2023-26-Order No. 2023-006 Recorded 1/17/2023Recorded in Deschutes County
Steve Dennison, County Clerk CJ2023-26
REVIEWED Commissioners' Journal 01 /17/2023 3:37:22 PM
Fs r
- bt_�
LEGAL COUNSEL
2023-26
BEFORE THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF DESCHUTES COUNTY, OREGON
An Order Directing the La Pine Rural Fire
Protection District, an Ambulance Service * ORDER NO. 2023-006
Franchisee of Deschutes County, to Comply with
the Deschutes County Ambulance Service Plan
and Chapter 8.30 of the Deschutes County Code
WHEREAS, the La Pine Rural Fire Protection District ("District") is an ambulance service franchisee of
Deschutes County and is therefore subject to Chapter 8.30 of the Deschutes County Code ("DCC 8.30") and
Appendix A to DCC 8.30, the Deschutes County Ambulance Service Area Plan ("ASA Plan"); and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners ("Board") received a complaint from St. Charles
Medical Group ("St. Charles") on November 16, 2020, and from St. Charles and La Pine Community Health
Clinic ("LCHC") on February 3, 2021, each of which alleged that the District had violated provisions of DCC
8.30 and/or provisions of the ASA Plan; and
WHEREAS, after the Board assigned the task of investigating the allegations from St. Charles and LCHC
to the Deschutes County Ambulance Service Area Advisory Committee ("Committee"), and thereafter the
Committee perforined their investigation; and
WHEREAS, on September 28, 2022, after completing its investigation, the Committee adopted findings
which substantiated two of the five allegations made by St. Charles and LCHC, to wit, that the District (1)
discouraged patients from utilizing the District for emergency transports; and (2) charged fees directly to St.
Charles and LCHC pursuant to District Ordinance #2019-03 and District Policy #02-03, rather than to patients
themselves or their insurers, and that such fees were invalid under Oregon law; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to DCC 8.30.0701 and Section 8.4 of the ASA Plan, the Board desires to withhold
imposition of a sanction against the District and in lieu of sanction provide the District with an opportunity to
cure the violations of DCC 8.30 and the ASA Plan found by the Committee; now therefore,
THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF DESCHUTES COUNTY, OREGON, HEREBY
ORDERS as follows:
Section 1. In lieu of revocation, suspension, or other sanctions as authorized by DCC 8.30.070, 8.30.0802,
and Section 8.4 of the ASA Plan, the District shall cure the violations of DCC 8.30 and the ASA Plan found by
the Committee within forty-five (45) days of receipt of a Notice of Violation describing the findings of the
Committee and relevant portions of this Order. Staff is directed to draft and sent a Notice of Violation to the
District as soon as is practicable.
1 Citation is to original provisions of DCC 8.30.070 (Enforcement), which was renumbered to DCC 8.30.075 after revisions
to DCC Chapter 8.30 in March of 2021.
2 Citation is to original provisions of DCC 8.30.080 (Appeals, Abatements and Penalties), which was renumbered to DCC
8.30.085 after revisions to DCC Chapter 8.30 in March of 2021.
PAGE 1 of 2- ORDER No. 2023-006
Section 2. The District shall cure the aforesaid violations as follows:
The District must cease and desist from unreasonably discouraging patients from requesting medical
transport or treatment via District resources and from unreasonably refusing to provide such transports or
treatment when requested.
2. The District must cease and desist from charging fees to parties other than patients or their insurers for
medical transport or treatment, or from collecting such fees that have been charged to third parties by the
District, unless the District first procures an agreement from such third parties to pay fees for the medical
transport or treatment of a patient prior to providing such medical transport or treatment. Any such
agreement between the District and a third party must otherwise comply with applicable law.
Section 3. The District shall notify the Board in writing of the actions taken to cure the aforesaid violations
within the time period provided in Section 1.
Section 4. Should the District fail to cure the aforesaid violations as required by the Board within the
time period provided in Section 1, the Board will impose sanctions against the District up to an including
revocation of its franchise.
Section 5. Pursuant to DCC 8.30.070 and Section 8.4 of the ASA Plan, the District may submit a written
request for a hearing within fourteen (14) calendar days of receipt of the Notice of Violation. The request must
set forth the reasons for requesting the hearing and the issue proposed for review by the Board. Should the District
timely submit a request, any action to enforce this Order shall be stayed pending a hearing and a final decision by
the Board, unless a change is required due to an immediate hazard to public safety. If a timely request is received
by the Board, a hearing will be scheduled and provided as otherwise required by DCC 8.30.070 and Section 8.4
DI
of the ASA I aii.
Section 6. This Order is effective upon signing.
�l
Dated this 1 `
ATTEST:
of January, 2023.
Recording Secretary
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF DESCHUTES COUNTY, OREGON
ANTHONY DeBONE, Chair .
< l
t,
PATTI ADAIR; Vice Chair
PHIL CHANG, Commissioner
PAGE 2 OF 2- ORDER No. 2023-006
MEETING DATE:
January 11, 2023
SUBJECT: Adoption of Board Order No. 2023-006 directing the La Pine Rural Fire Protection
District to comply with the Deschutes County Ambulance Service Plan and
Chapter 8.30 of the Deschutes County Code
RECOMMENDED MOTION:
Move approval of Order 2023-006 directing the La Pine Rural Fire Protection District to
comply with the Deschutes County Ambulance Service Plan and Chapter 8.30 of the
Deschutes County Code.
BACKGROUND AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
Following an investigation, and upon recommendation of the Ambulances Service Area (ASA)
Advisory Committee, II I ittee, the Board or der ed that La Pine Fir e cure ongoing violations W 1 De„hultCc
County Code Chapter 8.3 and the ASA Plan.
BUDGET IMPACTS:
None
ATTENDANCE:
Legal