HomeMy WebLinkAboutHRA Memo for BOCC 11-25-13
TO: BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
FROM: DAVE INBODY & RONDA CONNOR
SUBJECT: HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENTS
DATE: 11/22/2013
CC: TOM ANDERSON, ERIK KROPP
Background
Deschutes County first offered health risk assessments (HRAs) to employees and dependents in
January 2011. It was offered to anyone on the health plan over the age of 18. A total of 377
people received HRAs in 2011. The health risk assessment included the following:
Online Questionnaire –a series of questions regarding a variety of health-related topics
Biometrics – Height, weight and blood pressure was measured for each participant
Fasting Blood Work – cholesterol, triglycerides and glucose levels were tested
In 2012, HRAs were again offered. Employees were encouraged to make an appointment to
review their results with a provider at the Deschutes Onsite Clinic (DOC). In addition, e mployees
were given a one-month health insurance premium holiday ($65 value) for taking an HRA. This
had a significant impact on participation among employee. Spouse and dependent participation
was about the same as 2011. The total number of participants was 582
The incentive for getting a one-month health insurance premium holiday was extended in 2013
to include not only employees, but also spouses. Since the premium had increased to $90 per
month, the incentive was increased to $90 as well. In order to qualify for the incentive, an
employee needed to not only complete the online questionnaire, biometrics and blood work,
but a follow up visit with a health care provider to discuss the results was also required. The
additional incentive for spouses resulted in a significant increase in spouse participation.
Employee participation was about the same. Another change was a more concerted effort to get
patients into the Deschutes Onsite Clinic (DOC) for their blood work. In the previous two years,
large events were scheduled at work locations through which the vast majority of blood draws
were completed. Although there were a few events in 2013, the majority of blood draws
occurred at the DOC.
HRA Participation by Year and Participant Type
Year Employees Spouses Dependents
(18-26) Total
2011 Participants 320 48 9 377
% Participating 31% 7% 5% 20%
2012 Participants 536 40 6 582
% Participating 52% 7% 3% 30%
2013 Participants 532 265 2 799
% Participating 52% 37% 1% 38%
2
2014 Health Risk Assessment
For 2014, like 2013, it is recommended that the HRA include completion of an online
questionnaire, biometrics, blood draw and follow up visit with a provider. In addition, it is
recommended that anyone whose results indicate at least two risk factors be required to meet
with either a provider or the wellness coordinator to develop a plan for addressing those risk
factors in order to receive the incentive. This is intended to address identified risk factors, which
typically lead to high health plan costs if not managed.
Last year, the deadline to complete the blood draw was March 31, the deadline for the follow
up visit was June 30 and the incentives were disbursed in August and September. It is suggested
that instead of a one-month premium holiday, a monthly premium discount be provided. The
discount will begin in August and continue for the next 12 months. For those with two or more
health risks, they will be required to check in with a provider or the wellness coordinator on a
quarterly basis to review their health plan in order to continue receiving the incentive.
Each employee premium for the 2015 plan year (August 2014 -July 2015) will be based on the
following:
Employee Type HRA Participation Premium Rate*
Single Employee Employee Participates $74 per month
Employee Does Not Participate $82 per month
Married Employee
Employee & Spouse Participates $74 per month
Employee Participates, Spouse Does Not Participate $82 per month
Neither Employee or Spouse Participates $90 per month
*All rates are based on current plan rates. These rates could be altered for plan year 2015.
Why do Health Risk Assessments Matter?
The reason for providing HRAs is to encourage participants to pursue a pro-active, preventive
approach to health care. The participant is provided a snapshot of their health condition,
highlighting any risk factors identified. Early detection and management of potential risk factors
can prevent the onset of a chronic condition. Additionally, providing an annual opportunity for
employees to meet with a health care provider to discuss their health condition will enable
participants to better understand their health. For Deschutes County, a healthier population
results in lower health benefits costs.
1. HRAs Save Claims Cost by Detect Conditions Early
In the last 12 months, 60% of health benefits expenses were as a result of 284 (10%
of covered lives). Many high-value claims are for behavioral-driven conditions. For
example, among the 100 members with the highest claims cost in the health
benefits plan in the last 12 months, 19% were diagnosed with heart disease (vs. 4%
among all covered lives in plan) and 13% were diagnosed with diabetes (vs. 4% in
plan). The cost is significantly reduced if these conditions are detected early or
avoided completely through preventive treatment. The risk for both of these
conditions can be tracked through the testing provided as part of the health risk
assessment, such as blood pressure, cholesterol, triglycerides and glucose.
3
2. HRA Participation Leads to Cost Savings
People who participate in the HRAS process spend less in the following year than
those who do not participate. The greater the level of participation, the lower the
claims cost.
4
3. HRA Participants Increases Health-Conscious Behavior
HRA participant are more likely to take preventive steps toward detecting and treating
chronic conditions. Here are a few examples
Preventive Actions Plan HRA National
At least one office visit 88.6% 95.1% 78.2%
Mammogram (Women 40+) 48.1% 52.8% 33.4%
At least one dental visit 73.6% 86.9% 63.5%
Conversely, those who do not participate in the HRA process are more likely to pursue more
emergency-driven, higher cost actions.
Fewer ER by HRA Participants Fewer Urgent Care Visits by HRA Participants
More cases of diabetes and heart disease among HRA participants, but……..
5
The cost of treating cases of diabetes and heart disease is less among HRA participants.