENN'T GOVERNMENT - Drawing on my years as a systems analyst,I will examine the Pete will work hard to achieve: I county organization to make sure that departments'and . • Land use planning in accordance with Oregon laws. processes designed years ago become effective for today's condi- • Divers the economy tions. 'Diversify my...bring-in family wage jobs. • Provide dedicated leadership—listening to all the people. STOP THE SPRAWL_ • Adopt workable management plans for river_ I will focus on halting sprawl along main highways.Instead,I'll accessibility. \ encourage development in which mixes of housing and,retail • Work for affordable housing.' I ., . . ing.' grow and prosper in neighborhoods. ; Work for cleaner air and water...and conserving water. •. Support diversified economic expansion of the Redmond STREAMLINE PLANNING RULES. Airport; State land use guidelines are a good starting point,but I believe • .Continued support for human services provided by the we need to adapt those rules for use on this side of the moun m County. tas. PETE PEDONE KEEP;THE DOOR OPENFOR THE PEOPLE LEADERSHIP AND EXPERIENCE FOR DESCHUTES The people of Deschutes County represent.a pool;of unmatched COUNTY expertise.I will keep my office door open to hsten to every resi (This information dent.furnished by Committee to elect Pete Pedone Position r ; No.2,Deschutes CountyCommission.) - (This information furnished by Barry'Staughter J2), 157 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet + HOUSE DISTRICTS DWrict,Ma 54 AND 55 ;y p + ( DISTRICTS',. HOUSE 54 _ SENATE 54 & 55' - 27,, HOODRIVER wnsc0 TYBh CONGRESSIONAL =2 Valley e 216 I Maupin O o ' Wapinitia _--- I. Shaniko A S C . 0 218 28 Ant ope Warm ':Springs O F F R S 0 N w Metolius MADRAS , JEFFERSON Culver CROOK r . 20 28 Redmond -- Sisters 126 20 97 20 N i BEND 20 Brothers La Pine E S C H v 1 E . DESCHUTES DESCHUTES� - r :;. 7 KLAMATH. I LAKE LEGEND JEFFERSON , & DESCHUTES _ HOUSE DISTRICT B DISTRICT HOUSE OUNDARY � D STRICT'NUMBER 1 COUNTY BOUNDARY. COUNTIES MAR 158 Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet AIM 'A T -NON TI 4q kv • - 4 j 7, �. FK•t* lid a� it a Y s • •', I , y� hYK"7fr�V�.j.1{ATp��. , I The S DA- E PAR .M tate of Oregon has attemptetltocciirr c spelling errors, but is not;responsibleor g ` syntax or inaccuracies of:barididates state�nerr • 1b9 Official 1992 General Voters'Pam hlet CANDIDATE FOR JEFFERSON. COUNTY . IC6uhty'Sheffif SEAN F g MICHAEL L. CASEY � F .THROOP Nonpartisan Nonpartisan,.. OCCUPATION: OCCUPATION: Legal Invest ator& Sheriff;Jefferson Consultant,ff y' County. Employed party OCCUPATIONAL Management- Manager,Chambers 1B9A84 to presenv : . � Development Jefferson County, (Madras-Empac �'sl Sheriffs Office; Investors). E y OCCUPATIONAL Warm Springs Tribal BACKGROUND:15 Police Officer, •years of professional "Director of Public` experience,perform Safety,Castle Rock, ing Law Enforcement Washington;Castle and Legal Rock Police Officer; Investigations Ridgefield Police (Criminal and Civil ' Law)in bo h the p i.' Department, vate and plic sec- _., Reserves;Clark tors:Chief of Police, r County Sheriff's' Hoh River Washington-Chief Enforcement Division, Office Explorer Post. e• Department of Quileute Fish�c Wildlife Washington*n; EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND: 1983 Graduate Oregon Detective Deputy Sheriff Resident Deput Senior Officer Police `Academy, Interm diate Certificate; Graduate Clallam 3ounty Sheriffs bepartment,Washington;Corrections Washington Police Academy,Advance Patrol Officer;Over 1800 Staff/Inmate--Supervisor,ClallamrBay Corrections Center, ` o Washington;Le al Investigator&Consultant,Terry Roth' formal'Law Enforcement Training Hours;Attended Clark . Investigations,Port Angeles,Washington. College,Portland Community College, and Central Oregon EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND:Over 1600 hours of acade= Community College. mic studies and training in the fields of Criminal Justice,:Police PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:Jefferson Science,.and Legal Investigations; received from the following County Sheriff, Elected, paid;Jefferson County Undersheriff, named.schools and/or locations:Peninsula Community College, appointed,paid;Director of Public Safety,City of Castle.Rock, Port Angeles';Washington;Highline'Community College, Washington,'appointed,paid;Past Board Member,Jefferson Midway,Washington;Everett Community College, Everett, County Emergency Medical Services District,elected. Washington; University of Idaho,Moscow,Idaho;Universal Schools,Little Falls,New Jersey;American Police Academy, Mike Throop has over 20 years experience in the Law Washington,D.C.;Oregon Police Academy,Monmouth,Oregon; Enforcement field.Throop was elected Jefferson County Sheriff Washington State Criminal Justice Training Center, Police and took office in 1989.Since'taking over the reins as,Sheriff, Academy,Burien,Washington. Mike has been instrumental in forming the Narcotics Task PRIOR GOVERNMENTAL EXPERIENCE:None. Force Team which has had a great deal of impact on illicit drug activity in Jefferson County. LAW ENFORCEMENT COMMENDATIONS AND AWARDS:Certificate of Appreciation;Silver Star For Bravery; Mike has attended and successfully completed many training Good Samaritan Award;Life Saving Award; Officer Of The courses in Law Enforcement,has been certified as an instructor Year Award;Police Service Citation And Medal;Liberty And of Law Enforcement courses;and has brought numerous State Justice Award Of Merit. wide training seminars to Jefferson County. COMMUNI'T'Y INVOLVEMENT-ORGANIZATIONS: The American Police Academy,16-Year Member;Veteran's—The Mike has the initiative to get the job done and has brought new American Legion, Post No. 29, 20-Year Member; Fraternal and innovative ideas to the Jefferson County'Sheriffs Office. Order'Of Eagles,Aerie No.2089,19-Year Member;Benevolent Mike believes in giving the people of Jefferson County 24 hour , And Protective Order of Elks, Lodge No. 2017,07-Year protection and has been able to keep within the budget allotted Member. for Law Enforcement. MILITARY: United States Navy(Enlistment), National Mike has always maintained an"open door"policy allowing any Defense Service Medal,Honorable Discharge. citizen'to talk with him one on one.Mike has a strong conic- I am a 44 YEAR-0LD native CE1VTIiAi.-OREGONIAN hav- tion for community involvement and has worked and coordinat- ed many activities aimed directly to involve the youth of this ing been born and raised in Prineville.My wife Patti and I have community. two,children;a 20 year old son,Chanc Shane;and a 12 year old daughter,Cori Shannon. RE-ELECT MUM THROOP,JEFFERSON COUNTY Sean CASEY is a"POLICE OFFICER'S POLICE OFFI- SHERIFF . CER!".Elect INTEGRITY and CREDIBILITY for a change— VOTE BEAN CASEY for SHERIFF 1992. (This information furnished by Committee to Elect Sean Casey,,Sheriff 1992.) (This information furnished by Michael L.Throop.) 160 wdo- 1} ...... . ✓.�i V Ali '� Gffiaal 1992 General'Voters'Pamphlet _• - PreCIDESCHUTES CONTINUED ncts & Pollin :Pia g ces • UNTY Find your preeinct number in the left column.In addition to fir, , and con Yo polling place,it will dent' congressional district in the columns•at the right.If you have an �3'Ycgr,representative;senatorial please call the elections office. Some of the Polling Y questions abouti'which candidates you are eligible to vote for, accessible by election day.Check.published lists of polling places in grated here as inaccessible to elderly or disabled electors;may be ,. county clerk for-specific information on your polling place.He Your local newspaper just prior to',:election day,or,call,your t- assistance;in Jefferson County,47514451: Hearing impaired persons in Deschutes. may pall 388-6547 for Precinct and state' State U.S. Precinct Pollin Place Rep.,. Sen. Cong. and ",' State State'rU,S.11 ,Diet' Diet. Dist• Pollin Place �P• Sen.%.Cong. *: Bend 1 Diet• ,Diet:+"Diet. VFw Hall 54 27 2 * Bend 27 54 ;27 2 * Bend 2 'Kingston Elem.School , Bend Senior High School 54 27 2 Redmond 28 . * Bend 3 Redmond Armory 56 2 Deschutes County Public Works 54 27 2 * Redmond 29 Redmond Senior Center 65 r 27 2 * Bend 4 54 27 2 First Lttheran Church * Sisters 30 55 27 2 *.'Bend 5' `Sisters Fire Hall' Romaine Village Rec.Hall 54 27' 2, * ,Redmond 31 " 3 Redmond Sr.High School Bend ' 55� r27 *� o 27 The Hollins head Center b4 ,2 Bend 32 i b4� {27 F 2 * Bend 7 ; Masonic Temple Kenwood Elem.School Gym 54, ' 27 .'.2,' * Bend 33 {? ` + Bear Creek Elem,School b4 27 2 *"Bend 8 '. • 54 ' 27 2 .' G Bend 34' Kenwood Elem:School Gym New Hope Evangelical Church 54 27 2. * '.Bend 9 54 27 2 s Bend Villa Court. Bend 35 64 27 Kenwood Elem.School Gym * Bend a 55 27 2 Redmond 36 Nazarene Church Redmond Armory 55 27 t 2.- y * 'Bend 11 54, \27 2 * Tumalo 37 Kenwood Elem.School Gym Tumalo Elem.School * Bend 12 55 27 2 LaPine 38 ' Nazarene Church LaPine Fire Station#2 b4 27 2 * Tumalo'13 55 .,27 2 - i LaPine 39 Tumalo Elem.School Gym 54 A7 J 2, LaPine Fire Station#3 * Cloverdale 14 b5 27 2 LaPine 40" Cloverdale Fire Hall Assembly of God Church b4 -27 2'. ; * >Sisters 15 55 27 2 * Tumalo 41 Sisters Fire Hall bb "27 2 Tumalo Elem.School Gym * S�nriverl6' ` 54 27 2' * Bend 42 Sunriver Great Hall 54 Romaine Village Rec.Hall * Redmond 17 55 27 2 * Bend 43 St.Thomas Parish Hall Nativity Lutheran'Church 55 27 ' 2 Terrbbonne 18 r bb 27 2 * Bend.44 4 2�� � �n Terrebonne School b 27' Bear Creek Elem.School Y Redmond 19 55 27 2 * Bend 45 Redmond Assembly of God 54 27 Bend Senio B end 20 r High School ' * 54.. 27, `2 Bend 46 ±: Welcome Center Pilot Butte Jr.High School 64 2T ' Bend21., =r-_ First Missionary'Baptist Church 55 '` 2? 2 * Bend 47 64 r 2 First Lutheran Church * Bend 22 55 27 2 * Redmond 48 �s, Bend 23 Deschutes Count Bldg. Community Presbyterian Church * Deschutes County Administration Bldg. b 27 2 * Bend 49 55 g Kenwood Elem.School Gym`s j * LaPine 24 54' 27 2 LaPine b0 LaPine Fire Station#1 '.Assembly of God Church t * Bend 25 b4 27 2 * Black Butte'Ranch'51 Bend Senior High School Black Butte Ranch Fire Hall> * � � ''• * -Bend 26 54 27 2 * Bend 52' Jewell Elem.School Nativity Lutheran Church * `Access for Persons with Physical Disabilities&_Available i .161 _ Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet JEFFERSON PCPrCinCtS 8c Polling Places 'COUNTY I . . PrcclaM.',':'{ Sfate�"state.'U.S.' `:PrBCIIICt ..•State•'State Un ., and Rep. Sen. Cong. and Rep. `Sen. Cong. Po11IngPlace Dist .Dtst. Dist." Polling Place Diet. Dist. Dist. Bends 3; 54 27 2 JEFFERSON COUNTY Nazarene Church * Bend 54'--'- { 55 27 2 * No.1 Haystack 65. 27 2•, Deschutes County Administration Bldg. Culver High School LaPine 65 55 27 2 * No.2 Crooked River bb 27 2 Assembly of God Church Crooked River Ranch Club House , * No.6 Ashwood ' 55 27 2 *, Bend 56 64, 27 2 Ashwood School Kingston School` * Bend 57 55 27 " 2 * No.6 Kutcher b5 27 2. Welcome Center. United Methodist Church Sisters b8 *' No.8 Lyle Gap, 55 27 2 sisters'Fire Hall bb 27 2 Buff Elementry School *•Tumalo b9 65 27 2 * No.11 Metolius bb. 27 2 Tumalo Elem.School Gym Metolius City Hall ' Terrebonne 60 55 27, 2 No.13 E.Madras: 55 27 2 I I- "Terrebonne School Gym Old Library Building Redmond 61 55 27 . ,;2 85 S.E.D St.,Madras 2 55 27 No;14 Warm Springs Church sembl of God Ch Redmond Assembly, Way Springs Community Center *•Bend 62 54 27, 2 Romaine village Recreation'Hall * No.16 Camp Sherman 55 27 2 " . Fire District Hall * 'No.17 Culver. b5 27 2 Culver City Hall * No.18 Round Butte 55 27 2 Metolius School Gym " * No.19 W.Madras 55 2T 2 Jefferson County Senior Center. 860 S.W.Madison,Madras * No.'20 Circle M. 55 , 27 ' 2 Buff Elementary School * No.21 Central 55 27 2 7th Day Adventist School * No.22 Sunset b5 27 2 Madras Elementary School *-Access for Persons with Physical Disabilities C Available 162 T Official 1992 General Voters'Pa ' m Met _ w, y a VOTING: INSTRUCTI VQTING YOUR BALLOT.AT<THE°POLLI NG PLACE The voters of Deschutes and Jefferson Counties will cast their votes on the, ballot illustrated below-'This page has been;inserted into the Voters'P an aid for using this ballot: amphlet`as . ` 1• USE ONLY THE MARKER PROVIDED. 24 ,TO ,VOTE YOU, MUST BLACKEN THE OVAL .. F ' COMPLETELY!. xt f r�f EXAMPLE ,a PRESIDENT (VOTE FOR ONE) it J n o JOHN ALLEN DOE THOMAS JEFFERSON o J.O. PUBLIC � ' ~ i TO.WRITE-IN 'A NAIVE YOU MUST BLACKEN THE OVAL (: ) AND WRITE THE NAME ON THE LINE 4ry PROVIDED, WHERE APPLICABLE. . 4. DO NOT CROSS OUT - IF YOU CHANGE.YOUR MIND, EXCHANGE YOUR BALLOT FOR A NEW ONE. : 5.: AFTER VOTING -',INSERT BALLOT IN THE BALLOT . ' SLEEVE; DO NOT FOLD'THE BALLOT. If you have any questions about voting, call the Deschutes County Elections Office,at 388-6547, or Jefferson County Elections Office at 475-2417. (Hearing Impaired voters in,Deschutes County'may use our TTY/TDD line at 388 6547,;or.Jefferson County at 475-4451.) Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet k *' ma All s t i e . k A k W � • � �Yi E g s . t ; Jennie Michelle and a woman identified only as `Mrs. Katata"pose'with open-weave baskets,,wooden pry poles and mussels in this scene captured by photographer J.H.Bratt at Seaside circa 1894.Photograph cour- tesy of OreggnR41orical Society,#OrHi 49251. 164' Official 1992 General Voters'Pam ` �phlet -• tt.; r ABSENT,VOTER You may apply for an absentee ballot from your coon clerk if ` tY long term absent voters use this form—available at'embassies Y . I. You are a registered voter;and and military installations--whenever possible 2. You have reason to believe r. You will be unable;for an`rea- Special absentee voting s ' • son,to vote at the polling place on election day. Y (3 instructions and a ballot return . i ve ope will accompany en 1 each absentee ballot. I'°m application moat b°e in writing and must includei,'. ' Special Absentee Ballots:Any'long term :'absentee 1...Your signature.'(This is required, for comparison to ; vote may obtain a ' voter registration card.) your" or special absentee ballot for a primary general electionif the voter believes that. '> 2."Your residence address:. 3. The address to which the laallot should be mailed,if dtflerent 1 terrritorial 1 ts:Of the United States and he District of from your residence. Columbia;and , YOUR VOTED ABSENTEE BALLOT MUST BE RECEIVEI) fit IN THE OFFICE OF YOUR CO 2• The voter will not be able`to receive,vote and return a regu THAN 8:00 FIC THE DAY OF, UNTY CLERK NOT LATER Jar absentee ballot,by.normal mail deli very within the peri.' 3,1992. THE ELECTION,NOVEMBER od provided for absenteevoting. If a registered voter is frail*or disabled,the application." If you faclYo r coun selection officer forsdetailsballot1 you valid for eve subse should contact county r1' quent,election until the voter otherwise 1 ^° notifies the clerk or is no longer a voter in the county. *Where taalking as a means of transp'ortation'ts i»iposstble'or impractical. While'you may'apply for and receive an absentee ballot u A to 8:00 p.m.-on election day 'if your application is received by, DER,YOUR ABSENTEE �i,t the county clerk after October 29,1992,the county clerk is note, BALLOT MUST,BE RI+�(;j�',�Zj;D•BYO1� t required to_mail-your ballot.If your ballot is not mailed,you COUNTY CLERK NO LATER; ` must obtain it in person from the county clerk:Therefore if you TAN g•�0 k. apply for an absentee ballot b mail Y p•M'TIC DAY THE ELECTIONJg ,e „ 4 ' g time d receive the ballot vote and return the ballot to the NO����ER 3 1992 !t «1 Y ,you must allow enough h coup clerk.,REMEMBER:Your voted absentee ballot must be I ———— ——'———— -`aY� ?' t. v' physically in the,office of the county clerk by 8:00 p.m.on the I day of the election,,November•3,1992,or it will not be counted. ABS ENTE'E BALLOT ` T� > j :APPLICATION Ir, LONG TERM 'ABSENT VOTER t I t YOU may apply for long term absent voter status with I PRECINCT NAME/NUMBER your county clerk or the Secretary of State if- "j. Ii state,absent from your place of I TO DAYS DATE r r,(. i ELECTION ry4i,.5 � R . 1, .restdenoeaandtgent of this ` s rs.. 'T y 2.,.You are servin in the armed forces or merchant marine of I the United States;or PRINT YOUR NAME CLEARLY y `" 3. -You are:temporarily living outside the territorial limits of the U.S.and the District of Columbia;or kz tea. 4. You area spouse or dependent of a long term absent voteri I RESIDENCE STREETAODRESS as tr A spouse or dependent of a long term absent voter,not pre- viously a resident of this state who intends to reside in this I ' , state,is considered,a resident for voting g Purposes and may CITY I COUNTY; c ,vote in the same manner,as a long term absent voter. 7 ' Your application must be in writing and must include I'X 1 Your name and current mailing address. I SIGNATURE OF APPLICANT(HANDWRITTEN) 2 A'statement that you are a citizen of the U.S. I IF YOUARE FRAIL'OR DISABLED,C EC 1; yr a` .. 3}A-statement that you will be 18 or older on the day of,the i MAIL BALLOT TO f '., election 4 A?statement"that your home reside nce has been in this state ,I for more,than 20 days preceding the election,and giving the I STREETADDRESS address•ofyour last home residence. ff� * 6.'A"stateiiient`of,the facts that qualify, ' x absent voter fY You as a long I CITY 6 .A:statement that you are not requesting a ballot from any -otherxtate and are not voting in any other manner than by, ,Absentee ballot., I n � IS 7 A;designati'on ofy,oui political affiliation if you wish to vote TATS „ 'I^ in°a'$onbftalelection +x d;� + «I MAIL THIS APPLIC Departaientpf Defense provides standard form 76 I COUNTY INeWHICH YOU MAINTgJN OU ' EMS that,,00mplied=wltb,th"4reViremen t is reoo ended th ,*Wheiek' Id is I � mm at,' d w�/ orlmpracNca► e s.: 165 �;�, �'a EMVM"uriw....,<.3...,w official.1992 General Voters'Pamphlet BSENTIVOTER BAKER "HOOD RIVER POLK WALLOWA Julia Woods Sandra Berr Linda Dawson Charlotte McIver Baker County Clerk Dir.Assess%ec Polk County Clerk Wallowa County Clerk 1995 3rd St. 309 State St. Polk County Courthouse, 101 S.River St. Baker CV OR 97814-3398 Hood River,OR 97031-2093 RM 201 RM 100,Door 16 523 820 t 523-8208, 386-4522 Dallas,OR 97338-3179 Enterprise,OR 97828 1. BENTON JACKSON 623-9217/C 623-9217 426-4543,Ext.15 Dan Burk Kathy Beckett SHERMAN WASCO Dir.RectElections, Jackson County Clerk Linda Cornie Karen LeBreton 120 N.W.4th 10 S.Oakdale Sherman County Clerk Wasco County Clerk Corvallis OR 97330 Medford,OR 97501 P.O.Box 365 Wasco County Courthouse.+:, 757-679/`757-6756 776-7181/c.776-7183 Moro,OR 97039 The Dallas,OR 97058 ., CLACKAMAS JEFFERSON 565-3606 .296-6159/C 296-6159 John Kauffman " Elaine L.Henderson TILLAMOOK WASHINGTON Clackamas County Clerk. Jefferson County Clerk Josephine Veltri Jerry Hanson Elections Division - 75 S.E.'C'St. Tillamook County Clerk AssessfTaxatlon 825 Portland Ave. Madras OF1 97741 201 Laurel Ave. 155 N.1 st Ave. Gladstone OR 97027 475-2317/C 475-4451 Tillamook,OR 97141 Suite B 10 655-8510 f C 655-1685 842-3402 Hillsboro,OR 97124 k JOSEPHINE 648-8670/(.6937-4598, CLATSOP Georgette Brown UMATILLA Lori Davidson i Josepphine County Clerk Tom Groat WHEELER Clatsop County Clerk P.O.Box 69 Umatilla County Clerk Judy Potter P.O.Box 178 Grants Pas*,OR 97526-0203 P.O.Box 1227 Wheeler County Clerk Astoria,OR 97103 ` 474,5243/,C 474-5243 . Pendleton,qR 97801 ` P.O.Box 327 325-8511/C 325-8511 KLAMATH 276-7111/C 276-7119 Fossil, 0 OR 97830-0327 COLUMBIA Evelyn'Biehn UNION' Elizabeth Betty)Huser Klamath County Clerk Nellie Bogus=Hibbert YAMHILL Columbia�ounttyy Clerk 316 Main St.r Union County Clerk Charles Stem ty St(Helens OR 97051-2089 h � ' Klamath 8 17 Fa/CIs,83-418501 LaGrande,OR 97850 535 Yarnhill 5th St Clerk 397-37967 963-1006 McMinnville OR 97128 C 397-3796;Ex t.8445 LAKE 434-7518/ 4347519 Karen O'Connor coos. Lake County Clerk Mary Ann Wilson 513 Center t. —————————— ——T Coos County Clerk Lakeview,OR 97630 250 N.Baxter 947-6006/C947-6007 , ABSENTEE BALLOT Coquile,OR 97423 g96-3,21,Ext.241/ LANE, i, APPLICATION 1 396-3106 � Annette Newingham Elections CROOK 135 E.6th Ave. Della M.Harrison Eugene,O13 97401 Crook County Clerk '687-4234/t 687-4320 300 E.3rd PRECINCT NAME/NUMBER Prineville,OR 97754 LINCOLN 447-6553/C 447-6553 Dana Jenkins Lincoln County Clerk CURRY 225 W.Olive St.Room 201 DATE Elaine Joy Newport,OR 97365 ( TODAY'S DATE ELECTION Curry County Clerk 265-6611/C 265-4193 Curry County Courthouse Gold Beach OR 97444.- LINN 247-6440 '210/ Linn Co Druc0lermkiller PRINT YOUR NAME CLEARLY 247�6440 P.O.Box 100 I DESCHUTES Albany,OR 97321 Susie Penhollow' 967-3831./;967-3833 RESIDENCE STREETADDRESS Deschutes County Clerk 1130 N.W.Harriman MALHEUR. Bend,OR 97701 "Deborah R.DeLong 388-6547/C 388-6547 Malheur County Clerk �. CITY COUNTY t ZIP Courthouse Box 4, - DOUGLAS i 215"B'St.W. Gay Fields " Vale OR 97918 Douglas County Clerk' 473-b151/C 473-5157 X P.O.Box 10 R. Roseburg,OR 97470 MARION SIGNATURE OF APPLICANT(HANDWRITTEN) 440-4323/t 440-6092 Alan H.Davidson IF.YOU ARE FRAIL*OR DISABLED,CHECK HERE. Marion County Clerk GILLIAM 3180 Center St NE,Room 240 Rena Kennedy Salem,OR 9730, MAIL BALLOT TO: Gilliam County Clerk 588-5041/t 588-5610 P.O.Box 427 Condon,OR 97823-0427 MORROW 384-2311 Barbara Bloodsworth STREETADDRESS. -. Morrow County Clerk GRANT P.O.Box 338 Carol Voigt Heppner OR 97836 u, Grant County Clerk 676 906 P.O.Box 39 C 676-9061,Ext.26 CITY e Canyon City,OR 97820 575-1675/1575-1675 , MULTNOMAH Vicki Ervin I HARNEY Dir./Elections STATE ZIP lt, Dolores Swisher 1040 S.E.Morrison St. y Harney County Clerk Portland OR 97214-2495 MAIL THIS APPLICATION TO THE COUNTY CLERK OF THE 450 N.Buena Vista 248 3720/C 248 3729, COUNTY IN WHICH YOU MAINTAIN HOME RESIDENCE Bums,OR,97720 a 573-6641, *Where walking asp a means 'of transportation is'impossible C..Denotes Phone Number for Hearing Impaired ,orimpracticaL__ _, --- ——— ——— 166 " Official 1992 General Voters'Pamphlet t EX"' '§ CANDIDATES AuCoin,Les'. Page Borchers,Rose Marie. 140 .....,1• 148 Bryant;Neil R Bush�George Case 132': s t � Y,Sean.: .:.. ....... x ..... ..........:. lso Chen,"David. "^ . 149 C6 Beverl Y 4 156 ' Clinton;Bill Ferguson,Denzel: 134 �a e Fulani,Lenora B ° 142 a Garrow,Marge '1153b Gore,Al 6 x Hill,Jun......... t 135 Keisling Phil: 150 44 Kulon Kosk,Ted Lord,Nancy ....... 1 . ti 138 Luke;Dennis R z Lyons,Sarah D .... ... 155 ' Marrou'Andrd 14,5 Miller,Randy............................. 13? Oeither,Fred."..,.' 146 �. -Packw d,Bob. .............. ib2 o0 141: rr Pedone,Pete... 157 h f Pickard,Bob... 154 R ayle,Dan.:.:. 133 I deman,Rich .. . .... 153 I Savage;Shaun.. Slaughter,Barry 147, Smith,Robert F.(Bob):.. Throop Michael L 143 4 I ........ ... lso d°" 4 , y4+ Y n ATTENTION: Don't be alarmed if this COPY of the 1992 General.Voters',- s� = Pamphlet has one or 6wo'1/4:'flaps`as illustrated:To reduceF � {. the cost of this publication,the combination ofpages aiid the type of printing press used may require the flap(s)to { " ensure 1 rt ; '4 a Voters'Pamphlet i NOT riussiu P ro er bindin g.Th s k and u, pages,the flap is only a product of the printing press`used..,, ax ti Thank you xf fv -r 11:E- E P ' t 167 E' f SECRETARY OF STATE Phil Keisling T 1 e. y t ff State Capitol Building -��1 Salem,Oregon,97310-0722 5 1 i d. 7 RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER � t ( ,�+r i Mfr ''�,{�����r��� � F.� � .` °r,. 1 r •,_, r a a { 4 'r i Y U tes Jefferson 1 7 STATEOF OREGONGENERAL ELECTION NOVEMBER % 1992; OR j Please RECYCLE.this pamphlet with your newspapers